Are u by any chance a fox user??
anyway, the shine is gonna get nerfed either way, u would thinks Sakurai would know about the shines cheapness after 6 years since melee was released, being his game and all...
the shine will either:
a) have lag @ the beggining
b) wont be cancelable
or
c) wont stun/ have knockback
posting on the wii BTW
The primary modifications to the shine would only go towards the reflector.The knockback from the reflector is nothing but an easter egg.Besides,the shine isn't the only thing that makes Fox deadly.Sure he has Waveshines and other techniques,but that crap only works on characters who don't fall from the shine.
Also,the suggstions made would make the reflector a wasted move:
A) Having lag on the start would make it hard to use for suprise tactics.The use of it would be pointless.Also,why would he change it after two games when it really didn't do much to begin with?
B)Not having it cancelable would make the move very hard to get out of.It doesn't seem fair if yopu could escape a move if you weren't even using it.A few character have a move that they can cancel someway(such as Samus with her missles and Shiek with her needles).You're pretty much glued to the ground when you activate it,and ending it also has lag to it.
C)Why wouldn't it have knockback? It's an easter egg for the character.Alot of characters have one:
-Luigi's taunt attack
-Mario & Doc's Cape turn around(You can still do that in brawl as well)
-Luigi's Mis-fire
-Young Link's Dair sweet spot
-Link & Samus's Hook shot grapple
And Fox has his shine.The shine was put in the game intentionally as they ment it to inflict minor damage.There really is no point in nerfing the shine because of a few trivial uses of it,which are only relevant to this community(Which is hardly acknowledged by any game companies.I know Nintendo Power had an article on SmashBoards,but that doesn't do justice).Even if the shine was nerfed,you're still going to have a problem with Fox.