this list is too good stickie this for sure.
^ this is true, if his controller is visibly broken then i can see that, but if he says it, it is your win and he is johning.
Visible in what sense?
I just picked up my controller a few days ago and, only after using it for a few minutes, did I find the C-stick wasn't working. I have to get a new one.
To verify it's not working, would have needed to flick it while my opponent was watching and show that nothing happens, or let my opponent handle my controller.
I too am confused by the sportsmanship johns. After a match whether I win or lose, I always feel that no matter what I do, I'll sound like a jerk (including if I say nothing); this makes me focus on simply conversing with my opponent, going over the game events.
I am rarely offended by a "good game" comment, the exception being when one competitor clearly got ***** and/or most of the match involved "WTF?" moments (in Brawl this looks to mostly involve clipping through stage platforms). If I lose, I would feel best getting a silent handshake, and a "lolwut?", respectively. If I win, I have no idea how I'd respond to winning by that much at this time; but if I win through WTF moments, I'd make a comment about the nature of cookies and their crumbling or something, thank my opponent for his competition, and move on.
Also, I'm really REALLY confused as to how comments like "Huh." and "Wow." are johns. These are NOTHING BUT compliments, and usefully neutral comments. Who could not like hearing "Wow"? I mean, if you say it like an ***, that's a different matter. Also, I really very heavily on "huh" to keep my cool in a match. It's a completely harmless word, barely a breath of air! The
question is a jerky response, much like "glitches" and "I have a life"; the exclamation (a comment, really), "huh," is a way of acknowledging events that are enlightening. Wouldn't you be happy to give your opponent a "huh" moment?
One last thing, I suppose I should ask. . . reading accounts of some people... one way I would deal with an event like.. say, stabby2846's, with Tingle's Balloon, is by giving a quick "lol" comment. I mean only to acknowledge how the game has countered my ignorance in this momentous reversal of fortune. I don't mean it to be belittling to my opponent but rather to reduce the impact of my own failure, possibly to share in the "lol" with my opponent.
Is that so bad?