The reason why you think you beat me so easily is because MK beats Diddy on that stage. It's not a bad stage, my character just sucks on it.
It's not just your character, it's every single character other than G&W, Wario, and Jiggs I guess.
Considering your character does better there than most of the characters I've played there, and that you're a much better player than I am, it seems like I shouldn't have a stressless 2 stock victory, right after being 2 stocked on a neutral stage.
It's not like MK is completely broken all around. He's beatable on many stages that aren't stupid as ****, and Diddy's counterpicks are not even up to par as far as polarness goes.
Fighting against Diddy on FD is not even comparable to fighting MK on RC, unless you're Mister Game and Watch, or you're Wario.
Like fighting against Diddy on FD turns it into probably an even matchup, or possibly Diddy's favor (I'm not really sure, but it's probably 60-40, or 55-45 on SV), it's a noticeable, but fairly minor change.
Fighting MK on RC as Diddy really changes it into a ****ing 70-30 (or whatever number you'd put on a matchup where you have to be significantly better than your opponent to win), and not because Diddy is bad there, or Diddy doesn't have the tools there. Diddy might be bad there, but in that same way, most of the cast is bad there. Diddy is still tougher to fight there than almost everyone below him on the tier list, bar G&W, Wario, and I guess Snake and maybe Fox (I might be forgetting a few. EDIT: Oh ZSS isn't too pitiful here). It's so tough because MK gains things there he has on literally no other stage. There's no other stage where he can safely stay on the ledge, where you can't touch him, and then be under you with his really good uair the entire match.
idk if you guys want to keep these noncompetitive, ridiculous stages legal, go for it. It really doesn't effect me negatively, other than me feeling that it's simply unfair. I don't have the patience to sit here and debate against something that really only helps me (however stupid it is that it helps me, and shouldn't be there to help me at all).
Although I'd like to note that any analogy comparing ICs or Diddy on FD to MK on RC is complete and utter bull****. We don't live in a world of black and white, stages aren't separated into "advantage" or "disadvantage" in matchups. There's "small advantage", "noticeable advantage", "huge advantage", vice versa, and everything in-between.
It's completely ignorant, and foolish to assume that they are even comparable situations, when the degree of severity is so vastly different.
You can keep these stages legal if you want, because the 2 G&W mains, and 4 Wario mains deserve to benefit from having an extra CP, at the cost of the characters that keep MK down, Falco, Diddy, Snake, etc all having to go to a **** stage, and have a free-loss against the character that 50% of the damn community plays, go for it.
If you're so stuck in your ways that you believe that letting G&W and Wario have an extra counterpick is an important reason in letting the most controversial and borderline character in the series, one that is played in, what, 50% of the matches played in tournaments (or so, right? I might be off, but definitely not by a whole lot), and that it's worth it to give the best character in the game, who decides which characters are good in the metagame, then I really don't have the patience to debate with you, as it'll go no where.
I'm just gonna put this out there. If your main argument against the idea of RC/Brinstar combined being too powerful for MK is "But it gets rid of Wario and G&W and Jigglypuff having an extra good CP stage!", ask yourself this. Are the benefits of having 2 obscure characters, who have like 8 people combined playing them, gain CPs that help them a bit in certain matchups, (I don't think I've ever seen a good Wario play on Brinstar unless the opponent didn't know to ban it against him, since it's always just banned against wario players, it seems) worth the detriment of the best, most controversial character in the series, played by half the community, gaining a free win against a super majority of the cast, a free win that he doesn't have on really any other stages?
I can't imagine any reasonable person believing that Wario and G&W gaining a CP (that's usually banned against them anyways) is worth the cost of the already best and far away most popular character in the game gaining a free win. But if you believe that to be logical, and comparable to the strengths that ICs or D3 or Diddy or whoever you say gains on FD (even though there's only one FD, so you can just ban it, and they don't guaranteed have another FD to go to), go ahead, I can't stop you. I'll continue beating players that are better than me on these stages, and having chances at beating ranked players that I shouldn't even have available to me because I'm trash at the game.