Says the guy from colorado, LOL. I don't recall any major players coming from Colorado.
Ask the people that went to Event 52 about LoVo's Link. Ask Germ about 'em. Ferdi drew first blood on m2k there, too, though m2k still won. Ask Forward, Taj, Wobbles, or South Paw about CO smash. Just because we don't travel often doesn't mean we don't know what we're doing.
You know our scene about as well as I know yours.
The Netherlands have the best Melee scene in Europe. Of course Amsah is well known even in the US, but you also have other excellent players like Adam, Faab, choco, zgetto, Marc, the list goes on.
And you all lose to Nihonjin. lolololol.
Nah, I'm messin', he's just a really good player. It's not like Europe is garbage at Melee or anything.
Secondly, you are clearly unaware of how CC works. Read
this. You keep repeating how CC would help against Fox' dair, when that's one of the moves people use to COUNTER crouch canceling!
I'd suggest you actually read the posts you link to next time. I think you're a little confused on something:
You can Crouch needles/Fox's shines/Falco's lasers/spikes/meteors to get reduced launch speed and stun time, but they can't send you upwards until they knock you down and go into a tumble, so you can't Cancel them by instantly going into a regular landing by ASDIing down.
Because of the reduced stun-time, you are able to do things like get Peach's dsmash out before he completely lands and does a shine (at low percents), effectively nailing him with a CC dsmash because he's still going for the shine. At higher percents it doesn't work because you're stunned for longer. I've been playing Melee for a long time, it's not like I haven't done this before.
Though really, if you predict a dair, it's better to just WD back into dtilt.
Still, thanks for the link. It didn't occur to me that me CCing dair was the reason why I couldn't SDI outta drillshines. Hopefully now, I can.
Like paprika killer said, we are NOT remaking Melee. If I want Melee, I go to a smashfest and play Melee, LOL. Crouch canceling was a VERY powerful technique in Melee, so much that entire matchups revolve around it.
I'm not asking for l-canceling, wavedashing, jc grabs, and for battlefield to kill you if you try to recover too far in. I just wondered whether anyone had thought to try out CCing. CCing doesn't make the game Melee instantly. I don't know why paprika and you feel like it's some grave sin to simply inquire about a technique being added.
Also, CC pretty much ruins low tiers because they have less safe moves. If you're sheik, you can pretty much approach every low tier matchup like this:
He does some weird low tier bull****, I CC it/use my broken ftilt hitbox to hit him out of it->grab.
/stock
Now this I can agree with and see as a viable argument against CC. Granted, Sheik could **** most low-tiers without even CCing, but as someone who mained Roy for a very good deal of time, CCing was my enemy, and Samus made me D:
Granted, some characters like Link have workarounds (lol upb, it sounds scrubby, but ask m2k how his Sheik felt against LoVo's Link), but in general, low tier can kinda get ***** by it. Only character that comes to mind that doesn't mind it too much is Ness, since it=free dair mix-up which can equal a decent combo. Doesn't matter though, he still gets ***** by Sheik and Peach for free. D:
CC is very very powerful and there's enough reasons not to include it in Brawl+ other than "we don't want Melee 2.0".
I would much prefer to discuss thse reasons rather than "we dun want melee, lololololol". Intelligent discussion is much preferred over flame-baiting each other.
Btw, while we're on the subject of Melee, why is Peach where she is in the PAL tier list? She seems to be the same in a game where everyone else in the top tier got nerfed. Does Europe just lack Peach players to show how good she is, or is there something about the PAL metagame that I don't know about? Pretty sure she can **** Falco soundly, and if Sheik has more stun on dthrow, can she still dthrow to fair at kill percents? Marth still seems bad, but dair is a meteor, so Ken combo isn't that big of a deal, is it?