It gives me a headache reading this thread sometime..
Why would someone ask what you do in a situation and then you give like two possible scenarios or something?
You would say something like "well that's a guaranteed combo or way to get good percent or it's a mix up or jman did it."
I thought melee was about being unpredictable and mind ****** your opponent.. And doing something like double shine after an uthrow is kind of dumb...
1) When you uthrow even if they don't di the throw, it's not like they're going to not di inward after the throw... if their percent is low enough that they can't jump out, then you wouldn't have time to dash forward and shine so they did head off the edge. You could still shine them in the air but they'd just bounce into the ground and then off the stage, out of stun... but very close to the stage.
2) Also if you don't do a perfect double shine and then wd out or something, they will be below the stage and able to recover. You will hardly have time (even if you did a perfect double shine) to jump off and shine them to their death. So now they're recovering from below and you are on the edge. So they firefox back on, tech whatever you do, and the match goes on.
3) or you could just uthrow to utilt at like 60 if they don't Di and follow that with uair or bair which will definitely get them off the stage. Or if they're over 90 just hit them 3 times, uthrow, follow their DI and bair them off stage.
Mostly because of point 2), I don't get things like this. you call it situational, or a mixup, but what if you're just playing bad smash?
I wish people would just ask about priority and following DI and stuff, not situations. If you run to other people with help for situations that you haven't thought out yourself first (thoroughly), then you're not gonna get better cause you're relying on other people to process the situation for you.
These are just my thoughts but I'm a scrub. also any foxes coming to tipped off, I'm accepting all reasonable MM's. I love fox dittos.