Show me one match where linguini consistently shield grabs every attempt at spacie pressure on his shield.
Ganon's grab range is horrible <_<. He'd probably still get shined if he's within range to grab them. It would work for Marth because Marth's grab outranges their attacks. All he's using the shield DI for is to MAKE THEM MISS. And while I can't show you matches of players really using shield DI (mostly because of them not being recorded, not because it hasn't been used. Heck, my friends use it to avoid getting knocked onto the ledge when they're shielding really close to it), you still have not given me any valid reason that it wouldn't work.
And Dark Sonic. Im not a frame nerd but I think your overaating the usefulness and practicality of these things
Well let's see. Actually, smash DI and power shielding have been proven in practice. Show me one match where Armada DOESN'T powershield Falco's lasers <_<. And Hungrybox smash DI's Fox's upthrow->uair a good 50% of the time now (which means half of the times that he would've died he now doesn't.)
I've seen space animal players sometimes smash DI my uptilts behind me, making them impossible to followup. And it's not even the top space animal players, it's guys like Harriettheguy, Pengie, Sheermadness, ect. Mid level players are doing this and seeing success with it (and by success I mean they're ruining my combos >_<). Not to say that top level players don't do it at all (Shiz did it to me a couple times at noob1 in friendlies
![Stick Out Tongue :p :p](/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/tongue.gif)
. He's also notorious for teching counter edgeguards)
Ganon and Peach players smash DI the first hit of my nair and make the second miss when I tried to finish combos off stage with it instead of a tipped fair.
I've seen Marth players smash DI my f-smash edgeguards in order to ledge tech. And I do the same to them
![Stick Out Tongue :p :p](/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/tongue.gif)
.
I've PERSONALLY smash DI'd the first hit of Falcon's nair to avoid the second, smash DI'd Fox's dair to avoid getting shined, and on rare occasions have smash DI'd Falcon's uair to avoid getting combo'd (maybe they could followup with nair or something idk, but smash DIing down and away, while also DIing down and away....has suprising results). Of course I've also smash DI'd Fox's uair like everyone else does nowadays. Do I do this consistently? No, but every time I succeed it means that I don't die. Even if it only worked 10% of the time, it's still a way for me to keep my stock and potentially take theirs.
So+1 for smash DI being efficient in practice.
Powershielding lasers made me go from 1 stocking to 2 or 3 stocking those same Falco players consistently. Every time I powershield a laser it disrupts whatever the Falco player was doing, and forces him to change just for me. Some Falcos shoot less lasers, some Falcos shoot lower lasers, some Falcos full jump double laser (not too smart <_<), but in the end it weakens their characters abilities and strengthen mine. Falco without lasers<Falco with lasers.
+1 for powershielding being efficient in practice. I'm gonna learn to powershield Samus's missiles next, just for fun
Shield dropping is probably not revolutionary, but neither are pivot grabs and we tell every Marth player to learn those (they're useful outside of chaingrabs too btw. You can grab characters directly out of attacks more easily with pivot grabs).
Shield DI....anything that nets Marth a grab is useful. Only problem is that it's relatively hard to do consistently, and for most moves it's impossible on reaction. But, how much thinking do you really need to do to realize what a Falco player is going to use after he shorthops at you from behind a laser? Learning the timing will certainly be difficult, and it likely won't be consistent (just like smash DI right?), but if every time you do it right you get to see the opponent miss a shine from arm's length.... it's worth it don't you think?
So am I still overrating these techniques? I definitely don't think so. They're potentially useful escape tools. You don't have to be a frame nerd to understand that getting out of combos is good for you. You don't have to be a frame nerd to understand that getting free grabs is good for you. It seems that you believe that just because you don't see a technique used often, it automatically is worthless. Ever thought that they may just be difficult and people are lazy?