What? But you're biased against me! And slot 5 WAS the replacement... -_- Look, Metatitan judged us both and he deemed me as the better player. This might have to do with the fact that I beat his OTHER characters besides Jiggs in matches. Some of the characters that have an advantage against Jiggs. (But man, your peach was something else)
For some strange reason you have it set up in your mind that Online Jiggs dittos are the universal qualifier for the strength of a player in brawl. It's not. For many reasons, they are extremely different than actual matches in brawl. I want to run something by you: Our matches don't prove you're a better player than me. As soon as I switched characters to sheik, denoting I wanted to have ACTUAL matches, you left right after. You may have beat sheik, who I'm rusty with and has a 40:60 matchup against jiggs, but I would have liked to maybe play your characters with my jiggs, or used other characters.
I must first admit that you are a great player online. It is a fact. However, you used rollout to kill me a little too often, and I have a bit of a problem with that. Rollout online actually works, and as a player who actually does matches offline, it throws me off (not to john here, you really got me with them). I'm also not as willing to use rollout on you because it's a very BAD habit that I finally broke. So you had a home field advantage right there. If we played irl, very few of those kills would have worked.
You might place well online in ladders, but here's the thing: You play in ladders because it's the greatest form of competition you have available. You don't play people with low scores, you try and get as much points as possible, etc (like all people hoping to place well on the ladder should) so you get a high score. I play the ladder to get matchup experience so I can play better irl. I play almost anyone, play characters I probably won't win against and people with low scores. I'm not trying to win the ladder.
You might be a better choice for this online tourney, but you are NOT a better player than me. Not at all.
Oh, and sending the not finalized list and changing it to your benefit is low.