Official MBR Tier List

[KirbyKaze]

Whenever I do something cool they're like, "That never happened."

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

It's all right KK they never let me be happy either. why can't you people humor me about pichu not sucking huh my feelings are hurting and now i'll have to cut them out and steal a little child's feelings named little hitler.

 

[JPOBS]

Remember that combo I did to sauc3 with Fox that never happened?

yea but that was bad ***

i dont think i've ever played you with sheik.

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

That's Bull**** you got combo ***** by a pichu as sheik and I know somewhere you have a post about sheik being easy to play as. theory alone is enough for sheik sometimes.

 

[KAOSTAR]

The person I was responding to didn't state a reason why they thought mewtwo was underrated therefore I didn't see any reason to specify why I don't think he's better than Link. I wasn't making a counter argument because an argument wasn't made to begin with.

I'm not vbm. If you said that just to annoy me then you're an ***.

So you think ppl care enough about what you have to say to read you opinion? Because thats all you posted.

Im an ******* and Im sorry

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

I don't know good shoes went i see them I always go for those sexy ugly shoes that don't last and are made from the factors in asia that are uber underpayed compared to the other salve labor.

 

[SDC]

So you think ppl care enough about what you have to say to read you opinion? Because thats all you posted.

Im an ******* and Im sorry

Kaos we're all *******s sometimes. Its coo mayn

Whenever I do something cool they're like, "That never happened."

I believe you.

And on a relevant note.....when is MBR releasing this new tier list? They said "early August" well it's mid August now, and still no tier list. Methinks they be slackin.

 

[.Marik]

I don't know good shoes went i see them I always go for those sexy ugly shoes that don't last and are made from the factors in asia that are uber underpayed compared to the other salve labor.

What the hell are you talking about?

 

[Anth0ny]

What the hell are you talking about?

shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

just observe the ICG in it's natural habitat.

 

[Doc King]

Hey ppl, here's my opinion of what the 10th tier list should look like!
Top
*Jigglypuff
*Fox
*Sheik
High
*Marth
*Falcon
*Falco
*Peach
*Samus
Middle
*Ice Climbers
*Doc
*Pika
*Mario
Low
*Ganon
*Link
*Luigi
*Roy
*Y. Link
*DK
*Mewtwo
*Bowser
Bottom
*Ness
*Yoshi
*Zelda
*G&W
*Pichu
*Kirby

 

[Jimbo Slice]

Falcon shouldn't ever be above a space animal. He's a fast faller without a shine. He was doomed from day one.

 

[Stevo]

guys remember that april fools joke tier list with jiggs and mewtwo at the top

we should use that one

 

[Stratocaster]

guys remember that april fools joke tier list with jiggs and mewtwo at the top

we should use that one

April fools '04 tier list

Top
Sheik
Jiggs

Upper
Fox
CFalcon
Falco
Link

High
Marth
Roy
Peach
Luigi
IC's

Middle
Ganon
Samus
Mewtwo
Ness
Mario
Yoshi
Doc

Low
Ylink
Kirby
Pikachu
Mr. G&W
DK

Bottom
Zelda
Pichu
Bowser

Only the Jiggs placement is really accurate if you ask me

Lol at link in top 6...
Pikachu and DK below Kirby! I hope no one fell for this...

 

[shehehe11]

So is the MBR actually discussing/formulating a new tier list? I'd like to see new results

 

[BEES]

It's no longer early August, yet we still don't have a new list.

 

[KirbyKaze]

yea but that was bad ***

i dont think i've ever played you with sheik.

You did but we were drunk.

Beer pong btw.

 

[JPOBS]

You did but we were drunk.

Beer pong btw.

lolololol oh thats mad legit then.

and you;ve got to come down sometime(s) this year for more shenanigans.

 

[ChaosNoobSlayer]

Falcon shouldn't ever be above a space animal. He's a fast faller without a shine. He was doomed from day one.

but falcon kick tho

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

gannon's is better

 

[Doc King]

Yeah, I know, sorry about my list. I've been only playin this game since 08 so I don't know everything about the game yet! Also Ganon and Link should be in middle tier, my bad!

 

[Doc King]

April fools '04 tier list

Top
Sheik
Jiggs

Upper
Fox
CFalcon
Falco
Link

High
Marth
Roy
Peach
Luigi
IC's

Middle
Ganon
Samus
Mewtwo
Ness
Mario
Yoshi
Doc

Low
Ylink
Kirby
Pikachu
Mr. G&W
DK

Bottom
Zelda
Pichu
Bowser

Only the Jiggs placement is really accurate if you ask me

Lol at link in top 6...
Pikachu and DK below Kirby! I hope no one fell for this...

This wouldn't work out so well cause Link is too high and Kirby is too high, etc.

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

I'm glad you argee that kirby is to high in today's metagame.

 

[Doc King]

Yeah, I even think Pichu should be above him due to faster speed and the ability to chainthrow spacies

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

everyone chain throws space animals that's bad reason. however some people are amazinly to good at chain throwing them like ice climbers and DK and maybe marth.

 

[Doc King]

Yeah like when Mew2king chainthrows spacies with Marth. and yes i know pretty much every1 can chainthrow in melee.

 

[INSANE CARZY GUY]

falco can chain throw from mindgames f-throw DD into regrab or straigh up another grab or run up spot dodge falco dittos are nuts between me and my brother like near no combos like ever mostly mindgames.

klirby no can chain throw like the cool charcters.

 

[Doc King]

His down throw can but its slow, kindof similar to Puff's down throw

 

[Pi]

gannon's is better

Yeah, I know, sorry about my list. I've been only playin this game since 08 so I don't know everything about the game yet! Also Ganon and Link should be in middle tier, my bad!

This wouldn't work out so well cause Link is too high and Kirby is too high, etc.

I'm glad you argee that kirby is to high in today's metagame.

Yeah, I even think Pichu should be above him due to faster speed and the ability to chainthrow spacies

everyone chain throws space animals that's bad reason. however some people are amazinly to good at chain throwing them like ice climbers and DK and maybe marth.

Yeah like when Mew2king chainthrows spacies with Marth. and yes i know pretty much every1 can chainthrow in melee.

falco can chain throw from mindgames f-throw DD into regrab or straigh up another grab or run up spot dodge falco dittos are nuts between me and my brother like near no combos like ever mostly mindgames.

klirby no can chain throw like the cool charcters.

His down throw can but its slow, kindof similar to Puff's down throw

I've never...I mean what is...stop it...stop it right now!

 

[Doc King]

Relax, where just talking about the next tier list for Melee.

 

[.Marik]

shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

just observe the ICG in it's natural habitat.

Hmm. Point taken.

I understand the concept he's trying to imply about having people read your posts without them containing anything of substance, but then maybe I'm simply over analyzing something I shouldn't even be taking seriously.

Anth0ny, stop getting stuck in unlucky situations. We need to play Project Melee.

By the way, beer pong is one of the most legitimate ways to spend your time. Ever.

 

[KirbyKaze]

Yoshi
Doc
Fox
Peach

Falco
Jiggs

Sheik
Pikachu
Falcon
Marth

Samus
DK
Mario
Ganon
Luigi
Ice Climbers

Zelda
Mewtwo
Young Link
Game & Watch
Link
Roy

Kirby
Bowser
Solo Popo
Pichu
Ness

The new tier list

A little experimental

Tell me what you think

 

[Smooth Criminal]

Solo Popo too low.

Deff above Peach.

Smooth Criminal

 

[Doc King]

Why is Yoshi at the top?

However, I feel like Yoshi is really underrated and should move up to low tier or something. His only major weakness is his recovery.

 

[KirbyKaze]

Because I feel that he has untapped potential.

 

[JPOBS]

a yoshi that could perfectly anticipate and double jump through all incoming approaches and punish with *move* would be pretty ****

 

[Doc King]

Wow, my main in 2nd! I hope this could come true!

 

[KirbyKaze]

Yeah PC Jona convinced me that Doc is probably 2nd best in the game.

 

[Doc King]

He is a pretty good character! Gotta love the Super Sheet!

 

[KirbyKaze]

Yeah, his B-throw gimps are also broken.

I think he beats Marth too.

 

[sauc3]

Whenever I do something cool they're like, "That never happened."

cuz it never happened *glares*

sauc3 out