That's pretty funny, so you're saying Sakurai cut Mewtwo because everyone in America wanted him cut?
You're either exaggerating a lot, or are stupid.
I remember reading that many Melee fans (not just americans) all hated how mewtwo was designed that they made a petition to not have Mewtwo in the next smash. I remember them saying that it was sent to sakurai also.
Is it really Tingle's fault that the Triforce of Courage was divided up?
No, it is nintendo's fault for trying to make their games longer.
Mewtwo is more popular than Pokemon itself. Who wanted him cut?
Angry Melee and Mewtwo fans because they saw him as really poorly implemented and that his style did not match Mewtwo.
I don't get it- people complain that the roster is small, but then they say that they want characters cut.
And when people suggest new characters, they say no, because they don't like them, even though the thing they wanted in the first place were more characters.
.
I didn't want anyone to be cut. I hate it when fighting games cut characters in the next installment, That means I have to worry about mastering or playing two games instead of getting to enjoy everyone in one game.
That is an opinion. And like fliyingfilipino said, it isn't Tingle's fault that the Triforce of Courage was divided up. Besides, they needed to increase length and so they used Tingle to do so. If not Tingle, it would have been someone else.
Or they could have cut that silly idea and put in more dungeons.
Sakurai has limited time. Both Wolf Link and Tingle would take an equal amount of time to develop. This time could be used to program another character. Sakurai doesn't care if the roster won't fit into a pretty little box, as evidenced by Melee. They both would cause equal strain, and therefore Tingle is the better option.
Uh, Melee was symmetrical. He did care about balance for melee. For brawl, he made sure everything fit in the grid. He would not go 1 extra if it would have messed up that balance.
And Tingle being the better option is opinion.
You really should have sources and do research before you make unfounded accusations. Sheik was very highly requested for Melee.
do you have a source for that? I would like to read it.
I know Sheik was popular after melee only because of the tier list and her placement. That is the reason why everyone wanted her in brawl. (and even then, there was a bit of people who did not want her to return.)
...and you just proved my point. The rest of the world is not being vocal, and they realize that they will not have their voices heard. If they really hate Tingle as much as you say, than they would speak up. And what? Everybody wanted Mewtwo to return. Mewtwo in SSB4, however, is another matter.
People did not voice their concern for Brawl because everyone thought he was coming back. As I said, half likes him. Half Hates him.
Dr. Mario was the sole representative of a popular puzzle series, and he represented puzzle gaming in general. Lip is a better option now, but if the roster expands beyond 50 characters Dr. Mario has a shot. Try to look beyond "The same character" before making a blanket statement.
Stop trying to give meaning to the Doc. He was an easy clone. End of Story. I do not think Sakurai was trying to sneak in meaning for Doc other than "We need another character."
HE IS THE SAME CHARACTER! It is Mario. It has been established to be mario.
---
I don't see why everyone is desperate to have Tingle or Paper Mario. I never will. That is just my stance.
Time to move on. This debate is getting no where.
As for items, the Blue and Red Turtle Shell would be cool. So would Rings (for sonic), the health item (for megaman) and maybe the Tanooki suit. (Imagine Ganondorf in a Tanooki suit. That would be funny)