post 3: random votes tHe-Man. This will be interesting if he flips scum.
Dude, it's called RVS.
Even RVS can be used as evidence, even if it's not much. I think possible links can be found in it, in since tHE-MAN has flipped scum, my suspicion of you has gone up a small, tiny bit.
post 32: Points out what he considers to be flaws in Cello's first post. States that he has
an open playstyle and likes to debate. Asked cello why he voted for me. Votes cello.
I don't really think that TPK has been an open player this game, like he said he is. Tell
me, TPK, what other completed games of mafia were you in and what alignment were you? I do
think this could be important to know.
UCM: Mafia
SSBM: Mafia
Muppet: (not completed but I am dead) town
also, have you ever seen marshy or KevinM play? that is a closed playstyle. compared to that my style is quite open. not *THESE ARE MY CARDS* cello style, but you get the point
Alright, thianks. In those games that you have played where you were mafia, would you describe your playstyle "open" as well? What about Muppets where you were town? What would you say the difference is between your town play and scum play, if any? Please be honest.
post 56: He defends himself against Cello. Nothing really noteworthy there. States what
expieriance he has with this set up and states that he wants to reread.
post 57: asks what popcorn mafia is and asks cello to clarify what cellorule #28 means.
post 63: I don't really understand that post. He defends himself. Okay, I understand that
much, but I don't understand what he means by "if you specifically direct a question or FoS
at someone else and I believe you don't perfectly make sense I don't have to think weird of
that, but if you direct something at ME and somehow it is fine for me not understanding it,
you're being illogical." What I don't understand is why he thinks that he doesn't have to
find it wierd when someone makes a bad case against someone else (that's what I'm reading
here, please correct me if I'm wrong).
you're about right. when person A makes a case (irrelevant good/bad) against person B, it is B's job to defend himself, person C doesn't have to defend B.
Okay I can definitly understand that. But don't you think that it could still be good to butt in in some situations? What if the case is scummy? Scum make cases to you know.
If that is what he means, then I find that scummy. In tthat case, he's basically saying that
he ignores cases that arn't directed to him, no matter how bad they are.
Or how good.
See above. If a case is poor, then I believe you should point it out.
He also in that post states that he is "in a trench war" with cello and that cello sticks
out to him.
point being?
Just going over all your posts, even if I don't have anything to say about it.
post 90: He attacks SSBF. He unvotes cello, fos ssbf, and votes *The Jester*. Nothing really
scummy here.
Post 120: He asks Pierre for a read on SSBF. Not much, but I think that it's interesting to
note that Pierre and TPK have very little communication with one another, something I would
expect from scum buddies.
Why would oyu expect that?
Because I would think scum would try to keep away from each other, so that it's harder for links to be formed between if one was to be caught.
post 125: States that he thinks SSBF is a bad townie. He was right, but I don't really trust
TPK's meta knowledge that much.
how so? seems like you are prejudiced here.
See below.
TPK, what other games of mafia were in with SSBF, were he was town? Why did you think that
he was just a bad townie and not a bad scum?
SSBMafia, he was scum. there he took a very aggressive approach on things.
Whoa whoa whoa whoa. If you were only in one game with, in which he was scum, then how would you know that he was a bad townie? How is your meta knowledge of him sufficient? What would lead you to believe that he was just a bad townie but not a bad scum?
post 135: This one is interesting. He complains about the server problems and states that he
doesn't really find reason that when heat confirmed should matter. Okay, fair enough.
HOWEVER, he then goes on to state that there might be a link between Heat and Pierre, and
that he wants Heatstroke, cello, and pierre to stump. What is really interesting to note is
that he only wants Pierre to stump depending on how Cello and Heat flip. If he was scum,
then he would of known that Heat was town, and that there wouldn't be a link between the
two. That way, it could appear that he was focusing on Pierre without attacking him. I think
that there is a good chance this was a bus.
Wut? it had nothing to do with that, but only with Cello proclaiming that heat and pierre were scum. if heat flipped scum and cello town, pierre likely would be town. if the other way round (heat town, cello scum) pierre would more likely be town.
then they both flipped town and I got confused.
Okay, so that's convenient. Out of the two ways you most expected the scenario to turn out, both still would lead you to thinking that Pierre was town. But it ended turning up differently, and so, instead of having another read in case this happened you just "got confused". So no matter what Pierre couldn't turn up scum to you, hm?
Well, at least you're honest.
post 141: Asks Brockin to define "us".
post 144: Answers Brockin's question. Asks Macman a question about lynching stumps. This
question is. . . weird. TPK, why would you want to know? As in, why would it matter?
clarification of the rules. just like at somepoint someone wondered if stumps could die from inactivity and possibly ending the day with that.
\
Okay, fair enough. But why would this information matter? That's what I really want to know.
post 145: Disregards the question in his last post. I still find the question wierd. Also, I
find it scummy that even mentions his pm, in the same way I found Cello to be scummy at the
start of the game.
We saw how cello worked out hm?
You're not Cello. Just because Cello did something scummy but ended up being town doesn't mean that someone else can do something similar to it and not expect people to find it suspicions still.
That's all for right now, I'll complete it after school.
Also right now there is some weird things that I noticed about others in this game. I'll see if I can quickly say them on my school's computer later.