da K.I.D.
Smash Hero
well, isnt that the pot calling the kettle black, your last post has you completely reeming a well respected person for no other reason than according to you, his thoughts are totally incorrect. and dont talk to me about arragant, when you have the rep of being the most arrogant person on this entire forum. and once again you are making these outlandish claims that im disagreeing with everybody when, according to all the people ive seen post in this thread in the last 130 pages, the no ban camp is in the minority. also theres a very good chance (as in youve done it and admitted to it before, in this thread) that you saw my name on the page and basically in your mind attached it to the next 5 posts on the page and just went along believing that i was the one who posted whatever random crap that was on that page.You think they're valid. Many do not. While many in this thread think your post are valid because they agree with you, we think they're not valid because, um, we've played the game, read up on the theory, know our Smash and fighting game history and know what constitutes a need for a ban.
how can you know what deserves a ban if youve never banned a character?
You repeatedly use arguments that I repeatedly dash (you use some that I do not) followed by you ignoring me as if I'd never said anything or debating me as if I'm wrong without even checking up on the facts.
and ive repeatedly destroyed your arguments as well, i believe that makes you a hypocrite, and an uninformed one because i make a POINT to comment on everything you say, because you seem to be the leader of the no ban camp, so if i prove you wrong theres nothing else other ppl can do
Also, you also go "In my opinion" about a lot of things in which your opinion does not matter. Why should we listen to you when the Smash world at large (especially those of high regard (knowledge, not just skill)) disagree?!
you use your opinion tons too, because half this debate is speculation. perfect example, i asked you what it would take for you specifically to agree with a ban, and you answered with your opinion, since when is your opinion on bans factual
Why should we take your word for, say, Sonic's prowess when tons of other people (especially those that matter) disagree?
are you stupid, all sonics say the same thing, he sucks, where the hell are you getting this from, the only thing that ive personally disagreed with all teh other sonics on is his matchup with marth (i think its 50-50, they think its 65-35 marth) other than that the people that matter do agree with me on sonics (lack of) prowess.
Ban MK? He'll just go for the next logical step; D3 + Marth. He already knows how to play both.
both have (at least soft) counters, and even matchups, Mk (since you dont want me to use opinion) does not
How the hell would he do this? If he doesn't use it, then he can't win using it. If he does, Smashboard Whiners R' Us would be all over it the second he did it.
he does it in matches, but those things are very subtle so people might not always catch it, also i was reffering to the fact that M2K doesnt let people record his matches because he knows ppl will jack his style
What is this magical "******** crap"? Has he let it all lose yet? Is he still holding back? Has he let it all lose yet and we still haven't banned him? So the logic is: Had we known what we know now before, he'd be soooooo banned right now but at this moment, there's still doubt because its coming in increments?
fixed and yes thats the logic, and that logic is way more sane than "if we ban Mk now, we'll never know what does and doesnt work on him cus nobody will EVER play him again"
Also, baseless speculation, all of it!
just because you dont agree/believe what im saying doesnt make it baseless, get off your high horse for once dude.
No, your opinion won't matter 'til you actually show yourself knowledgeable. I haven't actually won a major American tournament, but a lot of people respect me for being knowledgeable (not one of the most but at least more than most people) about Smash. I'm not even the best in my tiny country of residence (Sweden).
But you know what? I read... a lot. I can memorize tons of theory. I read on SWF, I talk to actual people, I know some of the best Smashers in the world.
sounds like what yoursaying is that because you talk to the people, and i just hear about what they say after wards despite throughly checking my sources that what you say is more important than what i have to say? this is a question.
You don't have to be one of the best players to debate Smash. You just have to be one of the most knowledgeable ones. And the fact that you've said some highly erroneous things in this thread shows that you clearly aren't one of the most knowledgeable.
pls highlight these things for me, that are actually wrong as opposed to things that you dont agree with my opinion on
So why we should just take your word for it is beyond me. That's quite arrogant, even. "All of SWF is wrong. My take on this and that is right!"
so why dont you backtrack a little bit, listen to what I personally am saying and stop making random accusations
oh and replys are in the quote because youre not worth it to do otherwise