On Tom Nook being the AC rep, that is something I agree with, since no one else makes quite as much sense. For a AC male and/or female, that character's apperance is completely diecided by the player, and thus there's no one set thing to go off of. If a character who's apperance could be customized was included in Smash, it would make much more sense to use a Mii than a ACer. Outside of that, Nook makes more sense than say Resseti and Tokeke, because both of those characters are optional, and don't play a real role in AC's "story" like Nook does. Nook is the guy you buy your house from, and the guy you buy all your stuff from. K.K. Slider is just someone you can see on weekends, and Mr. Resseti is someone you're not supposed to see anyways.
Plus the one cool thing I thought could work with Nook is that he could have Mario's Tanuki powers.
AC Player: Yet sakurai picked generic ones fine for the BG Of Smashville...And he picked one when he gave the reason. His reason was not being able to fight, thus Tom Nook wouldn't make sense either.
Nook really doesn't do as much as people think he does in the game. Really; If generic was that much of a problem to Sakurai, we would've gotten nook, but It's the fighting part.
As for rest of the roster stuff:
You see Tom Nook basically the whole game.
Mona appears to be wario's love interest.
Little Mac is a Shoe-in
Sukapon was considered for Melee AND Brawl.
The way I set up pokemon was to where every gen got a rep.
Do you think Mario will get another rep? If so, it will likely be Toad.
Well, Yoshi is in need of another rep. but I think Kamek is very deserving
Show me your roster so I can respond to it. (I wasn't a member when you made a roster...)
AC: Not really.
WW: Yeah, If WW Get's another rep, I'd be fine with mona.
LM: Wait when did I say anything here? I'm just wtf'd on why pit is out.
Sukapon: Yeah, and If you have ridley on there, there's no excuse to not include him.
Poke: Well, better than putting in "5TH GEN REP LOL"
Mario: It deserves 6 Reps if Poke has 6 reps for sure. I personally think we'll just get one.
Yoshi: It's not "In need" The only series I can truly say is in need of a character is F-Zero.
And I never made a roster mainly based upon my opinion's here, but I have made this pic a while ago: (Explanations are below, for all people going "WAIT WHYS LUCARIO ON THERE" or "WAIT WHY ?" or "WAIT WHY NO LITTLE MAC")
45: I went with 45 Because really, the increasements have only been in 10-15. 50 Is just too far and 40 Just seems like too little of an update to me, so I just went with 45.
Mario: While I don't think Geno is the most likely for the slot, I already had his pic. This could also be BJ Or PM.
DK: Why not? Tho I wouldn't be annoyed If we got no newcomer here...
Yoshi/Wario: I don't feel they need another rep, especially before other franchises
LoZ: It's pretty fine as is; Tingle would be cool or Vaati If they used him more, but I'd just rather have this stuff as dlc or just not in at all.
Pokemon: Lucario = Current rep. If there's to be a 5th or 6th or w/e rep, then It would get in over lucario and we'd see lucario where we see Mewtwo and Pichu (I abuse the idea don't I?
)
F-Zero: Who disagrees with F-Zero needing a second rep?
Metroid: Self-Explanatory. Hey sakurai; This is much better than working on Sticker's or Masterpieces.
Mother: Bias, and Mega-Man is there close to him. Claus would make a great 3rd rep to the series and would make an interesting character to smash, and is pretty much first in-line, but the series is so small...
Starfox: Hi falco. Hi slot that's a question mark that we don't know why until the end of this post.
FE: Read pokemon's lucario for explination on why michiah's here. If we're to get a third rep It'll probably be the newest one (Possibly roy still) And currently asides from the FE1 remake she's the newest...
Kirby: Who doesn't think It's fine? Well daroach would be cool but that goes under ridiculous. Period.
And for explinations on the rest:
?: Didn't feel all veterans as welcome or so, and honestly I was going for as close to as original as possible, so this spot is simply for future downloadable content. It's a possibility If Wii HD Comes true, but If not, feel free to burn my house down for the lack of some veterans.
Third-Parties: I feel there should be two more asides from Sonic and Snake. No more, No less. I put Chrono in to accompany geno but I personally think our second rep is pointing towards Travis Touchdown (Hey, sakurai, you put snake in. no double standards plz).
Retro/Standalones: I personally don't even think the ACer will make it onto the roster and think LM's chances > His, but I already had the render and everything so I just stuffed ACer onto there like with Geno, as a kinda "ANOTHER NINTENDO REP" Or I guess you could call him a retro; But I had to push out rob to go for sukapon just to keep it to 45.
Anyhow; It's more of a "What I Want/Would like to see" Rather than a "WELL THIS IS PROBABLE DUE TO THIS REASON" (see: chrono, acer, geno) And of course with some as placeholders, like Geno technically meaning "5th Mario Rep" due to being lazy.
discuss I guess.