The Top 5 Brawl [ US | CAN | MEX]

[Mekos]

@ Cassio - Yea I agree. I'm with you.


Esam I understand what you are saying. We just have different views lol.

Answer this for me. If you looked at ADHD's gameplay on youtube and compared his gameplay to player-1's, are u telling me that you can't tell ADHD is better?

I'll answer it for you: You can. lol just kidding. Honestly answer that for me. Right now there is no set criteria to judge gameplay but maybe illmatic can create one since he is the owner of this thread.

 

[Player-1]

adhd is a noob, he can't even infinite ppl

 

[Mekos]

Just to make sure we both know what we are debating....

I am saying results should NOT be the only criteria for this thread.
You(Esam) is saying results SHOULD be the only criteria for this thread.

This thread that is not super official

 

[Eddie G]

I'll be back on Peach soon, count on it.

 

[Cassio]

ESAM I agree, I only add that making judgements on a diverse list of results isnt exactly an objective judgement either. We do the best that we can with what we have, and more information is better than less. In the end the list is for fun so its ok.

 

[Dcold]

Mekos the example you just used, is basically what Esam said atleast a page ago about him vs Snakes. Does that mean that MVD is better than Ally and other Snakes, based on how well you see him play vs. certain people?

 

[Vinylic.]

Dcold with the best point right there.

 

[[FBC] ESAM]

Dcold with the....he literally reposted what I said @_@

@Eddie: Yo, that post is perfect with that avatar xD

@Mekos: Yes, because videos are WAY WAY WAY WAY WAY WAY WAY worse as criteria for determining a rank.

@Cassio: It is way less biased and more consistent to compare the wins of different coasts than it is to compare the videos, especially considering almost all of the time there aren't videos for both of the potential spot-holders.

 

[B_AWAL]

Wait.... Mekos... WTF???

4 Diddy Kong, Pikachu & Sonic its Blatently OBVIOUS how much ADHD, Gnes, ESAM, _X_ & Espy are than every1 else with the same characters.

The issue of "watching" ppl comes into play 4 everyone else on the list. 4 example... The skill level 4 MOST Sonic's is so close that all of us can look the same to the naked eye IMO. The only way we can say who is actually better is to post up who they have beaten.

The idea of using the "way" someone plays in a video is the WORST... well not the worst but its a pretty effin bad idea.





I'm currently dying @ Esam realizing that Dcold repeated him.

 

[Dcold]

I mean, some things are so nice they need to be said twice. I told him Esam said it. :kanye shrug:

 

[FightAdamantEevee]

meekspeedy best sonic


kk

 

[TeeVee]

yea videos are too subjective although there are moments when you watch videos and realize that the person is THAT much better than everyone else using that character like esam with pika or koolaid with pit

 

[Eddie G]

I have to agree, Meek is something else...lol.

 

[Zano]

I will never unsubscribe from this amazing thread. Please continue

 

[Patches]

Meeks da bess

 

[1PokeMastr]

Edit: Yeah, no.

 

[[FBC] ESAM]

Pokemastr +1ing hard.

Also, people, this argument isn't about using videos for the blatantly obvious crap, it is in things like P1 vs Vato where they are close but regionally different. Videos still don't do anything, though.

 

[TeeVee]

p1 > jebus tho

 

[Luxord]

I am the best ROB Meek, stop being a liar

I agree, Kira best ROB.

Kira > rest tied for 2rd to 5th (we could also go back to late 2010 where i had better wins than every other rob :3)

You're right, Kira is the best ROB. And let's not go back then teevee, besides you play zss now and have better wins than all of them including your idol NickRiddle.

I'm Mekos and I just agree with things that support my side.

You're right, Mekos should agree with things that COUNTER his argument. Wise words.

For example, one can tell that a win on Vinnie is of more importance than a win on Falln.

Shots fired.

How the **** do you expect to determine who is playing better? By who wins by more?
I'll answer it for you: You can't.

^^^this

 

[Player-3]

p3 for top 5 diddy

 

[vato_break]

i wonder who teevee thinks is better. teevee honestly knows everything

 

[TeeVee]

out of who ?

 

[Mekos]

Yea this thread is good. Good discussion people!

 

[stingers]

No he doesnt, he put me equal to chibo LOL

 

[ViperGold42]

You realize it matters who you beat, not your placing?

on that thought I saw that ENTIRE tournament son. and I did see who he beat too so yeah I still stand by my original statement.

 

[[FBC] ESAM]

You're right, Mekos should agree with things that COUNTER his argument. Wise words.

>_> It is pointless to add an "I agree" when you could just wait for somebody to argue against the point...+1s everywhere.

@Mekos: Less so discussion, more like proving why your logic was bad.

 

[Seagull Joe]

D1aos>Meek. I say this based on my perceptions playing both of these 's (as the slayer I can tell things) and the fact that he continually improves. He even took Esam to game 5. The first Md/Va local he went to, he beat Will lol. He just always ends up bracket ****ed and has to play Coney and Logic. Odd that Logic beats D1aos though since he's meh vs .

 

[Espy Rose]

DK is a free win for Sonic though.

 

[Dcold]

on that thought I saw that ENTIRE tournament son. and I did see who he beat too so yeah I still stand by my original statement.

Alright son then how about listing who he beat rather than just saying he got 1st. I lost my power to read your mind 2 weeks ago so please forgive me.

 

[vato_break]

i notice seagull only brings up biased information to this thread

 

[Dcold]

A good portion of this thread is biased, lol.

 

[Nike.]

So like.

If P1 and Jebus switched places, and Jebus was in Georgia.
Would Jebus place better/same/lower then P1 normally does?

Same for P1 in SoCal.

 

[Player-1]

I'd place better, he'd place worse

 

[vato_break]

yet player-1 has yet to get an S-tier win like jebus, lolz

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

yet player-1 has yet to get an S-tier win like jebus, lolz

Tyrant and Reflex???

 

[vato_break]

player-1 beat tyrant when he was drunk/faded/and not in tournament lol. and okay he's beaten reflex but jebus still probably has better wins career wise(Rich Brown, Tearbear, and Dehf)

 

[Nike.]

I was in the room when that happened, and I can vouch for P1 when I say that Tyrant was not drunk.

Get out.

 

[vato_break]

Thats what tyrant said, lol. he said he lost to p-1 cross faded at some late time(though i don't recall the time he said)

 

[Player-1]

johns.

the fact that it was a $1 MM is the only excuse he has.

 

[LordXav1er]

Sounds like a john to me, I would too after that naner lock 3rd stock.