BEES
Smash Lord
Someone made a Travis texture for Lucas in Brawl+. I never played Lucas before, but now I have a good reason to.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Just thought I'd say this here. You can't make online lagless, you can only make the lag smaller and smaller, but like the number infinity, you never reach it. Still, less lag in general would be a godsend.They would also need to make online better (NO MORE LAG!!!) and have more options in stage builder. Alternite costumes would be amazing, but I think having a costume designer in game would also be bad***.
We still have Claus anyways so bleh.was talking about the masked man
Takamaru, hmm, now that's a lot of texture changing.
Its not really treated like one of the bigger series, but it does get attention. Still this can be chalked up to the fact that the series expanded between Melee and Brawl, and all the Mother content was a reflection of that. But you're not agreeing with me if you think its on the big franchise scale at all though, since its not. Mario, Zelda, and Pokemon are big franchises. Maybe if you want to argue it enough, Kirby, DK, and Metroid are also big franchises. Compared to them though, Mother is small, and the series is quite dead. Its not plausible to give another character to a series that will not get a new installment, especially if the series itself wasn't that popular to begin with. This is like Geno really, in that there is a large fanbase that has a voice but doesn't have much of a force. Really the fact that it has two characters is more than it really desrves, and it really shouldn't be pushed beyond that.It's treated for sure in Smash as one of the bigger ones, and it did help inspire Pokemon last I remember. I agree It's pretty bottom of the big franchises, but I think you're still looking too far into the series. One of the mother villians for sure is plausible If the series is considered as "Static"
Takamaru using a body slam wouldn't count as creepy?We still have Claus anyways so bleh.
Anyways, I would think that it would be better to give Goroh a Takamaru costume quite frankly, but since you're suggesting that the likes of Gardevior and Pichu should be added in with the movesets of Mewtwo and Pikachu, I don't see what your concern would be.
Hate running over this again as Toise has already explained this, but my version.Its not really treated like one of the bigger series, but it does get attention. Still this can be chalked up to the fact that the series expanded between Melee and Brawl, and all the Mother content was a reflection of that. But you're not agreeing with me if you think its on the big franchise scale at all though, since its not. Mario, Zelda, and Pokemon are big franchises. Maybe if you want to argue it enough, Kirby, DK, and Metroid are also big franchises. Compared to them though, Mother is small, and the series is quite dead. Its not plausible to give another character to a series that will not get a new installment, especially if the series itself wasn't that popular to begin with. This is like Geno really, in that there is a large fanbase that has a voice but doesn't have much of a force. Really the fact that it has two characters is more than it really desrves, and it really shouldn't be pushed beyond that.
As stated, I am very well aware that Mother is at/near the bottom of the barrel when it comes to supporting characters. I am also aware of the Static/Evolving discssion, which If Sakurai considers the series as Evolving, there's no way we're getting any more supporting characters to it.Myself/edited some whatever said:Sales do have affect on a character to a certain extent, for instance compare this:
1)
Mother: Ness, Lucas, Pokey, Claus
Mario: Mario, Luigi
2)
Mother: Lucas, Ness
Mario: Mario, Luigi, Peach, Bowser
Thus supporting characters with more popularity or known or whatever tend to get in first.
There's also cases where this happens:
Mother: Ness, Lucas
Metroid: Samus
But of course, that's more due to the character itself being harder to program.
Who ever said Goroh has a body slam attack?Takamaru using a body slam wouldn't count as creepy?
It could work I suppose. Cafe also had a nice idea
I wouldn't call F-Zero, PO, or Pikmin big series at all really. Your definition of big is much to vague. What do you consider a medium series or a small series? Heck, Pikmin is barely a series there since it only has two games, and that's pretty much the bare minimum you can have for a series.Hate running over this again as Toise has already explained this, but my version.
Then we see big franchises as differently, I see all the big franchises of Nintendo probably as:
Mario, Zelda, Pokemon, Wii Series (...*Insert "Sadly" Here*), Animal Crossing, Kirby, DK, Metroid, Star Fox, F-Zero, Golden Sun, Pikmin, Punch-Out (Moreso recently), Wario, Yoshi (Not as much as DK With these two) Fire Emblem, And Mother.
The other series besides Mother in there are from series that actually have the pottential to expand, and for some of them have a large fansbase. With the lack of a new game and small fanbase, there's no point in adding a character to the series at this point other than just doing it to expand the roster for the sake of expansion. And for the most part the game is heavily influenced by what would be the best thing for promoting other games, because it is moronic for Nintendo not to view it as such. Now does this mean that every character has to be someone that helps promote other games? Not at all. But Mother has already gotten two characters as it is, and without a new game and such a small fanbase, there is very little incentive to expand.I probably forgot one but whatever. Anyways; You're worrying about far too much on the "My Series > Your Series" Theory. Quite honestly, there's no reason any of those series with VALID Supporting characters should get in. Why should Krystal be denied? K. Rool? Black Shadow? Masked Man? Pokey? Because you think a series doesn't "Deserve" The number? That's ridiculous "Hey Sakurai, we should add Krystal." "Nope, too many fox characters. ADD MOAR TO MARIO" - We're in a fighting game, not a nintendo press sales meeting.
Those lesser/supporting characters were from series that got new content inbetween the two games. Given that the Mother series has officially ended, its not going to do that again. Its not the same thing and thus can't be compared to them.Speaking of similar representation in characters with series, Here's a food for thought: Smash 64 Had similar representation between series. Nobody complained about that. Mario still technically got more characters with Yoshi + DK Being partial still, and everything went smoothly. Now, If you take a look at brawl, It continues on that. Mario didn't get a newcomer added to It's series just for being Mario. Some new worthy series and guests joined the fray, like Pikmin, Wario, and Olimar, and some series got complete (Well, at least we can all agree on Kirby), along with some series getting there long awaited supporting characters (Lucas, Wolf, Diddy Kong, etc)
Metroid doesn't have any real supporting characters outside of Ridley, so its really not a valid comparison.And yet that did fine too. Now of course, even If you count my list of all big franchises, I do realize that Mother is at the bottom of the barrel/priority list most probably. As I've explained before, quoted from earlier:
quote
...Static and Evolving? What do you mean by that? The Mother series is dead. Its creator said Mother 3 was the end of it. There aren't enough fans to demand a Mother 4 anyways, so the series is effectivley out of commision.As stated, I am very well aware that Mother is at/near the bottom of the barrel when it comes to supporting characters. I am also aware of the Static/Evolving discssion, which If Sakurai considers the series as Evolving, there's no way we're getting any more supporting characters to it.
-Neither have a good chance. There's still a posibility as there is a posibility that a Gen 3 Pokemon will show up somehow, but the chanes are far from fighting.Point made:
-Do one of them have a fighting/decently good chance? Very well, yes.
-Is it an Extremely good chance like other supporting characters, ie K. Rool/Goroh/Etc? Nope. Not really. Not. At. All.
-Can the series be evolving thus treating Ness as repping all of Mother 2 and Lucas all of Mother 3? Yes. It's still possible.
See, I'm thinking on the characters, you're thinking on the series. Now where's this about Sales?Smash isn't completely guided by sales, but a huge chunk of it is, directly and indirectly. Mother has poor sales, indicating poor popularity, on top of the fact that it is mostly limited to Japan. This combined with the fact that it won't get a new game...like ever, makes it incredibly unlikely to get a new character. Why would Sakurai choose to add another character to a series that hasn't done anything since before Brawl, and said series really isn't that popular? The only reason for doing anything with Mother is to simply expand the series for the sake of expanding, which is where you get flawed ideas of putting Jody Summer in Smash.
I've already posted my thoughts on supporting characters to evolving series. Really, after F-Zero, Metroid, and DK, I just put everything in a "Possible" Bin, which is more of a 50/50 bin.And if extremely good is only about 50% then what you're ranking under that percentile certainly does not have a good chance.
Supporting character? Oh right, noticeable and fine ones at that. Mother has It's villians reoccuring throughout there three games. I wouldn't be so quick to say that's shoeing in a character for the sake of shoeing in a character.And no, they shouldn't all get their supporting characters. That again is just expanding the series for the sake of expansion. You're taking virutally unknown series and giving the supporting characters extra roles for no reason other than that they were the supporting character in this series, rather than the character themself, and that's just incredibly flawed.
edit:series actually ended because M3 had everything wiped out at the ending.
I haven't played MOTHER 3 (will during winter break), but I'm certain that after the credits you find out everyone survived. Anyway, MOTHER4, if it will ever happen can always pull a Final Fantasy or maybe it will bring to light Giygas' home planet. I was expecting that in 3, but that didn't seem to happen.
Assist Trophies/Pokeballs are far more interesting than regular trophies. That being said, my top 10 for those would be:Two questions:
What would be your top 10 trophy suggestions that aren't already seen in Brawl?
Would you expect them to be trophies. (eg. Gold Skulltula from Zelda: Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask)
Sales charts are a good indication if a series is popular, and if a series isn't popular then there's no reason to give it more characters than it needs. Bringing up every series to that level without regard to what the fans want or how the series has progressed IS placing in the characters only so that the numbers are larger, and I don't quite get why you don't get this. The Mother series isn't equal to the others, and compared to most its much less. It doesn't matter if Jody Summer is more recognizable than other F-Zero racers if she's still so very very unimportant. It doesn't matter what their standing in they provide so little, or their series is too weak. Those two can stand out as much as you or anyone else wants, but that doesn't change the fact that the Mother series shouldn't get a new character if the series doesn't do anything from here until Smash 4, which is likely going to be the case.Supporting character? Oh right, noticeable and fine ones at that. Mother has It's villians reoccuring throughout there three games. I wouldn't be so quick to say that's shoeing in a character for the sake of shoeing in a character.
Every series that can should, regardless of sales, I see no reason to not and I still don't see any reason that isn't "LOL SALES CHARTS" Which we have no proof that Sakurai cares on those, asides from which ones get there supporting characters first.. Now, with Jody Summer you were debating with Toise on whether she stands out to all the other F-Zero racers. In Masked Man's and Pokey's case, they do very well stand out against every other supporting character in there series and even rival Lucas and Ness in Popularity (Mainly in the series themselves considering Lucas/Ness have Smash Popularity)
I don't really know but in the credits you just see the credits and then "THE END" But anyways, I would like to see more of the middle or something pulled. You know, I've kinda always wanted to see a Star Fox game that fills in the missing holes. I never got how James Mccloud keeps coming back, a Clear picture of Venom, how the SF Team moved back away from each other, which ending is real in Command, etc. It's so mindboggling. And It doesn't help that the first one has no storyline whatsoever.
Yeah, the idea on the series itself is a pretty bad mindset. I do agree I think too much on the characters, but I think we need to open ourselves further. I did by listening to Toise's and Fatmanonice's posts along with Kuma's line about "This isn't a smash congress" And it really did open my mindset on the view of characters.You were right when you said my ideas were on the series, so why did you stray away from that? That's the real issue here. I myself advocated that Porkey was the best suited third Mother character for Pete's sake. But just because someone would be the next in line, doesn't mean that more should be taken from the line.
Actually there is. Usually 2D Trophies don't happen. I don't think most of my suggestions were even that probable for regular trophies.True, but the basic trophies have the one thing Assist Trophies and Pokeball Pokemon don't have:
No limits on what you want.
Thanks for telling me about that, I'll try seeing that.It's at THE END do you press the A button and you "see" that the characters survived. They mention that they would have to start their world anew since the world was, depending on how you look at it, was purified of technology and Porky's influences.
More of the middle? Are we talking MOTHER or Starfox here?
It would be nice if we got more info on the backstories for the Starfox characters. Currently, Wolf's trophy saying he knew James is inaccurate, but that may be something mentioned in the next Starfox game. As for the whole James thing, the best theory I've seen derives from the '93 Starfox comic. It basically explains how he can see the dimension Fox is in, but can't directly interact with anything besides talking.
Venom is another vague thing along with Andross' body. As for the Starfox team moving away from each other. Falco leaving was explained with a tie-in manga for Starfox Adventures. Command, IIRC, is only partially canon. I think none of the current endings are canon which is good because they either signified the end of the series, or it sucks for the characters.
The first Starfox game is not considered canon anymore. Starfox 64 took its place in the timeline.
If we were to go by what you want there, there would be sort of Smash senate. Certain sereis do get more representation than others, and those series are the ones that have accomplished more. No one can deny that.Yeah, the idea on the series itself is a pretty bad mindset. I do agree I think too much on the characters, but I think we need to open ourselves further. I did by listening to Toise's and Fatmanonice's posts along with Kuma's line about "This isn't a smash congress" And it really did open my mindset on the view of characters.
It IS bad that things are getting more obscure. Its something that is happening, I won't deny that, but it is far from a good thing. In fact its probably the worst thing that can happen to Smash because its so possible. When you get more and more obscure characters, you lose touch with the mainstream audiance. When you lose touch with the mainstream audiance you start to lose sails. Brawl got away with obscure characters because it could deflect the problem with first rate third party characters, but if it keeps on getting more and more obscure, it will be the death of the series. To that end, it is damaging if you add more and more things from unimportant series, even if the character you're adding is important to said unimportant series. You're throwing away popularity for the sake of a character's position within a series is not progressive at all and is more and is more recessive. If the Smash series is to survive, it needs to keep on expanding, instead of going back to old, unpopular games, and just choosing characters because they had a large role in it. Again this reminds me too much of the Geno debates where the fans disregard the age and unimportance of the character as a whole and cite how the character is popular and important ot the game itself. Claus and Porkey are very close to this, but they don't have nearly as many fans gunning for them because people generally don't know the series.I consider the statuses of the series themselves, as shown with my example, but you have to consider the characters too. Each game in smash has gone further obscure in characters yet at the same time, appleasing more parts of Nintendo. If you don't think It's getting more obscure; Get off of whatever drug you're on There is no bad thing in getting too obscure supporting characters just as long as they're all fine additions (As in: Important, Standing out in Importance/Priority over most of the rest of the series, etc) to there series and loved by the fans of those. We are merely only fans, thus we have no true say on if a series "Deserves" A Certain number. Heck, as I said, there is technically no cap, so If Sakurai sees the series not complete in the evolving/protaginist theory, he can take one from the line with us having no say about it.
No you're not getting what I'm saying. If Mother was actually popular it would be a bigger series like Metroid, DK, and whatever, but its simply not, and it never will be if you go by everything we know right now. There's zero point in including a new character to a series that so few have played and won't ever start up again. Its going to get closer and closer to a retro series, but due to its good forture of lasting a bit longer than those had gotten two characters instead of one. Now tell me if you can, if a series isn't popular, and there's so few games for it that so few have played, what is the incentive of adding a new character from it when it is already represented?Now, I do get what you're saying still. The Priority on Mother characters with supporting characters isn't the highest, especially when Metroid, DK, Starfox, F-Zero, and others are still running around a bit. Thus rendering Pokey/Masked Man as less probable suggestions.
Close to very improbable however? Nope. With nobody actually confirmed as newcomers, we have no info that suggests this asides from the Evolving/Static Theories.
I'd like to see a Starfox Chronicles game that filled in the missing information and expand on the generalized info. I've always wanted to see a Starfox Zero be made where we play the mission James embarked on prior to the events of 64. Overall, I could really see a lot of this stuff, along with the game events, in a comic like the Street Fighter and Darkstalkers UDON comics (but canon), or possibly a canon anime which would also make it one of the few kemono anime out there.Thanks for telling me about that, I'll try seeing that.
Anyways, I would like to see more on Starfox and Mother. That's very interesting info. I just really wish Command wasn't the end of the series If It actually turned out to be, because Assult and Starfox 64 were just so good in my eyes but also left me with so many questions.
I personally would enjoy to see a game that ties in with all these loopholes and plot stuff. Andross's body is just so weird and It's just all never explained. There's also more content you can fill in, like Bill and Fox (Correct?) At the training academy together or so. When I replayed 64 I was like "Wait, what?" I mean, Wolf's a cool character but he's just never really explained on how his rivalry began.
There's just so much left open about the past, the present, and the future of it.
As for Mother, I would like to see how some of the stuff ties in as well. Giygas always seemed interesting and I suppose with that ending It's possible to make a sequel, but on the contrary, I can understand why they ended Mother 3 there
Since Claus is dead, Giygas's army is gone, and Pokey's in safety for eternity
Certain series get more representation over others first.If we were to go by what you want there, there would be sort of Smash senate. Certain sereis do get more representation than others, and those series are the ones that have accomplished more. No one can deny that.
It IS bad that things are getting more obscure. Its something that is happening, I won't deny that, but it is far from a good thing. In fact its probably the worst thing that can happen to Smash because its so possible. When you get more and more obscure characters, you lose touch with the mainstream audiance. When you lose touch with the mainstream audiance you start to lose sails. Brawl got away with obscure characters because it could deflect the problem with first rate third party characters, but if it keeps on getting more and more obscure, it will be the death of the series. To that end, it is damaging if you add more and more things from unimportant series, even if the character you're adding is important to said unimportant series. You're throwing away popularity for the sake of a character's position within a series is not progressive at all and is more and is more recessive. If the Smash series is to survive, it needs to keep on expanding, instead of going back to old, unpopular games, and just choosing characters because they had a large role in it. Again this reminds me too much of the Geno debates where the fans disregard the age and unimportance of the character as a whole and cite how the character is popular and important ot the game itself. Claus and Porkey are very close to this, but they don't have nearly as many fans gunning for them because people generally don't know the series.
I didn't just read this, did I? If you want a tl;dr explination, It's at the bottom. I think I've completely shifted from Claus/Pokey and got into views in general.In fact its probably the worst thing that can happen to Smash because its so possible.
Or B) Adding in characters just for being popular instead of important in the Grand Scheme of things and ignoring most of the actual popular suggestions on the internet and not opening any new fan eyes at all along with what some people want (Let's face it, any console fanbase of the three is pretty spread out asides from "Main" Series)It makes a great roster as all series that have the important characters get there important characters. Some Third-Parties join the Boat. Some series with only one PC And Retro's are in for a nice Touch, and some nice Alternative costume stuff asides from Wario and whoolah. Nice roster. Nobody's complaining there asides from people who want something like every mario character ever made playable.
Picking off of series popularity only is completely boring and creates a bland roster which should be also avoided at all costs and also causes a lack of interest.If you're seeing the roster as Blue Hair, Blue Hair, and Blue Hair or 1st gen, 1st gen, 4th gen, then there's something wrong with you. People want characters, not categories
Bump because other post was way too long.I'd like to see a Starfox Chronicles game that filled in the missing information and expand on the generalized info. I've always wanted to see a Starfox Zero be made where we play the mission James embarked on prior to the events of 64. Overall, I could really see a lot of this stuff, along with the game events, in a comic like the Street Fighter and Darkstalkers UDON comics (but canon), or possibly a canon anime which would also make it one of the few kemono anime out there.
The way I see it, MOTHER 3's ending was the type where you can either end there or go on. After all, a new evil may rise to take over or Giygas' people have been preparing a full scale invasion all this time.
Now that I think about it, MOTHER, Starfox, Metroid, Zelda, and Fire Emblem would make for some very good anime if done right.
Speaking of MOTHER,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgV9K6Parqs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVaZ1O06G10
Well, the reason I suggest a new evil is that, from my understanding, it was just the Earth itself that was purified, not the entire universe. Thus, Giygas' planet was unaffected. This applies to everywhere else as well. Then there's your inherent darkness that exists in everyone. I mean, look what happened to Porky.Bump because other post was way too long.
Yeah, I could see this working very well with Star Fox. Star Fox: The Missing Ends. Give me that and an actual ending to the series like Mother gave me and I'll be fine with that It keeps me curious on If we'll ever see a SF6 (5 because of SNES) before Smash 4.
Could be possible, but it just seems it defeated all the evil. When you play the three it just really comes to feel like that. I guess one of the Pigmasks If still alive could come and take over with a whole new idea. I don't really know, but If that is the true ending of the series, I'm pretty fine with it. It at least didn't leave me with a ton of questions unlike Star Fox.
I don't know why but I'm not thinking TV shows. I'm thinking books and I usually don't think that. Like ever.
While you may not want to say that it is a Smash congress, its closer to that than a Smash senate.Certain series get more representation over others first.
Mario has four characters first because It accomplished enough to get them first. See: You view sales as a general deciding factor. I view them moreso as what a series should get first. We each have our reasons and there's absolutely no way to decipher which one is right.
Anyways, It's not a smash congress. Now, back to obscurity discussion:
The Roster will become more obscure characters becaue there's no stopping that, but it will be characters that people know despite their obscurity. K.Rool, Goroh, Bowser Jr., and pretty much every other pottential pick outside of Mega Man, are obscure characters but they are characters that are actually featured in curent games. Now Mother 3 may still be considered curent to a degree, but by the time of Smash 4, it most certainly will not be.By this logic, most newcomer ideas for Smash 4 shouldn't be considered, which is ridiculous on It's own. If we're comparing these standards then how about I begin listing a number of characters you've basically said "lol, no" Too? The roster will get more obscure regardless unless you start shoeing in popular characters. At least shoeing in important characters has more of a logic into it.
No other character has the same situation that Geno does, but its fairly simmilar to your two Mother picks given the situation of Smash 4. At the time they will be characters who have not shown up in a new game in a very long time, and their only claim to fame would be a somewhat major role in one game. (Actually this is closer to Claus than Porky. I don't know why you keep on throwing in Claus in there, since it seems that Porky is such a better choice than him, but that's a totally different debate) The only thing that will be pushing them is a very vocal yet small fanbase, and time after time, its clear that something like that just doesn't matter.Geno =/= Pokey and Claus.
Geno is from a series where all the "Main" Characters are done, at least for now. Possible Bowser Jr/Toad mention. Claus and Pokey are next in line in Mother.
Expanse in smaller series should only occur if said smaller series are expanding. F-Zero really shouldn't get its second character unless it has a new game inbetween now and next time. If the main series do not get a new game, then they simply shouldn't expand, and the focus should go to newer series instead of trying to milk a series for all its worth, which is what you're suggesting for Mother. Also, I can only think that your friends have poor memories of the Kirby games if they played Super Star and don't remember MK.Now then, this is pretty tangenty but whatever. Things are getting more Obscure, nobody can deny that. Now why should things stop getting more obscure? To say we should start shoeing in completely unimportant/less important characters for a larger series instead of expanding on smaller ones along with other parts of Nintendo/Third-Parties is just completely stupid. We still have the other Popular ones, and it is clearly not the direction the Developers want to take. It's not damaging the series in any way when you look at what Smash has already done, as there's not really many "Popular" characters of Nintendo's history left that wouldn't be filler. Heck, even some of the more considered popular additions from Brawl's collection of Newcomers aren't the most appealing. I asked some of my friends who HAVE Played Kirby Games. They didn't even know who Meta-Knight was yet they played Super Star, 64, and Air-Ride.
Heck, are we just looking at the characters popularity or are we not even looking at the game itself? Game mechanics come in as a selling part of a game as well. Some may just enjoy the game for what it is and not every new addition. You know, just as a fun game. There's certainly many other ways to keep that fanbase happy. Alternative-Ego's are certainly possible on a fresh few characters like Dr. Mario/Mario. Online would help increase a number of people greatly. Anactual story that isn't a kirby platformerAmazing Campaign without a ton of time spent could also prove to be very casual warming. There's many things the series could do without just completely selling itself on characters, you know, like what helped it in the first place.Alter-egos are not something that should be promoted all too seriously. They are true filler you know. Better online would help though. The story that you got in SSE is probably the best you can really hope for, but the platforming should be modified to fit Smash instead of Kirby, which I agree with. What helped it in the first place (assuming you mean SSB) was the characters though. =/
It will kill the series if you go too far. What you're saying is milking older series for all they are worth instead of turning to new things which is what can help move it along. The Fire Emblem thing is silly though as its a reason why a series like Mother shouldn't be revisited. In any case, I agree with this paragraph for the most part, which is what confounds me because it disagrees with what else you're saying. What will adding to the Mother series do? Anyone who wants to play it here pretty much would have to steal it, and there won't be a new game. Why would you focus on a dead series instead of focusing on one that's still around or a new one?Furthermore, why is obscurity so bad? You're treating it here like It's going to kill the entire series, which on It's own is pretty crazy to say. Putting Lucas into brawl helped his popularity a lot and was a very nice thing to do for the fans. Putting Ness in helped the series. Putting Olimar and Ice Climbers into Smash created a fresh new playstyle, along with Ice Climbers. Putting Fire Emblem into Smash made the series have a fanbase in the US and EVEN BE IN THE US IN THE FIRST PLACE Along with helping Roy, Ike, and Marth greatly. Putting Fox and his friends into Smash opened many of my friends to Star Fox. Putting F-Zero and Metroid into Smash had many people I know getting into those games.
Again, you're missing my point here. I am saying that you need to go to new series instead of pulling out obscure characters from dead series that have already been covered. What you're advocating here is what I want, and the opposite of what you're trying to pitch here. If you're going to go and take another character from a series which is already esablished, then it should be a popular and well known character, and the series should be alive and well. If not though, you should bring in new blood from a unrepresented series. The problem though is that series and the characters are unknown, and there is nothing to promote. Taking new characters from in then is just trying to bring in new characters for the sake of new characters, and that is what will kill the series. Its not what the fans want, and it won't open the fan's eyes to anything new.etc, the list can go on. Really now, this game is even moreso about pleasing fans than completely adding in popular characters along with opening eyes to series. The Additions turn out great because they make you want to find out more about series and whatnot. Well, not always great. There's the chance of getting a dud like Dr. Mario, but even then, that was loved by many smash fans oddly enough. Maybe not so much on forums who have the knowledge of knowing most of these crazy supporting characters, but I do have a lot of friends who were very questioned so on the melee veterans at least.
Again, this is a mix up that you're not understanding here. There's no way to avoid obscure characters, but there are different levels to this and different effects that inclusion can create, which you yourself have stated. Porky and Masked Man don't enlighten anyone about the series more than Lucas does. Porky and MM aren't popular, as is you yourself understand. Porky and MM will almost certainly not have new mechanics that make them a needed inclusion. That's why they have such low chances. Few people want them, their series is dead, and all that other jazz I've been restating so many times that you're not listening to. When you are forced to resort to characters like these, then you are digging too deep. When its got this bad, then you're at the point where you're killing the series. Everything else you said about including obscure characters is true, but it does not apply to these guys here, which is what I just don't understand.Adding in popular characters only creates a very bland roster. If you look at some fan-made roster's, that's wide open proof of that. Creating a roster of complete obscurity isn't the best thing ever, but when you realize it, the game WILL Get more obscure, and Sakurai and Devs along with players do not seem to have any problem with that. Heck look at it, Mario, the most popular gaming character. Anything else would get too obscure, so just keep it to him? Yep. Sounds like a great idea! (Obvious Sarcasm Applied)
High sales and repeating apperances are great indicator to the general popularity of a character. Its how you can meassure things outside of the internet, though its not very exact and can't always be your full basis.Here's another thing: You're now getting into applying outside of the internet where as the internet knows all these crazy supporting characters. How do we even know what most people outside of the internet, which is the fanbase you seem to be talking to want? All I know is Melee Veterans and Ridley, along with some Third-Parties. See: That's the thing. There's no direct choices there.
Its even worse to just add in more characters for the simple sake of expansion which is what you're advocating here. The middle ground here is that obscure series get at least some representation, while more popular series get their more popular characters included. Giving a obscure series more characters despite the fact that no one really cares for the characters is just as bad as creating a roster only comprised of the most popular characters. Since I feel that this mostly responds to the rest of your point below, I'm going to skip over some quotes (Really, there's no need to keep restating your point again and again....wait, I'm doing that aren't I? )Everyone infact on the internet seems to be fine with the idea of each series expanding to there important characters. It just comes down to what they believe is important, asides from the Fan-Made logic of "A SERIES CAN ONLY HAVE THIS MANY CHARACTERS BECAUSE IT'S NOT AS POPULAAR" Which is a horrid way to base a roster.
It shouldn't though because the series is dead and unpopular. Trying to give every series their supporting character only works if the supporting characters are worth something. The Mario series is so popular that it gets multiple games, and with its multiple games it gets to exapnd the characters and increase their popularity as well. In Addition to this it doesn't matter how curious your friend is, because the series is also grounded in Japan for the most part, and he'll likely have to steal to get it....Heck again your explanation is still just more exapnsion for the sake of expanding the series instead of the merits of the characters.Finally, you want a reason for Claus and Pokey? Sure. Here's something: If you explain say, Mario to a friend, you end out telling about Mario, Luigi, Peach, and Bowser for the most part. If you end up explaining Mother, you end out explaining Claus, Lucas, Ness (/ninten), Giygas, and Pokey. I've had to actually explain the series multiple times to my friends who don't understand it. Having Lucas and Ness only is kinda bad in a way, since it leads to mis representing the series a bit. Like some people will think Lucas and Ness are brothers.
One of them even asked after I explained "Why aren't Pokey and Claus there?" And I said "Well, the series isn't really that big, but there's always a shot in the future along with other series who aren't complete on there line of supporting characters too" It already started expanding, so it might as well finish the line.
The fans of the franchise already have their characters, and these addition ones are pushing way beyond what is needed. Heck, Lucas himself is more than it really needs, but he's there anyways. It garners hate in that it ignores characters who do have enough fans and enough games in favor of some obscure second stringer from a unknown franchise. Mother is already very well represented given all that it has done, so it hasn't been left behind. Its received more than its earned, and given that it won't expand with new games or fans, it shouldn't get new characters either. You're still not giving a real point other than your own self satisfaction.And that is why I believe every series should have It's important characters along with what Toise and FMOI Say that have opened me up. It gives fans of each of the installed franchises something great and in the end, doesn't garnet too much hate as long as It's presented correctly like Brawl has shown. NO SERIES LEFT BEHIND!
And the only thing you can really have against it is the series itself, which is putting too much stock into the series. If I may quote Toise earlier (since you know, I've like never done this before /sarcasm):
Thus you're being just as bad a the Blue Hair, Blue Hair, etc type people because you're jsut going Mother Character, Mother Character, F-Zero Character, F-Zero Character, Yoshi character, and what not without actually paying attention to what people actually want. Most of what you're saying is completely right here, but you just don't seem to understand how it is a double standard.
I would disagree with that. Even if the next 10 characters added were 3rd party, some from the same game, the cast would still be overwhelmingly Nintendo. People said the addition of any 3rd party characters detracted from the 'Nintendoness' of the game, and they weren't exactly right. I heard rumors that Tails was planned for Brawl, but SEGA wouldn't allow it. Not sure how true those rumors are, but considering there's a full model of 4 other Sonic characters in the game, I could certainly see it.Knuckles shouldn't get in...nor should any other Sonic (or MGS) character for that matter. It takes away from this being about Nintendo all-stars, so third party characters should really only be limited to one playable character per franchise.
If I'm following your logic here, that means there should be more Metroid and Mario characters because they're fresher series than a lot of others (each will have had a game this year and one next)Again, you're missing my point here. I am saying that you need to go to new series instead of pulling out obscure characters from dead series that have already been covered. What you're advocating here is what I want, and the opposite of what you're trying to pitch here. If you're going to go and take another character from a series which is already esablished, then it should be a popular and well known character, and the series should be alive and well. If not though, you should bring in new blood from a unrepresented series. The problem though is that series and the characters are unknown, and there is nothing to promote. Taking new characters from in then is just trying to bring in new characters for the sake of new characters, and that is what will kill the series. Its not what the fans want, and it won't open the fan's eyes to anything new.
Well their inclusion does take away from the Nintendo-ness to a degree, though nothing to be distressed about. The thing with adding in another from the series is that just means you add another and another and another until you get a Sonic series which is as big as the Mario series. Thus I feel that if the third parties are to expand, they should really just expand out with new third party series. I have no problem with Sega contributing another third party character, as long as its someone from a series that hasn't been covered. (Thus we can also have the same apply to Konami and get a Castlevania character) Otherwise all we'll ever get from Sega is just more Sonic characters. >_>I would disagree with that. Even if the next 10 characters added were 3rd party, some from the same game, the cast would still be overwhelmingly Nintendo. People said the addition of any 3rd party characters detracted from the 'Nintendoness' of the game, and they weren't exactly right. I heard rumors that Tails was planned for Brawl, but SEGA wouldn't allow it. Not sure how true those rumors are, but considering there's a full model of 4 other Sonic characters in the game, I could certainly see it.
I think Megaman is the only truly essential 3rd party character for the next game. Capcom definitely needs the representation, and their classic platformer is the most appropriate. If they added no other 3rd parties but him, I would be content.
Assuming, of course, the gameplay is improved somewhat.
You could argue that data of Tails simply never got in, but you could apply this to every character not on the roster.And I think that rumor is just that. Sakurai basically said that Sonic was the last character due to fan demand, and there's no indication that Tails was ever intended to be a playable character like Mewtwo or Roy were.
The only things I can remember is the personal victory theme and I think all the other stuff Mewtwo got save for a classic mode screen.I thought just popped into my head, but I remember Roy was said to be like Mewtwo in having more data than more of the other cut characters, but I can't remember exactly what said data was. Can anyone remind me what he got that the others (bar Mewtwo) didn't get?
Roy and Mewtwo (as well as Luigi, Peach, Bowser, Falco, Wolf, DeDeDe, Ike, Lucario, Pokemon Trainer, Diddy Kong, Zelda, Gannondorf, and Toon Link) were supposed to have special victory fanfares because they have files (like all the Mario characters have the same fanfare, all Pokemon characters have, Kirby and DeDeDe have, Meta-Knight has, etc.) that were unused/empty and none of the other scrapped characters have any directories or files like that.@everyone else
I thought just popped into my head, but I remember Roy was said to be like Mewtwo in having more data than more of the other cut characters, but I can't remember exactly what said data was. Can anyone remind me what he got that the others (bar Mewtwo) didn't get?