Illmatic I honestly want to hear yours and king beefs (or other peach mains) opinions regardless how you come off. You should be fine as long as your careful with your wording.
I don't care whether or not Peach is higher on the tier list. Doesn't really matter to me because I'm going to probably be maining her until I quit.
Drop her? Sweet, now it's "better" if I perform well with her.
Give her a boost? Okay, Peaches are actually "performing" with this character. That's good.
Tier list isn't going to change anything for me. At the end of the day I'm still going to run into Metaknights, Diddies, Snakes, Marths, Ganons (lol), and I'm still going to be playing on the stages that the Unity Ruleset enforces.
I've practically given up on this place. No point in expressing my thoughts if I can't really back it up and people want to post stupid **** every other post.
I'm just going to go ahead and say this - This was probably the most ******** discussion I've ever seen in the tier list thread. You shouldn't take one specific tournament and amplify it to determine a character's placement over a broad period of time. You also shouldn't take into account cash earnings because some regions/states/cities are much harder than others. For example, San could live in Idaho and make over $400 a month - does this mean Ike should rise eight spots on the tier list? Thankfully, the reality is that San lives in New York and still makes decent cash with tough competition from higher leveled players. But this isn't always the case. If you remove one player that lives in a "easier" section of the USA but makes "more money" it will drastically effect the data.
Look at who the characters beat, both matchups and specific players over a broader period of time. That's how tier lists are created.
Did we put Snake above Metaknight when Ally beat M2k? Nope.
Diddy above Snake when ADHD won MLG Raleigh? No.
We take into consideration all of the Diddies, all the tournaments, all the players beaten, and go into specific details to figure out what character is truly better than the other.
People state that Yoshi should rise. Why? Because he consistently outperforms a great number of characters both above and below him with multiple players. There is no exception or outlier. Yoshi is better than any given character in Low Tier.
John's post was really well written. So props on that.