sundayseclipse
Smash Journeyman
oh ok thank you =)You are wrong. Click the next arrow.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
oh ok thank you =)You are wrong. Click the next arrow.
You make it seem like he rallied the entire 2ch boards to find out how much they like such and such. $5 says he got a dozen people to keep chiming in with their opinions at most. And nothing was stopping him from copying all the responses as they came in (either in plaintext or screenshot) if he really wanted to prove what he claims. You should know better than to take someone's word at face value.Baseless assumptions? He has done research on 2ch, and the only reason he lacks sources is that 2ch purges topics at a certain length.
I see stuff like this:I will never understand why people mock "deservedness." It's only THE ENTIRE BASIS OF ROSTERS. Every point you've ever made about a character being popular or having moveset potential is an aspect of it and you use it in every post in the thread. Moveset potential is an aspect of deservedness. Bias? He's said that he likes certain characters and dislikes others, but still he presented many reasons for his inclusion of Lip, and he even had Krystal in his roster for a while, despite his strong dislike of the oversexualized pile of fanservice like any rational person.
It doesn't work because Olimar is the same relative size in Smash as he is in Pikmin. The heads of his Pikmin still go up to his neck and Bulborbs are still massive. Everyone sees that. If Mario was a playable character in Pikmin 3, he'd still stand over Olimar the way he does in Smash. Anyway the reason I brought that up is because I've never heard anyone change their mind over this stunning revelation, and really, they shouldn't unless their opinions are easily swayed."Olimar is the size of a quarter" is plenty valid. Plenty of Pikmin players noticed for a while that a character shown to be half the height of a GCN memory card in the instruction manual, but they got over it. Ridley fans can get over it too.
Considering the lack of brevity, unnecessary details, and general repetition, yeah. It's painful to read. Just look at this sentence:You lose all respect with the final comment. Is it such a big deal?
...no I didn't, I just said that he has done several surveys. Hyperbole right there. He may not have direct proof, but that's difficult to obtain when threads purge so quickly. And it's not like Chronobound/Snakey is some random guy off of the street who I trust for no reason whatsoever. I know him and he's proved that he's trustworthy before. More importantly, the things he's claimed are all common knowledge, like certain characters being popular. Claiming that his research on 2ch is invalid is like saying that Ridley and Black Shadow are unpopular: because, y'know, that's what he found out.You make it seem like he rallied the entire 2ch boards to find out how much they like such and such. $5 says he got a dozen people to keep chiming in with their opinions at most. And nothing was stopping him from copying all the responses as they came in (either in plaintext or screenshot) if he really wanted to prove what he claims. You should know better than to take someone's word at face value.
Where are you going with this? By this logic, the roster would be worse than Brawl's. Instead of getting unique, recognizable and popular characters from new series like Isaac, we would get obscure characters like the Duck Hunt dog. In fact, when you were arguing for the Duck Hunt dog, you were using deservingness yourself, saying that the dog is popular and recognizable: the definition of deservingness. You've been arguing that Duck Hunt "'deserves' a character for whatever reason over any other series that isnn't represented yet" (which is ridiculous, but that's a different argument.)I see stuff like this:
- "Now for another series that I felt is lacking a playable character. Puzzle League (AKA Panel de Pon) is one of Nintendo’s two biggest puzzle series (the other being Dr. Mario)."
and this:
- I see a lot of people attack the idea of adding Lip as a playable character in Brawl for foolish reasons.
and this:
- I do feel that Lip is worthy enough to enter because she is the best fit to represent the Puzzle League series which is one of Nintendo’s two biggest puzzle franchises (unlike Krystal whom I mainly placed in due to popularity).
As if Puzzle League in itself is this amazing franchise that absolutely MUST have some form of representation. Like it "deserves" a character for whatever reason over any other series that isn't represented yet.
So some characters have the same pros going for them, so he repeated them. Is that such a big deal? He says a lot more than that about Lip, saying that she reps Nintendo's biggest puzzler series, that Sakurai thinks that Panel de Pon is a masterpiece and many other valid reasons. Tell me why these do not make her stand out. And he did cut Krystal from his roster, so he clearly now agrees with your almighty opinion.- Many Japanese Smash fans have longed for Lip to be a playable character ever since the first Smash Bros. was released.
Watch how this works:
- Many Japanese Smash fans have longed for Sigurd to be a playable character ever since the first Smash Bros. was released.
- Many Japanese Smash fans have longed for Toad to be a playable character ever since the first Smash Bros. was released.
- Many Japanese Smash fans have longed for Ridley to be a playable character ever since the first Smash Bros. was released.
All he says is "Lip is popular in Japan" and "she has moveset potential." Then he says it a couple more times. Not once does he say something that actually makes Lip stand out from any other newcomer. And he says the same thing about Krystal while tacking on the "I hate her but she's too popular to ignore" bit. How the hell am I supposed to take this guy seriously?
Umm... play some Pikmin? Olimar is shown in the manual of Pikmin to be half the height of a memory card, and he's constantly standing aside implements like batteries that dwarf him. Mario wouldn't stand over Olimar in the same way as in Smash if he was playable in Pikmin 3- he would be around twenty-five times his height, unless you mean just bigger, in which case Ridley can be made to be bigger than Samus. I'm lucky that I knew better than to take somebody's words at face value. Nobody's been swayed by your revelations that R1DL3Y 1Z 2 81G! either, and Chronobound never intended it to do anything but support his case.It doesn't work because Olimar is the same relative size in Smash as he is in Pikmin. The heads of his Pikmin still go up to his neck and Bulborbs are still massive. Everyone sees that. If Mario was a playable character in Pikmin 3, he'd still stand over Olimar the way he does in Smash. Anyway the reason I brought that up is because I've never heard anyone change their mind over this stunning revelation, and really, they shouldn't unless their opinions are easily swayed.
So you aren't taking him seriously because his essays are too long? Wow.Considering the lack of brevity, unnecessary details, and general repetition, yeah. It's painful to read. Just look at this sentence:
- Now for another series that I felt is lacking a playable character.
Seriously, read that over and over again until it sinks in.
I'm defending him because I have respect for him. He's shown his intelligence many times over. I guess you're right that I shouldn't though, you're a lost cause.I don't know why you feel the need to defend him, but whatever. I'd rather he defend himself though, I know he posts on here.
Strange hard-ons for the Sonic and Pokemon series aside, Iron Man is owned by Marvel, not Capcom, did not originate in video games, and is a comic book character, which Sakurai said would not be in Smash. Even if for some reason the director wasn't Sakurai, it still wouldn't happen I'd wager.Add Shadow, Metal Sonic, Emerl ( who'd every think of Emerl wouldn't be neat to have metal sonic and Emerl!) Zero, Ridely, Rayquaza, Roy, Master Hand (epesally Master Hand!), Crazy Hand, Knuckles, Tails, Silver,Tabuu, Mewtwo, Grouden, Kyrge, Palcia, Diolga, Iron Man (since megaman is made by capom why shouldn't iron man be added!) stages: The pipe house, eggman's base, Angel island, and Emerald Hill.
Woah! Slow down there buddy... First of all, WAY too many Sonic characters. Don't expect any more than one, Sonic himself. Sakurai obviously doesn't care too much for the guest series like he does mainstream Nintendo series. There are plenty of mainstream Ninendo characters to get in before we see any new guest appearances. Same with stages, one stage per every guest series is fine. I'm guessing you're a major Sonic fan?Add Shadow, Metal Sonic, Emerl ( who'd every think of Emerl wouldn't be neat to have metal sonic and Emerl!) Zero, Ridely, Rayquaza, Roy, Master Hand (epesally Master Hand!), Crazy Hand, Knuckles, Tails, Silver,Tabuu, Mewtwo, Grouden, Kyrge, Palcia, Diolga, Iron Man (since megaman is made by capom why shouldn't iron man be added!) stages: The pipe house, eggman's base, Angel island, and Emerald Hill.
Oh, I'm not denying Ridley or Black Shadow (or pretty much any universally popular character). But when I see "Why Lip, Alvis, and Plusle & Minun will be in SSB4," I can't help but wonder what the hell he's thinking. I don't see any reason to trust him over anyone else who posts here with Shy Guys and Boos....no I didn't, I just said that he has done several surveys. Hyperbole right there. He may not have direct proof, but that's difficult to obtain when threads purge so quickly. And it's not like Chronobound/Snakey is some random guy off of the street who I trust for no reason whatsoever. I know him and he's proved that he's trustworthy before. More importantly, the things he's claimed are all common knowledge, like certain characters being popular. Claiming that his research on 2ch is invalid is like saying that Ridley and Black Shadow are unpopular: because, y'know, that's what he found out.
You must be confusing me with Arcadenik (probably the only one here who actually thinks the Duck Hunt dog has a chance). This is the only statement I've ever made on the dog:Where are you going with this? By this logic, the roster would be worse than Brawl's. Instead of getting unique, recognizable and popular characters from new series like Isaac, we would get obscure characters like the Duck Hunt dog. In fact, when you were arguing for the Duck Hunt dog, you were using deservingness yourself, saying that the dog is popular and recognizable: the definition of deservingness. You've been arguing that Duck Hunt "'deserves' a character for whatever reason over any other series that isnn't represented yet" (which is ridiculous, but that's a different argument.)
When I say he repeats himself, I mean he does this:So some characters have the same pros going for them, so he repeated them. Is that such a big deal? He says a lot more than that about Lip, saying that she reps Nintendo's biggest puzzler series, that Sakurai thinks that Panel de Pon is a masterpiece and many other valid reasons. Tell me why these do not make her stand out. And he did cut Krystal from his roster, so he clearly now agrees with your almighty opinion.
First of all, I'm in favor of Ridley making it in, I've said it like 5 times already in the last two days. And I'm talking relative size. Olimar's proportions are correct in comparison to the other creatures in his games (Pikmin, Bulborbs). If they added Mario as a playable character in Pikmin (as in the same size he appears to be on Distant Planet), he and Olimar would have the same difference in height as they do in Smash. That's how the scaling thing works.Umm... play some Pikmin? Olimar is shown in the manual of Pikmin to be half the height of a memory card, and he's constantly standing aside implements like batteries that dwarf him. Mario wouldn't stand over Olimar in the same way as in Smash if he was playable in Pikmin 3- he would be around twenty-five times his height, unless you mean just bigger, in which case Ridley can be made to be bigger than Samus. I'm lucky that I knew better than to take somebody's words at face value. Nobody's been swayed by your revelations that R1DL3Y 1Z 2 81G! either, and Chronobound never intended it to do anything but support his case.
Are you even paying attention to what I've said? I don't have a problem with long essays, my posts are pretty long too. I have a problem with repetition, verbosity, and inconclusive evidence. Snakey's posts are full of that. It's 95% fluff.So you aren't taking him seriously because his essays are too long? Wow.
For every good point I see him make, he tacks on three more crappy ones. I've been reading his essays since he started writing them, and I've seen no evidence that suggests he's as smart as you make him out to be. On that note, I'm having a hard time taking you seriously when you seem to be confusing me with someone else. You should cool down too, you sound pretty flustered.I'm defending him because I have respect for him. He's shown his intelligence many times over. I guess you're right that I shouldn't though, you're a lost cause.
Yes, it would be very coolya know what would be cool if they put Viewtiful Joe in SSB4, but it wont happen because its a dead series =(
Iron Man first appeared in the comic book Tales of Suspense #39 in 1963. He is absolutely not a video game originating character.But Iron Man? That is just not possible, I really don't think he originated as a video game character, and I don't think he has appeared very much on Nintendo consoles in well-selling games (there have been maybe one or two). Iron Man isn't going to happen, don't get your hopes up.
Sad truth: Probably half the pages in this thread are about that. As for your download idea, I like that but, as Sakurai said, stuff like this highly depends on whether or not Nintendo's next console has a decent hard drive.Bowser should vouch for Ridley.
Seriously, how come the past twenty+ pages are mostly "Ridley's size is a problem" or "Dixie's better than K.Rool"
Can we actually talk about the game ideas, not the eternal arguments?
What if Nintendo had a "download hub" that you could download textures for add-on alternate costumes. With the only restriction for uploading being obvious censorships. (You know what I mean)
How to be taken seriously in the SSB4 discussion thread:Add Shadow, Metal Sonic, Emerl ( who'd every think of Emerl wouldn't be neat to have metal sonic and Emerl!) Zero, Ridely, Rayquaza, Roy, Master Hand (epesally Master Hand!), Crazy Hand, Knuckles, Tails, Silver,Tabuu, Mewtwo, Grouden, Kyrge, Palcia, Diolga, Iron Man (since megaman is made by capom why shouldn't iron man be added!) stages: The pipe house, eggman's base, Angel island, and Emerald Hill.
I'm sorry, those are great rules, but nobody will follow 1, 3, 4, 6, or 7 indeffinatly.Sad truth: Probably half the pages in this thread are about that. As for your download idea, I like that but, as Sakurai said, stuff like this highly depends on whether or not Nintendo's next console has a decent hard drive.
How to be taken seriously in the SSB4 discussion thread:
1. Don't post lists.
2. If you have to post a list, do no more than 5 characters and provide a decent explanation for each choice.
3. Do not overly support one franchise. People are more willing to listen to you when it's obvious that you play around with more than just the most popular franchises.
4. Do not suggest comic book, anime, or cartoon characters.
5. Do not suggest original Smash characters like Master Hand or Tabuu.
6. Do not suggest multiple characters from the same third party. Chances are, representation will be reduced to one per third party.
7. Do not suggest controversial characters like Mewtwo or Ridley without a decent arguement.
These are the big points and I'll just leave it at that.
That's a great list, unfortunately, not many people here will understand that. Bias and fanboyism is overtaking this thread, one of the reasons debates here are a bit difficult.How to be taken seriously in the SSB4 discussion thread:
1. Don't post lists.
2. If you have to post a list, do no more than 5 characters and provide a decent explanation for each choice.
3. Do not overly support one franchise. People are more willing to listen to you when it's obvious that you play around with more than just the most popular franchises.
4. Do not suggest comic book, anime, or cartoon characters.
5. Do not suggest original Smash characters like Master Hand or Tabuu.
6. Do not suggest multiple characters from the same third party. Chances are, representation will be reduced to one per third party.
7. Do not suggest controversial characters like Mewtwo or Ridley without a decent arguement.
These are the big points and I'll just leave it at that.
As amazingly advanced as teh human species is, I can't think of a logical explanation for your question. But I do really wish that list were in the original post...Fatmanonice, contact a mod to put that into the OP.
Then again, people will flock here to list their ideas without even checking to see if there are any guidelines...
WHY MUST WE ALL BE SO IGNORANT?
*cough*aviwh0re*cough*Inorite? Just earlier I was being told about how much of an avi wh0re I was.
I can't quite think of anything to make this post less spammy right now...
I have to agree with Clownbot. While a few of the Assist Trophies have potential to be a playable character, we won't see many "graduatiing" Assist Trophies, like many of the ones you mentioned.I think those AT's are the most reasonable choices and since sakurai has already laid them out, it's afe to assume they'll be playable.
Mmm, I dunno C: Have you ever played Joy mech fight? ANd I heard he was considered for ssb64
I want Mewtwo again as well, it felt awesome when I unlocked him. That was back when I wasn't very familiar with the internet and spoilers, so Mewtwo was completely unexpected, it was awesome.I want mewtwo in again.
I can't give that many reasons why
He's my favourite character, unlocking him for the first time when I was a kid was just so great,
HUZAH!!!!!I want Mewtwo again as well, it felt awesome when I unlocked him. That was back when I wasn't very familiar with the internet and spoilers, so Mewtwo was completely unexpected, it was awesome.
But we have to face the facts... *puts up flame shield* Mewtwo isn't a very likely candidate for SSB4. There will be plenty more Pokemon possibilities in the future, and not many of those possibilities include Mewtwo.
Little Mac and Tingle are the only two that I really think are going to be playable. Others like Samurai Goroh, Isaac, Ray Mk III, Jeff, and Saki Amamiya have chances as well, although they aren't very high chances.hmm while on the subject of AT which 1s do you think welk be added
Oh my god i c wut u did thar!I seriously do not see any addition of Sega characters in Smash. It was already "Tabuu" enough that Sonic was put in it. The game would be much too loud with more than one, and I also mean "loud" literally, if you catch my drift.