who has one of the best match ups against MK? falco
who loses horridly to ICs and pika? falco
who beats Ics considerably (thanks to CP) and pika just by being better? MK
your turn
I'm really curious where you disagree? The few times MK/Pika has happened at top level it... wasn't pretty. Ant1 (who to the best of my knowledge doesn't really have that much high, and no top level experience vs Pika) vs Es4m wasn't particularly... well even looking. Sure, es4m messed up a lock, but even despite that, even with Ant1's lack of MU knowledge (especially compared to Es4m's), Ant1 beat es4m well enough and demonstrated that MK wins the MU; especially when MK gets any kind of noticeable lead. Then M2K beat Es4m enough to knock him off of Pika and to IC.yeah...youre just wrong here.
Before you reference Tyrant (who is notorious for being bad against a lot of characters and has- actually probably zero MU exp) vs Es4m, I do not believe that to be a good representation of the MU.
As for Ice Climbers, I believe- as do many others- that even on FD IC loses to MK and is even at best for IC. But given the fact that FD will be banned by MK in that MU, MK certainly has a winning MU with IC.
I don't believe there is anything remotely close to an argument that IC/pika beat Falco.
Then, especially assuming a LGL, it's fairly commonly accepted that Falco has one of the better MUs with MK.
To be completely honest, I don't see anything in Ripple's post that is very far from the truth, even assuming that it isn't completely accurate. I don't see how you can refute a post that contains information that is largely considered to be true by most players (sans M2K because, while I like the guy, I don't adhere to his opinion of MUs by any stretch of the imagination) by just saying "no." If you would be so kind as to give evidence as to why you believe the commonly thought MU "numbers" are wrong, please demonstrate.