Hey guys been lurking here since the inception if the SSB4 announcement, thought i'd finally join the discussion. First to discuss the most controversial topic which is of course Characters
Zelda series: I might be among the few (if any) who thinks Zelda is perfectly represented in Smash and does not need anymore characters. We have a perfect balance. The hero, The villain, and the sidekick
Mario: I think if anyone deserves to be playable its Toad. He has been with Mario since the beginning and has a myriad of support. He still remains significant today so newer fans will also be familiar with him. If for some reason Sakurai decides not to include him, then I guess we have no choice but Bowser jr.
DK: King K.Rool needs to be added. He has appeared in a nintendo game in the last few years so they haven't forgotten about him. Yeah he'll be awesome as one of the big villains along with Bowser and DDD
Kid Icarus: This series definitely needs some love. With a new game coming out lead by Sakurai himself. I say Medusa in her human size would be a great choice. Either her or the new guy from the trailer who looks to be working with Pit. Either of them will be great to have
Kirby: FIne the way it is
Yoshi: nobody relevant enough, but doesnt matter its fine the way it is
Fire Emblem: Unfortunately ive never played a FE game, so i can't fully substantiate anything lolz. I know the game hasn't gotten a new game in a few years, but if they do before Smash's release the new protagonist will probably replace Ike. If not then Ike should stay and they should someone else possibly Lyn
F-Zero: The series is pretty much dead, but I think it would be cool to see Samurai Goroh in their
Star Fox: I think its perfect the way it is. Hero, Villain, and Sidekick. No need for Krystal
Ice Climbers: good
Mother: I don't think Lucas or Ness will be cut, but I think Claus could make a good addition
Pokemon: Now this one is pretty tough to to do. Pikachu and Puff are in because they are mascots of pokemon and the original smash characters. Pokemon trainer should be enhanced so that he gets a starter of a different stage from the first 3 generations. One example could be Charizard, Crocanaw, and Sceptile, Lucario should stay, and a new gen 5 should be added
Pikmin: Olimar is good by himself, unless we get a brand new character in Pikmin 3, in which case he should be added as well
Metroid: We need Ridley. He should have already been in brawl
Wario: Good enough
Wtf Characters: Game and watch, ROB, and Baloon fighter
New Series: Issac and/or Matthew(Golden sun)
Lil Mac (punch out)
Tom Nook (animal Crossing)
Starfy
Saki (Sin and Punishment)
3rd party: Sonic and Snake should definitely return. I think 2 new third party characters are ok. In which case Megaman, because he is now the most requested and has been in many nintendo systems. and Ryu from Ninja Gaiden. The ones who made Ninja Gaiden worked with nintendo for Metroid, and he started off on the Nes has a game on the DS and A new game on WII-U
so what do you guys think, I also have some gameplay ideas casue character talk can become rather tiresome.