• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Geno (♥♪!?): Return of the Starsend Savior

Status
Not open for further replies.

Griselda

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
1,077
Dark Samus doesn't move like Samus at all either, and she become a Echo Fighter.
That's really just a difference in how they get around. Dark Samus still tends to shoot at you with her arm cannon during her boss battles, so she and Samus share a base attacking moveset of 'shooting energy blasts/missiles'. On the other hand, even if you change Metal Sonic's animations to have him floating off the ground rather than running, he would still end up jumping and using spin attacks, which he doesn't really do in the games.
 

ForsakenM

Smash Lord
Joined
Sep 14, 2018
Messages
1,984
Fatmanonice Fatmanonice considering that Namco has only one character at this point, do you think it's possible that Lloyd/Nightmare could be a "both" situation rather than an either/or?

Looking at the Power of 6, Namco is the only company with an odd number of costumes remaining (Lloyd, Heihachi, Gil). All three costumes could return with the next Namco rep, or one could be held back for another fighter. That said, including Heihachi's costume with Nightmare might make a lot of sense. With both Tekken and Soul Calibur as well regarded Namco fighting game franchises, Nightmare could bring 3 SC and 3 Tekken costumes, for example: Sophitia, Siegfried, Yoshimitsu || Heihachi, King, Jin. From there, Lloyd would bring his own costume, other Tales series costumes, and Gil.
This is what I was talking about before. Every new character has only brought back two costumes, but Bamco has three.

Thus, it would make perfect sense for Lloyd to come as a character and without his costume and have the Heihachi and Gil costumes come back with two other Tales Of costumes and maybe another new Tekken or Soul Calibur costume.

Let's be real: Nightmare would be cool as a character, but he would also be a sick-ass costume.
 
Last edited:

RetrogamerMax

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2018
Messages
12,221
Location
Houston, Texas
NNID
RetrogamerMax2
Fatmanonice Fatmanonice considering that Namco has only one character at this point, do you think it's possible that Lloyd/Nightmare could be a "both" situation rather than an either/or?

Looking at the Power of 6, Namco is the only company with an odd number of costumes remaining (Lloyd, Heihachi, Gil). All three costumes could return with the next Namco rep, or one could be held back for another fighter. That said, including Heihachi's costume with Nightmare might make a lot of sense. With both Tekken and Soul Calibur as well regarded Namco fighting game franchises, Nightmare could bring 3 SC and 3 Tekken costumes, for example: Sophitia, Siegfried, Yoshimitsu || Heihachi, King, Jin. From there, Lloyd would bring his own costume, other Tales series costumes, and Gil.
You know I just realized: If the Namco rep comes out after the Season Pass and it's Nightmare, we could get a Siegfried Echo to go alongside him. How sick would that be. :2gud:

Let's be real: Nightmare would be cool as a character, but he would also be a sick-ass costume.
No thank you.
 
Last edited:

Griselda

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
1,077
Also.. am I just horribly misreading things because I'm sick, or are we now saying that Geno isn't very likely to appear as a fighter, despite it having been claimed that his chances were pretty good and people were talking about him?
 

EarlTamm

Smash Hero
Joined
Jun 17, 2018
Messages
7,348
Also.. am I just horribly misreading things because I'm sick, or are we now saying that Geno isn't very likely to appear as a fighter, despite it having been claimed that his chances were pretty good and people were talking about him?
It's a character 5 thing, not overall DLC.
 

Spatulo

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 8, 2019
Messages
1,258
Location
Planet Bomber
NNID
Spatulo
Switch FC
SW 6433 1491 0045
Also.. am I just horribly misreading things because I'm sick, or are we now saying that Geno isn't very likely to appear as a fighter, despite it having been claimed that his chances were pretty good and people were talking about him?
Misreading I think haha. Geno is most likely not character 5, but he’s still likely for Season 2
 

RetrogamerMax

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2018
Messages
12,221
Location
Houston, Texas
NNID
RetrogamerMax2
Also.. am I just horribly misreading things because I'm sick, or are we now saying that Geno isn't very likely to appear as a fighter, despite it having been claimed that his chances were pretty good and people were talking about him?
I think it's misinformation some of the guys are spreading around. Fatmanonice Fatmanonice clearly thinks Geno is coming before E3 and I believe that if he does.
 
Last edited:

StarLight42

Smash Lord
Joined
Jul 17, 2014
Messages
1,683
Also.. am I just horribly misreading things because I'm sick, or are we now saying that Geno isn't very likely to appear as a fighter, despite it having been claimed that his chances were pretty good and people were talking about him?
Fatman said he’s around 3rd on his list of most likely. Lloyd being 1st. Not bad.
 

Grumbo

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
673
Lloyd and Geno seem to be the most likely huh?
EAB3E833-6146-4BF4-A684-A4AD39945700.jpeg

AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
 
Last edited:

Griselda

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
1,077
Has there been any evidence for or against characters continuing to come with stages and music?
 

Franco Geno

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 26, 2019
Messages
1,445
Location
Argentina
Hey guys, i had my nose surgery this morning so i was not able to keep up with everything that happened so yeah, what did i miss?
 

Griselda

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
1,077
Not really.
I just want Geno to come with a SMRPG stage. We have Mario stages, already, but none of them represent the version of the mushroom world depicted in SMRPG very well. ..That, and it'd be good twice over if it was Bowser's Keep with Exor, since we still lack a dedicated Bowser's Castle stage, which is rather odd after all this time.
 

RetrogamerMax

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2018
Messages
12,221
Location
Houston, Texas
NNID
RetrogamerMax2
Hey guys, i had my nose surgery this morning so i was not able to keep up with everything that happened so yeah, what did i miss?
- Resident Evil getting Spirits.

- Fatmanonice Fatmanonice and the discord saying FP5 will probably either be Lloyd, Dante, Nightmare, Sol, or a curveball.

That's pretty much it.

Edit: That's great news to hear that your nose surgery went well.
 
Last edited:

Droodle

Smash Lord
Joined
Nov 29, 2018
Messages
1,185
Location
Milky Way
Hey guys, i had my nose surgery this morning so i was not able to keep up with everything that happened so yeah, what did i miss?
Fatman is saying Lloyd is the most likely DLC 5 character (or character in general).

Which is good for me because I've been on the Yuri/Lloyd train since day 1, even through all the "leaks" not hinting at them.

If Lloyd or Yuri get in; that means that I've been able to guess all the DLC characters at least 2 weeks ahead of time. So far I have a 100% track record, which I've been proud of!
 

AdamBel731

Smash Ace
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
756
Everytime someone uses the played out "anime swordfighter" comment, I feel like a puppy dies. It's such a blanket statement and I feel like people make a huge mountain out of a mole hill.

A VAST majority of the roster isn't like that. Want to know how many could be considered "anime swordfighters"? Less than 15 (allowing for margain of error fue to opinions, as I'd personally say 10). Like for the love of God, that's less than a quarter people. The game is made IN JAPAN. Don't you think it is natural for some fighters to have that "anime-esque" artsyle?

Like @Serenade01, dude, I usually like what you have to say, but saying you're "sick and tired of these 'anime swordfighters'" is a little much in my eyes. Especially chalking up Lloyd as just "another one." I have 0 experience with Tales of and/or Lloyd, but I'm not gonna make a blanket statement about him and act like he'll just be "another anime swordsman." Of course, you and others who feel that way are entitled to their opinions and are welcome to voice that in a respectful way. But come on, I'm not even into anime and I think that the "anime swordfighter" thing is so played out and made a bigger deal than it is. It just seems like another example of how the Smash community hates characters that that don't know/don't want.
 
Last edited:

Franco Geno

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 26, 2019
Messages
1,445
Location
Argentina
- Resident Evil getting Spirits.

- Fatmanonice Fatmanonice and the discord saying FP5 will probably either be Lloyd, Dante, Nightmare, Sol, or a curveball.

That's pretty much it.

Edit: That's great news to hear that your nose surgery went well.
Fatman is saying Lloyd is the most likely DLC 5 character (or character in general).

Which is good for me because I've been on the Yuri/Lloyd train since day 1, even through all the "leaks" not hinting at them.

If Lloyd or Yuri get in; that means that I've been able to guess all the DLC characters at least 2 weeks ahead of time. So far I have a 100% track record, which I've been proud of!
Thank you very much guys!
 

RetrogamerMax

Smash Legend
Joined
Sep 3, 2018
Messages
12,221
Location
Houston, Texas
NNID
RetrogamerMax2
Fatman is saying Lloyd is the most likely DLC 5 character (or character in general).

Which is good for me because I've been on the Yuri/Lloyd train since day 1, even through all the "leaks" not hinting at them.

If Lloyd or Yuri get in; that means that I've been able to guess all the DLC characters at least 2 weeks ahead of time. So far I have a 100% track record, which I've been proud of!
I've been predicting Lloyd since the November 1st Assist Trophy slaughter of 2018.

Thank you very much guys!
Your welcome.
 

frozolloyd

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Feb 25, 2019
Messages
125
Fatmanonice Fatmanonice I also got a question for you, just more so confirmation then anything. I remember back in, wow, last November or so that you said Lloyd's name was heard a ton more the Yuri's when talking of DLC speculation. Is the new info you guys got since then in the private discord directly linked to Lloyd Irving himself, or is it simply linked to the Tales of series in general?
 
Last edited:

AdamBel731

Smash Ace
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
756
I can't answer dead on questions like that but the names we've shared are kind of par the course for the rest: very few females, no indies, very few Western characters, and overwhelmingly third party. Crash had been heard and Banjo's already in. I think there's a decent chance for one more at this time but I'm warning people in advance not to expect a ton.
So you're saying you HAVE heard legitimately good things about one or two Nintendo characters? (Sorry if you already said this and I forgot.) I DO remember you saying how one singular Assist Trophy promotion was possible.
I'm going to post the evidence for Lloyd later today hopefully. Obviously it's not going to be as in-depth as Geno's analysis but I want get it out that,if he's not 5, he's probably 6 or 7.
So if things are so good for Lloyd (like Geno), then what's the point of Nightmare? Is it possible that we get a Bandai Namco character for both Fighter #5 AND post pass DLC?
 

MamaLuigi123456

Smash Champion
Joined
Nov 7, 2015
Messages
2,400
Location
Realm 75731
Everytime someone uses the played out "anime swordfighter" comment, I feel like a puppy dies. It's such a blanket statement and I feel like people make a huge mountain out of a mole hill.

A VAST majority of the roster isn't like that. Want to know how many could be considered "anime swordfighters"? Less than 15 (allowing for margain of error fue to opinions, as I'd personally say 10). Like for the love of God, that's less than a quarter people. The game is made IN JAPAN. Don't you think it is natural for some fighters to have that "anime-esque" artsyle?

Like @Serenade01, dude, I usually like what you have to say, but saying you're "sick and tired of these 'anime swordfighters'" is a little much in my eyes. Especially chalking up Lloyd as just "another one." I have 0 experience with Tales of and/or Lloyd, but I'm not gonna make a blanket statement about him and act like he'll just be "another anime swordsman." Of course, you and others who feel that way are entitled to their opinions and are welcome to voice that in a respectful way. But come on, I'm not even into anime and I think that the "anime swordfighter" thing is so played out and made a bigger deal than it is. It just seems like another example of how the Smash community hates characters that that don't know/don't want.
See normally I'd agree with you but considering five of the seven Fire Emblem characters, which all consist of swordfighters, have the same three specials :ultmarth::ultlucina::ultroy::ultchrom::ultike: and we have another pair of swordfighters that have similar movesets :ultlink::ultyounglink: (and :ulttoonlink: if you really want to count him since he's not anime, at least not in the way the aforementioned characters are) I feel the complaints are justified.

EDIT: you could probably count :ultpit::ultdarkpit: as well but they don't use swords as much as they use dual butterknives.
 
Last edited:

3DSNinja

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 30, 2018
Messages
1,390
Ike has completely different specials. He has a dash side-b, more like falcon kick then anything. and his neutral special, isn't a shield breaker at all, it's a ledge option. Same with Roy and Chrom on the neutral special.
Play SSF2 Lloyd tho, he is pretty well done there. (heck, just play SSF2. Zelda is a top tier there, you need more motivation?)
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
I just wanna comment on the whole “anime swordsman thing”

If a game series is based around melee weapons, the hero will have a sword. Always. It’s simple, versatile, and they can dramatically clash with the bad guy and the camera zooms in on their faces as they get real close dramatically.
Smash almost always goes for the main character in a series, so it’ll always be the sword guy. It’s like being annoyed that hand to hand focused fighting game protags punch.

And I know people always bring up axes and lances, but to be honest I don’t think these characters would end up that functionally different from sword characters.
For one, there's lots of ways that a character who fights with a weapon that isn't a sword would actually be functionally different. But, function really isn't the point. Dedede just has a big sword like Ike in function, but no one calls him a swordfighter. Joker and Bayonetta both fire physical, non-reflectable projectiles, so they actually just have a really long sword. Hell, while we're at it, everyone who punches something actually just has a really short sword, especially if they get intangibility. Rising Tackle just turns Terry into a sword!

The visuals of the fact that maybe someone has a giant hammer, or a big axe, or a lance is what counts. It's neat, unique, and stylistically different. People always jump to the other end of the spectrum and start wondering why no one ever complains when we have so many fist fighters, but those people need to do themselves a favor and look up all the styles of weaponless martial arts. It's super different, even in two characters so seemingly similar as Mario and Luigi.

Like @Serenade01, dude, I usually like what you have to say, but saying you're "sick and tired of these 'anime swordfighters'" is a little much in my eyes. Especially chalking up Lloyd as just "another one." I have 0 experience with Tales of and/or Lloyd, but I'm not gonna make a blanket statement about him and act like he'll just be "another anime swordsman." Of course, you and others who feel that way are entitled to their opinions and are welcome to voice that in a respectful way. But come on, I'm not even into anime and I think that the "anime swordfighter" thing is so played out and made a bigger deal than it is. It just seems like another example of how the Smash community hates characters that that don't know/don't want.
Well, I can't always say something people like. I said before that I don't fault the anime part of the anime swordsman, but Lloyd is comically anime. He'd be the epitome of the trope if added to Smash. Sure, two swords etc etc. I didn't play too much of Tales of Symphonia. I thought Lloyd looked cool back when I was 16, and I'll admit that nearly 14 years later I still think he is visually appealing. I'm a sucker for double breasted coats (even though he doesn't seem to be wearing one when you really inspect it), silver buttons, high collars and dual swords. He's wearing two belts so he could do without the goofy suspenders, but I guess that's a unique flair, silly as it is.

I have a lot of good stuff to say about Lloyd. What I think about his potential playstyle isn't one of those things and as it is, I would prefer him to just not be added to Smash, which puts him in an interesting position since typically when I don't want a character, I dislike some or all facets of just them. Just for the record though, me not wanting him doesn't affect my opinion on why I think he's not #5. I didn't want Hero but I had to admit he was coming as part of the Fighter Pass.

Dude, aren't like 3/5 of your most wanteds anime swordfighters (not counting Isaac as well)?
This may seem off topic, but jokes aside, I don't consider Robin an anime swordfighter. If I'm being super hyperbolic, I throw him in with the rest of the Fire Emblem guys, but I was excited to see him revealed (and had that excitement murdered when it meant Marth was getting another clone) He uses his sword(s) as a way to close the stock and cover what would otherwise be a zoner's weakness - close range. If he weren't so slow and didn't have the worst gimmick in the game weighing him down, I would love to play him. The same goes for Hero.

I did joke that 3 of the guys on my 3x3 could be considered anime swordfighters, but I see them as more than a swordfighter. I've always dreamed Masked Man's moveset to be like a Mii Swordsman fused with Mii Gunner with Diddy Kong's up B and maybe even a lightning strike attack similar to the one Hero has now realized. The sword is just a facet of his moveset. Obviously the same for Isaac/Felix and Django's kind of like my joke character - I appreciate him for the light sensor gimmick that Boktai tried out, but there's no way to incorporate that into Smash. I know he has absolutely no way of being a fully fleshed out fighter because Konami probably hates him, and the solar gun's probably the most ridiculous weapon possible for anything outside of vampire combat, but still, since several passive damage attacks have been added in, I think it could work and be something different. Switching lenses to do different things would make him another sort of stance character and having to yell "taiyou" all the time to recharge the solar gun would be different. Really, that's what I'm after. But hey, that's just my justification for it, maybe you looked at (and still look at) those guys and thought "yeah all they do is run up and hit people with a sword", like Marth and his three echo fighters, Ike, and Cloud - and like Lloyd would be awfully prone to doing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Ovaltine

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 7, 2018
Messages
3,905
EDIT: you could probably count :ultpit::ultdarkpit: as well but they don't use swords as much as they use dual butterknives.
They are absolutely READY for breakfast toast, let me tell you.

Dark Pit eats his toast pumpernickel with coconut oil butter. Pit eats his very fairy bread-esque, toasting white bread, spreading butter, and smothering it in nonpareils. Relevant to Geno, he himself would likely try a fairy bread-type thing with crushed star bits.

Dark Pit is disgusted by both of them.
 

DeputyDalmatian

Smash Cadet
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
28
One thing I wanna say is that regardless of who FP5 is, I’m actually really grateful for the picks thus far. Joker came out and I had no idea who he was, so I played Persona 5 and it became one of my favorite RPG experiences in recent years. Same thing with hero and Dragon Quest 11. And as weird as it might sound, I was the only one in my friend group growing up who owned a 64 but never played Banjo. The hype was such I finally got around to playing it, and it brought back fond memories of Mario and DK 64. I haven’t gotten around to playing any SNK games yet, but if Lloyd really does wind up being FP5, I can see myself finally getting around to trying Symphonia. This fighters pass really opened up a whole bunch of new franchises for me. I just hope the sentiment is returned for people that don’t know about Geno and Klonoa, haha
 

Organization XIII

Smash Champion
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
2,083
See normally I'd agree with you but considering five of the seven Fire Emblem characters, which all consist of swordfighters, have the same three specials :ultmarth::ultlucina::ultroy::ultchrom::ultike: and we have another pair of swordfighters that have similar movesets :ultlink::ultyounglink: (and :ulttoonlink: if you really want to count him since he's not anime, at least not in the way the aforementioned characters are) I feel the complaints are justified.

EDIT: you could probably count :ultpit::ultdarkpit: as well but they don't use swords as much as they use dual butterknives.
What always bothered me about that argument is they were meant to be the same and or similar. The whole point of those clones slash echoes slash whatever is too increase the size of the roster without putting in the time that a unique addition would require. That's not a swordsmen problem that's a dev time saving problem.
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
What always bothered me about that argument is they were meant to be the same and or similar. The whole point of those clones slash echoes slash whatever is too increase the size of the roster without putting in the time that a unique addition would require. That's not a swordsmen problem that's a dev time saving problem.
But how much could they really differentiate them? Link and Young Link is the biggest tragedy, honestly, because Young Link could have incorporated so many Majora's Mask concepts vs Link's traditional concepts - now that Link is Breath of the Wild Link, it's not as big a deal, but I think it's still equally a tragedy that Young Link doesn't have Majora's Mask concepts while Toon Link keeps that traditional Link approach. He has to earn his keep somehow...

Blue haired Fire Emblem lords, though? There's just not so much you can do. You pad the roster with clones or spare us the saturation. I prefer to be spared the saturation, to be honest.
 

Organization XIII

Smash Champion
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
2,083
But how much could they really differentiate them? Link and Young Link is the biggest tragedy, honestly, because Young Link could have incorporated so many Majora's Mask concepts vs Link's traditional concepts - now that Link is Breath of the Wild Link, it's not as big a deal, but I think it's still equally a tragedy that Young Link doesn't have Majora's Mask concepts while Toon Link keeps that traditional Link approach. He has to earn his keep somehow...

Blue haired Fire Emblem lords, though? There's just not so much you can do. You pad the roster with clones or spare us the saturation. I prefer to be spared the saturation, to be honest.
I mean considering Marth Ike Robin and Corrin all are different it shows you can still put in creativity. At the end of the day it's mostly just sprites for the earlier games barely moving and models kinda of doing a bit more later, how much effort Sakurai it's into making them different is up to him.
 

RingJ5

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 24, 2018
Messages
617
See normally I'd agree with you but considering five of the seven Fire Emblem characters, which all consist of swordfighters, have the same three specials :ultmarth::ultlucina::ultroy::ultchrom::ultike: and we have another pair of swordfighters that have similar movesets :ultlink::ultyounglink: (and :ulttoonlink: if you really want to count him since he's not anime, at least not in the way the aforementioned characters are) I feel the complaints are justified.

EDIT: you could probably count :ultpit::ultdarkpit: as well but they don't use swords as much as they use dual butterknives.
On top of this, we literally just got Hero a few months ago as a straight-faced example of the trope, and with his three distinct alts it can really make it feel like the pass is already well and truly filled with that exact kind of character. Not to mention Joker, who doesn’t quite wield a sword but is still a JRPG protagonist who uses a blade for quite a few attacks.

Having Lloyd be #5 would just end up weighing things so that literally the majority of the Fighter’s Pass are anime-styled blade-wielding JRPG protagonists, which is simply something that I can’t see happening in the slightest. Lloyd as post-pass, though? Absolutely, that makes perfect sense, being a costume promotion along with Geno.
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member

Guest
On top of this, we literally just got Hero a few months ago as a straight-faced example of the trope, and with his three distinct alts it can really make it feel like the pass is already well and truly filled with that exact kind of character. Not to mention Joker, who doesn’t quite wield a sword but is still a JRPG protagonist who uses a blade for quite a few attacks.

Having Lloyd be #5 would just end up weighing things so that literally the majority of the Fighter’s Pass are anime-styled blade-wielding JRPG protagonists, which is simply something that I can’t see happening in the slightest. Lloyd as post-pass, though? Absolutely, that makes perfect sense, being a costume promotion along with Geno.
I can't, in good conscience, consider Joker a part of the problem of guys who run up and hit things with a sword. He's very much a rogue and that's fine. Same for Hero. Lloyd just feels so much like he's just gonna be two swords Marth.
 

MissingGlitch

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
3,359
They are absolutely READY for breakfast toast, let me tell you.

Dark Pit eats his toast pumpernickel with coconut oil butter. Pit eats his very fairy bread-esque, toasting white bread, spreading butter, and smothering it in nonpareils. Relevant to Geno, he himself would likely try a fairy bread-type thing with crushed star bits.

Dark Pit is disgusted by both of them.
Toast with pumpkin butter tastes great.
The thread is speculating over who will be fighter number 5 and you two are discussing toast.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom