• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Official Viability Ratings v2 | Competitive Impressions

Status
Not open for further replies.

RayNoire

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Apr 30, 2015
Messages
325
Location
Madison, Wisconsin, USA
NNID
RayNoire
In terms of just hit frames, Mewtwo's frame data is not bad; it's average at worse. Bad would be Shulk, Greninja, and I'm pretty sure Triple D, Bowser, and Ganondorf - thank his Utilt for destroying his average hit frames - are among the worst. In terms of damage output, it's Sheik, in terms of range, it's someone like Meta Knight despite him having a disjoint - not really sure about this one and Wii Fit Trainer being tall helps with this, in terms of knockback, it's probably Sheik, and in terms of mobility, well, Sonic wins in ground speed, Yoshi wins in air speed, and Greninja or ZSS wins overall. Collectively, bad is something like er... Triple D's? Sure, he's got range, but he hits really slow, moves really slow, and sometimes, he doesn't even feel as strong as Ganondorf or Ike. Collectively, Mewtwo's frame data isn't bad when you factor everything in.

Note: Falco's going to be the dummy for all of these comparisons since he's a fast hitter. Mewtwo's frame data isn't that bad. His moves are average in speed. When I put hit frames for the Falco MU discussions, they're there to stop things like, "Rosalina hits faster than Zelda", but does that really matter? In some ways, yes. At close range, Falco will have an upper hand on Mewtwo, but Mewtwo will slap Falco out when Falco is outrange which is... pretty much the entire time as Falco has no moves other than his Specials that compete with or outrange Mewtwo except against Mewtwo's Nair and perhaps jab. Falco's frame 2 jab isn't going to do jack when Mewtwo sweeps his tail with Dtilt. Nair does nothing when Mewtwo can swipe and kill with Fair. The shortest range Mewtwo has are Down Smash, Nair, grabs, Confusion, and Disable. Everything else is pretty decent or long.
Move Hit Frames|:4falco:|:4mewtwo:
Jab|2-4, 10-12, 17-21, 22-26, 27-31, 32-36, (infinite), 41-42|6-6, (infinite), (finisher)
Dash Attack|8-11 or 12-19|10-11 or 12-20
Ftilt|6-8|10-12 or 10-11 (angled)
Utilt|5-9, 12-16|8-8 or 9-13
Dtilt|7-9|6-7
Side Smash|17-19 or 20-20|19-21
Up Smash|8-12, 12-21|9-9, 14-15, 18-19, 22-23, 26-27, 30-31, 34-35
Down Smash|7-9|21-22
Nair|3-5, 6-9, 14-17, 21-24|7-8, 11-12, 15-16, 19-20, 23-24, 27-28, 31-32, 35-36, 39-40
Fair|10-13, 14-17, 18-21, 22-25, 26-27, 28-29|7-8
Bair|4-5 or 6-12|13-17
Uair|7-11|10-14
Dair|16-19 or 20-30|15-16
Grab|8-9|7-8
Dash Grab|10-11|9-10
Pivot Grab|11-12|10-11

Captain Falcon is actually below average in hit speed since other than jab, he hits at average or pretty below average-speed with slow Smashes for a melee-range fighter and average speed aerials. Does not matter much when his jab is ridiculous, he hits hard, and he has random disjoints on rapid jab finisher, dash attack, and Side Smash. Captain Falcon also being fast in the air and ground also helps since his dash grab is just wacky. The Capt. having average hit speed helps since it he was as fast as Fox, Mario, or Sheik, he'd be a monster with that kind of mobility, strength, and hit speed.
Move Hit Frames|:4falco:|:4falcon:
Jab|2-4, 10-12, 17-21, 22-26, 27-31, 32-36, (infinite), 41-42|3-5, 12-14, 22-23 (Gentleman)
Dash Attack|8-11 or 12-19|7-9 or 10-16
Ftilt|6-8|9-11
Utilt|5-9, 12-16|17-20
Dtilt|7-9|11-12
Side Smash|17-19 or 20-20|19-22
Up Smash|8-12, 12-21|22-22, 28-28
Down Smash|7-9|19-20, 29-30
Nair|3-5, 6-9, 14-17, 21-24|7-8, 20-21
Fair|10-13, 14-17, 18-21, 22-25, 26-27, 28-29|14-14 or 15-30
Bair|4-5 or 6-11|10-11 or 12-15
Uair|7-11|6-10 or 11-12
Dair|16-19 or 20-31|16-18
Grab|8-9|7-8
Dash Grab|10-11|9-10
Pivot Grab|11-12|12-13

Falco gets **** on by Shulk because Shulk outranges Falco horribly. Shulk being faster even without his Monado Arts makes it even worse. Monado Arts just makes Falco look bad when he loses his title of highest jump, he loses his title of being a hard hitter since Shield negates that while Smash and Buster makes Falco look weak, and Speed just makes it even worse for Falco since he's already slower than Shulk without Monado Arts. Fast hits don't mean anything when you can't even hit your target. How does Falco get in? Blaster's useless when Shulk can use Speed or Jump and soar over while putting out a lingering hitbox and start comboing him. Reflector getting baited out is just hilarious when Shulk can run in and run out then hit him at range.
Move Hit Frames|:4falco:|:4shulk:
Jab|2-4, 10-12, 17-21, 22-26, 27-31, 32-36, (infinite), 41-42|5-6, 15-17, 33-32 or 34-34
Dash Attack|8-11 or 12-19|15-16
Ftilt|6-8|12-13
Utilt|5-9, 12-16|11-23 or 13-23
Dtilt|7-9|10-11
Side Smash|17-19 or 20-20|14-15 (normal) or 14-16 (angled) , 23-24
Up Smash|8-12, 12-21|18-33 (Monado Slam and Beam) or 18-21 (Monado Beam-only)
Down Smash|7-9|18-19, 23-24, 28-29, 35-36, 41-42
Nair|3-5, 6-9, 14-17, 21-24|13-30
Fair|10-13, 14-17, 18-21, 22-25, 26-27, 28-29|14-18
Bair|4-5 or 6-12|18-22 or 21-22
Uair|7-11|14-15, 24-25
Dair|16-19 or 20-31|14-15 or 23-24
Grab|8-9|7-8
Dash Grab|10-11|9-10
Pivot Grab|11-12|10-11

Or how about this close frame data? Bear in mind that because of the patch, Falco actually has about 2? frames less landing lag than Fox and his aerial hit frames are now about 1-2 frame on average slower than Fox's. Well, why is Falco just worse than Fox in terms of MU despite being stronger than Fox, hitting about the same speed than Fox, having a better edgeguard game, and having a better throw game? Fox is much, much faster on the ground, slightly faster in the air, Fox's grab game is better which allows him to use throws for positioning better, and Fox has lots of kill confirms which Falco lacks. Oh, and Fox's Blaster is usable unlike Falco's which is "functioning". Should I mention how Fox's recovery actually works or that their recoveries launch at similar frames, but Falco's not only travels less, but has shoddy hitboxes? Or the fact that Fox's fall speed lets him survive just mere digits away from Falco despite Falco weighing 3 units more? Oh wait, that's right, Fox falls 0.25 units faster than Falco which more or less makes Fox and Falco's weight differences negligible.
Move Hit Frames|:4falco:|:4fox:
Jab|2-4, 10-12, 17-21, 22-26, 27-31, 32-36, (infinite), 41-42|2, 7-8, ?, (infinite), ?
Dash Attack|8-11 or 12-19|4-7 or 8-15
Ftilt|6-8|6-8
Utilt|5-9, 12-16|3-5 or 6-7
Dtilt|7-9|7-9
Side Smash|17-19 or 20-20|13-15 or 16-18
Up Smash|8-12, 12-21|8-9 or 10-11
Down Smash|7-9|6-7
Nair|3-5, 6-9, 14-17, 21-24|4-6 or 7-25
Fair|10-13, 14-17, 18-21, 22-25, 26-27, 28-29|7-8, 13-14, 19-20, 26-27, 32-33
Bair|4-5 or 6-12|9-11
Uair|7-11|9-10, 12-13
Dair|16-19 or 20-31|5-6, 8-9, 11-12, 14-15, 17-18, 20-21, 23-23
Grab|8-9|6-7
Dash Grab|10-11|10-11
Pivot Grab|11-12|11-12

Being a lightweight with poor aerial range, horrible horizontal mobility, and being a fairly good hurtbox makes Falco's life that much more difficult than Kirby and Mr. Game & Watch who are both short with Mr. G&W having disjoints for his entire moveset, Luigi who has a useful projectile to help his slow movement, Robin who has strong disjoints, usable projectiles, and weighs decently, or Ganondorf who just tanks hits while having good range thanks to his height. Mewtwo moves quicker than Falco, jumps fairly high, outranges Falco, has a good and useful projectile - the reward Falco gets from using Blaster are 3%, hitstun while dealing with heavy end lag, and a chance to gimp while Mewtwo can wreck shields, kill, and recover with Shadow Ball -, and has a reliable kill throw unlike Falco where you basically gamble with your opponent being an idiot who can't DI. Cons to Mewtwo? He's lighter than Falco, he's not a fast faller so his weight doesn't get "countered" for vertical kills, he has a larger hurtbox, and he has an average frame data. Of those 4 cons, average frame data is the least of Mewtwo's problems. Freaking Palutena and Zelda get away with like 3 freaking moves and they do fine, well, customs and even default Palutena. Don't know about Zelda, but Melee Zelda got away with Down Smash, Fair/Bair, and air dodge. Oh, and there's Lucario with his hit lag on everything and he does fine.


It's not consistent, though, which would be helpful if Dr. Mario just wants to land the strong hitbox at all times instead of dealing with 3 different hitboxes with the middle being the strongest.
We have a frame data "tier list" somewhere don't we? I'd be interested to see exactly where Mewtwo's at (assuming it has him on there).
 

Speed Boost

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Jun 21, 2015
Messages
195
Location
Ganymede
Listed below are the characters used in the Top 8 of the two biggest events since 1.0.8. My goal is to discuss what, if anything, we can desypher from these results as far as character viability is concerned.

The data and sampling size is very small and the rules are arbitrary, but it seemed like an interesting way of dissecting things.

EVO Top 8
1. Zero :4sheik::4diddy:
2. Mr. R :4sheik:
3. Nairo :4zss:
4. Abadango *
5. Ally :4mario:*
5. Dabuz :rosalina:*
7. FOW :4ness:
7. ESAM :4pikachu:

CEO Top 8
1. Zero :4sheik:
2. Nairo :4zss:*
3. Dabuz :rosalina:
4. Larry Lur :4fox::4luigi:
5. MVD :4diddy:*
5. ESAM :4pikachu:*
7. Shaky :4ness:
7. Nick Riddle :4zss:*
*Anomalous or low impact counterpick characters are not included in this exercise.

TOTALS: 2:4sheik:, 2:4zss:, 2:4ness:, 2:4diddy:, :4fox:, :4luigi:, :4mario:, :4pikachu:, :rosalina:
There are 4 characters that were represented more than once between the Top 8 of CEO and EVO.

For me this group holds the most value when talking about character strength because multiple competitors are having success with the same character.

If you calculate the average place each of these 4 characters finished you have something that looks like this:

:4sheik: 1.33
:4diddy: 3.00
:4zss: 4.00
:4ness: 7.00
Next we have the characters with single representation, but their represenatives placed in both tournaments:

:rosalina: 4.00
:4pikachu: 6.00
The last group are characters that only placed once between both Top 8s combined and their finishes.

:4luigi::4fox: 4.00
:4mario: 5.00
If we weight the characters using these criteria we get a pseudo tier list that looks like this:

1 :4sheik:
2 :4diddy:
3 :4zss:
4 :4ness:
5 :rosalina:
6 :4pikachu:
7 :4luigi::4fox:
8 :4mario:
 
Last edited:

TriTails

Smash Lord
Joined
Dec 29, 2014
Messages
1,720
Location
Looking at your face
Ganondorf - thank his Utilt for destroying his average hit frames - are among the worst.
Let's forget Ganon has Volcano Kick for a bit.

Without that's he is about as fast as Falcon.

That's huge considering none of his attacks deal below 10% aside from throws.

Doc's fair is scary af. It's so much more powerful than you'd think. Is it his best option after a pill reset when it's fresh?
Doc's F-air is probably as strong as Ganon's. It's scary, and if you practice Mario's F-air spike all the time it should be feasible to land it. It feels better than Mario's simply on how it can kill both onstage and off-stage and as Ikes said, much more consistent.

I don't know much about pill reset... what's that again? But just remember Doc's F-air can kill at like 90% with rage iirc.

BTW, Larry Lurr used Luigi? When
 

Ffamran

The Smooth Devil Mod
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
14,629
Doc's fair is scary af. It's so much more powerful than you'd think. Is it his best option after a pill reset when it's fresh?
It's a hilarious move you can throw out at neutral and catch rookies who don't think you're going for a telegraphed Superman punch. AND IT WORKS! Remember kids, fighting dumb people is fun. :p

Frame data also says that Dr. Mario's Fair when sweet-spotted is stronger than Ganondorf's, but let's remember about Zelda and Captain Falcon and if they manage to consistently land their sweet-spotted Fairs.

We have a frame data "tier list" somewhere don't we? I'd be interested to see exactly where Mewtwo's at (assuming it has him on there).
Hasn't been updated since May, so no Lucas, Roy, Ryu, or any of the changes to Falco, Link, Ike, etc. According to the list, Mewtwo's below average at 38 which considering that Captain Falcon is at 46 and Ganondorf is at 52, but would be at 46 without his Utilt, that's not bad when the blazing Captain Falcon is actually slower on average than Mewtwo. It's still skewed since Captain Falcon would be using jab (3), Nair (7), Uair (6), and Bair (10) more than anything and that averages out to 6.5 frames. Don't know what Mewtwo would be using a lot, but for fastest five normals, he'd be hitting at 6.4 at rank 40 is just 0.4 slower than Captain Falcon at rank 35. Still pretty below average. Pretty sure someone else has a more complete and updated one out there.
Frame data (hitbox coming out) averages for each character from fastest to slowest. Normals only since specials are usually meant for different things than instantly hitting the opponent. All variations of grab are taken into account.

1. Ganondorf: 15.111
2. Bowser: 13.889
3. King Dedede: 12.444
4. Captain Falcon 11.944
5. Link: 11.833
6. Donkey Kong: 11.667
6. Rosalina: 11.667 (with Luma)
6. Zelda: 11.667
9. Ike: 11.389
10. Charizard: 11.111
11. Shulk: 10.889 (no arts)
12. Mewtwo: 10.833
12. Samus: 10.833
14. Mr. Game & Watch: 10.722
15. Robin: 10.611
16. Bowser Jr.: 10.556
16. Peach: 10.556
18. Olimar: 10.389 (all purple)
19. Dr. Mario: 10.333
19. Jigglypuff: 10.333
19. Ness: 10.333
22. Marth: 10.278 (all tippers)
22. Toon Link: 10.278
24. Wario: 10.222
25. Falco: 10.111
25. Duck Hunt Duo: 10.111
27. Yoshi: 10
28. WFT: 9.944 (no boost)
29. Mii Brawler: 9.889
30. Luigi: 9.833
30. Mega Man: 9.833
32. Pit: 9.778
32. Dark Pit: 9.778
34. Lucario: 9.667
35. Palutena: 9.5
35. Villager: 9.5
37. Fox: 9.333
37. Mii Swordfighter: 9.333
39. Kirby: 9.278
40. Diddy Kong: 9.222
40. Pacman: 9.222
42. ROB: 9
43. Little Mac: 8.944 (10.615 without aerials)
43. Mario: 8.944
45. Sonic: 8.778
45. ZSS: 8.778
47. Mii Gunner: 8.667
48. Greninja: 8.389
48. Lucina: 8.389
50. Pikachu: 8.333
51. Meta Knight: 7.889
52. Sheik: 7.444
1. Luigi: 6.375
2. Mario: 6.8125
3. Fox: 6.875
3. Sheik: 6.875
5. Dr. Mario: 7.1875
6. Diddy Kong: 7.3125
7. Little Mac: 7.4375
7. Pikachu: 7.4375
9. Meta Knight: 7.75
9. Mii Brawler: 7.75
11. Lucina: 7.8125
11. Marth: 7.8125
13. Pit: 7.8125
13. Dark Pit: 7.8125
15. Duck Hunt Duo: 8.125
16. Falco: 8.375
17. Wario: 8.5625
18. Mega Man: 8.8125
19. Rosalina: 8.875
20. Kirby: 8.9375
20. Ness: 8.9375
22. Olimar: 9
23. Peach: 9.0625
24. Jigglypuff: 9.1875
25. Sonic: 9.25
26. Pacman: 9.4375
27. Yoshi: 9.5
27. Zelda: 9.5
29. WFT: 9.625
30. Robin: 9.6875
31. Bowser Jr.: 9.8125
31. ROB: 9.8125
33. Mr. Game & Watch: 10
34. ZSS: 10.0625 (8.6154 without grabs)
35. Mii Swordfighter: 10.0667
36. Mii Gunner: 10.125
37. Lucario: 10.25
38. Mewtwo: 10.3125
39. Samus: 10.375 (9 without grabs)
40. Donkey Kong: 10.4375
41. Toon Link: 10.75
42. Palutena: 10.8125
43. Villager: 10.9375 (9.769 without grabs)
44. Charizard: 11
45. Bowser: 11.375
46. Captain Falcon: 11.75
47. Link: 11.9375
48. Shulk: 12.5625
49. Greninja: 12.625
50. Ike: 13.25
51. King Dedede: 14.4375
52. Ganondorf: 16.0625 (11.7333 without utilt)
1. Little Mac: 3
1. Mega Man: 3
3. Fox: 3.6
3. Sheik: 3.6
5. Luigi: 3.8
5. Mario: 3.8
5. Dr. Mario: 3.8
5. Pikachu: 3.8
9. Diddy Kong: 4
9. Falco: 4
11. Peach: 4.167
12. Kirby: 4.4
12. Mii Brawler: 4.4
12. ZSS: 4.4
15. Meta Knight: 4.6
15. Pacman: 4.6
15. Yoshi: 4.6
15. ROB: 4.6
19. Ness: 4.8
19. Sonic: 4.8
21. Pit: 5.2
21. Dark Pit: 5.2
21. Wario: 5.2
21. WFT: 5.2
25. Villager: 5.6
25. Bowser Jr.: 5.6
25. Lucina: 5.6
25. Marth: 5.6
25. Mr. Game & Watch: 5.6
25. Samus: 5.6
25. Zelda: 5.6
32. Greninja: 5.8
32. Lucario: 5.8
32. Jigglypuff: 5.8
35. Captain Falcon: 6
35. Donkey Kong: 6
35. Duck Hunt: 6
35. Olimar: 6
35. Rosalina: 6
40. Mii Gunner: 6.4
40. Mewtwo: 6.4
40. Robin: 6.4
43. Mii Swordfighter: 6.6
43. Palutena: 6.6
45. Charizard: 6.8
46. Ike: 7.2
46. Toon Link: 7.2
48. Link: 7.4
49. Ganondorf: 7.6
50. King Dedede: 7.8
51. Bowser: 8.4
52. Shulk: 8.8
1. Kirby: 13.8
2. Lucario: 14.6
3. Peach: 15.2
3. ZSS: 15.2
5. Mario: 15.8
6. Sheik: 16.6
7. Captain Falcon: 16.8
7. Luigi: 16.8
7. WFT: 16.8
10. Rosalina: 17
10. Yoshi: 17
12. Pacman: 17.2
12. Wario: 17.2
14. Link: 17.4
15. Palutena: 18
15. Villager: 18
17. Mr. Game & Watch: 18.2
18. ROB: 18.4
19. Greninja: 18.6
19. Jigglypuff: 18.6
21. Dr. Mario: 18.8
22. Lucina: 19.2
22. Marth: 19.2
22. Samus: 19.2
22. Shulk: 19.2
26. Ike: 19.6
26. Meta Knight: 19.6
28. Diddy Kong: 20
28. Fox: 20
30. Mega Man: 20.5
31. Falco: 20.6
31. Ness: 20.6
33. Olimar: 21
34. Bowser Jr.: 21.8
34. Ganondorf: 21.8
34. Robin: 21.8
37. Pit: 22.4
37. Dark Pit: 22.4
39. Donkey Kong: 22.6
39. Duck Hunt Duo: 22.6
39. Zelda: 22.6
42. Little Mac: 23.2
42. Toon Link: 23.2
44. King Dedede: 23.6
45. Sonic: 26.2
46. Pikachu: 26.8
47. Charizard: 29.4
48. Bowser: 31.2
1. ZSS: 10
2. Link: 10.67
2. Sheik: 10.67
4. Captain Falcon: 11
4. Lucario: 11
6. Mario: 11.33
7. Kirby: 11.67
8. Peach: 12
9. Mr. Game & Watch: 13
10. Wario: 13.33
11. Dr. Mario: 14
11. Luigi: 14
11. Yoshi: 14
14. Greninja: 14.33
15. Pacman: 14.67
15. Villager: 14.67
15. WFT: 14.67
18. Falco: 15
18. Jigglypuff: 15
18. Olimar: 15
18. Rosalina: 15
22. Diddy Kong: 15.33
22. Palutena: 15.33
22. Samus: 15.33
25. Fox: 16
25. ROB: 16
27. Lucina: 16.33
27. Marth: 16.33
27. Ness: 16.33
30. Shulk: 16.67
31. Ike: 17.67
32. Toon Link: 18
33. Duck Hunt Duo: 18.33
34. Meta Knight: 18.67
35. Bowser Jr.: 19
36. Ganondorf: 19.33
36. King Dedede: 19.33
36. Mega Man: 19.33
39. Donkey Kong: 19.67
40. Little Mac: 20
40. Robin: 20
42. Sonic: 21
43. Pikachu: 21.33
43. Pit: 21.33
43. Dark Pit: 21.33
46. Zelda: 21.67
47. Bowser: 25.33
48. Charizard: 25.33
 

TriTails

Smash Lord
Joined
Dec 29, 2014
Messages
1,720
Location
Looking at your face
It's a hilarious move you can throw out at neutral and catch rookies who don't think you're going for a telegraphed Superman punch. AND IT WORKS! Remember kids, fighting dumb people is fun. :p
I have caught people off-guard and hit them with a Falcon Punch for the lulz of it. I once traded a FP with Ryu's U-smash and two red lightings appeared. He died seconds before me (I was pretty dang close to the blast zone. Had it been Wii U, I would've died first). It's hillarious that I posted it online :p.

Frame data also says that Dr. Mario's Fair when sweet-spotted is stronger than Ganondorf's, but let's remember about Zelda and Captain Falcon and if they manage to consistently land their sweet-spotted Fairs.
Landing Dr. Mario's F-air sweetspot is way easier than Falcon's/Zelda's.
 

Ikes

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
477
Location
Yoshi's Island
NNID
Smooth_Moonman
remember that while the hitbox may only be out for a few frames, considering how quick the animation is, those few frames could easily be the majority of the attack animation/arc.
 

Lavani

Indigo Destiny
Joined
Oct 24, 2014
Messages
7,256
Late to the frame data discussion, but Mewtwo has startups comparable to a sword character with somewhat lesser disjoint but also generally much less end lag. Jab, dtilt, and utilt are all disjointed and all quick to end, dsmash's end lag is low for a smash and safe on shield, and Shadow Ball has 25 frames of end lag. Which to put it in perspective, it's a high-powered killing projectile with only 2 more frames of endlag than Luigi's fireballs.

Also since :4olimar: was brought up, can we talk about how nuts his smashes are? Dsmash with a red pikmin is only -4~6 on shield after shield drop and it comes out frame 10, and fsmash is in a similar boat (actually even safer, I believe). Not suffering hitlag because it's attributed to the pikmin instead is a pretty big deal, though the frame data on said moves is good even without that.
 

RayNoire

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Apr 30, 2015
Messages
325
Location
Madison, Wisconsin, USA
NNID
RayNoire
Late to the frame data discussion, but Mewtwo has startups comparable to a sword character with somewhat lesser disjoint but also generally much less end lag. Jab, dtilt, and utilt are all disjointed
You sure? If they are, it's not by much. Some hurtboxes are definitely thrown out there.
 

Lavani

Indigo Destiny
Joined
Oct 24, 2014
Messages
7,256
You sure? If they are, it's not by much. Some hurtboxes are definitely thrown out there.
Mewtwo is unfortunately the one character whose tail is like 50% hurtbox instead of (15~)0%, but you can blow up Bob-ombs safely with all his tail attacks (and Gooey Bombs with bair) as long as the base portion of his tail isn't touched.

There is more raw disjoint on jab than dtilt though, even if the overall range is lesser.
 

A2ZOMG

Smash Legend
Joined
Oct 13, 2007
Messages
12,542
Location
RPV, California
NNID
A2ZOMG
Switch FC
SW 8400 1713 9427
I have caught people off-guard and hit them with a Falcon Punch for the lulz of it. I once traded a FP with Ryu's U-smash and two red lightings appeared. He died seconds before me (I was pretty dang close to the blast zone. Had it been Wii U, I would've died first). It's hillarious that I posted it online :p.


Landing Dr. Mario's F-air sweetspot is way easier than Falcon's/Zelda's.
Disagree. It's much easier to land a Zelda Lighting Kick sweetspot in almost all situations than Doc's F-air. Falcon Knee is a little easier to trap set up than Doc F-air though is slightly harder to land in neutral.

Doc/Mario F-airs are pretty crappy and generally shouldn't hit people for the most part.
 
Last edited:

Browny

Smash Hater
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Messages
10,416
Location
Video Games
Then show me a copy of this exact image with Mario on the receiving end.



...Huh?

Shadow Ball is useless in disadvantage. It's frame 23.



...Huh??

Outdated? Nothing about those hitboxes has been changed. And nothing else about this makes any sense.



We can land Disable in a lot of different ways too. (Landing traps, tech chases, etc.) It's transcendent and goes decently far. But yeah, we'll agree to disagree since I'm not super-sure on this MU.
Later tonight I'll upload some images for you, ill make it seem like marios hurtbox extends more than an entire character length from his body.

And the hitbox trails, I'll also get some screenshots for you to make it seem like other characters have no hitboxes on the attack trails, I just need time to upload all the images.
 
Last edited:

TriTails

Smash Lord
Joined
Dec 29, 2014
Messages
1,720
Location
Looking at your face
Disagree. It's much easier to land a Zelda Lighting Kick sweetspot in almost all situations than Doc's F-air. Falcon Knee is a little easier to trap set up than Doc F-air though is slightly harder to land in neutral.

Doc/Mario F-airs are pretty crappy and generally shouldn't hit people for the most part.
Really?

Then I better take a look at Zelda's lol. Falcon's... I never seem to be able to land it. I rarely use it unless I'm ready to take risks.
 

NairWizard

Somewhere
Joined
Oct 28, 2014
Messages
1,947
Really?

Then I better take a look at Zelda's lol. Falcon's... I never seem to be able to land it. I rarely use it unless I'm ready to take risks.
Falcon's knee is not hard to land at all against most mid-level opponents. Just save your double jump, read an airdodge, and double jump fastfall into the knee. Really clever opponents know not to airdodge until you've used your double jump, but those are rather rare.
 

A2ZOMG

Smash Legend
Joined
Oct 13, 2007
Messages
12,542
Location
RPV, California
NNID
A2ZOMG
Switch FC
SW 8400 1713 9427
Really?

Then I better take a look at Zelda's lol. Falcon's... I never seem to be able to land it. I rarely use it unless I'm ready to take risks.
I'm meh at this game, Doc is effectively a second main for me, and I land waaaaaay more Zelda lightning kicks than Doc F-airs.

The sweetspot hitbox is a bit more generous than you would expect, plus Zelda F-air/B-air have decent range and are frame 9/6 respectively. Landing lag sucks, but really, in simple punish situations, landing those moves is not actually that difficult. Especially since you can set up with D-tilt.
 

Ikes

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
477
Location
Yoshi's Island
NNID
Smooth_Moonman
So do we consider Toon Link higher tier yet or is he still too underrepresented/overlooked to have a definite tier placing for him?

i mean the kid's got some of the best projectile game, good mobility and fantastic KO power (fair, bthrow, usmash, among others) and there's really not many glaring flaws about him other than his grab, which is still one of the faster tether grabs in the game if we're really gonna go there, not to mention he can force a lot of players into shield to confirm a grab.

I know for a fact Rosalina is a horrible matchup for him due to her gravitational pull pretty much invalidating all of his projectiles bar arrows (since they're very fast and hard to punish due to low endlag so it's very safe to throw them out anyways and can catch some players off guard) and his swordplay is admittedly slightly lacking in some ways, though his range is about that of Roy's and on a much smaller frame which is a fairly good ratio of sword size:character size, and most of his moves lack significant endlag and come out quickly (especially his tilts, utilt is a fantastic combo tilt and ftilt is great when you dont want to commit to an fsmash, though I still haven't found much use in dtilt though maybe im just not looking into that move enough)

I'm honestly not sure where to put him at this point. High tier? Lower high tier? Upper mid? I can't see him having many bad matchups with the top tiers due to how strong his zoning/trapping game is with projectiles and his hit&run tactics work pretty well so he doesn't need to play campy. All of his projectiles have some form of combo potential, especially bombs and boomerangs, which are known to be able to set up into his most reliable kill moves (bthrow and fair), and projectiles can be used to mix up utilt strings (on more than one occasion i have gotten up thrown bombs or boomerangs to hit players stuck in my utilt combos)

Before anyone asks though, I'm not judging this on For Glory experience, I rarely play the gamemode.
I personally think this half-pint hero is far better than his taller, grittier counterpart and is a contender for high tier (maybe around Diddy, or if we're gonna undersell him, Villager, once we start seeing his optimal projectile play) but that could just be me.
 

Nocally

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jan 26, 2011
Messages
210
Location
Denmark
3DS FC
3840-6058-2117
So do we consider Toon Link higher tier yet or is he still too underrepresented/overlooked to have a definite tier placing for him?

i mean the kid's got some of the best projectile game, good mobility and fantastic KO power (fair, bthrow, usmash, among others) and there's really not many glaring flaws about him other than his grab, which is still one of the faster tether grabs in the game if we're really gonna go there, not to mention he can force a lot of players into shield to confirm a grab.

I know for a fact Rosalina is a horrible matchup for him due to her gravitational pull pretty much invalidating all of his projectiles bar arrows (since they're very fast and hard to punish due to low endlag so it's very safe to throw them out anyways and can catch some players off guard) and his swordplay is admittedly slightly lacking in some ways, though his range is about that of Roy's and on a much smaller frame which is a fairly good ratio of sword size:character size, and most of his moves lack significant endlag and come out quickly (especially his tilts, utilt is a fantastic combo tilt and ftilt is great when you dont want to commit to an fsmash, though I still haven't found much use in dtilt though maybe im just not looking into that move enough)

I'm honestly not sure where to put him at this point. High tier? Lower high tier? Upper mid? I can't see him having many bad matchups with the top tiers due to how strong his zoning/trapping game is with projectiles and his hit&run tactics work pretty well so he doesn't need to play campy. All of his projectiles have some form of combo potential, especially bombs and boomerangs, which are known to be able to set up into his most reliable kill moves (bthrow and fair), and projectiles can be used to mix up utilt strings (on more than one occasion i have gotten up thrown bombs or boomerangs to hit players stuck in my utilt combos)

Before anyone asks though, I'm not judging this on For Glory experience, I rarely play the gamemode.
I personally think this half-pint hero is far better than his taller, grittier counterpart and is a contender for high tier (maybe around Diddy, or if we're gonna undersell him, Villager, once we start seeing his optimal projectile play) but that could just be me.
He is still underrepresented and has not shown any high level consistency yet.
 
Last edited:

Routa

Smash Lord
Joined
May 14, 2015
Messages
1,208
Location
Loimaa, Finland
I think his biggest issue is how strong the shield is in this game. Yes his arrows are excellent for zoning and his bombs and boomerang are great, but they all get countered by shield. This is a huge problem for character like Tink who's damage is mostly made by projectiles. He also has okish recovery at best and he has a tether grab (maybe the best tether grab in game but still). Customs do help him a bit (Fiery Arrows), but they wont improve his game much.

If you ask me he is mid or high mid but that is very unlikely.
 

Ikes

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
477
Location
Yoshi's Island
NNID
Smooth_Moonman
except that at high % his projectiles force shields which can be reacted to with a grab, meaning Tink can get grab semi-confirms out of his projectiles and then lead into a back throw
 
Last edited:

Browny

Smash Hater
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Messages
10,416
Location
Video Games
You sure? If they are, it's not by much. Some hurtboxes are definitely thrown out there.
OK here we go

How to make attacks not hit, despite the enemy being in the attack trail. Its simple, its called the attack missed.
http://imgur.com/8Texm9a

How to make a characters hurtbox look gigantic. You just take a screenshot a few frames after an attack hit them, as they extended a hurtbox
http://imgur.com/SoyRtDX

How to measure disjoint
http://imgur.com/9pHb1bm
There, thats how you do it

Surprise surprise... mewtwos downtilt has more of a disjoint than marths dtilt! I bet you didnt see that one coming
http://imgur.com/Q3qOaoo

This is because Mewtwo doesnt have some oversized hurtbox
http://imgur.com/BVKNvC3

On a related note, here is possibly the worst extended hitbox in the game I only found out about a few days ago, Yoshis fair.
http://i.imgur.com/3jK8XEP.png
http://gfycat.com/AmbitiousTintedHornshark
Do you see yet @ RayNoire RayNoire how I can get screenshots to show some absurd hitbox/hurtboxes? With the perfect circumstances I can make things happen that would make you think Mewtwo is high tier, but they wont play out in a real match very often.

This is why screenshots showing his attacks missing are pointless, because I can make his attacks hit from a mile away if I wanted to.
 
Last edited:

Konneh

Smash Cadet
Joined
Jul 20, 2015
Messages
46
Location
Germany
except that at high % his projectiles force shields which can be reacted to with a grab, meaning Tink can get grab semi-confirms out of his projectiles and then lead into a back throw
Which projectile of Tink is fast enough to force me to hold a shield in front of him instead of trying to dodge the move? I can only think of a fully charged Arrow, which has enough Wind Up for me to react to, i.e. space myself further away from you before I shield so you can't grab me out of it. For Boomerangs and Bombs, I feel like Shield is definitely not the only option available to me, so unless I have a wrong understanding of "forcing shield", I'd really appreciate if you went into more detail.
Here in Germany, we have a few Tink players, but the consensus I've gathered from asking them was that they do have big trouble dealing with shields.
I feel like his most reliable kill options against defensive opponents are pressuring the opponent with bombs and forcing a mistake, capitalizing on that with fair/bair/running usmash/other fast options depending on what your opponent did.
 

meleebrawler

Smash Hero
Joined
Sep 8, 2014
Messages
8,158
Location
Canada, Quebec
NNID
meleebrawler
3DS FC
2535-3888-1548
Characters I think Mewtwo has at least a slight advantage against:

:4charizard::4lucario::4villager:

Mewtwo in general has a good time against larger characters because he doesn't have to worry as much about his attacks whiffing. Charizard in particular is I think vulnerable to this because he doesn't have quite the kill power of the other heavies (though still a good amount). Another big thing is that Flare Blitz is a really bad idea against Mewtwo. Like, people say that you shouldn't Flare Blitz against anyone, but Mewtwo can literally shield, dash forward and instantly do one of the strongest up smashes in the game.

I know some people disagree with this, but I think Mewtwo still does well against Lucario, winning neutral, neutralizing Aura Sphere, and being able to exploit holes in offense with some strong attacks.

Re: Villager, Mewtwo's Reflect can be baited but the large Reflect Window can be nasty. Dash attacks get tossed aside. Reflecting lloid rocket at close range will simultaneously pick up Villager AND launch the rocket into him. Slingshots off the ledge can also get eaten by reflect.

Closer to 5:5 :4dk::4ganondorf::4bowser::4pacman::4palutena::4dedede::4olimar:

This isn't to say all of the other characters are 4:6 or worse, I just haven't thought as much about them. Also somewhat ironically I think Mewtwo's best against himself.
Thing is when people try to theorycraft Mewtwo's matchups there always seems to be this "anti-Ganon" asterisk in their minds.
You know how when most people talk Ganon matchups, no matter how badly he gets beat in neutral or whatever he can always turn it around with the right reads or punishes. It generally seems to go the other way with Mewtwo: even when it looks like he wins neutral people remind themselves of how easily he can die which makes it hard to imagine scores above even.
 
Last edited:

Shaya

   「chase you」 
BRoomer
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
27,654
Location
/人◕‿‿◕人\ FABULOUS Max!
NNID
ShayaJP
@ Browny Browny
Varying degrees of sarcasm can be hard to accurately gauge but... it seems like you're asserting mewtwo outdisjoints Marth... although you're definitely down tilting on Marth for a different timing than Mewtwo.
AND that "measuring disjoint" is also suss due to the way Z-axis shenanigans go.
 

Browny

Smash Hater
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Messages
10,416
Location
Video Games
@ Browny Browny
Varying degrees of sarcasm can be hard to accurately gauge but... it seems like you're asserting mewtwo outdisjoints Marth... although you're definitely down tilting on Marth for a different timing than Mewtwo.
AND that "measuring disjoint" is also suss due to the way Z-axis shenanigans go.
How was I sarcastic? Sarcasm would be me saying the exact opposite of what is true, yet I was simply stating the facts.

Those images of Mewtwos wonky hitboxes have been going around for ages and they are just as inaccurate as ever I wish people would stop referring to them. The attacks missed and/or the enemy fell into the trail after the attack was completed. There's nothing else to it.

At absolutely no time was I able to hit Mewtwos dtilt with marth, and not have marth take the hit while the opposite was true many times.

My way of measuring the disjoint makes perfect sense to me, Mewtwo didnt take damage despite the fsmash smacking right into his tail.

Observe round two

This is marths dtilt max range, on the spark
http://i.imgur.com/f6G1vEn.png

This is the start of marths hurtbox during dtilt, on the spark
http://i.imgur.com/uIFQtkV.png

This is roughly the disjoint, the area of the hitbox with no hurtbox attached
http://i.imgur.com/5jJogJT.jpg

There is no z-axis wonkiness going on here its plain and simple.

Now look at Mewtwos, using the image from my previous post (http://i.imgur.com/9pHb1bm.png) to determine the beginning of his hurtbox
http://i.imgur.com/MDdsZqc.jpg

Its close, but I think, in light of all that screenshot proof; Mewtwos dtilt has a larger disjoint than Marths dtilt. Since I have never managed to hit mewtwo from a distance where marth couldnt be hit, I see no evidence against what I am claiming here.

I swear if anyone challenges this with 'Marth's dtilt has a bigger disjoint, that's obvious' or anything that doesn't involve concrete evidence to disprove all the work that I just did, I'm calling the cyber police.
 
Last edited:

Routa

Smash Lord
Joined
May 14, 2015
Messages
1,208
Location
Loimaa, Finland
Wario's Dtilt has the biggest disjoint.

/s

So shall we talk about character that do well in doubles teams other than G&W + filler?
 
Last edited:

Rashyboy05

Your Average Touhou fan~
Joined
Jun 18, 2015
Messages
322
Location
Philippines
3DS FC
4570-8659-2698
Wario's Dtilt has the biggest disjoint.

/s

So shall we talk about character that do well in doubles teams other than G&W + filler?
Shiek+Anyone is pretty good in theory. Mainly because Shiek is Shiek.
 

Smog Frog

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Messages
1,180
:4zelda:+:4falcon: seems good in theory because :4zelda: forces defensive options w/ phantom and dins and :4falcon: either grabs or knees that option
 

Ffamran

The Smooth Devil Mod
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
14,629
Zelda and Villager is a thing since Villager can Pocket Phantom Slash. Not sure about how well Pocketing a Din's Fire would go and Farore's Wind is probably not Pocketable. The fact Farore's Wind kills and that in doubles Zelda isn't always on the spotlight and if she is, someone can bail her out is terrifying. She can be anywhere, she can punish severely, and everything bad about her gets countered by the right partners.
 

Mr. Johan

Smash Hero
Joined
Jul 9, 2009
Messages
5,579
Location
Edmond, OK
NNID
Sonicboom93
Any team with :4robinm: is hilarious because if they can keep a wall going, Robin can get a Thoron+ charged up, and one single mistake or overcommitment means your stock hits the road at 60%.

Either pair him up with someone who can easily avoid the Thoron (:4sonic: :4sheik:), someone who can armor through it, someone who can reflect/absorb it(:4villager: :4ness: :rosalina:), or simply someone who is heavy enough to tank the hit (:4wario:) and take advantage of the rage given from taking 30% damage, and let the lulz begin.


And if the Robin team gets it down to a 2v1 situation, you just need one grab. From there, just imitate Piccolo's Special Beam Cannon. :3
 
Last edited:

Smog Frog

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Messages
1,180
what characters are better in doubles as opposed to their singles counterparts? i can think of: :4zelda::4gaw::4littlemac::4villager:. but are there more? conversely, what characters get worse in doubles?
 

outfoxd

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
672
Location
Grand Blanc, Mi
NNID
outfoxd
Default Wii Fit seems good as a support with her offstage game, charge shot and heing able to be covered when she needs deep breathing room.
 

Rashyboy05

Your Average Touhou fan~
Joined
Jun 18, 2015
Messages
322
Location
Philippines
3DS FC
4570-8659-2698
Diddy Kong + Jigglypuff seems good as well since Diddy Kong helps Jigglypuff find kills by setting up bananas and he can simply Jab/F-tilt her to wake her up.

I think ZeRo and H-Box has shown how good this team can be due to CEO doubles and that other tournament I forgot.
 

Wintropy

Peace and love and all that jazzmatazz~! <3
Joined
Aug 28, 2014
Messages
10,032
Location
Here, there, who knows?
NNID
Winterwhite
3DS FC
1461-6253-6301
what characters are better in doubles as opposed to their singles counterparts? i can think of: :4zelda::4gaw::4littlemac::4villager:. but are there more? conversely, what characters get worse in doubles?
I want to say DK. I've had some tremendous matches with a DK backing me up: great space control and rewarding kill setups if your doubles partner is judicious with their toolkit, while a partner with decent range can mitigate his lag and whiff.

Ganondorf is also a great in doubles if you have a good partner. Flame Choke tech-chase sets up for some excellent kill confirms and a fighter with range to help out can be a huge boon to him too.

You can also do some truly disgusting tricks for style with Warlock Punch. Partner's grab-release -> turning Warlock Punch is just filthy and hysterical. Hell, I've had good results with just getting my friend to stunlock the opposing team and then just Warlock Punching them both into oblivion!
 
Last edited:

Routa

Smash Lord
Joined
May 14, 2015
Messages
1,208
Location
Loimaa, Finland
Hmm... Should we make a list of different roles? Like Wario being in tank and support part? Like counterpart for tier list in singles, but more interesting?
 

Vipermoon

King Marth's most trusted advisor.
Joined
Jan 4, 2015
Messages
2,661
Location
PNW
Switch FC
SW-3371-7457-0227
Dr. Mario and Mario's Fair startup is 16 frames and while Dr. Mario's kills early, it doesn't spike. Ganondorf's Fair startup is 14 frames and is pretty similar in strength, but it's faster and consistent. So, why not the Doc's too? The fact it doesn't spike, but is still slow as one while having 3 hitboxes like Mario's where the late hit is the weakest, early hit is the second weakest, and the middle hit is the strongest, but guess what? The middle hit doesn't come out until frame 17 which for Mario, spikes, for Dr. Mario? Does 16.8% which hey, Ganondorf already does a consistent 16% or 17% through his Fair's hit frames of 14-19; 6 active frames. At 16, Doc does 11.2%, 17-19, 16.8%, and 21-22, 10.08%. For a total of 7 active frames, you only have 3 active frames for the good hit which begins 3 frames slower than Ganondorf's. If Dr. Mario's was a frame 16-22 move that consistently did 16%, that might be better or if it was made quicker like frame 15-21 or 14-20 while doing 15%, that might be better since there's this consistent hit of it's going to kill at that one percent and always that one percent instead of having to make sure you land the right hit. Or we could go with a frame 10-16 move that only does 12%. It'd be weaker, but it'd be a lot faster.

Sources: Ganondorf's frame data, Dr. Mario's frame data, and Mario's frame data.
In 1.0.6 Dr. Mario's Fair was changed to hit the same way as Mario's. So early hit is frame 16, sweetspot is 17-20, and late hit is 21. This now applies to both characters. They simply reduced the late hit by 1 frame for Dr. Mario. This was a reason why I messed up Fair sometimes with Doc so I wished and prayed for this exact buff and they did it.
 

Scarlet Jile

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
1,223
Location
The Woods, Maine
NNID
ScarletJile
Apparently, every Yoshi main in the entire world is awful. Come on, man, your character is better than Diddy. At least win one tournament. :yeahboi:
 

Emblem Lord

The Legendary Lord
Joined
Aug 11, 2005
Messages
9,720
Location
Scotch Plains, NJ
NNID
ShinEmblemLord
3DS FC
3926-6895-0574
Switch FC
SW-0793-4091-6136
@ Browny Browny
Varying degrees of sarcasm can be hard to accurately gauge but... it seems like you're asserting mewtwo outdisjoints Marth... although you're definitely down tilting on Marth for a different timing than Mewtwo.
AND that "measuring disjoint" is also suss due to the way Z-axis shenanigans go.
Honestly his example just looks like a "counter poke" to me. Mewtwos tail is striking Marths hand while Marths sword misses due to its angle.

Not saying Mewtwo doesnt have a large disjoint on his tail as he clearly does, but you can see the angle of where the attacks meet.

That said I do like the example as its basically counter poking brought to is most basic level.
 
Last edited:

hypersonicJD

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jun 28, 2015
Messages
431
NNID
I don't have
3DS FC
2122-7467-7267
I think :4mario: + :4falcon: could be a good team. Mario could set-up a Falcon Punch with his FLUDD, also Mario could thrown a Fireball and Falcon would just run with the Fireball and get a grab. Or even Captain Falcon's Up Air and then Mario could kill with Fair to make a powerful spike. And both of them have really good grab combos and good Up Airs. :4greninja: + :4sheik: Could also be good. I just saw in my mind this: Hydro Pump, it pushes Sheik though the Stage and Sheik gets a Tipper Up Smash. Both of them have good speed and nice aerials. So they could help each other. Sheik could cover Greninja's Approaches with Needles or Greninja could connect Water Shurikens with Sheik's Fair and gimp a recovery. Just my opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom