What?
How the tournaments were counted isn't even clear, but I did make a post about why MX (at the least) should be above both of you and why the ranbats not counting was a bad decision. In any case, I did it in 40 mins:
Since all the Ranbats weren't counted (effectively killing all of Carls well-earned results and a number of MX's as well):
Season Period: 6/25/12 - 11/25/12
MX:
OS Monthly (No solid way to determine who beat who):
Wins: Krystedez, Kel, Hadesblade, Tako, Carls, Xisin(x2), Mister Eric, Xeroxen
Losses: Krystedez, Kel
Rage:
Wins: Beat Everyone in his pool (Kel, Space Thing, Gio, DRDN and KingYoshi)
Losses: Carls, Blue Rogue
Return of the Mack:
Wins: Squid, Sorasin, Sneakytako, Hadesblade, Count
Losses: Count (x2)
Retribution:
Wins: Beat everyone in his pool (except Player-1).
Losses: Croi, Zeton
Carls
OS Monthly (No solid way to determine who beat who): Well, I know he did beat me (MX) in the final pool. Not sure who else aside from that. CARLS WHERE YEW AT
Unclear, but he ended up placing 5th
Rage:
Wins: Beat Everyone in his pool except Sparta Kick I believe, Tech Chase, MX, Thugz
Losses: AlphaZealot, Zinoto
SPAU2:
Wins: Gifts, Zyth, Pzo, Sparta Kick
Losses: Ally, Lain
Retribution:
Wins: I think the only person he lost to in pools was Delta-Cod. Everyone else, I think he won against.
Losses: DLA, Judo
Rolling with the Punches 2:
No results thread, but he beat KB in a $10 MM.
Sneakytako
OS Monthly (No solid way to determine who beat who):
Unclear, but he ended up placing 4th
Rage:
Wins: Beat Everyone in his pool except Ally I believe, Bulletsquall
Losses: Blue Rogue, King Beef
S2D:
Wins: Bubblegum, James, Megarobman
Losses: Ralph Cecil, Masquerain
Retribution:
Wins: Delux (pools)
Losses: Everyone else in his pool
Return of the Mack:
Wins: Sovereign, Braxton
Losses: MX, Hadesblade
Even without the Ranbats, you fall below Carls and MX. Why reasoning can be said to justifiably put you above Carls and MX?