I just wanna comment on the whole “anime swordsman thing”
If a game series is based around melee weapons, the hero will have a sword. Always. It’s simple, versatile, and they can dramatically clash with the bad guy and the camera zooms in on their faces as they get real close dramatically.
Smash almost always goes for the main character in a series, so it’ll always be the sword guy. It’s like being annoyed that hand to hand focused fighting game protags punch.
And I know people always bring up axes and lances, but to be honest I don’t think these characters would end up that functionally different from sword characters.
For one, there's lots of ways that a character who fights with a weapon that isn't a sword would actually be functionally different. But, function really isn't the point. Dedede just has a big sword like Ike in function, but no one calls him a swordfighter. Joker and Bayonetta both fire physical, non-reflectable projectiles, so they actually just have a really long sword. Hell, while we're at it, everyone who punches something actually just has a really short sword, especially if they get intangibility. Rising Tackle just turns Terry into a sword!
The visuals of the fact that maybe someone has a giant hammer, or a big axe, or a lance is what counts. It's neat, unique, and stylistically different. People always jump to the other end of the spectrum and start wondering why no one ever complains when we have so many fist fighters, but those people need to do themselves a favor and look up all the styles of weaponless martial arts. It's super different, even in two characters so seemingly similar as Mario and Luigi.
Like
@Serenade01, dude, I usually like what you have to say, but saying you're "sick and tired of these 'anime swordfighters'" is a little much in my eyes. Especially chalking up Lloyd as just "another one." I have 0 experience with Tales of and/or Lloyd, but I'm not gonna make a blanket statement about him and act like he'll just be "another anime swordsman." Of course, you and others who feel that way are entitled to their opinions and are welcome to voice that in a respectful way. But come on, I'm not even into anime and I think that the "anime swordfighter" thing is so played out and made a bigger deal than it is. It just seems like another example of how the Smash community hates characters that that don't know/don't want.
Well, I can't always say something people like. I said before that I don't fault the anime part of the anime swordsman, but Lloyd
is comically anime. He'd be the epitome of the trope if added to Smash. Sure, two swords etc etc. I didn't play too much of Tales of Symphonia. I thought Lloyd looked cool back when I was 16, and I'll admit that nearly 14 years later I still think he is visually appealing. I'm a sucker for double breasted coats (even though he doesn't seem to be wearing one when you really inspect it), silver buttons, high collars and dual swords. He's wearing two belts so he could do without the goofy suspenders, but I guess that's a unique flair, silly as it is.
I have a lot of good stuff to say about Lloyd. What I think about his potential playstyle isn't one of those things and as it is, I would prefer him to just not be added to Smash, which puts him in an interesting position since typically when I don't want a character, I dislike some or all facets of just them. Just for the record though, me not wanting him doesn't affect my opinion on why I think he's not #5. I didn't want Hero but I had to admit he was coming as part of the Fighter Pass.
Dude, aren't like 3/5 of your most wanteds anime swordfighters (not counting Isaac as well)?
This may seem off topic, but jokes aside, I don't consider Robin an anime swordfighter. If I'm being super hyperbolic, I throw him in with the rest of the Fire Emblem guys, but I was excited to see him revealed (and had that excitement murdered when it meant Marth was getting
another clone) He uses his sword(s) as a way to close the stock and cover what would otherwise be a zoner's weakness - close range. If he weren't so slow and didn't have the worst gimmick in the game weighing him down, I would love to play him. The same goes for Hero.
I did joke that 3 of the guys on my 3x3 could be considered anime swordfighters, but I see them as more than a swordfighter. I've always dreamed Masked Man's moveset to be like a Mii Swordsman fused with Mii Gunner with Diddy Kong's up B and maybe even a lightning strike attack similar to the one Hero has now realized. The sword is just a facet of his moveset. Obviously the same for Isaac/Felix and Django's kind of like my joke character - I appreciate him for the light sensor gimmick that Boktai tried out, but there's no way to incorporate that into Smash. I know he has absolutely no way of being a fully fleshed out fighter because Konami probably hates him, and the solar gun's probably the most ridiculous weapon possible for anything outside of vampire combat, but still, since several passive damage attacks have been added in, I think it could work and be something different. Switching lenses to do different things would make him another sort of stance character and having to yell "taiyou" all the time to recharge the solar gun would be
different. Really, that's what I'm after. But hey, that's just my justification for it, maybe you looked at (and still look at) those guys and thought "yeah all they do is run up and hit people with a sword", like Marth and his three echo fighters, Ike, and Cloud - and like Lloyd would be awfully prone to doing.