Pluvia
Hates Semicolons<br>;
ODIN, that is fantastic.
+rep.
+rep.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
yeah, was great playing with you too. This game's mp is so much more enjoyable when not playing with randoms.http://imgur.com/a/EPNNB
The MURDERTRAIN has left the station, ON GOLD.
Krogan Vanguard is VERY doable and able to dominate in Gold.
You just have to be smart.
Nice having you along for the ride Xanthan.
Thanks mate.ODIN, that is fantastic.
+rep.
I gotta work my way up. I'm looking forward to doing Cerberus next. But Reapers are on the list.How about them Reapers, ODIN?
I want the MURDERTRAIN now...
I have had no such luck at all.
MUCH more enjoyable. :Dyeah, was great playing with you too. This game's mp is so much more enjoyable when not playing with randoms.
Okay.I'm sticking to the whispering throughout the TIM vs Shep and Anderson scene. It seems to implicate something. Very strange imo.
Meh...I never interpreted it that way due to Miranda saying TIM forbade her from having devices that would control Shepard.
There's a lot up for interpretation though. :/
TIM would have to have put something in Anderson, and that's pretty unlikely since he spent the whole game on Earth. I'm leaning towards this scene being a hallucination as evidenced by the whispering and oily shadows, and Anderson and TIM being representations of Shep's mind/reaper influence--the main thing leading me to that conclusion is Shep bleeding where Anderson was shot after he passed away.
I'd REALLY like Bioware to provide some closure.
It's all oily because it represents TIM controlling them, TIM gets advanced Reaper indoctrination tech put inside him as evident from the logs on the Cerberus base, that's why he's able to control them. Shepard grabs his side before that scene too, when he was standing up, he just doesn't notice how badly he's hurt until after.
The IT theory doesn't like to tell you these things because it's counter to its points.
:/But...the oily shadows first appear in the 2nd dream.
I'm analyzing the way you said "them" in 2 different ways. If you mean Shep and Anderson, then they would need Cerberus implants, and only one of them definitely has it (whether or not those implants in Shep are reaper tech is another story, but I'm doubting it tbh). If you mean "them" as in the reapers, I find that hard to believe because the Starchild admits that TIM couldn't control them. I do think you mean Shep and Anderson tbh.
And, you're right that Shep clutches that area even before Anderson gets shot. Good point there, but I've also noticed that Shep's left hand is relatively clean until after Anderson passes. Once that happens, the left hand's covered in fresh bright blood, and Shepard is like "Huh..look at that..."
And maybe I'm seeing this differently, but that log seemed to imply that with mastery over his indoctrinated troops, he could risk indoctrinating himself (although he's had reaper influence for decades) to completely control his army.
No TIM has the Reaper implants, it's TIM enforcing his will upon them, because of their advances in Reaper indoctrination technology and the implants he gets inside of him he's able to control others to an extent. Notice how the shadows don't appear until after we see TIM, he speaks for a bit and keeps them both frozen, then it strengthens greatly just before TIM forces Shepard to shoot Anderson, and he even does that biotic thing with his hand to help show this.
For the bleeding thing, the wound obviously just worsened, and the log states mastery over his already indoctrinated troops, but that influence also extends to control, albeit quite weak, to non indoctrinated individuals at close range by the looks of it.
We are on the same page. I just want to ride the Krogan train.I honestly don't care about these discussions anymore. It feels like the same old points being made by both sides. I'm just gonna sit and wait.
Something to keep in mind is that the whispering starts almost immediately, and while those oily tentacle-like shadows appear when TIM shows up and strengthen at points, both of those elements are a big part of the dream sequences along with that kid, who also appears. Some of the symptoms of indoctination are there in the scene; they can be interpreted differently (like the headaches--Shep did just survive a laser blast and was flung to the citadel so that's understandable), but those 3 things and a few others tie so well together--especially when the reapers' master takes the form of the child.
What's also of note is that the kid says TIM was under his control. So, if TIM's trying to control/convince Anderson and Shep but he's being manipulated himself, you can essentially say that the reapers are trying to control Shep and Anderson. Even if the shadows and whispers are TIM's influence, the fact that he's indoctrinated mean that those are also reaper elements. TIM doesn't succeed in convincing the 2; 1 "dies" and the other faces the reapers' master himself. I find it likely that the leader of the reapers, who assert their greatness in all 3 games would atleast try to get you to see things his way. He definitely tries by making you doubt your plan to destroy them and highlighting 1-2 other options. They've been doing this routine for billions of years, so I'm sure they're deeply rooted in their morals.
The main evidence against it is they'd never pull the rug out from under you and reveal that everything with TIM didn't actually happen and he's in fact still alive, and you'll have to have yet another confrontation with him. You probably could make a 20 minute long video of why everything after the start of ME2 is the afterlife with evidence if you looked hard enough too.
And if I recall correctly the codex states guns don't actually need to reload, the reload mechanism is actually just an instant cooldown thing, but if you don't do that your guns can break like Zaeed's.
oh i don't think that bioware intended the indoctrination theory. i just think it's a MUCH better ending than assuming that what we saw was real. yes, even though that would mean you haven't really beaten the Reapers yet. because what we saw makes no sense, and the indoctrination theory makes sense with the rest of the game, even though it leaves the true resolution unfinished.Plus if the indoctrination theory is true then there should be more gameplay because then you haven't really beaten the Reapers yet you've only made their attempt to indoctrinate you fail.
Technically the whispers only start when Shepard approached Anderson, someone who is already being controlled, then as soon as TIM appears the oily stuff appears. The whispers are just him being within range of TIM and the oilyness is him being controlled by TIM.
He doesn't make you doubt your plan to destroy them, in fact if you get your squaddies killed and suck at everything he just plan straight up gives you the option to destroy them if you did so to the Collector base.
I'm looking forward to the DLC. I'd like to see how these things factor into everything.The rest I left out because it's irrelevant. I can tell we're speaking from a different viewpoint here, you're speaking like the IT is a fact whereas I'm speaking from the viewpoint that it's just a theory. They've all but directly confirmed it's not true, the DLC will clarify it, as the IT theory being true would completely change their ending and they've already stated they're not doing that.
So, despite being controlled by reapers everything in that scene is directly TIM's doing. Were the whispers and shadows in Shep's dreams also TIM? I dont think TIM was near Shepard when he sleeps in the Normandy. A reaper puppet can manipulate Shepard but the reapers can't. TIM must be more powerful, which is pretty ironic.
He does imply that its bad and pointless, regardless of EMS. The other 2 are presented as better options, and we learn before that indoctrinated people seek to control them. Shepard survives the destroy option with a high enough EMS; that's already defying what the kid implied prior to this.
If the IT theory was real this is what would happen:
The game would end without a resolution. Or, there would a whole section afterwards that you would only get if you had a high EMS and picked destroy, which would make that element of choice pointless as the other 2 endings aren't real. Upon getting it everything would play out near identical, Shepard would still be injured, TIM would have to be resolved and so would the Crucible. Now what to do with TIM? Make the 2nd biggest antagonist in the series get a quick anti-climactic end, or give him yet another 10 minute long scene.
Whatever the case you would basically be playing out everything you already did a few minutes ago, and then you'd end up at the Crucible. What does it do this time? Well most people seem to stumble when asked this, but the general wants are it to be a massive laser, which I assume means every Reaper would have to get in single file directly infront of it, or some sort of pulse that disables the Reapers weapons, shields and indoctrination tech. In otherwords a slow version of the destroy ending.
So if it were real you'd either have to leave everything unresolved or get a high EMS and pick destroy, replay everything again with slight differences, then pick destroy again. That's not a better ending, if people complained about their choices not mattering then they'll complain even louder once they realise they're getting railroaded into choosing one ending.
TIM isn't being directly controlled by the Reapers, that's not how indoctrination works (well, not until the Husk stages) he's mearly doing their will, but I doubt they were even aware he was until just before they attacked Horizon. His implants gave him the ability to control his troops but the tech obviously backfired as all it did was speed up his indoctrination and the stuff he could do was crap compared to what the Reapers can. The dreams have nothing to do with that scene. Shepard never fell under indoctrination, it's even confirmed beforehand from Vendetta who disappears when an indoctrinated presence appears, and TIM wasn't more powerful, in fact he even admits it right before he blows his brains out.
He says it's pointless because the peace wont last, but he spends an equal amount of time detailing it as he does the other 2. I was surprised, I expected him to breifly gloss over it, but if you watch the ending he gives them all equal time. Shepard surviving doesn't defy what the kids said, as he only points out Shepard is partially synthetic, which is another way of saying your synthetic parts will be destroyed, whereas Shepard is also partially organic.
Anyway I'm getting bored. You are only setting yourself up for disappointment, the fact that you mentioned the dreams, something completely unrelated to the ending, shows that you believe the IT theory to be correct and that means we're effectively talking about two completely different things but in one argument.