• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Here's the keys - make a crossover fighter with [INSERT IP HERE].

Speed Weed

Smash Master
Joined
May 16, 2020
Messages
3,715
Location
Portugal
Switch FC
SW-1814-1029-3514
**** it - Taito fighting game
  1. Bub (Bubble Bobble)
  2. Sayo-chan (KiKi KaiKai)
  3. Kart Bradfield (Elevator Action Returns)
  4. Reika Kirishima (Time Gal)
  5. Kunoichi (The Ninja Warriors)
  6. Kage (The Legend of Kage)
  7. Emilio Michaelov (Psychic Force)
  8. Tiki (The New Zealand Story)
  9. Chack 'n (Chack 'n Pop)
  10. Rastan (Rastan Saga)
  11. Patrako (Cleopatra Fortune)
  12. Ptolemy (The Fairyland Story)
  13. Bob (Don Doko Don)
  14. Sonic Blast Man (...)
  15. Zac/Mel (PuLiRuLa)
  16. Garnet (Puchi Carat)
  17. Hipopo (Liquid Kids)
  18. Kaori Tachibana (Kirameki Star Road)
  19. The General (Kaiser Knuckle)
Might have too much of a classic lean and I wish I'd added someone from Groove Coaster but eh
 

Wario Wario Wario

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
11,905
Location
Cheese Wheels of Doom
Here is my wildly unrealistic roster for a 200-man Smash fangame - I have full creative control, and no baggage from past games or fan demand played much of a role.
is that mr x.

oh my god that's so based

Even though I don't really like the concept from a realistic perpsective, I've been meaning to a ludicrously large Smash roster for a while - maybe I should give it a shot?
 

Wario Wario Wario

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
11,905
Location
Cheese Wheels of Doom
just realised this is LegallyTM a creation thread, so I get 3 double posts - here's the roster. 400 characters - including some picks that may or may not have been chosen out of malice!

  1. Mario (Super Mario)
  2. Luigi
  3. Peach
  4. Bowser
  5. Daisy
  6. Waluigi
  7. Goomba
  8. Piranha Plant
  9. Dr. Mario
  10. Dr. Bowser
  11. Roy Koopa
  12. Fire Mario
  13. Small Mario
  14. Small Peach
  15. Mario and Yoshi
  16. Prince Peasley
  17. Vivian
  18. Baby Face
  19. President Koopa
  20. Yoshi (Yoshi)
  21. The Stork
  22. Pak E. Derm
  23. Donkey Kong (Donkey Kong)
  24. Diddy Kong
  25. King K. Rool
  26. Cranky Kong
  27. Dixie Kong
  28. Rambi
  29. Klump
  30. Stanley
  31. Pipsy
  32. Diddy Kong Head-Shaped CD
  33. Wario (Wario)
  34. Wario Land
  35. Ashley
  36. Jimmy T.
  37. Penny
  38. Captain Syrup
  39. Wario’s Nose
  40. Link (Zelda)
  41. Zelda
  42. Sheik
  43. Ganondorf
  44. Ganon
  45. Toon Link
  46. Toon Zelda
  47. Wild Link
  48. Octorok
  49. Moblin
  50. Bokoblin
  51. Ghirahim
  52. Midna
  53. Impa (Elderly)
  54. Toon Bokoblin
  55. Morshu
  56. Tingle (Tingle)
  57. Samus (Metroid)
  58. Ridley
  59. Metroid
  60. Kirby (Kirby)
  61. King Dedede
  62. Waddle Dee
  63. Whispy Woods
  64. Adeleine
  65. Daroach
  66. Dashing Super Guy
  67. Fox (Star Fox)
  68. Falco
  69. Peppy
  70. Slippy
  71. Wolf
  72. Arwing
  73. Wolfen
  74. Andross
  75. Mewtwo (Pokemon)
  76. Jigglypuff
  77. Squirtle
  78. Ivysaur
  79. Rattata
  80. Ditto
  81. Magikarp
  82. Haunter
  83. Beedrill
  84. Krabby
  85. Ho-Oh
  86. Igglybuff
  87. Onix
  88. Genesect
  89. Meloetta
  90. Trubbish
  91. Braixen
  92. Rowlet
  93. Incineroar
  94. Iron Valiant
  95. Giovanni
  96. Lucy Fleetfoot
  97. Todd Snap
  98. Technology Guy
  99. MissingNo
  100. Ness (EarthBound)
  101. Lloyd
  102. Kumatora
  103. Master Belch
  104. Ice Climbers (Ice Climber)
  105. Topi US
  106. Topi JP
  107. Marth (Fire Emblem)
  108. Lucina
  109. Robin
  110. Corrin
  111. Byleth
  112. Oliver
  113. Mr. Game & Watch (Game & Watch)
  114. Pit (Classic) (Kid Icarus)
  115. Uprising Pit
  116. Olimar (Pikmin)
  117. Pikmin
  118. Bulborb
  119. Oatchi
  120. ROB (ROB)
  121. Villager (Animal Crossing)
  122. New Villager
  123. Crazy Redd
  124. KK Slider
  125. Wii Fit Trainer (Wii Fit)
  126. Little Mac (Punch-Out!)
  127. Glass Joe
  128. King Hippo
  129. Duck Hunt (Duck Hunt)
  130. Inkling (Splatoon)
  131. Callie/Marie
  132. Pearl/Marina
  133. Ted & Archie (Nintendogs)
  134. Yuka (Rhythm Heaven)
  135. Widget
  136. Excitebiker (Excitebike)
  137. Jill (Drill Dozer)
  138. Sundes (Mole Mania)
  139. Who Are You Running From? (Game Boy Camera)
  140. Wii Remote Silicone Jacket (Wii)
  141. Mii Brawler (Mii)
  142. Mii Gunner
  143. Mii Swordfighter
  144. Fighting Polygon Team (Super Smash Bros.)
  145. Snake (Metal Gear)
  146. Senator Armstrong
  147. Sonic (Classic) (Sonic the Hedgehog)
  148. Tails
  149. Knuckles
  150. Dr. Eggman
  151. Super Sonic
  152. Modern Sonic
  153. Shadow
  154. Motobug/Flicky
  155. Big the Cat
  156. Fang the Sniper
  157. AoStH Robotnik
  158. Segapede
  159. Mega Man (Mega Man)
  160. Roll
  161. Bad Box Art Mega Man
  162. Pac-Man (Pac-Man)
  163. Ms. Pac-Man
  164. Blinky
  165. Pinky
  166. Inky
  167. Clyde
  168. Pac-Mom
  169. Gyaraga
  170. Taizo Hori
  171. Mappy
  172. Toc-Man
  173. Pac-Man 2
  174. Naked Blinky
  175. Ryu (Street Fighter)
  176. Ken
  177. Chun-Li
  178. Akuma
  179. Blanka
  180. Sakura
  181. Zangief
  182. M. Bison
  183. Vega
  184. Dracula (Castlevania)
  185. Captain N Alucard
  186. Cloud (Final Fantasy)
  187. Sephiroth
  188. Kefka
  189. Chocobo
  190. Tifa
  191. Barret
  192. Erdrick (Dragon Quest)
  193. Solo
  194. Eight
  195. Luminary
  196. Slime
  197. Jinjo (Banjo-Kazooie)
  198. Terry (Fatal Fury)
  199. Iori
  200. Nakoruru
  201. Steve (Minecraft)
  202. Ender Dragon
  203. Pig
  204. Kazuya (Tekken)
  205. Kuma
  206. Bob
  207. Yoshimitzu
  208. Lin
  209. Doomguy (Doom)
  210. Spider Mastermind
  211. Kratos (God of War)
  212. Zeus
  213. Arteus
  214. Master Chief (Halo)
  215. Arbiter
  216. Cortana
  217. Red (Angry Birds)
  218. Bad Piggy
  219. Big Smoke (Grand Theft Auto)
  220. I (Tetris)
  221. L/J
  222. Z/S
  223. O
  224. T
  225. Bubsy (Bubsy)
  226. Woolie
  227. Miner Willy (Manic Miner)
  228. Cursor (Windows)
  229. Clippy
  230. Inori Aizawa
  231. Yeti
  232. Space Cadet
  233. Gex (Gex)
  234. Rez
  235. Horace (Horace Goes Skiing)
  236. Lara Croft (Tomb Raider)
  237. Modern Lara
  238. Voodoo Vince (Voodoo Vince)
  239. Lockjaw (Rise of the Robots)
  240. Sqij (Sqij!)
  241. Urban Yeti (Urban Yeti)
  242. Putt-Putt (Junior Adventures)
  243. Pajama Sam
  244. Spy Fox
  245. Freddi Fish
  246. Dingodile (Crash Bandicoot)
  247. Ripper Roo
  248. Tiny Tiger
  249. Pinstripe
  250. Nina Cortex
  251. Mettaton EX (Undertale)
  252. Undyne
  253. King Dice (Cuphead)
  254. Ribby and Croaks
  255. Baron von Bon Bon
  256. Shovel Knight (Shovel Knight)
  257. Mona
  258. Peppino (Pizza Tower)
  259. The Noise
  260. Sim (The Sims)
  261. Sub-Zero (Mortal Kombat)
  262. Johnny Cage
  263. Gordon Freeman (Half Life)
  264. Headcrab
  265. Flappy Bird (Flappy Bird)
  266. Annalynn (Annalynn)
  267. Elizabert Megafig (Bugsnax)
  268. Snaxsquatch
  269. PaRappa (PaRappa the Rapper)
  270. Lammy
  271. Guru Ant
  272. Plok (Plok)
  273. Yumetaro (Mr. Gimmick)
  274. Dweeb (The Outfoxies)
  275. Professor Ching
  276. Kung Fu Man (MUGEN)
  277. Willy (Rockin’ Kats)
  278. Hat Kid (A Hat in Time)
  279. Bow Kid
  280. Sackboy (LittleBigPlanet)
  281. Aloy (Horizon)
  282. Penguin (Club Penguin)
  283. Om Nom (Cut the Rope)
  284. Crazy Dave (Plants vs. Zombies)
  285. Ben (Talking Friends)
  286. Power Pro (Power Pros)
  287. Evil Otto (Berzerk)
  288. Yorgle (Adventure)
  289. Jazz Jackrabbit (Jazz Jackrabbit)
  290. Space Invader (Space Invaders)
  291. Toejam and Earl (Toejam and Earl)
  292. Bonanza Bros (Bonanza Bros)
  293. Headdy (Dynamite Headdy)
  294. Ristar (Ristar)
  295. Kapu Kapu (ChuChu Rocket)
  296. Game Genie (Game Genie)
  297. Pin Bot (Pin Bot)
  298. Fall Guy (Fall Guys)
  299. Impostor (Among Us)
  300. UItra Fishbunjin 3000 (Ittle Dew)
  301. Masked Ruby
  302. Orka (Healthy Weapon)
  303. Business Casual Man (Slap City)
  304. Princess Remedy (Princess Remedy)
  305. Wrastor (Rivals of Aether)
  306. Elliana
  307. Ranno
  308. Pomme
  309. Monty Mole (Monty Mole)
  310. Bridget (Guilty Gear)
  311. Faust
  312. Untitled Goose (Untitled Goose Game)
  313. Commander Keen (Commander Keen)
  314. Delay Lama (Delay Lama)
  315. Lemming (Lemmings)
  316. Zoombinis (Zoombinis)
  317. Frog (Chrono Trigger)
  318. Skye (Darkened Skye)
  319. Freddy Fazbear (FNAF)
  320. Mei (Overwatch)
  321. Reaper
  322. Octane (Rocket League)
  323. Hornet (Daytona USA)
  324. Q*Bert (Q*Bert)
  325. Dragonborn (Skyrim)
  326. BD Joe (Crazy Taxi)
  327. Noob (Roblox)
  328. Peeley (Fortnite)
  329. Cuddle Team Leader
  330. Meow Skulls
  331. Geno
  332. Stubbs the Zombie (Stubbs the Zombie)
  333. Banjo Man (Phalanx)
  334. Chip (Chip’s Challenge)
  335. Bomberman (Bomberman)
  336. Act Zero Bomberman
  337. Pete (Harvest Moon)
  338. Boogerman (Boogerman)
  339. Blue Suede Goo (Clayfighter)
  340. Earthworm Jim (Earthworm Jim)
  341. Atrus (Myst)
  342. Kang Fu (Kang Fu)
  343. Drake (Drake of the 99 Dragons)
  344. Spike (Ape Escape)
  345. Sam Fisher (Tom Clancy)
  346. Rabbid (Rabbids)
  347. Bandito Chinchilla (Thrillville)
  348. Flo (Metal Slug)
  349. Shiori (Tokimeki Memorial)
  350. Jumbo Josh (Garten of Banban)
  351. Vibri (Vib Ribbon)
  352. Croc (Croc)
  353. Necky (Famitsu)
  354. Octodad (Octodad)
  355. Plane (Flight Simulator)
  356. Paddle (Pong)
  357. Reindog (Multiversus)
  358. Larry the Bird (Twitter)
  359. Dante (Devil May Cry)
  360. Vergil
  361. Cole (Infamous)
  362. Nathan Drake (Uncharted)
  363. Big Daddy (Bioshock)
  364. Radec (Killzone)
  365. Avatar (Ultima)
  366. Sock Puppet (Pets.com)
  367. Chosen Undead (Dark Souls)
  368. Ceaseless Discharge
  369. Chaos Witch Quelaag
  370. Baby (Super Monkey Ball)
  371. Diablo (Diablo)
  372. Annie (Anton)
  373. Paul
  374. Bertie (Bertie the Brain)
  375. Fido (Don’t Buy This)
  376. Jake (Subway Surfers)
  377. Suzane (Blender)
  378. Bosch (Line Rider)
  379. Nemesis (Resident Evil)
  380. PB (Polar Bowler)
  381. Dingle Kringle (Elf Bowling)
  382. Big Rig (Big Rigs)
  383. Trapper (Dead by Daylight)
  384. Thrall (World of Warcraft)
  385. Aatrox (League of Legends)
  386. Leona
  387. Blitzcrank
  388. Danzaburou (Smite)
  389. Ultraman (Ultraman)
  390. Godzilla (Godzilla)
  391. Doraemon (Doraemon)
  392. Goku (Dragon Ball)
  393. Totoro (Studio Ghibli)
  394. Chibi Maruko-Chan (Chibi Maruko Chan)
  395. Darth Vader (Star Wars)
  396. Garfield (Garfield)
  397. Shrek (Shrek)
  398. SpongeBob (SpongeBob)
  399. Ronald McDonald (McDonalds)
  400. Homer Simpson (The Simpsons)
 
Last edited:

Champion of Hyrule

Smash Master
Writing Team
Joined
Sep 15, 2018
Messages
4,343
Location
*doxxes myself*
just realised this is LegallyTM a creation thread, so I get 3 double posts - here's the roster. 400 characters - including some picks that may or may not have been chosen out of malice!

  1. Mario (Super Mario)
  2. Luigi
  3. Peach
  4. Bowser
  5. Daisy
  6. Waluigi
  7. Goomba
  8. Piranha Plant
  9. Dr. Mario
  10. Dr. Bowser
  11. Roy Koopa
  12. Fire Mario
  13. Small Mario
  14. Small Peach
  15. Mario and Yoshi
  16. Prince Peasley
  17. Vivian
  18. Baby Face
  19. President Koopa
  20. Yoshi (Yoshi)
  21. The Stork
  22. Pak E. Derm
  23. Donkey Kong (Donkey Kong)
  24. Diddy Kong
  25. King K. Rool
  26. Cranky Kong
  27. Dixie Kong
  28. Rambi
  29. Klump
  30. Stanley
  31. Pipsy
  32. Diddy Kong Head-Shaped CD
  33. Wario (Wario)
  34. Wario Land
  35. Ashley
  36. Jimmy T.
  37. Penny
  38. Captain Syrup
  39. Wario’s Nose
  40. Link (Zelda)
  41. Zelda
  42. Sheik
  43. Ganondorf
  44. Ganon
  45. Toon Link
  46. Toon Zelda
  47. Wild Link
  48. Octorok
  49. Moblin
  50. Bokoblin
  51. Ghirahim
  52. Midna
  53. Impa (Elderly)
  54. Toon Bokoblin
  55. Morshu
  56. Tingle (Tingle)
  57. Samus (Metroid)
  58. Ridley
  59. Metroid
  60. Kirby (Kirby)
  61. King Dedede
  62. Waddle Dee
  63. Whispy Woods
  64. Adeleine
  65. Daroach
  66. Dashing Super Guy
  67. Fox (Star Fox)
  68. Falco
  69. Peppy
  70. Arwing
  71. Andross
  72. Mewtwo (Pokemon)
  73. Jigglypuff
  74. Squirtle
  75. Ivysaur
  76. Rattata
  77. Ditto
  78. Magikarp
  79. Haunter
  80. Beedrill
  81. Krabby
  82. Ho-Oh
  83. Igglybuff
  84. Onix
  85. Genesect
  86. Meloetta
  87. Trubbish
  88. Braixen
  89. Rowlet
  90. Incineroar
  91. Iron Valiant
  92. Giovanni
  93. Lucy Fleetfoot
  94. Todd Snap
  95. Technology Guy
  96. MissingNo
  97. Ness (EarthBound)
  98. Lloyd
  99. Kumatora
  100. Master Belch
  101. Ice Climbers (Ice Climber)
  102. Topi US
  103. Topi JP
  104. Marth (Fire Emblem)
  105. Lucina
  106. Robin
  107. Corrin
  108. Byleth
  109. Oliver
  110. Mr. Game & Watch (Game & Watch)
  111. Pit (Classic) (Kid Icarus)
  112. Uprising Pit
  113. Olimar (Pikmin)
  114. Pikmin
  115. Bulborb
  116. Oatchi
  117. ROB (ROB)
  118. Villager (Animal Crossing)
  119. New Villager
  120. Crazy Redd
  121. KK Slider
  122. Wii Fit Trainer (Wii Fit)
  123. Little Mac (Punch-Out!)
  124. Glass Joe
  125. King Hippo
  126. Duck Hunt (Duck Hunt)
  127. Inkling (Splatoon)
  128. Callie/Marie
  129. Pearl/Marina
  130. Ted & Archie (Nintendogs)
  131. Yuka (Rhythm Heaven)
  132. Excitebiker (Excitebike)
  133. Jill (Drill Dozer)
  134. Sundes (Mole Mania)
  135. Who Are You Running From? (Game Boy Camera)
  136. Wii Remote Silicone Jacket (Wii)
  137. Mii Brawler (Mii)
  138. Mii Gunner
  139. Mii Swordfighter
  140. Fighting Polygon Team (Super Smash Bros.)
  141. Snake (Metal Gear)
  142. Senator Armstrong
  143. Sonic (Classic) (Sonic the Hedgehog)
  144. Tails
  145. Knuckles
  146. Dr. Eggman
  147. Super Sonic
  148. Modern Sonic
  149. Shadow
  150. Motobug/Flicky
  151. Big the Cat
  152. Fang the Sniper
  153. AoStH Robotnik
  154. Segapede
  155. Mega Man (Mega Man)
  156. Roll
  157. Bad Box Art Mega Man
  158. Pac-Man (Pac-Man)
  159. Ms. Pac-Man
  160. Blinky
  161. Pinky
  162. Inky
  163. Clyde
  164. Pac-Mom
  165. Gyaraga
  166. Taizo Hori
  167. Mappy
  168. Toc-Man
  169. Pac-Man 2
  170. Naked Blinky
  171. Ryu (Street Fighter)
  172. Ken
  173. Chun-Li
  174. Akuma
  175. Blanka
  176. Sakura
  177. Zangief
  178. M. Bison
  179. Vega
  180. Dracula (Castlevania)
  181. Captain N Alucard
  182. Cloud (Final Fantasy)
  183. Sephiroth
  184. Kefka
  185. Chocobo
  186. Tifa
  187. Barret
  188. Erdrick (Dragon Quest)
  189. Solo
  190. Eight
  191. Luminary
  192. Slime
  193. Jinjo (Banjo-Kazooie)
  194. Terry (Fatal Fury)
  195. Iori
  196. Nakoruru
  197. Steve (Minecraft)
  198. Ender Dragon
  199. Pig
  200. Kazuya (Tekken)
  201. Kuma
  202. Bob
  203. Yoshimitzu
  204. Lin
  205. Doomguy (Doom)
  206. Spider Mastermind
  207. Kratos (God of War)
  208. Zeus
  209. Arteus
  210. Master Chief (Halo)
  211. Arbiter
  212. Cortana
  213. Red (Angry Birds)
  214. Bad Piggy
  215. Big Smoke (Grand Theft Auto)
  216. I (Tetris)
  217. L/J
  218. Z/S
  219. O
  220. T
  221. Bubsy (Bubsy)
  222. Woolie
  223. Miner Willy (Manic Miner)
  224. Cursor (Windows)
  225. Clippy
  226. Inori Aizawa
  227. Yeti
  228. Space Cadet
  229. Gex (Gex)
  230. Rez
  231. Horace (Horace Goes Skiing)
  232. Lara Croft (Tomb Raider)
  233. Modern Lara
  234. Voodoo Vince (Voodoo Vince)
  235. Lockjaw (Rise of the Robots)
  236. Sqij (Sqij!)
  237. Urban Yeti (Urban Yeti)
  238. Putt-Putt (Junior Adventures)
  239. Pajama Sam
  240. Spy Fox
  241. Dingodile (Crash Bandicoot)
  242. Ripper Roo
  243. Tiny Tiger
  244. Pinstripe
  245. Nina Cortex
  246. Mettaton EX (Undertale)
  247. Undyne
  248. King Dice (Cuphead)
  249. Shovel Knight (Shovel Knight)
  250. Mona
  251. Peppino (Pizza Tower)
  252. The Noise
  253. Sim (The Sims)
  254. Sub-Zero (Mortal Kombat)
  255. Johnny Cage
  256. Gordon Freeman (Half Life)
  257. Headcrab
  258. Flappy Bird (Flappy Bird)
  259. Annalynn (Annalynn)
  260. Elizabert Megafig (Bugsnax)
  261. Snaxsquatch
  262. PaRappa (PaRappa the Rapper)
  263. Lammy
  264. Guru Ant
  265. Plok (Plok)
  266. Yumetaro (Mr. Gimmick)
  267. Dweeb (The Outfoxies)
  268. Professor Ching
  269. Kung Fu Man (MUGEN)
  270. Willy (Rockin’ Kats)
  271. Hat Kid (A Hat in Time)
  272. Bow Kid
  273. Sackboy (LittleBigPlanet)
  274. Aloy (Horizon)
  275. Penguin (Club Penguin)
  276. Om Nom (Cut the Rope)
  277. Crazy Dave (Plants vs. Zombies)
  278. Ben (Talking Friends)
  279. Power Pro (Power Pros)
  280. Evil Otto (Berzerk)
  281. Yorgle (Adventure)
  282. Jazz Jackrabbit (Jazz Jackrabbit)
  283. Space Invader (Space Invaders)
  284. Toejam and Earl (Toejam and Earl)
  285. Bonanza Bros (Bonanza Bros)
  286. Headdy (Dynamite Headdy)
  287. Ristar (Ristar)
  288. Kapu Kapu (ChuChu Rocket)
  289. Game Genie (Game Genie)
  290. Pin Bot (Pin Bot)
  291. Fall Guy (Fall Guys)
  292. Impostor (Among Us)
  293. UItra Fishbunjin 3000 (Ittle Dew)
  294. Masked Ruby
  295. Orka (Healthy Weapon)
  296. Business Casual Man (Slap City)
  297. Princess Remedy (Princess Remedy)
  298. Wrastor (Rivals of Aether)
  299. Elliana
  300. Ranno
  301. Pomme
  302. Monty Mole (Monty Mole)
  303. Bridget (Guilty Gear)
  304. Faust
  305. Untitled Goose (Untitled Goose Game)
  306. Commander Keen (Commander Keen)
  307. Delay Lama (Delay Lama)
  308. Lemming (Lemmings)
  309. Zoombinis (Zoombinis)
  310. Frog (Chrono Trigger)
  311. Skye (Darkened Skye)
  312. Freddy Fazbear (FNAF)
  313. Mei (Overwatch)
  314. Reaper
  315. Octane (Rocket League)
  316. Hornet (Daytona USA)
  317. Q*Bert (Q*Bert)
  318. Dragonborn (Skyrim)
  319. BD Joe (Crazy Taxi)
  320. Noob (Roblox)
  321. Peeley (Fortnite)
  322. Cuddle Team Leader
  323. Meow Skulls
  324. Geno
  325. Stubbs the Zombie (Stubbs the Zombie)
  326. Banjo Man (Phalanx)
  327. Chip (Chip’s Challenge)
  328. Bomberman (Bomberman)
  329. Act Zero Bomberman
  330. Pete (Harvest Moon)
  331. Boogerman (Boogerman)
  332. Blue Suede Goo (Clayfighter)
  333. Earthworm Jim (Earthworm Jim)
  334. Atrus (Myst)
  335. Kang Fu (Kang Fu)
  336. Drake (Drake of the 99 Dragons)
  337. Spike (Ape Escape)
  338. Sam Fisher (Tom Clancy)
  339. Rabbid (Rabbids)
  340. Bandito Chinchilla (Thrillville)
  341. Flo (Metal Slug)
  342. Shiori (Tokimeki Memorial)
  343. Jumbo Josh (Garten of Banban)
  344. Vibri (Vib Ribbon)
  345. Croc (Croc)
  346. Necky (Famitsu)
  347. Octodad (Octodad)
  348. Plane (Flight Simulator)
  349. Paddle (Pong)
  350. Reindog (Multiversus)
  351. Larry the Bird (Twitter)
  352. Dante (Devil May Cry)
  353. Vergil
  354. Cole (Infamous)
  355. Nathan Drake (Uncharted)
  356. Big Daddy (Bioshock)
  357. Radec (Killzone)
  358. Avatar (Ultima)
  359. Sock Puppet (Pets.com)
  360. Chosen Undead (Dark Souls)
  361. Baby (Super Monkey Ball)
  362. Diablo (Diablo)
  363. Annie (Anton)
  364. Bertie (Bertie the Brain)
  365. Fido (Don’t Buy This)
  366. Jake (Subway Surfers)
  367. Suzane (Blender)
  368. Bosch (Line Rider)
  369. Nemesis (Resident Evil)
  370. PB (Polar Bowler)
  371. Dingle Kringle (Elf Bowling)
  372. Big Rig (Big Rigs)
  373. Trapper (Dead by Daylight)
  374. Thrall (World of Warcraft)
  375. Aatrox (League of Legends)
  376. Leona
  377. Blitzcrank
  378. Danzaburou (Smite)
  379. Ultraman (Ultraman)
  380. Godzilla (Godzilla)
  381. Doraemon (Doraemon)
  382. Goku (Dragon Ball)
  383. Totoro (Studio Ghibli)
  384. Chibi Maruko-Chan (Chibi Maruko Chan)
  385. Darth Vader (Star Wars)
  386. Garfield (Garfield)
  387. Shrek (Shrek)
  388. SpongeBob (SpongeBob)
  389. Ronald McDonald (McDonalds)
  390. Homer Simpson (The Simpsons)
I read “Bandito Chinchilla” and it unlocked childhood memories I didn’t even remember I had
 

AlRex

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 12, 2012
Messages
1,154
I’m not gonna do a 200+ Smash roster just yet, but I’ve had an on again, off again fiddling around with a 5000 character roster doc that may eventually be completed, and some of these characters are noted, certainly.
 

Torgo the Bear

Smash Lord
Joined
Mar 30, 2019
Messages
1,176
Location
the country where the pretty girls are from
NNID
u2outofcontrol
Switch FC
SW-1209-7008-3905
By any chance the selection is merely based on your likes or there is more reasons for the selections? They are good but I'm kinda impressed for see characters like Crobat or White Mage apart of having the two Pits but not Palutena for some examples.
It's mainly based in my own interests and who I think would be the most interesting aesthetically.

However, I did intentionally make sure to include all of the original 12 Smash characters, and I enforced a rule that 10 characters would be considered clones of someone else.
 
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
895
Made a new take on a Super Smash Bros. reboot!

A 60-character roster for a SSB reboot? Mind if I throw in my two cents?

Super Mario: We have Mario, Luigi, Peach, Daisy, and Bowser. A perfect size for the franchise.
Mario Spinoffs: My one gripe here is that Funky Kong is the third DKC rep. I understand that he's meant to be a clone, but still.
Zelda: Two Links with different movesets, Ganon is the blue pig monster, and we get Vaati as the first non-Triforce wielder. I'd say the changes were for the better, with Sheik and Young Link being obvious cuts.
Fire Emblem: Marth, Roy, Robin, and Byleth. Those are the four I'd allow to stick around as well.
Pokemon: Who are the two newcomers? Also, would the likes of Mewtwo and Charizard at least appear as summons?
Metroid: Let's face it: We only needed Samus and Ridley.
Star Fox: Actually, I would also cut Wolf from the roster.
Mother: Kumatora replaces Lucas as the second fighter, but getting a newcomer from this series is still astonishing.
Kid Icarus: Maybe Palutena becomes an Assist Trophy?
Kirby: To admit with sheer honesty, Meta Knight isn't as mainstream as Kirby or Dedede are.
Xenoblade: Cutting Shulk in favor of Pyra and Mythra? I have mixed opinions on that, but I can see why you went there.
Punch-Out: I would have chosen King Hippo, but Mr. Sandman is equally as iconic as a second PO boxer goes.
Splatoon: Of course Octoling would make it in.
Retro Nintendo: Yes, I'm lumping Captain Falcon into the "retro" category, but between him, Duck Hunt, Mr. G&W, and ROB, we've got the best oldies remaining. Also, adding Prince Sable and Lip does add some appeal to longtime Smash fans.

Sonic the Hedgehog: It's about time we got another Sonic rep, and Eggman's good for the job.
Mega Man: Proto Man is in the game? Fair.
Street Fighter: If it came down to it, I would cut Ken with a lump in my stomach.
Pac-Man: Mrs. Pac-Man as a newcomer just makes me happy.
Rayman / Space Invaders: I'm glad to see them in here, although I wonder how the latter could fight.
Dragon Quest: Slime instead of the Heroes? Alright, it's your roster.
Associated Third-Parties: Is that Paimon? And what is that purple thing?
Kingdom Hearts: I'd cut both Cloud and Sephiroth if it meant Sora was in, and I'm not kidding.
Undertale: Are Sans and Papyrus a duo fighter? Why are they deemed as longshots on par with Sora and...
Popeye: POPEYE? You have Popeye in this roster? This excuses most of the disagreements I have with your roster if you pulled this stunt.

Honestly, despite a couple of things I wouldn't agree with, like the two Pokemon newcomers or cutting Shulk, Diddy Kong, and Cloud, the choices of newcomers make up for it in the long run.
 

Torgo the Bear

Smash Lord
Joined
Mar 30, 2019
Messages
1,176
Location
the country where the pretty girls are from
NNID
u2outofcontrol
Switch FC
SW-1209-7008-3905
Pokemon: Who are the two newcomers? Also, would the likes of Mewtwo and Charizard at least appear as summons?
Kid Icarus: Maybe Palutena becomes an Assist Trophy?
Rayman / Space Invaders: I'm glad to see them in here, although I wonder how the latter could fight.
Undertale: Are Sans and Papyrus a duo fighter?
Associated Third-Parties: Is that Paimon? And what is that purple thing?
The two new Pokemon are Crobat and Zorua.
Palutena would definitely be an Assist character, yes.
For the Space Invaders, you control the UFO and use the other Invaders as meatshields and projectiles. So, kind of like the between ground of Olimar and Rosalina.
Papyrus and Sans are credited as one character, but you only play as Papyrus. Sans, the lazy bones he is, just watches from the background, selling hot dogs.
That is not Paimon. It is the White Mage from Final Fantasy. And the "purple thing" is Baku from Yo-kai Watch.
 
Last edited:

BowserKing

Smash Lord
Joined
Feb 16, 2019
Messages
1,902
Location
winnipeg
Today is the 10 year anniversary of my favourite kids cartoon: Wander Over Yonder. With that I have a roaster in mind.

Wander Over Yonder vs Gravity Falls

Roaster
Wander Over Yonder Side
1.Wander
2.Sylvia
3.Lord Hater
4.Commander Peepers
5.Emperor Awesome
6.Prince Cashmire
7.Westley
8.Brad Starlight
9.Princess Demira
10.Rider
11.Lord Dominator
12.Dr.Screwball Jones
13.Starbella
14.Jeff (Major Threat)
15.Ripov
16.Scrooge McDuck (Guest Fighter)

Gravity Falls Side
1.Dipper
2.Mable
3.Grunkel Stan
4.Soos
5.Wendy
6.Old Man McGucket
7.Gideon
8.Pacifica
9.Candy
10.Grenda
11.Multi Bear
12.Rumple McSkirmish
13.Bill Cypher
14.GIFfany
15.Grunkel Ford
16.Luz (Guest Fighter)
 
Last edited:

nirvanafan

Smash Champion
Premium
Joined
Oct 14, 2016
Messages
2,727
Smash (or fangame) with a ridiculous roster in the 100s, sure ill give it try.

Just kept adding characters till i slowed up which was around 350 then did some brainstorming to reach 400.
  1. Mario
  2. Luigi
  3. Peach
  4. Daisy
  5. Bowser
  6. Bowser Jr.
  7. Rosalina & Luma
  8. Piranha Plant
  9. Waluigi
  10. Birdo
  11. Toad/Captain Toad
  12. Toadette
  13. King Boo
  14. Geno
  15. Vivian
  16. Fawful
  17. Waluigi
  18. Yoshi
  19. Kamek
  20. Baby Mario Bros.
  21. Poochy
  22. Wario
  23. Syrup
  24. Ashley
  25. Mona
  26. Jimmy T.
  27. Donkey Kong
  28. Diddy Kong
  29. Dixie Kong
  30. DK Crew
  31. King K Rool
  32. Pauline
  33. Donkey Kong Jr.
  34. Cranky Kong
  35. Funky Kong
  36. Candy Kong
  37. Wrinkly Kong
  38. Animal Buddies
  39. Link
  40. Zelda
  41. Ganondorf
  42. Ganon (Pig)
  43. Impa
  44. Skull Kid
  45. Tingle
  46. Vaati
  47. Medli
  48. Zant
  49. Ghirahim
  50. Yuga
  51. Master Khoga
  52. Darunia
  53. Mipha
  54. Pikachu
  55. Squirtle
  56. Ivysaur
  57. Charizard
  58. Jigglypuff
  59. Meowth
  60. Togepi
  61. Mewtwo
  62. Gengar
  63. Eevee
  64. Ditto
  65. Todd Snap
  66. Kirby
  67. Meta Knight
  68. King Dedede
  69. Adeline & Ribbon
  70. Prince Fluff
  71. Magalor
  72. Dark Matter
  73. Elffin
  74. Suzie
  75. Daroach
  76. Star Fox
  77. Star Wolf
  78. Krystal
  79. Andross
  80. Rob 64
  81. Samus
  82. Zero Suit Samus
  83. Ridley
  84. Raven Beak
  85. Sylux
  86. Ness
  87. Lucas
  88. Ninten
  89. Porky
  90. Giygas
  91. Captain Falcon
  92. Samurai Goroh
  93. Black Shadow
  94. Jody Summer
  95. Mr. EAD
  96. James McLeod
  97. Octoman
  98. Spade
  99. Marth
  100. Catria
  101. Camus
  102. Anna
  103. Nanna
  104. Lyn
  105. Lyon
  106. Black Knight
  107. Tiki
  108. Azura
  109. Felicia/Flora
  110. Reginn
  111. Flame Emperor
  112. Shez
  113. Yunaka & Emblem Micaiah
  114. Elenora & Virion
  115. Pit
  116. Palutena
  117. Medusa
  118. Hades
  119. Pandora
  120. Viridi
  121. Magnus
  122. Thanatos
  123. Olimar
  124. Oatchi
  125. Plasm Wraith
  126. Bulborb
  127. Isabelle
  128. Nooklings
  129. KK Slider
  130. Mr. Resetti
  131. Miis
  132. Wii Fit Trainer
  133. Little Mac
  134. King Hippo
  135. Shulk
  136. Pyra
  137. Mythra
  138. Lora
  139. Mio
  140. A
  141. Elma
  142. Kos Mos
  143. T Elos
  144. Inkling
  145. DJ Octavio
  146. Min Min
  147. Hedlok
  148. Chibi Robo
  149. Drake Redcrest
  150. Ray Mk II
  151. Bayonette
  152. Conductor (& Chorus Kids)
  153. Tibby
  154. Sami
  155. Nell
  156. Isaac
  157. Jenna
  158. Ice Climbers
  159. Mr. Game & Watch
  160. ROB
  161. Duck Hunt
  162. Ayumi
  163. Takamaru
  164. Ballon Fighter
  165. Bubbles
  166. Master Hand
  167. Solid Snake
  168. Liquid Snake
  169. Psycho Mantis
  170. Revolver Ocelot
  171. Gray Fox
  172. Raiden
  173. Senator Armstrong
  174. Blade Wolf
  175. Sonic
  176. Eggman
  177. Tails
  178. Knuckles
  179. Shadow
  180. Amy
  181. Cream & Cheese
  182. Team Chaotix
  183. Big
  184. Rouge
  185. Silver
  186. Blaze
  187. Sage
  188. Chaos 0
  189. Mega Man
  190. Wiley
  191. Zero
  192. Tron Bonne & Servbots
  193. Ryu
  194. Chun Li
  195. Bison
  196. Juri
  197. Dhalsim
  198. E. Honda
  199. Alex
  200. Vega
  201. Cloud
  202. Sephiroth
  203. Bartz & Boco
  204. Kefka
  205. Squall
  206. Cid (FF14)
  207. Yuna
  208. Vivi
  209. Bayonetta
  210. Balder
  211. Simon
  212. Alucard
  213. Joker
  214. Yu Narukami
  215. Makoto Yuki
  216. Morgana
  217. Teddie
  218. Jack Frost
  219. Igor
  220. Aigis
  221. Hero
  222. Slime
  223. Banjo & Kazooie
  224. Gruntilda
  225. Mumbo Jumbo
  226. Klungo
  227. Terry
  228. Mai
  229. Steve
  230. Wither
  231. Kazuya Mishima
  232. Yoshimitsu
  233. King
  234. Gun Jack (Jack-3)
  235. Kuma/Panda
  236. Alisa
  237. Sora
  238. Roxas
  239. Xehanort
  240. Axel
  241. Bomber Man
  242. Act 0 Bomber Man
  243. Jacky
  244. Wolf
  245. Vanessa
  246. Shun Di
  247. Lion
  248. Goh
  249. Kiryu Kazuma
  250. Goro Majima
  251. Ichiban Kasuga
  252. Sakamoto Ryōma
  253. Ryo
  254. Lan Di
  255. Beat
  256. DJ Professor K
  257. Gouji Rokkaku
  258. Onishima
  259. Arle Nadja & Tetrominos
  260. Dante
  261. Trish
  262. Vergil
  263. Lady
  264. Wesker
  265. Jill
  266. Nemesis
  267. Krauser
  268. Phoenix Wright
  269. Herlock Shomes
  270. Arthur
  271. Firebrand
  272. Morrigan
  273. Hsien-Ko
  274. Edward Falcon
  275. Ryoma
  276. Batsu
  277. Akira
  278. Ruby Heart
  279. Nightmare
  280. Raphael
  281. Tira
  282. Zasalamel
  283. Ivy
  284. Cervantes
  285. Chosen Undead
  286. Solaire
  287. Lloyd
  288. Yuri
  289. Agumon
  290. 2B
  291. Emil
  292. Gex
  293. Conker
  294. Berri
  295. Gregg
  296. Panther King
  297. Joanna
  298. Elvis
  299. Fulgore
  300. Orchid
  301. Sabrewulf
  302. Jago
  303. TJ Combo
  304. Hisako
  305. Juno/Vela
  306. Lupus
  307. J-Bomb
  308. Battletoads
  309. Evil Queen
  310. Master Chief
  311. Arbiter
  312. Cortana
  313. Prophet of Regret
  314. Doom Slayer
  315. Blazkowicz
  316. Dragonborn
  317. Vault Boy
  318. Crash/Coco
  319. Cortex
  320. Dingodile
  321. Tawna
  322. N. Tropy
  323. Oxide
  324. Spyro
  325. Hunter
  326. Captain Price
  327. Ghost
  328. Tracer
  329. D. Va
  330. Thrall
  331. Axel Steel
  332. Ryu Hayabusa
  333. Momiji
  334. Ayane
  335. Phase 4
  336. Zack
  337. Ryza
  338. Nyutengu
  339. Sol Badguy
  340. Ramlethal Valentine
  341. Jin Kisaragi
  342. Nu-13
  343. Rayman
  344. Ezio
  345. Commander Shepherd
  346. Garrus
  347. Tali
  348. Liara
  349. The Sim
  350. Big Smoke
  351. John Marston
  352. Jimmy Hopkins
  353. Cole Phelps
  354. Big Daddy (Bioshock)
  355. Scorpion
  356. Sub-Zero
  357. Lui Kang
  358. Raiden
  359. Mileena
  360. Shao Khan
  361. Chell
  362. Gordon Freeman
  363. Kratos
  364. Ratchet & Clank
  365. Ahri
  366. Jinx
  367. Jibanyan
  368. Prof. Layton
  369. Shantae
  370. Travis Touchdown
  371. Farmer (Harvest Moon/Story of Seasons)
  372. Shovel Knight
  373. Frisk
  374. Monika
  375. Cuphead
  376. Filia
  377. Hat Kid
  378. Reimu
  379. Traveler (Genshin)
  380. Earthworm Jim
  381. Crypto
  382. Lara Croft
  383. Agent 47
  384. Jonesy
  385. Geralt
  386. James Bond
  387. Oddjob
  388. Yugi
  389. Tony Hawk
  390. Hatsune Miku
  391. Goku
  392. Piccolo
  393. Darth Vader
  394. Boba Fett
  395. Batman
  396. Joker
  397. Spider Man
  398. Venom
  399. The Simpsons
  400. Krusty the Clown
 

KneeOfJustice99

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 29, 2018
Messages
2,222
Location
the building from smash mouth's astro lounge
Okay, so this is probably a weirder pick, but I think it'd be an interesting one to delve into: What if Sakurai didn't come back for Brawl?

According to what we know about the early stages of Brawl's conceptualisation, Satoru Iwata originally suggested that if he were director, he would have simply released a remastered port of Melee with online capabilities. With that in mind, I think it'd be interesting to conceptualise how that port might have looked, and some of the content that might have been potentially added to it (even if it'd admittedly be pretty minimal.)

With that in mind, let's see how Super Smash Bros. Melee: Encore would have looked!

RELEASE
Given that this game would only have been a port of Melee with a few changes, development would be unlikely to take as long as Brawl's did. With that in mind, I'm suggesting that the development of this port would also have started in October 2005, with the full design document being finalised by Feburary 2006 (which acts as our cutoff point for inclusions.) The game would have then been released for the holiday season of 2007, without Brawl's delayed development.

CHARACTERS
Probably the most controversial consideration - but Encore would have maintained Melee's base roster and not added any characters. I feel like, given how Sakurai has discussed his creative process for movesets and the like, it'd be unlikely that the new team would feel like they were equipped to add completely new picks, as much as I think it would be fantastic to see. However, some characters would be considered as holdovers from the original concept - these including Wario, Lucas, Snake, Sonic, Olimar and King Dedede. The idea of adding new characters at all would unfortunately be dropped. That said, certain characters would have a couple of changes, albeit purely cosmetic in nature.
  • Link, Zelda and Ganondorf would be redesigned to appear in their Twilight Princess forms.
  • Sheik would recieve a similar Twilight Princess-inspired redesign to that she recieved in Brawl.
  • Fox and Falco would be redesigned to appear in their Star Fox: Assault forms.
  • Captain Falcon would be redesigned to appear in his F-Zero GX form.
  • Mewtwo would also be slightly redesigned to appear a little "softer", akin to his look in Pokemon: The First Movie.
That being said, every character would now have six alternate costumes - all of which are simple palette swaps. These would be intended to reference other characters where possible, though unique textures wouldn't happen - so for instance, Mario's "stars and stripes" costume wouldn't be included.

STAGES
Every stage from Melee would return in Encore, albeit obviously with a few graphical touch-ups to make it look less like a game released in 2001. However, whilst I didn't feel that new characters would be reasonable, I do think it's a possibility that some new stages would be introduced.
  • Hyrule Castle and Saffron City would be brought into Encore as Past Stages from the first game, with a few touchups here and there but for the most part remaining true to their original vision.
  • Archanea would also be added as a de-facto Fire Emblem stage, utilsing the (admittedly limited) resources that were pooled into the original game to make this possible. In terms of appearance, it'd be similar to Castle Siege's first form, but without transformations.
  • Online Waiting Room would also be added, which is effectively a white-themed variation of Final Destination that can't be selected in typical play. This works akin to how it did in Brawl's WFC.
Yeah... that's it. As much as I'd like to suggest some more stages, I think this is a pretty decent (and honestly charitable) estimate of what might have happened for the time. Sorry, y'all.

MUSIC
That being said, I do think there's a possibility that stages would get a couple of additional music tracks. Don't get your hopes up, though - a lot of them are simply because other tracks enter the random rotation. For instance, Battlefield now has a chance of playing Multi-Man Melee and Multi-Man Melee 2 alongside just Battlefield. In other cases, direct gamerips from older (or related) games are used so that an orchestra isn't put to use - for example, Termina Field is pulled directly from The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask to play as part of Great Bay's rotation, whereas Fire Emblem is no longer in Temple's rotation due to Archanea being added. No stage will have more than three songs - you can select their alternate songs by holding down either L or R when selecting the stage. There's also two bonus pieces of unlockable music that you'll only find in the Sound Test - I'll get to them later.

MODES
Again, for the most part Encore's modes would remain similar to the original game's. I will note, however, that the Sound Test is available from the start - and doesn't have to be unlocked. That said - the main new menu option of note is Wi-Fi! Utilising Nintendo WFC, it's possible to fight opponents online. You have two options - With Friends, or With Anyone. These matches allow you to fight your friends or complete in battles that have the same degree of rules customisation that a typical local match would have - including being able to engage in either a basic battle or a team battle. Not only this, but it's possible to send your replays and snapshots to your friends using Wi-Fi! However, there's no method of communicating with others online in order to alleviate concerns of potential bullying or misuse.

TROPHIES
Whilst the disappointing lack of new characters might be a bummer to some people, a reasonably large number of new trophies would be added - bringing the number of trophies from 290 to 350. Amongst other things, the trophies Tamagon, Mario and Yoshi, and Samus Unmasked would be included in the international release - and Captain Olimar would unlock if you have a Pikmin save file, but would also be unlockable through normal means. Several of these trophies would outright reuse models or sprites from relatively recent games, such as some later Gamecube or Game Boy Advance titles. As such, a lot of them wouldn't be overly exciting - I imagine at least 10 would just be new Pokémon models from Pokémon Colesseum - though some familiar characters, such as Lucas, would recieve trophies too.

Furthermore, to attempt to honour the original request of Hideo Kojima, Solid Snake would be included as the series' first third-party trophy - with Sonic the Hedgehog being second at the behest of Yuji Naka. Neither of them would, however, be playable. Upon unlocking them, Encounter (ripped directly from Metal Gear Solid) and Green Hill Zone (ripped directly from Sonic the Hedgehog) would be unlocked to listen to in the Sound Test, but can't be played on any stages.

ITEMS
Not much to report here. In terms of Pokéball Pokémon, Ditto finally functions as intended - similarly to its function in Ultimate. However, the Cloaking Device and Motion-Sensor Bomb items would be removed, due to potential licensing issues with Rare given their recent acquisition.

GAMEPLAY
I should note that this version of the game would be based on v1.02, which would include some of the bug fixes present in that version. However, in keeping with the vision of maintaining this as a port, certain gameplay elements would be kept in place mostly because removing or replacing them would lend to the game being pretty different - and remember, this doesn't need to be high-effort.

BONUS CONTENT
Six of the seven Bonuses that were cut from Classic Mode have been added back - these being Barrel Blast KO, Crash & Burn, Green Shell Shooter, Poolshark, Red Shell Shooter, and Richochet Rifler. The exception to this is Deflector, which is due to the fact that it's unclear what it actually would have rewarded you for. Furthermore, Archives is now accessible in all regions, containing the How To Play video, the Special Movie that was previously NTSC-exclusive, and the Opening Movie.

IN CLOSING
Whilst I think this would be a pretty interesting alternate universe to look into, I'm kind of curious how it would have affected the series going forward. Whilst I think I can speak for all of us when I say I'm kind of glad Brawl happened, it'd be a strange world where it didn't.
 

DragonRobotKing26

Smash Champion
Joined
Sep 26, 2021
Messages
2,731
Location
Earth-201769
I liked to participate the DC VS Marvel: Infinity Crisis,so i wanted a sequel of the thread

DC VS Marvel 2: Injustice War (The title makes reference of the sagas 'Injustice' and 'civil war')

Marvel Side
1-Captain America
2-Iron Man
3-Thor
4-Hulk
5-Spider-Man
6-Wolverine
7-Doctor Strange
8-Black Panther
9-Namor
10-Vision
11-Nova (Richard Rider)
12-Black Window
13-Hawkeye (Clint Barton)
14-Captain Marvel
15-Daredevil
16-Phoenix
17-Black Cat
18-Venom
19-Carnage
20-She-Hulk
21-Ghost Rider
22-Mr. Fantastic
23-Doctor Doom
24-Apocalypse
25-Ultimate Spider-Man (Miles Morales)
26-Ant Man
27-Deadpool
28-Scarlet Witch
30-Wasp
31-Winter Soldier
32-Magneto
33-Cyclops
34-Quicksilver
35-Ultron

DC Side
1-Superman
2-Batman
3-Wonder Woman
4-Flash (Barry Allen)
5-Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)
6-Martian Manhunter
7-Joker
8-Lex Luthor
9-Aquaman
10-Blue Beetle
11-Green Arrow
12-Doctor Fate
13-Shazam
14-Nightwing
15-Red Hood
16-Harley Quinn
17-Catwoman
18-Supergirl
19-Raven
20-Bane
21-Lobo
22-Elastic Man
23-Atom
24-Static
25-Doomsday
26-Black Adam
27-Zatanna
28-John Constantine
29-Deathstroke
30-Bumblebee
31-Gorilla Drodd
32-Black Manta
33-Black Canary
34-Poison Ivy
35-Brainiac

Guest Characters
1-Judge Dredd
2-Hellboy
3-Kick-Ass
4-Green Ranger (Tommy Oliver)
5-Billy Butcher
6-Savage Dragon
 

Wario Wario Wario

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
11,905
Location
Cheese Wheels of Doom
3 takes on a "4th parties" fighter pass

MAXIMUM REACTIONS
  1. Goku (Commonly mentioned in discussions of 4th parties in Smash, same applies to the next 2)
  2. Shrek
  3. SpongeBob
  4. Doraemon (Not well-known outside of JP)
  5. Homer Simpson (Not well-known in JP)

MAXIMUM NINTENDO CONNECTIONS
  1. James Bond (GoldenEye)
  2. Popeye (Donkey Kong was conceived as a Popeye game)
  3. Michelangelo (TMNT (or should that be TMHT) was the main reason the NES found an audience in Europe)
  4. Mario (Bob Hoskins) (Literally Mario)
  5. Scrooge McDuck (One of the most beloved NES games, so much so that he was one of the most popular 4th party picks during the era of NES-talgia)

MAXIMUM GAMING CONNECTIONS
  1. Tony Hawk
  2. Darth Vader
  3. Batman
  4. Spider-Man
  5. E.T.
 
Joined
Aug 14, 2021
Messages
6,683
Location
Bloodsauce Dungeon, Pizza Tower, ???
Since I'm getting brainrot from TMNT, I decided to create a TMNT tradifighting game based on various universes of the franchise. It's like "Turtles forever as fighting game". This isn't first time where TMNT has got a fighting game. I got 3 of them, but it won't hurt if we did a 4th one...

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Multiversal Mayhem!
The game is a traditional 2.5D fighting game made by Arc System Works and it\s based on various variations of the franchise (minus the live action ones). It ranges from mirage comics to mutant mayhem universe. The game is similar to Guilty Gear and street fighter, but it's based on TMNT (it also takes cues from TMNT tournament fighters game from 1990's).

The roster:
1. Raphael (Mirage)
2. Leonardo (1987)
3. Michelangelo (2003)
4. Donatello (2012)
5. Shredder/Oroku Saki (1987)
6. Bebop (1987)
7. Rocksteady (2012)
8. April O'Neil (1987)
9. April O'Neil (ROTTMNT) (She would use her bat)
10. Krang (1987)
11. Splinter (2003)
12. Leatherface (2012)
13. Jennika (IDW)
14. Karai (Mirage)
15. Rat King (1987)
16. Slash (Archie)
17. Tokka & Rahzar (1987 & 2012)
18. Baxter Stockman (1987)
19. Lord Dregg (2012)
20. Bishop (2003)
21. Miyamoto Usagi (Dark horse)
22. Casey Jones (1987)
23. Hun (2003)
24. Ice Cream Kitty (2012) (Joke character)

Boss fighters:
1. Tengu Shredder
2. Superfly

Cowabunga pass 1:
1. Metalhead (1987)
2. Cassandra Jones (ROTTMNT)
3. Superfly (as playable)
4. Attila the Punk frog (1987)
5. Mutagen Man (2012)
6. Sol Badguy (Guest - due to being made by Arc System Works)

Cowabunga pass 2:
1. Umeko (TMNT Adventures)
2. Tiger claw (2012)
3. Tengu Shredder (as playable)
4. Wingnut (Mutant Mayhem - due to small amount of Mutant mayhem representation, I wanted him in form of 2023 movie)
5. Drako (2003)
6. Batman (Due to being connected to the franchise by comic crossover and Injustice 2)

(I didn't included live action versions because it would be too hard to redraw the realistic characters and that representation would look jarring comparing to drawn/animated ones. I'm allowing only drawn/animated universes of TMNT to get representation)

Note: I know some of variants of characters are kinda random, but i wanted to go with "multiverse" aspect where random incarnations of characters appear and I wanted to go little bit crazy due to TMNT being a crazy/juxtaposition franchise due to being a parody of superhero comics like creators of franchise said.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
895
Call me crazy, but I made an all-encompassing Mario Spinoff roster. Kart racing? Golf? Tennis? Olympics? Anything else? It doesn't matter.
 

Champion of Hyrule

Smash Master
Writing Team
Joined
Sep 15, 2018
Messages
4,343
Location
*doxxes myself*
SEGA Superstars Skateboarding
1. Sonic
2. Tails
3. Knuckles
4. Alex Kidd
5. Lion Rafale
6. Ulala
7. Beat
8. Aiai
9. Ichiban Kasuga
10. Arle Nadja
11. Joker
12. Skull

Notes about how I made these character decisions:
  • Tried to make this roster “realistic” for the concept of a SEGA skateboarding game and part of that also meant characters who make sense with a skateboarding aesthetic so younger and more “hip” characters are emphasized. Well I guess Ichiban is 42 but you know what I mean.
  • I admit Lion Rafale is a bit of a weird pick but I felt like it might make sense to have someone who feels more like a “sports villain” and Lion’s rich boy personality definitely fits this
  • I imagine everyone would be in “skateboarder clothes” so imagine all those characters but dripped out
  • A character from Go Go Hypergrind was considered since that’s actually a Sega owned game about skateboarding but it’s extremely obscure and probably has some rights issues about it so maybe as DLC but not likely
  • The one helping you if you’re hurt is, I dunno, someone from Trauma Centre
 

darkvortex

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 1, 2023
Messages
2,356
a new Sonic Riders

  1. Sonic (Type: Speed)
  2. Tails (Type: Flight)
  3. Knuckles (Type: Power)
  4. Jet (Type: Speed)
  5. Wave (Type: Flight)
  6. Storm (Type: Power)
  7. Amy (Type: Speed)
  8. Cream (Type: Flight)
  9. Big (Type: Power)
  10. Shadow (Type: Speed)
  11. Rouge (Type: Flight)
  12. Eggman (Type: Power)
  13. Blaze (Type: Speed)
  14. Silver (Type: Flight)
  15. Mighty (Type: Power)
  16. Espio (Type: Speed)
  17. Charmy (Type: Flight)
  18. Vector (Type: Power)
  19. Tangle (Type: Speed)
  20. Wisper (Type: Power)
  21. Sticks (Type: Flight)
  22. Fang (Type: Speed)
  23. Chaos (Type: Power)
  24. Metal Sonic (Type: Flight)
  25. Classic Sonic (Type: Speed)
  26. Beat (Type: Speed)
  27. NiGHTS (Type: Flight)
  28. Alex Kidd (Type: Power)
 
Last edited:

CapitaineCrash

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 30, 2018
Messages
2,876
Location
Canada, Québec
Made a roster recently for a Microsoft fighting game. I decided 22 characters, which might seems fairly small but it was the size of Nasb roster incuding Garfield and Shredder. Also I figured I'd add Activision characters because at this point I doubt the acquisition is getting blocked.

1. Master chief (Halo)
2. Arbiter (Halo)
3. Marcus Fenix (Gears of war)
4. Kait Diaz (Gears of war)
5. Myrrah (Gears of war)
6. Banjo & Kazooie (Banjo-Kazooie)
7. Gruntilda (Banjo-Kazooie)
8. Conker (Conker)
9. Joanna Dark (Perfect dark)
10. Fulgore (Killer instinct)
11. Jago (Killer instinct)
12. Rash (Battletoads)
13. Blinx (Blinx)
14. Ori (Ori)
15. Raz (Psychonauts)
16. Steve (Minecraft)
17. Hero of Oakvale (Fable)
18. Crash Bandicoot (Crash Bandicoot)
19. Spyro (Spyro the dragon)
20. Doomguy (Doom)
21. Dohvakkin (The elder scrolls)
22. Chai (Hifi rush)

And dlc:
1. Kameo (Kameo elements of power)
2. Eddie Riggs (Brutal legend)
3. Tracer (Overwatch)
4. Vault boy (Fallout)
5. Corvo Attano (Dishonored)
 

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,250
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Paper Mario
The Emblem Chronicles

Story
The tales of many a hero have been chronicled for centuries, all spanning across different worlds and different times. One day, however, a dark entity known only as the Fell Blaze seeks to erase all of history by burning the chronicles down to the last cinder. Elimine, an ancient hero who has seen the countless legends herself, sends 12 of the fabled heroes and herself inside a book chronicling the stories of an even greater hero…Mario. Following the word of Elimine, Mario and his allies must travel across the world forged from the remains of the other heroes’ chronicles and find Emblem Cards that can summon them in corporeal form.

The main gameplay takes inspiration from Trails in the Sky; Mario mostly travels on an overworld and can engage enemies by touching them (or, if you prefer, jumping on them or smacking them with a hammer). The actual battles take place on a grid where you can select units to move or attack, but the twist is that the actual combat is closer to Paper Mario 64’s gameplay. This is mixed in with the Emblem Cards, which offer different abilities based on the character represented by the card.
  • Mario
  • Luigi
  • Peach
  • Toad
  • Bowser
  • Bowser Jr.
  • Marth
  • Alm & Celica
  • Sigurd
  • Leif
  • Roy
  • Lyn
  • Ephraim & Eirika
  • Ike
  • Micaiah
  • Lucina
  • Corrin
  • Byleth
(Basically, I designed this to be an alternate take on Engage)
 
Joined
Feb 9, 2023
Messages
895
Paper Mario
The Emblem Chronicles

Story
The tales of many a hero have been chronicled for centuries, all spanning across different worlds and different times. One day, however, a dark entity known only as the Fell Blaze seeks to erase all of history by burning the chronicles down to the last cinder. Elimine, an ancient hero who has seen the countless legends herself, sends 12 of the fabled heroes and herself inside a book chronicling the stories of an even greater hero…Mario. Following the word of Elimine, Mario and his allies must travel across the world forged from the remains of the other heroes’ chronicles and find Emblem Cards that can summon them in corporeal form.

The main gameplay takes inspiration from Trails in the Sky; Mario mostly travels on an overworld and can engage enemies by touching them (or, if you prefer, jumping on them or smacking them with a hammer). The actual battles take place on a grid where you can select units to move or attack, but the twist is that the actual combat is closer to Paper Mario 64’s gameplay. This is mixed in with the Emblem Cards, which offer different abilities based on the character represented by the card.
  • Mario
  • Luigi
  • Peach
  • Toad
  • Bowser
  • Bowser Jr.
  • Marth
  • Alm & Celica
  • Sigurd
  • Leif
  • Roy
  • Lyn
  • Ephraim & Eirika
  • Ike
  • Micaiah
  • Lucina
  • Corrin
  • Byleth
(Basically, I designed this to be an alternate take on Engage)
Okay, but do the Fire Emblem characters look like Paper Mario characters in this game or not?
 

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,250
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Okay, but do the Fire Emblem characters look like Paper Mario characters in this game or not?
Kind of? They’d be based on their Heroes sprites…which sport a similar enough art style that one wouldn’t look too out of place when placed next to the other.
IMG_2361.jpeg IMG_2500.png
 

Infinity Sorcerer

Smash Champion
Joined
Sep 24, 2020
Messages
2,372
Location
Right Behind You
Impossible Size Smash Roster because I like to participate in trends even if it was like a week ago goddamn that's a long name for a game.
100% fun and bias drived.
Some of these characters aren't like favorites of mine but I saw some concepts for them that I find very cool.

If the torder seems quite odd, is not only me lacking the ability to actually arrange in perfect squares a roster, but I also dislike when the franchises are cut in parts so I tried to mantain all the characters from a series in the same row
 
Last edited:

Wario Wario Wario

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
11,905
Location
Cheese Wheels of Doom
Impossible Size Smash Roster because I like to participate in trends even if it was like a week ago goddamn that's a long name for a game.
100% fun and bias drived.
Some of these characters aren't like favorites of mine but I saw some concepts for them that I find very cool.

If the torder seems quite odd, is not only me lacking the ability to actually arrange in perfect squares a roster, but I also dislike when the franchises are cut in parts so I tried to mantain all the characters from a series in the same row
Classic as the default Sonic design is incredibly based - that being said, it's cancelled out by plumber being the default Wario design. Ew.
 

Infinity Sorcerer

Smash Champion
Joined
Sep 24, 2020
Messages
2,372
Location
Right Behind You
Classic as the default Sonic design is incredibly based - that being said, it's cancelled out by plumber being the default Wario design. Ew.
It's mostly to reflectthe idea that I saw of a moveset more based in his platform games, I like the WarioWare design more too but it was moreso that just for that, I ain't like a Sonic fan but I like more the classic sonic look too.
 

FazDude

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 26, 2021
Messages
3,151
Location
Wherever good books are sold.
My ideal Echo lineup. Barring characters who already have echoes and being able to make minor skeleton tweaks if need be. Cross-series is only in effect for the "retro" franchises, but their replacement picks must remain in that pantheon.
  • Mario: Jumpman
  • DK: Funky Kong (different aerials)
  • Link: Twilight Link (reverted grab/Down Special)
  • Yoshi: Boshi
  • Kirby: Gooey
  • Fox: Fay
  • Pikachu: Raichu
  • Luigi: Gooigi
  • Ness: Ninten
  • Captain Falcon: Jody Summer
  • Jigglypuff: Igglybuff
  • Bowser: Midbus
  • Ice Climbers: Topis (US design)
  • Sheik: Impa
  • Zelda: Hilda
  • Dr. Mario: Foreman Spike
  • Pichu: Plusle/Minun
  • Falco: Miyu
  • Young Link: Ravio
  • Ganondorf: Demise
  • Mewtwo: Mega Mewtwo X
  • Mr. Game & Watch: Ms. Game & Watch
  • Meta Knight: Galacta Knight
  • Zero Suit Samus: Gandrayda
  • Wario: Vampire Wario
  • Snake: Liquid Snake
  • Ike: Black Knight
  • Squirtle: Wartortle
  • Ivysaur: Venusaur
  • Charizard: Charmander
  • Diddy Kong: Dixie Kong
  • Lucas: Kumatora
  • Sonic: Classic Sonic
  • King Dedede: Forgo Dedede
  • Olimar: Alph
  • Lucario: Zeraora
  • ROB: Virtual Boy
  • Toon Link: Tetra
  • Wolf: Leon
  • Villager: Islander (New Horizons-based)
  • Mega Man: Proto Man
  • Wii Fit Trainer: Ring Fit Adventurer
  • Rosalina & Luma: Kamek & Toady
  • Little Mac: Glass Joe
  • Greninja: Frogaider
  • Palutena: Medusa
  • Pac-Man: Ms. Pac-Man
  • Robin: Celica
  • Shulk: Noah? Maybe?
  • Bowser Junior: Fawful
  • Duck Hunt: Classic Duck Hunt (more slapstick based)
  • Cloud: Zach Fair
  • Corrin : Kana
  • Bayonetta: Jeanne
  • Inkling: Octoling
  • Ridley: Neo Ridley
  • King K. Rool: Kaptain K. Rool
  • Isabelle: Digby
  • Incineroar: Hawlucha
  • Piranha Plant: Nipper Plant
  • Joker: Violet
  • Hero: Erik
  • Banjo & Kazooie: Tooty & Baby Breegull
  • Terry: Rock
  • Byleth: Edelgard
  • Min Min: Spring Man
  • Steve: Piglin
  • Sephiroth: Young Sephiroth
  • Pyra/Mythra: Pneuma
  • Kazuya: Jin
  • Sora: Roxas
 

Wario Wario Wario

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
11,905
Location
Cheese Wheels of Doom
A while back I made a newcomer roster for an Ultimate sequel, don't know if I ever posted it here, but I just added some echoes, and kinda feel like going through why I went with the characters I did


I'll do the unique characters first, since a lot of the reasoning for the echoes was derived from gaps in this set. The aim here was to please both Celebration-of-Gaming fans and Nintendo All-Stars fans, and fill perceived gaps in the roster without just overloading it with fan-requests. Realism wasn't considered.
  1. Waluigi is the fan demand pick of the 1Ps. That's really the whole rationale. Of the major 1P fan picks, he's my favourite, and also probably the most popular from a mainstream perspective.
  2. Impa, Midna, and Tingle were all in response to a percieved lack of Zelda rep. There aren't really any fully agreed upon Zelda reps who are overwhelmingly wanted by fans, even if Ninja Impa and Skull Kid seem to be more popular, that isn't overwhelming. Impa was chosen for her importance, with Elderly Impa being chosen in specific for making up the majority of Impa appearances and lending herself to a more unique moveset, along with a lack of geriatric characters in fighting games. this was before the nasb 2 leak I tried to make sure the female characters were unlike the usual female characters of Smash, since most of the women in Smash fall into the camp of "slender, pretty, human, young adult" - not that there's anything wrong with that alone (as you'll see with a later 1P pick), but it's nice to have more diverse female designs.
  3. I really like Midna's character design, and I think that her whole hair thing lends itself to a fun moveset. TP fans were probably disappointed by Ultimate, so she fills that niche. Being a non-human female character is also an advantage she brings.
  4. A lack of modern Kirby rep is a common criticism of Smash, and Susie fills that niche, being a bit of a fan favourite from what many consider the definitive best Kirby game. She also has a very abstract design, which is fun, especially for a female character.
  5. Youngster was a me pick - I wanted more Gen 1, and I wanted a weaker, sillier Pokemon like Squirtle, Jigglypuff, and Pichu before him. While there are other Pokemon that fit either or both descriptors I'd prefer, I think Youngster's trio (Pidgey, Rattata, and Zubat) is so iconic that it's hard to really shoot down or view as "random", and a second Pokemon stance fighter has been a common request since Brawl.
  6. The lack of legendary Pokemon representation in Smash is quite bizarre from an objective standpoint, and Genesect just fits Smash perfectly as a mobile, powerful, and fast creature. Gen 5 is, like Robobot, often considered the best Pokemon game, so it makes sense to represent it here.
  7. While not particularly popular Smash requests, Callie and Marie are in a similar spot to Isabelle as being overwhelmingly popular outside of that niche, and probably having a large support base that's just silent and doesn't frequent Smash forums.
  8. Rhythm Heaven has been a popular Smash pick for a while, and had a few devastating close calls. Yuka was chosen because she's so generic that she can basically do anything. Hanging on to a rocket, partaking in a quiz show, slashing a sword - she could basically do anything because she's just... a girl who hangs out with monkeys. Unlike Karate Joe, the Chorus Boys, or the Wandering Samurai who are all very specific in themes. Rhythm games are also not yet repped in Smash
  9. Tingle is a bit of a me pick, he's very much a popular character, and has received quite a bit of re-evaluation in recent years from the Westerners who once got him banned from the Zelda series. I think I like Tingle as a sort of way of saying "hey, the dust has settled, you want to give this guy another go?" choice. I also like that he represents a spin-off series that isn't Mario.
  10. Going into third parties, the reasons will be a lot more simple since 3Ps are nowhere near as comprehensive as they exist today. Case in point: Dr. Eggman. Sonic is underrepped, villains are underrepped, Eggman is one of the most iconic villains and one of the most iconic Sonics.
  11. Blanka was a me pick of sorts. It doesn't really make sense to only rep a fighting game series, known for its wide cast, with the basic protagonist - and Blanka is my favourite of the SF cast.
  12. M-rated games are underrepped, gritty games are underrepped, Western games are underrepped - these 3 things were all being kept in mind heavily for 3Ps. CJ is a somewhat humourous pick that would catch people off-guard and get people talking - but, like Steve, makes perfect sense when you step back and forget about the Smash discourse and fan rules.
  13. Sub-Zero basically has the same reasoning as CJ, even if not exactly as memetic. I chose Sub-Zero over Scorpion simply because I think ice is more unique, with there only really being one character in Smash who is mostly ice-based. Also a bit interesting as a series that has infamously flopped in Japan. MK also has an interesting role in Nintendo history, which would give SZ's inclusion a bit of irony factor.
  14. Kratos is the most iconic PlayStation character, and falls under the gritty Western M-rated camp. I think I would want to encourage a Nintendo-based audience to learn more about PS.
  15. PaRappa supplements Kratos as a sort of way to say to Nintendo fans "hey, PlayStation does silly kiddie stuff too!". A lot of PaRappa fans haven't played the games, so it's very likely that he has a bigger fandom overlap with Nintendo than any other PS character. Also technically the first rhythm game (this title is somewhat dubious, but mostly correct) so a nice game to honour. Also a me-pick, as should be obvious
  16. Master Chief fills the big 3 criteria I was looking for, and also properly represents Xbox after two non-Xbox-associated Microsoft reps.
  17. Nintendo fans don't like Call of Duty - at all, it almost has a cryptid-like status where nobody in the Nintendo scene knows anything about it, but hates it for... killing platformers or something (which it didn't). Ghost is probably the most controversial non-echo on the roster for this, so I guess you could call him an "evil pick". I think a game this big should probably be represented somehow, and it'd be nice to try and quell the sheer hatred Nintendo fans have for COD, even if it'd be at its most intense before the reveal sets in. Ghost was chosen because the mask gives him a slightly more stylised edge.
  18. Adventurer? Want to teach Nintendo fans about history, simple really. I chose the square over the dragons/ducks/seahorses because well... playing as a faceless square is funny, and feels more representative of "character design" of the era.

Now, the echoes, these were a little more driven by personal bias.
  1. Dr. Bowser is THE joke pick. I have no non-comedic justification for him, that's why he got in. Just a weird, obscure, excessively nonsensical pick who gets a quick laugh every time you hover over him on the CSS. While I like Igglybuff and Small Mario better for this role, I think that Dr. Bowser benefits from being more obscure (being from a defunct mobile game), the sheer juxtaposition of a powerful monster being a professional heathcare expert, and technically being a mixture of two Smash characters. It all just culminates in something very bizarre and questionable, wheras Small Mario and Igglybuff are well known characters in their own right regardless of how frail they are.
  2. Paula is just a very obvious pick - all of Ness' moves are from her, why wouldn't she get in as an echo? Plus, she is really the true hero of EarthBound all things considered. I think having female echoes of male characters is a very good thing to do, so people who want to play as a woman but like the moveset of another character could have an option.
  3. Malos was a response to a mistake I feel I made with the initial version - an overcorrection on "anime swordfighters".
  4. While the other 2 retro picks are third party, The Amazon is for the retro Nintendo fans specifically. I also think cross-series echoes are fun, and The Amazon makes a lot of sense since few of Incin's moves are that heavily themed, while Pro Wrestling is a very popular NES title.
  5. The Classic Sonic games are near-universally regarded as the series' peak, so it's frankly a little bizarre as is that the series' representation leans so much towards the modern games. Hell, I could imagine Modern Sonic being the one with the echo e and adjective in his name this go around.
  6. Most of the 3P picks here are general gaming history picks rather than Nintendo picks, with Blanka as the main and barely-counting exception - Roll is here to somewhat remedy that, so the Nintendo side of the fandom gets a pick they're more familiar with in the 3P pool. I chose her over ProtoMan for the same reason I mentioned for Paula earlier.
  7. Zack Fair was added for the same reason as Malos. Additionally, FF is such a big deal that it'd be strange to not give it a 3rd rep.
  8. Giana is a historical curio, which I think is fun. I regretted not putting in a microcomputer rep (I couldn't think of one who didn't overlap somehow with Adventurer), and I think having a rip-off game represented as an echo fighter is just very cheeky and clever. This Giana would have a design similar to her original version instead of the Twisted Dreams version to further drive in the intent as a microcomputer rep, but would also be less ugly and a little more cartoonish, sorta like a reverse Pit. I think it's nice to represent something Nintendo were previously against, like with Sub-Zero earlier.
 
Last edited:

KneeOfJustice99

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 29, 2018
Messages
2,222
Location
the building from smash mouth's astro lounge
Something I brought up in a conversation earlier today was how I personally think that Gameboy Smash Bros. concepts sort of limit themselves because of their tendency to only include around six fighters (whether this is due to Super Smash Land or a desire to include less than Super Smash Bros., I'm not 100% sure.) That said, fighting games on the Game Boy weren't actually as small as you might expect - hell, The King of Fighters '95 had no less than 18 unique characters, including the port-exclusive Nakoruru!

Oh - and as for controls, the fact that there's only two action buttons shouldn't be a problem. Directional inputs coupled with a Normal or Special attack input should suffice, with the D-Pad being used to jump in the Up position. It was pretty common for ported fighting games to the console to use a unique Light/Heavy attack system with the two buttons like that, so that's what I'd suggest. Unfortunately, this means grabbing and throwing aren't available yet - but it does make it possible to have both directional Normal and Special attacks, even if we don't have a difference between tilts and smash attacks yet.

That said, I ended up wondering to myself - if the first Smash game had been a Game Boy title released circa early 1996, what could its roster have looked like? Introducing... Smash Bros.! (Yes, it isn't Super yet. Shh.)



You'll note that this is a somewhat... eclectic mix, even by today's standards - but I think this is a genuinely good indication of Nintendo's output at around this time. The immediate elephant in the room is the lack of Pokémon content - but given the release date was specifically picked to avoid it, I felt it'd allow for a bit more focus on a pretty interesting period in Nintendo's history! Also, no clones - I felt characters like Luigi or Dark Link, whilst possible, would be illogical on a monochrome screen with only four colours.

Anyways, let's look at the roster one-by-one:
  • Mario is obviously our first character, though I should note that his design here is predominantly based on a fusion between his Super Mario Land series appearances with small elements from Super Mario World - though he'd mostly use items in his moveset as opposed to relying purely on his own physicality. Not much to comment on here aside from that, though.
  • Link comes second, and he's based primarily on his look in Link's Awakening though also on A Link to the Past. He'd fight predominantly using his array of items with differing effects, coupled with sword swings to bring it all together. That said, he wouldn't bring over a magic meter or anything like that, mostly just relying on fairly basic items overall - some of which we've seen in Smash like the Hookshot, Boomerang and Bow, and others we haven't yet seen like the Mirror Shield and the Pegasus Boots.
  • Kirby is third, with a moveset predominantly inspired by his Game Boy titles with little hints of other titles. He mainly fights using Copy Abilities, but I do think his Animal Friends would also make for a fun and cool inclusion on top of that. As for whether to include his Smash Bros. ability to copy other fighters... sure, why not! He'd only copy their Neutral Special, though.
  • Donkey Kong Jr. is a bit more unorthodox. See, Donkey Kong himself would make a lot of sense here - but Jr. feels like he'd fulfil the role of a true "retro" pick a lot better, whilst also having some degree of relevance considering his appearances in games like Super Mario Kart and Mario's Tennis. It's also partially because I think representing Donkey Kong Country would sort of necessitate the use of digitized sprites, which... I don't think look very good on the Game Boy. His moveset would, as such, predominantly be pulled from the arcade Donkey Kong titles - using various elements, like his father's barrels, Stanley's bug spray, and even Jumpman's whip!
  • Samus is predomianantly inspired by her appearance in Super Metroid, with some elements from Metroid II: Return of Samus. In terms of her gameplay, she's intended to more closely mirror her source material with a generally more mobile nature, though her focus on projectiles does still land her in the role of a zoner. I wouldn't have her as complex as some fans have suggested in the past, but I would include various items like the Ice Beam for the sake of representing a wider variety of her own repertoire.
  • Marth is probably the biggest departure from his Smash Bros. incarnation, in that his moveset is intended to reflect the gameplay of the Fire Emblem series as opposed to just the concepts behind his own design. Whilst he does maintain stylish sword slashes, his specials involve him "summoning" characters of different classes from Fire Emblem: Mystery of the Emblem, which each have a unique attack of their own. He's also designed to mirror his appearance later in the first game, having both the Falchion and the Fire Emblem shield.
And, as for unlockable fighters...
  • Wario is here as our main "antagonist", picked over Bowser because of his growing popularity at the time and the fact that he was blossoming into his own series at this point! As such, his design is primarily based on that of Wario Land: Super Mario Land 3, though with minor elements of his boss battle in Super Mario Land 2: Six Golden Coins at play as well.
  • Ayumi Tachibana might seem unorthodox, but I think she'd be a genuinely good pick as another "retro" character, on top of representing another new genre - visual novels! The Famicom Disc System had quite a few prominent games that I considered representing, with me also considering Shin Onigashima, but I felt that given Famicom Detective Club was also seeing Satellaview rereleases, she'd be an awesome pick. As for her moveset, she relies on an unorthodox mixture of items and objects from that series, fighting mostly with her handbag in terms of her normals.
  • Lip is another instance of a seemingly odd pick who I think makes more sense when you really consider it. Panel de Pon was a decently popular SNES game, and Tetris Attack did get ported to the Game Boy - plus, the Game Boy had a variety of puzzle games that made it popular with a wider group of people overall. I wanted a puzzle rep of some kind, and felt Lip would be far more interesting than Dr. Mario.
  • Sukapon is our last character, picked partially because of his unusual placement in one of the Famicom's last games, but also because I genuinely think he'd be a good fit for a game like this - already being from a fighting series! Some of his moves will be pulled directly from the original, with a couple of others here and there being pulled from other characters in Joy Mech Fight as required.
I think that does a good job of representing a decent swathe of Nintendo's output at around this time - primarily biased toward platformers, but with a decent variety of takes on the formula, whilst also introducing a good variety of genres beyond that (action RPG, arcade?, tactical RPG, visual novel, puzzle and fighting) which results in a decently varied character roster overall. As for some notable omissions beyond the aforementioned, some honourable mentions:
  • A MOTHER character came pretty close to making it in, with me originally considering either Paula or Ness for the role, but I kind of ended up struggling to justify how they'd turn out in a game like this. The ability to represent their psychic effects and abilities would be difficult on a console like this, and when it came down to the wire, I felt that the unlockables I did include were just a better representation of Nintendo's output overall.
  • Donbe or Hikari as a Disc System rep as opposed to Ayumi, though I ended up deciding Ayumi was just more fun and potentially interesting.
  • Basically any third-party pick was also briefly considered, but I quickly shut that down after deciding it'd make more sense for Nintendo to keep this first game completely in-house (even though some Intelligent Systems/HAL characters were here, but shhh.)
    • Mega Man was actually at the top of my list in this regard, considering his continual prominence and association with the Famicom, Super Famicom, and Game Boy... but I felt he ran the risk of overlap with Samus in terms of moveset and general concept, plus as a third-party character, he was a little difficult to justify to begin with.
  • Bowser, who I actually almost included, before deciding that the trio of Mario, Donkey Kong Jr. and Wario was a better group for this specific time period. Don't get me wrong, he'd be cool - I just felt that he wasn't quite a good fit for what we already had going on.
 
Last edited:

FazDude

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 26, 2021
Messages
3,151
Location
Wherever good books are sold.
Made a NASB 2 that I'd do if I were in charge and had a base roster size of 40.

Do note that while not all the leaked NASB 2 characters are on the roster, the majority of them are, so spoiler warning.


Oblina, Krumm, and Ickis are a PokeTrainer-style team, Fanboy and Chum Chum are like Banjo and Kazooie, and the Angry Beavers are like Pythra.

Blue and Mr. Crocker are free DLC ala Garfield and Shredder in NASB 1, while the 3x2 grid is paid DLC.
 

darkvortex

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 1, 2023
Messages
2,356
download_4.png

Disney Roster. Tired to play it more realistically


  • Mickey Mouse is the only series to get more than two reps because it's Mickey feaking Mouse.
  • Scrooge is our only TVA rep.
  • Snow White is here to rep the princesses. Fights by summoning animals and dwarfs
  • Pincchio kinda stumbles his way though a fight. he can use his nose and even call on the Blue Fairy.
  • Peter Pan would have a sort of Luma thing going on with Tinkerbell
  • Cruella has a playstyle that reflects her cruel nature. She can drive her car around and have Jasper and Horace do her dirty work. Sort of like a skinny Wario
  • Tigger was chosen over Pooh due to more moveset potential.
  • Ursula was chosen due to Arial being, well, a mermaid and also wanting some more villains
  • Genie was chosen due to just being personally more interesting
  • Timon and Pumba are one of two duo fighters, with Timon riding Pumba's back, like Ren & Stimpy from NASB. I figured Lion King was a big enough series to get two reps, being one of only two series to get that treatment.
  • Maui was chosen due to having a more fun gameplay style and unique body build
  • No Encanto. There wasn't a moveset I liked enough
  • Kronk is the wild card pick. A true heavy, he'd have attacks that reflect his clumsy nature
  • Kermit would be kinda like Octodad from Freymakers
  • I'm not a fan of the Pirates films nor am I fond of the weird cult that are Johnny Depp fans, but I figure if they did a live action character it would be him
  • Toy Story is the other series to get two reps, I considered a team up between them but I didn't want too many duos and I had a different idea for a Pixar duo
  • Mike and Sully fight together like the Ice Climbers, but you can control which one is in front, which changes their moveset.
  • Elestagirl was chosen over Mr. Incredible due to an already having quite a few big bruiser types and also just having a more interesting moveset
  • Miguel uses music to fight and also some stuff with the dead
  • Mei is weak in her human form but can build up meter to transform into her Panda form
  • Figment is there as a rep for the Parks. He would be one of two unlockables
  • Merlin is there due to how weirdly prevalent he is in Disney crossover games. He's the other unlockable and is the narrator of the Adventure Mode
  • Chernabog is the final boss of Adventure Mode. It's a more simple melee styled affiar
 
Last edited:

Wario Wario Wario

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2017
Messages
11,905
Location
Cheese Wheels of Doom
Re-dos of the NES and SNES Classic Minis. Assume there's no licensing issues. (in other words: except lots of licensed games from companies that would never work together for something like this.) Going for 31 SNES games instead of 21. Aiming for a T rating.

NES
  1. Super Mario Bros.
  2. Super Mario Bros. 2
  3. Super Mario Bros. 3
  4. Bubble Bobble
  5. Castlevania
  6. Double Dragon 2
  7. Excitebike
  8. Dragon Warrior
  9. Metroid
  10. Ninja Gaiden
  11. Punch-Out!!
  12. StarTropics
  13. Contra
  14. The Legend of Zelda
  15. Zelda 2
  16. Kirby's Adventure
  17. Tecmo Bowl
  18. Mega Man 2
  19. DuckTales
  20. Darkwing Duck
  21. River City Ransom
  22. Mr. Gimmick
  23. Blaster Master
  24. Battletoads
  25. Tiny Toon Adventures
  26. Little Nemo: The Dream Master
  27. Kid Icarus
  28. Metal Gear
  29. Batman
  30. Bionic Commando
SNES
  1. Donkey Kong Country
  2. Super Mario World
  3. Yoshi's Island
  4. Donkey Kong Country 2
  5. Tetris Attack
  6. Final Fantasy 3
  7. EarthBound
  8. Chrono Trigger
  9. Secret of Mana
  10. Kirby Super Star
  11. Mega Man X
  12. Star Fox
  13. Zelda: A Link to the Past
  14. TMNT: Turtles in Time
  15. Street Fighter 2 Turbo
  16. Super Bomberman
  17. Earthworm Jim 2
  18. Zombies Ate My Neighbors
  19. Pac-Man 2: The New Adventures
  20. Super Ghouls and Ghosts
  21. Super Mario RPG
  22. Tetris & Dr. Mario
  23. Harvest Moon
  24. Sim City
  25. The Adventures of Batman and Robin
  26. Aladdin
  27. Stunt Race FX
  28. Kirby's Dream Course
  29. Sunset Riders
  30. The Legend of the Mystical Ninja
  31. Star Fox 2
here's a gamelist for a DS Classic Mini while I'm at it
  1. New Super Mario Bros.
  2. WarioWare: Touched!
  3. Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
  4. Mario vs. Donkey Kong: March of the Minis
  5. DK Jungle Climber
  6. Mario Kart DS
  7. WarioWare DIY
  8. Animal Crossing: Wild World
  9. Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training
  10. The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass
  11. The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks
  12. Freshly-Picked: Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland
  13. Big Brain Academy
  14. Pokemon Platinum
  15. Rayman Raving Rabbids 2
  16. Nintendogs: Best Friends
  17. Sonic Rush
  18. The Legendary Starfy
  19. Drawn to Life
  20. Super Scribblenauts
  21. Contact
  22. Zoo Keeper
  23. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
  24. Pokemon Ranger: Guardian Skies
  25. Super Monkey Ball: Touch N' Roll
  26. Rhythm Heaven
  27. Electroplankton
  28. Cooking Mama 2
  29. Cut the Rope (DSiWare)
  30. Go! Go! Kokopolo (DSiWare)
 

Champion of Hyrule

Smash Master
Writing Team
Joined
Sep 15, 2018
Messages
4,343
Location
*doxxes myself*
Re-dos of the NES and SNES Classic Minis. Assume there's no licensing issues. (in other words: except lots of licensed games from companies that would never work together for something like this.) Going for 31 SNES games instead of 21. Aiming for a T rating.

NES
  1. Super Mario Bros.
  2. Super Mario Bros. 2
  3. Super Mario Bros. 3
  4. Bubble Bobble
  5. Castlevania
  6. Double Dragon 2
  7. Excitebike
  8. Dragon Warrior
  9. Metroid
  10. Ninja Gaiden
  11. Punch-Out!!
  12. StarTropics
  13. Contra
  14. The Legend of Zelda
  15. Zelda 2
  16. Kirby's Adventure
  17. Tecmo Bowl
  18. Mega Man 2
  19. DuckTales
  20. Darkwing Duck
  21. River City Ransom
  22. Mr. Gimmick
  23. Blaster Master
  24. Battletoads
  25. Tiny Toon Adventures
  26. Little Nemo: The Dream Master
  27. Kid Icarus
  28. Metal Gear
  29. Batman
  30. Bionic Commando
SNES
  1. Donkey Kong Country
  2. Super Mario World
  3. Yoshi's Island
  4. Donkey Kong Country 2
  5. Tetris Attack
  6. Final Fantasy 3
  7. EarthBound
  8. Chrono Trigger
  9. Secret of Mana
  10. Kirby Super Star
  11. Mega Man X
  12. Star Fox
  13. Zelda: A Link to the Past
  14. TMNT: Turtles in Time
  15. Street Fighter 2 Turbo
  16. Super Bomberman
  17. Earthworm Jim 2
  18. Zombies Ate My Neighbors
  19. Pac-Man 2: The New Adventures
  20. Super Ghouls and Ghosts
  21. Super Mario RPG
  22. Tetris & Dr. Mario
  23. Harvest Moon
  24. Sim City
  25. The Adventures of Batman and Robin
  26. Aladdin
  27. Stunt Race FX
  28. Kirby's Dream Course
  29. Sunset Riders
  30. The Legend of the Mystical Ninja
  31. Star Fox 2
here's a gamelist for a DS Classic Mini while I'm at it
  1. New Super Mario Bros.
  2. WarioWare: Touched!
  3. Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
  4. Mario vs. Donkey Kong: March of the Minis
  5. DK Jungle Climber
  6. Mario Kart DS
  7. WarioWare DIY
  8. Animal Crossing: Wild World
  9. Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training
  10. The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass
  11. The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks
  12. Freshly-Picked: Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland
  13. Big Brain Academy
  14. Pokemon Platinum
  15. Rayman Raving Rabbids 2
  16. Nintendogs: Best Friends
  17. Sonic Rush
  18. The Legendary Starfy
  19. Drawn to Life
  20. Super Scribblenauts
  21. Contact
  22. Zoo Keeper
  23. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
  24. Pokemon Ranger: Guardian Skies
  25. Super Monkey Ball: Touch N' Roll
  26. Rhythm Heaven
  27. Electroplankton
  28. Cooking Mama 2
  29. Cut the Rope (DSiWare)
  30. Go! Go! Kokopolo (DSiWare)
I get why you replaced final fantasy with dragon warrior but I think final fantasy would still be better IMO since dragon warrior is a little hard to get into for new players of RPGs while final fantasy still holds up really well. This is just a “what’s the best for a new player” perspective tho
 

CapitaineCrash

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 30, 2018
Messages
2,876
Location
Canada, Québec
So I had a new idea for a Nintendo crossover fighting games. The game is called Nintendo heroines. The idea is based on SNK Heroines. If you haven't heard about this game, the basic concept is that it's a crossover of many SNK characters, but it's unique because it only used SNK female characters. I thought this was a cool concept because Nintendo actually have more female characters if you look deeper in their games, and it open the doors to a lot of characters that would have little to no chances to be in Smash.

Before posting the roster, here's a few rules that I gave myself before people ask "why is (character name) not here?"
1. No character that gender is not really clear. The character must be clearly female (which is why I didn't add Birdo because Nintendo seems to have retcon the trans thing, but I didn't want to go there)
2. No avatar or characters that can be both gender (so no Fire emblem avatars or Pokémon for example aside from stuff like Nidoqueen or Miltank).
3. No third party. This is Nintendo heroines, not Smash heroines.
4. No OC or gender swap character. Yeah this might be obvious, but since the game I'm basing the roster on have Cutie Terry, I'm specifically saying it. No, Cutie Mario (or Maria?) won't be here even if it's Nintendo's mascot.

With that out of the way here's the 35 characters roster:
1. Peach (Super Mario)
2. Daisy (Super Mario)
3. Rosalina (Super Mario)
4. Toadette (Super Mario)
5. Plum (Super Mario)
6. Pauline (Donkey kong)
7. Dixie kong (Donkey kong)
8. Ashley (WarioWare)
9. Captain Syrup (Wario land)
10. Zelda (Legend of Zelda)
11. Impa (Legend of Zelda)
12. Marin (Legend of Zelda)
13. Midna (Legend of Zelda)
14. Urbosa (Legend of Zelda)
15. Paya (Legend of Zelda)
16. Linkle (Legend of Zelda)
17. Samus (Metroid)
18. Krystal (Star fox)
19. Adeline (Kirby)
20. Cynthia (Pokémon)
21. Paula (Earthbound)
22. Jody Summer (F-zero)
23. Lyn (Fire emblem)
24. Micaihah (Fire emblem)
25. Lucina (Fire emblem)
26. Tiki (Fire emblem)
27. Edelgard (Fire emblem)
28. Palutena (Kid icarus)
29. Isabelle (Animal crossing)
30. Pyra/Mythra (Xenoblade)
31. Mio (Xenoblade)
32. Marie (Callie is a skin) (Splatoon)
33. Ayumi Tachibana (Famicom detective club)
34. Lip (Panel de pon)
35. Sami (Advance wars)

And here's the roster in image format:
myroster (4).png
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom