: Going to go with Kamek, seeing how it's either him or Poochy. While I like Poochy, Kamek is a much more proactive figure in the Yoshi series and has a much better defined set of powers for a moveset.
: Samurai Goroh just seems to make the most sense here. He has perfect attendance in F-Zero, a strong relationship with Captain Falcon, and a basis for a moveset in his katana.
: Uhh... the Polar Bear, I guess? Him, the seals/yedis, and the condor are the only options here and he is the easiest to translate to a fighting game from that list.
: Another tough one, seeing how the Game & Watch series doesn't really have defined characters. Maybe do what was done for Mr. Game & Watch and combine multiple characters into an OC (like a Ms. Game & Watch)?
: Sorry Ashley fans, going with Captain Syrup. It would be nice to see Wario Land get a little more love, plus we have yet to see a full pirate moveset in Smash.
: Raiden because cybernetic ninja. Honourable mention to Big Boss as a possible Snake echo.
: A lot of good options here, but I have to go with Tails. He's one of my personal favourite Sonic characters, so some of that is bias. However, a slightly slower take on Sonic's design with an emphasis on aerial combos and stage control through technology sounds pretty neat.
: Louie, he comes with a Smash taunt that details how to cook each fighter. On a serious note, Louie could either work great as an Olimar echo or as a unique character utilizing some of his skills from Pikmin 3.
: Unless we're looking towards generic mooks, Professor Hector is really the only character from the Robot series of games. So, he wins by default.
: Another series with a lot of good options. However, X seems to be the most logical next step for another Mega Man character, as his subseries is the most iconic after classic Mega Man, of course. Plus, a zoner who focuses on mobility could be neat.
: Sakurai, give the people what they want. A playable balance board that uses other Wii accessories to fight would change Smash forever.
: King Hippo is the most iconic and unique of Punch-Out's rogue gallery, so bring him in.
: I still like the idea of a more formal Mii moveset that's based around things the Miis actually do in their various appearances. The fighter model is definitely better for customization and the "this can be whoever you want it to be!" angle of the character, but this new moveset would do a lot to make the miis feel better integrated into Smash.
: I know she's in legal hell, but Ms. Pac-Man as an echo is honestly the best I could do here. I mean, she is a massive icon, so yay?
: While I have definitely warmed up to Rex as time has gone on, I still think Elma would be the more interesting fighter. Laser swords, machine guns, and mechs are a pretty cool basis for a moveset.
: I mean, there's three characters in the Duck Hunt game (the player, the ducks, and the dog) and they all make up the Dunk Hunt character. But if any Zapper characters are eligible, uh... Mr. Stevenson?
: If they have to be from FF7, then Tifa. If they can be from anywhere in the Final Fantasy series, Terra. I like girls with names that start with the letter T.
: I know diddly about Bayonetta, but Jeanne could be her echo, right?
: Octoling seems to be the only logical choice and they have the Louie appeal of working as either an echo or a fully unique character. Otherwise, maybe the Squid Sisters with an idol based moveset?
: Yu's kind of a generic mid 2000's shonen protagonist (especially relative to Joker), but he'd still be cool. Maybe his moveset could focus on his status as the Wild Card, summoning different persona for various attacks?
: Going to accept my bias to DQVIII and say Jessica Albert. The roster could use another whip user.
: It's really between Mumbo and Gruntilda for this one. I like Mumbo a fair bit, but Grunty seems to be the better pick both for representing the series and for creating a fun character. Plus, we all know the magic Sakurai can bring when translating villains with hammy personalities to Smash.
: Andy's is both my Fatal Fury main and a criminally underrated character character, so he can join the battle. However, if the entirety of SNK is open, then Nakoruru would be my choice. May as well get SNK's other face in the game.
: In case my profile picture didn't give it away, I like Spring Man. He eats pizza and makes boing noises with his mouth. Plus, it still feels kinda weird to not have him in the game. I know he's not technically more a protagonist than any other character from ARMS, but he is the face of the game. His absence is strange for the same reason that Mega Man's absence from MvC3 felt strange, it kinda feels like we're skipping a semi-obvious step.