The Halloween Captain
Smash Master
Frankly, 1-1 motion controls for a flagship series after the unveiling of wii motion plus should actually be expected. I mean, Zelda is the 4th biggest franchise (after Pokemon, Mario, and "Wii *insert verb here*"). I would almost expect the company to attempt at least Metroid Prime 3 motion controls, if not better.1-1 motion controls are a big yes. But light sabers? Maybe, maybe in a Future Zelda type deal. But a Zelda RPG is something I can get excited over. Just as long as the gameplay stayed similar without leaving the overworld/dungeon for a separate battle. That would just be bothersome and tedious. But if you just fight in a similar manner to other Zeldas, except with experience, that would be awesome.
They could return to Zelda's oft-forgotten RPG roots, and give you a bonus of your choice in hearts, power, or magic meter at each level. Of course, there would be more depth involved, but that's the basic idea there. Throw in multiple weapons, items, etc, and they're on their way.
However, I would not be disappointed at all with TP controls if something else was improved upon. In fact, the TP motion controls would still be fine, except for the need for shield attack to be mapped to a button.
Once again, both kinda sad and amazing that TP has some of the best motion controls on the wii.