buffer would be hillarious, guaranteed sheild break upon hitting a single shine
Yep, that would suck
melee falco would win easy, the sheer mobility would mean camping is not really an option. if falco had his jump heights from melee and it was any stage thats not fd it would be pretty silly.
BF is a slightly larger frame / bigger hitboxes than MF. But you're right that MF could probably run away extreeeemely well. BF can cover half the length of smashville with multiple hitboxes at around 9 frames though.
depends on the mechanics but brawls mechanics helps melee falco heaps
Well if Brawl Falco can air dodge out of hitstun, while Melee Falco cannot there's a huge advantage given to a slower character. I can tell you (from fun hijynx of project m character files thrown into 'regular brawl') that a character with a frame advantage on jab and close to on things like dash attack/utilt on BRAWL characters probably would result in stupid things like 1 hit = smash 64 (you know, like dash attack cancelled into upsmash will probably combo into 50 utilts). How shield hits work is the confusing part, because Melee hits produce more shield stun, and brawl hits produce less shield stun then it probably evens out (maybe even better for Melee Falco). But if a hit on shield was similar to their game origins (like Brawl Falco having 6 frame oos options) and a melee character being ****ed in shield, then a brawl character gains another advantage. Also power shielding over both games goes towards Brawl, where the window is 3 frames and cancels all shield stun, but it wouldn't reflect lasers back.
One thing that could mean death for BF is that low knockback hits aren't regular DIable (although brawl smash di crap may be able to save him), so at low percents or on certain moves (like shine) there's no DI coming from Brawl Falco. Hit stun values between both games are actually very similar, just Brawl lets you cancel hit stun.
dont forget melee falco can sit in reflector, campings not really going to work?
BF has a projectile that would hit falco out of a reflector (i.e., Falco's ranged shine would hit Falco in his shine). In a "shoot lasers and let's reflect them back" situation, I'd probably put that on BF, maybe not though, but he would if he was able to jump cancel like Wolf/Fox in brawl do if projectiles hit their reflectors.