• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Can Marth become top tier again?

Divinokage

Smash Legend
Joined
Aug 6, 2006
Messages
16,250
Location
Montreal, Quebec
Nope.. I did not unfortunately, I played his sheik again but I got my *** kicked as usual.. *sigh* I was really trying to figure it out but its just so dumb.. lol.

Though I saw him 4 stock Vwins in Marth dittos.. it's like almost impossible to beat him in that matchup lol.
 

strawhats

Smash Master
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,273
Location
Bronx
lol he's too good at them. Which is why people wanna see m2k vs ice. Put my money on m2k still
 

TheZhuKeeper

Smash Champion
Joined
Jul 2, 2007
Messages
2,908
Location
Philadelphia, PA
Nope.. I did not unfortunately, I played his sheik again but I got my *** kicked as usual.. *sigh* I was really trying to figure it out but its just so dumb.. lol.

Though I saw him 4 stock Vwins in Marth dittos.. it's like almost impossible to beat him in that matchup lol.
I think the key thing with m2k is that you really got to beat him at his own game. He "dumbs" down the game in a sense where you only have some two options, and have to beat him at those two options, and it's really tough because he's relentlessly careful at those two options. I think that's why he doesn't do as well against Falco because Falco naturally plays that style, especially the careful ones.

And with Taj's bracket, it was definitely a tough one, maybe not as tough as it "should've" been, but still tough. MacD (2nd seed) and Fly (1st seed) happened to be put together, and MacD has a history of beating Fly, so it was just a person counter. I actually would've been very interested to see how Fly did against Taj, just because we rarely see that matchup anymore, and Wobbles said that Taj is a god against Ice Climbers and has never beaten his Marth (I may be wrong about this). Oh yeah Taj, what do you think about the IC matchup? Do you think you would've beaten Fly?



After watching a few Ice videos, my first impression tells me that Taj's style works better against Falco. Ice seems a little hesitant and only seems to react to Falco's mistakes, rather than forcing them in any way. I'll definitely check out more though, but I'd put my money on m2k's Marth in dittos too.

It's just silly to make stupid claims when Ice hasnt even played NTSC vs falco (which is MUCH better for marth!) t and Taj has just starting placing in the very top.
I almost feel like Falco would benefit from NTSC cause of his late spike. Basically both of them get a dair, and I feel like Falco's would be way more useful than Marth's right?
 

strawhats

Smash Master
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,273
Location
Bronx
ALSO didn't Ice lose to hack in marth dittos at B.E.A.S.T 2 and sheik dittos to EK (another legendary player)
 

Divinokage

Smash Legend
Joined
Aug 6, 2006
Messages
16,250
Location
Montreal, Quebec
I think the key thing with m2k is that you really got to beat him at his own game. He "dumbs" down the game in a sense where you only have some two options, and have to beat him at those two options, and it's really tough because he's relentlessly careful at those two options. I think that's why he doesn't do as well against Falco because Falco naturally plays that style, especially the careful ones.

And with Taj's bracket, it was definitely a tough one, maybe not as tough as it "should've" been, but still tough. MacD (2nd seed) and Fly (1st seed) happened to be put together, and MacD has a history of beating Fly, so it was just a person counter. I actually would've been very interested to see how Fly did against Taj, just because we rarely see that matchup anymore, and Wobbles said that Taj is a god against Ice Climbers and has never beaten his Marth (I may be wrong about this). Oh yeah Taj, what do you think about the IC matchup? Do you think you would've beaten Fly?
Heh it sucks because the way he covers options against Ganon.. Ganon only has very limited options and my Falco is terribad too. Ganon is slow too it doesn't help, I can see what he's doing but either I get out-prioritized or I can't put enough pressure. If I fail once i can die really easily too.. it's just so many things against me.
 

Druggedfox

Smash Champion
Joined
May 13, 2007
Messages
2,665
Location
Atlanta
I think the key thing with m2k is that you really got to beat him at his own game. He "dumbs" down the game in a sense where you only have some two options, and have to beat him at those two options, and it's really tough because he's relentlessly careful at those two options. I think that's why he doesn't do as well against Falco because Falco naturally plays that style, especially the careful ones.


After watching a few Ice videos, my first impression tells me that Taj's style works better against Falco. Ice seems a little hesitant and only seems to react to Falco's mistakes, rather than forcing them in any way. I'll definitely check out more though, but I'd put my money on m2k's Marth in dittos too.
The first part is soooooooo so true. Also, Ice really doesn't look like anything special vs falco judging from his matches with leffen. His punishment game was overall very inconsistent, he made a lot of crucial edgeguarding misjudgments, and the style in and of itself is more of an anti-fox than an anti-falco. Leffen wasn't really shooting lasers at all, so Ice had a lot more freedom than he would against any other falco. A lot of taj being good vs falco has to do with the times he chooses to challenge falco's aerial approaches versus the times he chooses to retreat; marth is forced to be proactive to actually consistently stay on par with falco in the neutral game. Ice did a lot more waiting around than you can really afford to do, to be honest.

Idk, zhu's post made me want to say the same stuff in a different way...there was a lot of truth in it >_>
 

Taj278

TIME TO GET PAID!
BRoomer
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
1,499
Location
MT. OLYMPUS, Arizona
And with Taj's bracket, it was definitely a tough one, maybe not as tough as it "should've" been, but still tough. MacD (2nd seed) and Fly (1st seed) happened to be put together, and MacD has a history of beating Fly, so it was just a person counter. I actually would've been very interested to see how Fly did against Taj, just because we rarely see that matchup anymore, and Wobbles said that Taj is a god against Ice Climbers and has never beaten his Marth (I may be wrong about this). Oh yeah Taj, what do you think about the IC matchup? Do you think you would've beaten Fly?
I think I'm still pretty good at the IC matchup. I don't know if I would've beaten him or not, but I would've gone into the matches with a lot of confidence. The matchup is so straight forward, I can probably put it into M2K terms. (Wobbles has beaten my Marth before, but I did win pretty consistently against him.)

Marth vs. ICs is one of my best matchups even if I haven't played it in a while, I think I still have it figured out.

Looking at the matchup objectively, I'd rate it as one of ICs worst high tiered matchups next to Fox and Peach. Nowadays, it's probably a bit closer with ledge chain throws into wobbling and nastier edgeguards, but I'd still put it at a 60-40 Marth at least.

It's one of the few matchups where everyone's perceptions of Marth are actually applicable. You can even use Mow strats against them with great effectiveness. It's just harder for them to slip the cracks than other characters. Not to say it's not impossible, Wobbles and Fly are easily the scariest ICs for any Marth to fight, but it's REALLY hard to slip in on Marth, and it's soooo easy to mix up your swings. You can literally just swing your damn sword around, it's the ONLY match-up that I can think of where that's legitimately effective in the current metagame.

Wobbles is hopefully moving in with me next week, so all of this is subject to change. :)
 

strawhats

Smash Master
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,273
Location
Bronx
I think I'm still pretty good at the IC matchup. I don't know if I would've beaten him or not, but I would've gone into the matches with a lot of confidence. The matchup is so straight forward, I can probably put it into M2K terms. (Wobbles has beaten my Marth before, but I did win pretty consistently against him.)

Marth vs. ICs is one of my best matchups even if I haven't played it in a while, I think I still have it figured out.

Looking at the matchup objectively, I'd rate it as one of ICs worst high tiered matchups next to Fox and Peach. Nowadays, it's probably a bit closer with ledge chain throws into wobbling and nastier edgeguards, but I'd still put it at a 60-40 Marth at least.

It's one of the few matchups where everyone's perceptions of Marth are actually applicable. You can even use Mow strats against them with great effectiveness. It's just harder for them to slip the cracks than other characters. Not to say it's not impossible, Wobbles and Fly are easily the scariest ICs for any Marth to fight, but it's REALLY hard to slip in on Marth, and it's soooo easy to mix up your swings. You can literally just swing your damn sword around, it's the ONLY match-up that I can think of where that's legitimately effective in the current metagame.

Wobbles is hopefully moving in with me next week, so all of this is subject to change. :)
what would you have done if you had to play hbox?
 

Druggedfox

Smash Champion
Joined
May 13, 2007
Messages
2,665
Location
Atlanta
Why is that marth's swinging sword strategies are acceptable vs ICs but like... not vs other similarly limited characters?
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
@ Kevin: I told you to have Jason play Fox for a few reasons, but they were specific to a few things. The biggest one is teams though. IIRC I told you:

- Sheik has approach problems in general. If the opposing team splits you two up into my famous 2 vs 1 vs 1 situation, you lose serious momentum. This gets a lot worse when one of your characters can't get back into the fray to prevent the **** to the other teammate. For example, if Player X and Player Y split you two up and both go after you, Jason is likely to have problems stopping them from doing a 2 vs 1 on you and forcing you to eat lives. This isn't because he's a bad player, it's just a limitation of the character. If you look at the matches you guys lost, that's exactly what happened for most of them.
- Sheik has issues against Fox and Falco and those are losing matches for her and Cali has no shortage of talented players for either character. In retrospect, Sheik isn't nearly as weak to Fox/Falco in teams as she is in singles so I guess it didn't matter.

And some stuff I didn't mention:

- Fox is definitely Jason's best chance to beat Armada and Hungrybox, two players he is clearly better than but loses to anyway. He needs to practice the character with the best chance of winning. This is no disrespect to either of those players.
- His Marth isn't doing it for him anymore. When your strategy stops working, it's time to try a different one.
- Marth is just garbage in teams. He's just bad at it.

Jason told me that he has the only Sheik that's any good in teams, and I totally agree with him. But frankly, if you have a top tier fox/jigglypuff/peach, that's the character you should be playing in teams over anyone else. The ability to get random low KOs with little/no drawback and no exploitable weakness for it is just too good in a format where you want to work with and exploit small advantages on your opponents. If I were going to pick a teammate, I'd rather have the Nth best fox in the world than the best sheik, and m2k is probably the second best fox after mango for the time being.
 

OverLord

Smash Ace
Joined
Aug 14, 2010
Messages
645
Location
Roma, Italy
lol he's too good at them. Which is why people wanna see m2k vs ice. Put my money on m2k still
I think they'd go Sheik ditto, it would still be a tough match for Ice, but at least he's very good in ditto, while M2K is **** in Marth dittos. (Jason is extremely good against Sheik too, but Ice is very good too, I would like to see some matches)

Leffen wasn't really shooting lasers at all
Trust me, if you ever play Ice, you'll understand how shooting lasers is just stupid against him. I think Leffen tried the best strategy in that moment.

Aldwyn played similar in his set against Ice, and did wonderful.
 

Divinokage

Smash Legend
Joined
Aug 6, 2006
Messages
16,250
Location
Montreal, Quebec
@ Kevin: I told you to have Jason play Fox for a few reasons, but they were specific to a few things. The biggest one is teams though. IIRC I told you:

- Sheik has approach problems in general. If the opposing team splits you two up into my famous 2 vs 1 vs 1 situation, you lose serious momentum. This gets a lot worse when one of your characters can't get back into the fray to prevent the **** to the other teammate. For example, if Player X and Player Y split you two up and both go after you, Jason is likely to have problems stopping them from doing a 2 vs 1 on you and forcing you to eat lives. This isn't because he's a bad player, it's just a limitation of the character. If you look at the matches you guys lost, that's exactly what happened for most of them.
- Sheik has issues against Fox and Falco and those are losing matches for her and Cali has no shortage of talented players for either character. In retrospect, Sheik isn't nearly as weak to Fox/Falco in teams as she is in singles so I guess it didn't matter.

And some stuff I didn't mention:

- Fox is definitely Jason's best chance to beat Armada and Hungrybox, two players he is clearly better than but loses to anyway. He needs to practice the character with the best chance of winning. This is no disrespect to either of those players.
- His Marth isn't doing it for him anymore. When your strategy stops working, it's time to try a different one.
- Marth is just garbage in teams. He's just bad at it.

Jason told me that he has the only Sheik that's any good in teams, and I totally agree with him. But frankly, if you have a top tier fox/jigglypuff/peach, that's the character you should be playing in teams over anyone else. The ability to get random low KOs with little/no drawback and no exploitable weakness for it is just too good in a format where you want to work with and exploit small advantages on your opponents. If I were going to pick a teammate, I'd rather have the Nth best fox in the world than the best sheik, and m2k is probably the second best fox after mango for the time being.
It's actually much easier to get low % kills with Sheik assuming your partner is strong enough to help Sheik put characters off-stage.. like with me for example, I just hit the opponent once and then M2k gimps him.. too easy. lol I disagree that its hard to get low % KOs, especially if they are spacies. You underrate him a little bit here. And to be fair, together we are a top team of the world, so ya he doesn't **** up and I have an easy time to put opponents back off-stage just incase he misses.
 

strawhats

Smash Master
Joined
Feb 19, 2009
Messages
4,273
Location
Bronx
And how is that ?
I mean I understand with hbox, because m2k doesn't know the marth/puff MU and hbox devours sheiks as well (unless you're overtriforce and possibly amsah as he said he's confident he can win against hbox next time they play). However m2k's marth has done well vs armada b4. Jason told me he was getting 3 stocked by armada a few games, then he adapted and 3 stocked right back a few times at G2 in friendlies. (marth/peach)
 

Tekk

Smash Lord
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
1,112
Location
Lyon, France
M2K already lost several times to Hbox with fox.
Armada is different, but he still lost to him like 4 times in tournament, while he never took a set from him.

So saying that M2K is clearly better than Hbox and Armada seems a bit absurd to me.
And never, never take friendlies seriously people.
 

Divinokage

Smash Legend
Joined
Aug 6, 2006
Messages
16,250
Location
Montreal, Quebec
Ya like I beat M2k in multiple friendlies too, does that make me the champion of the world now? No it doesn't, it kinda pisses me off when people gloat about friendlies. Everyone does it.
 

AustinRC

Smash Lord
Joined
Dec 11, 2005
Messages
1,482
Ya like I beat M2k in multiple friendlies too, does that make me the champion of the world now? No it doesn't, it kinda pisses me off when people gloat about friendlies. Everyone does it.
So your telling me the best players don't always play their best in friendlies? Q.Q
 

Taj278

TIME TO GET PAID!
BRoomer
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
1,499
Location
MT. OLYMPUS, Arizona
Why is that marth's swinging sword strategies are acceptable vs ICs but like... not vs other similarly limited characters?
ICs are missing critical frames, grab range, and priority that makes slipping through Marth's sword that little bit harder. Their displacement from wavedashing is good and quick, but they are slightly less likely to hit Marth's hands when he's winding up than characters like Luigi/Samus/Doc/Mario/Ganon on approach.

Once Marth breaks up their sync, the matchup plays much differently than other characters.

Maybe I'll do a write up on the matchup someday. But I want Wobbles to win a few tournaments first. :)
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
It's actually much easier to get low % kills with Sheik assuming your partner is strong enough to help Sheik put characters off-stage.. like with me for example, I just hit the opponent once and then M2k gimps him.. too easy. lol I disagree that its hard to get low % KOs, especially if they are spacies. You underrate him a little bit here. And to be fair, together we are a top team of the world, so ya he doesn't **** up and I have an easy time to put opponents back off-stage just incase he misses.
You don't know what you're talking about.

Obviously if it's the best player of the best character at edge guards getting a clean edge guard he doesn't need your help. The idea is that you need to be able to get random low% kills fast so if the opponents make any careless mistakes or get into bad positions, they can be down multiple stocks very quickly and that position is impossible to come back from.

Sheik's edge guarding is reliable and amazing in 1 vs 1 because they can't get back but it takes a good 5 to 10 seconds without interruption, which gives the teammate enough time to get over to the edge to stop sheik's edge guard. Fox's shine can't really be reacted to. If you shine kill or rest kill a character, all they can really do is die and keep playing. As a certain someone once told me, "our strategy is to keep them from using teamwork". It also let's you exploit the weaker player/character very badly.

Sheik gets worse going from 1 vs 1 to teams. Her downthrow and edge guards take forever and are easily interrupted. Her approaching problems are a bigger problem for her if the opponents choose to abuse it. Jason should be playing Fox in teams at least more than he is at this point if only because it's a tactically better choice of character given his relative talent at both.
 

Divinokage

Smash Legend
Joined
Aug 6, 2006
Messages
16,250
Location
Montreal, Quebec
Lol at idk what I'm talking about when I've been doing either extremely well in teams or I won. Your team tactics is outdated, I have an easy time putting characters off-stage and helping my partner, it's really easy to put any character off-stage with Ganon, I'm not dumb enough to be away from my partner and if that happens he can just stall. If there's a 2v1 situation with M2k, he shields then I fair all of them. And if I do manage to put one character off-stage, I'll definitely make sure the other one is busy too while M2k edgeguards him. There's always something going on, what you are saying never happens.

You say it takes 5 to 10 seconds to edgeguard? It's more like one second. The guy is off-stage? Boom he's dead, the other tries to save him? Awww he gets faired or backfisted.
 
Top Bottom