Tree Stump Mafia - OVER! Who lived happily ever after in the forest?

[Cello_Marl]

Sworddancer, Paprika, you two will be the next two people I'm going after. If one of you is town, please save me some time and go ahead and stump yourself. I'm asking this as a favor.

 

[Deleted member]

next town stump will bring us in LyLo. So unless you have an actual case against me, no.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Yeah, it was "led".

Anyway, it's just mylo, not lylo. I see Dancer is replying; let's hear what he has to say.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Like, right now? If I stump it would put town at L-1 (that's including the nk). I'll say this again, though, if the majority of people want me to stump then I'll do it.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

ninja'd

10ninjas

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

EDWOP: By L-1 I meant lylo. >_> Even though I guess that's not even correct.

 

[Deleted member]

my bad, it's MyLo. point still stands

 

[Cello_Marl]

@Dancer: That's why I asked as a favor. Whatever. I'll just do both back to back. I'll start with Dancer though.

Just so it's known, tHe-Man is still scum, so it's just one of you two that's the other, probably, but hate.

Work. It's hard.

I'll do it later. I have something else to catch up on.

 

[Purple]

anybody dead yet?

 

[Nicholas1024]

@Cello

I'm going to have to disagree with you there. I've long held that one of SSBF/Omis is scum, and as SSBF flipped town, I'm going to go with Omis. I agree that Sworddancer can go after Omis though. He hasn't given us anything to work with, and there's no way I could trust him in LYLO. Besides, my 6th sense is telling me he's scum.

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

fyi i requested replacement i was really only in this game for the hydra

sowwy <3

 

[Nicholas1024]

Hey Xonar, while you're on could you just stump yourself?

 

[#HBC | ZoZo]

no man would ruin it for the replacement, he still needs his share of the fun

 

[Xiivi]

tHe-Man has requested replacement.

For future reference, if you wish to replace out please make sure you contact me as I'm the active mod currently.

 

[Brockin]

Xonar, replacing this late in the game? Seriously?

That's terrible. >:

Also

My argument is in red.



Might as well end this post with this...

ALAKAZAM KADABRA ABRA GENGAR!

So SSBF is town after all? Need to reread and reevaluate. ATM Omis is my #1 choice though.

Yes; yes.

Day 1 Vote Count X-7
mentosman8: (0)
Omis: (0)
Nicholas1024: (0)
SummonerAU: (0)
Sworddancer.: (0)
tHe-Man: (0)
The Paprika Killer: (0)
Not Voting: mentosman8, Omis, Nicholas1024, SummonerAU, Sworddancer., tHe-Man, The Paprika Killer (

)

Living Treestumps:
HeatStroke (Town)
Cello_Marl (Town)
Brockin (Town)
Super Smash Bros. Fan (Town)

4/7 to lynch.
Deadline is May 8, 11:59PM EST.

God ****it, Nick confirmed town BEFORE the mod. how much more scummy could he be? Seriously.

Town in this game sucks (not sure about my other half, but I didn't do too hot me thinks... =/ )

 

[Cello_Marl]

I considered that, Brockin, and I think he has a good reason, but let him say it.

 

[Nicholas1024]

For crying out loud, Rockin! What kind of idiot scum would stump themselves? It'd be almost as dumb as you were in Spidey mafia. And SSB mafia. And UCM mafia. And so on.

I mean, by doing that they essentially give town a free stump, and deprive themselves of a NK. There is no way ANY scum would stump themselves, and for you to even think so is unimaginably stupid.

 

[Brockin]

For crying out loud, Rockin! What kind of idiot scum would stump themselves? It'd be almost as dumb as you were in Spidey mafia. And SSB mafia. And UCM mafia. And so on.

I mean, by doing that they essentially give town a free stump, and deprive themselves of a NK. There is no way ANY scum would stump themselves, and for you to even think so is unimaginably stupid.

Seriously, you have to learn to respect others, whether they play stupidly or not.

UCM and Spider Mafia were understandable, but I felt I did decently well in SSB Mafia. The only thing I did wrong was just not claiming at that moment (and yes, the shot I did on you was legitimate. Deal.)

Now then.

It isn't that farfetch to say that a mafia would give up. Hell, SSBF hammered himself AS MAFIA, so what's to say he can't stump himself as mafia again. Sure, Mafias rather die then submit to a stump, but we can't always assume that.

If you don't like how I think, then that's fine, but calling me names and whatnot doesn't make you look any better/cooler.

 

[Omis]

I love how extremely defensive you got, Nick. Like shooting fish in a barrel.

 

[SummonerAU]

I think the point is "Why would scum stump in this game when they can force a lynch and get a night kill out of it"

 

[Omis]

That is what I took out of his original post also but do you not see how bad his reaction looks?

 

[SummonerAU]

Omis, could you do a post on the two people you believe to be scum and include notable posts and your interpretations of that post?

 

[Nicholas1024]

Seriously, you have to learn to respect others, whether they play stupidly or not.

UCM and Spider Mafia were understandable, but I felt I did decently well in SSB Mafia. The only thing I did wrong was just not claiming at that moment (and yes, the shot I did on you was legitimate. Deal.)

Maybe, but I'm sick of you tunneling on me. You did it D2 in SSB mafia, you've done it today in this game, and i need to shut up about ongoing games.

Now then.

It isn't that farfetch to say that a mafia would give up. Hell, SSBF hammered himself AS MAFIA, so what's to say he can't stump himself as mafia again. Sure, Mafias rather die then submit to a stump, but we can't always assume that.

Yeah, and in that game it deprived us of half a day and plenty of discussion. It was a reasonable enough move, and I believe his scumbuddies advised him to make it. Here he'd just lose a nightkill, and get slammed 10x harder then he did in that game.

If you don't like how I think, then that's fine, but calling me names and whatnot doesn't make you look any better/cooler.

*shrug*

@Omis
I'm sick of his tunneling crap, especially as there's no good reasoning behind it.

 

[Brockin]

I (swordsRbroken) am now posting. I don't think that Nich is scum just because he said SSBF was town before the mod. And yeah, why would scum stump themselves when they could lynch someone and get a nightkill?

Omis, are you actually going to stop posting fluff and contribute?

 

[Omis]

Im thinking hard about who I want to go after because after messing up with SSBF I dont what to think.
Id like Paprika and SwordDancer to post some more also so I can get me some reads on them.

 

[SummonerAU]

Well then, go off people that aren't Paprika and Sworddancer and list the suspicions you have on the others. I'd like to see what you think and why you think it.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Summoner and Nicholas, of the remaining players, is there a person that you both trust enough to take to Final 3? One of you two is going to die after we lynch tHe-Man (or let him get modkilled [quick, vote for an extension so there's enough time for that to happen! Day 1 win!]), probably Nick, so we need a second chair for Summoner.

 

[Omis]

Vote for Deadline Extension
I dont see why not at this point.

 

[Cello_Marl]

This is just getting tedious. This game is going to boil down to who is scum of Omis, Dancer, Paprika, and Mentos.

Here's my plan. First, we accept Nick and Summoner as clears.

Nick and Summoner, each of you pick someone of those four that you think is town or scum. We'll lynch tHe-Man, prove that he's scum, and one of you will die. At that point, we'll stump the two they didn't select (or did select, if they want to choose a scum instead), and all the stumps will form a council and decide on a final lynch if we haven't won by that point.

Currently, it looks like you want Dancer and Omis to stump. Is that right?

 

[SummonerAU]

Omis, Dancer, Paprika and Mentos: Could you do a post on the two people you believe to be scum and include notable posts and your interpretations of that post/s?

Omis, why should you be considered town and if you had to choose between Mentos and Paprika, who would you pick as most town(I mean, assume both are town, who is most town)?

Dancer, do you agree with Cello current idea and have you agreed with any of his ideas in the past? List what you agreed with and then make a list of who you believe is scummiest out of Omis, Paprika, Nicholas, Myself and Mentos and include notable posts from each individual and why/whynot you think it is notable(please do this).

Paprika: same as above but Paprika = Dancer.

Mentos, should people listen to Cello? If no, please tell me what you think is the best course of action. If yes, see Omis but replace you with Omis.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Alright, after doing a quick reread I have now decided that Nicholas isn't as scummy as my feelings have been telling me (I was only semi-serious about that anyways).

I don't think anyone has answered my question in post 554.

@SummonerAU: I'll answer the first part of your question now.

The thing about Cello's current plan that bothers me is that I'm suppose to accept that both you and Nicholas are clear. While I can accept Nicholas for the most part, I don't yet see why I should accept you as cleared.

But what I do like about it is that, if we can really accept you and Nicholas as, then I think it narrows it down to the two last scum (Paprika and Mentos).

As for his past plans. . . I'll have to say that I have agreed with some of his past plans. The thing is, most of his past plans I haven't even formed an opinion about. I have agreed with:

His case against Brockin
Letting him live after he ducked out of deal with Heat.

I have disagreed with:

Quicklnyching mentos when Pierre was about to modkilled.

I haven't even formed an opinion about:

His case against Heat.
His case against Pierre.

There might be some more that I missed.

I'll tell of who I think is scummy and why when I get home from school.

 

[Deleted member]

cello @ #587, pay attention please, tHe-Man is awaiting replacement so it would be stupid to quicklynch that person when they get in. modkill won't happen anymore also.

Request Deadline extension
because we're not getting anywhere right now

sommoner, give me a moment and you get that list

 

[Nicholas1024]

Request Deadline extension

My best guess is that Omis and Dancer are our two scum left. Omis I've suspected for a while, Dancer has been the least useful player in the game and just hasn't given us much. I really need to reread.

 

[Cello_Marl]

@Paprika: "Awaiting replacement" is not the same as "getting replacement". Further, "not getting anywhere"? How is extending the deadline going to help that? I feel motivated to build a case against you now, partly because I can't help but feel that you are just trying to waste time by delaying. We'll see how we judge you.

If we go with my plan, my suggestion to Nick to is to choose Mentos for his townie. I'll be honest; I really dislike Mentos's play, but Today's play is sooooooooooo townie.

Summoner looks like he doesn't need advice, so I'll get on that Paprika case.

 

[Nicholas1024]

Yeah, Mentos v.s. Paprika feels like a coin flip to me ATM, but Today played well, and Mentos at least started well, so I'll take Mentos for my townie, I suppose.

 

[Xiivi]

Replacement for tHe-Man still not located, if one is not found 24 hours from now he will be modkilled. Feel free to invite others to join.

 

[mentosman8]

*sigh* another modkill coming up, and probably another scum. This has really hurt my motivation toward this game.

@Summoner: the-man, and probably Omis or Pap as the other(pretty much a coinflip). Not going to do a big notable post thing, as I said the modkills(likely a second one coming up) have severely hurt my motivation for this game. I'll continue playing and posting my views, but I'm not going to try and build a big case, at least until I see if the-man's modkill happens, and if so how much it messes with the game.

Cello's idea seems reasonably good to me. I've already said that Omis and Pap are pretty much a coinflip to me. As for why I should be considered more townie? I couldn't answer that. I guess I could argue that I have been less parroting than Omis, and speaking my own mind despite it getting extreme backlash on me, but other than that I've been thrown mostly on the defensive since I replaced in, so I guess I have to let my defenses speak for themselves.

 

[Purple]

wtf, no, we don't need a deadline extension, we've gained 7 days from town, we should have more than enough.

 

[Omis]

Still liking The Man for scum as I pointed out earlier.

Nick gets some trust but mostly from Marshy. Still really dislike how defensive he was of Brockin but maybe Brockin is as tunneling on him as he says idk.

Liking Mentos for being a townie. He has at least worked pretty hard in most of his posts to find scum. I havent agreed with some of what he has said but he is thinking.
On the other hand....

SwordDancer and Paprika havent done anything for me. Like nothing. I dont think Ive really gotten solid stances or attempts from any of them and I know Im calling the kettle black but that is how I see it. They just feel like theyve been out of everything.

I dont really like how Summomner has basically taken up attacking everyone and asking questions as if he should be under fire. The gun man rarely gets the weapon turned on him which I think he is attempting here. (Brazillian saying so it might not make sense in English)

Not approaching the post from Summoner from now because I want to analyze him first.

Workin hard but school finals are coming up.

 

[Deleted member]

Sorry that I haven't been on for awhile. And what do you know, I am a stump. Oh well, I least I don't have to face lynch.

Anyway, I guarateen it, if I was scum, I would have still stumped. This is what Brockin is saying, however, given that you're still allow to post, I would have agreed to help you guys on helping the other two scums, even thought I wouldn't confirm them.

Nicholas, you're starting to get a bit defensive. I'm also noticing a bit of ATM from you as well, not good.

However, I would highly prefer a lynch/stump from Omis, I said that he was the most likely scum and he still is.

Virtual Vote: Omis