Nysyarc
Last King of Hollywood
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2009
- Messages
- 3,389
- Location
- Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
- NNID
- Nysyarc
- 3DS FC
- 1075-0983-2504
This may have been brought up already but I don't feel like sifting through 100+ pages of posts to find out... I think you can understand that.
I have a few suggestions for the general posting ranks. From what I've gathered, you start as a Smash Noob, then become a Smash Child at 10 posts, then a Smash Journeyman at 100 posts (maybe?), then a Smash Apprentice... not sure when, and then a Smash Lord I believe? Maybe there are some in between I missed.
I don't like the idea of using the terms 'Noob' and 'Child' in a forum title, especially when it is not the poster's choice in the matter. Creative posting titles don't have to be derogatory (it's obviously not intended to be insulting, but people don't like to be labeled as noobs or children, I'm 22 years old and have been playing SSB for years, I don't like to think of myself as a Smash Child).
I also understand that the titles are pertaining to the person's rank on the forum, and not their skill in SSB, but with the pre-title Smash involved, it's easy to be confused. I also have to disagree with the rank Journeyman preceding the rank Apprentice (an apprentice studies to become a journeyman), and at the fact that posters are labeled as Apprentices for a long time, unless they are fervent contributers.
I think having more ranks would make things more interesting (like a new rank every 50 posts), and maybe keeping the ranks in the same context (a Child, to a Journeyman, and eventually to a Lord... not really in the same league theme-wise). Administrators and Moderators are exempt from posting ranks, but for the rest of us, I think maybe a poll is in order to decide if ranks should be changed, added, or both.
If pressed I could come up with several ideas for new posting rank names myself, and I know that editing posting ranks is quite simple, as I have administrated forums before. Let me know what you think, and let me know if you want me to clarify or embellish any of my arguments.
I have a few suggestions for the general posting ranks. From what I've gathered, you start as a Smash Noob, then become a Smash Child at 10 posts, then a Smash Journeyman at 100 posts (maybe?), then a Smash Apprentice... not sure when, and then a Smash Lord I believe? Maybe there are some in between I missed.
I don't like the idea of using the terms 'Noob' and 'Child' in a forum title, especially when it is not the poster's choice in the matter. Creative posting titles don't have to be derogatory (it's obviously not intended to be insulting, but people don't like to be labeled as noobs or children, I'm 22 years old and have been playing SSB for years, I don't like to think of myself as a Smash Child).
I also understand that the titles are pertaining to the person's rank on the forum, and not their skill in SSB, but with the pre-title Smash involved, it's easy to be confused. I also have to disagree with the rank Journeyman preceding the rank Apprentice (an apprentice studies to become a journeyman), and at the fact that posters are labeled as Apprentices for a long time, unless they are fervent contributers.
I think having more ranks would make things more interesting (like a new rank every 50 posts), and maybe keeping the ranks in the same context (a Child, to a Journeyman, and eventually to a Lord... not really in the same league theme-wise). Administrators and Moderators are exempt from posting ranks, but for the rest of us, I think maybe a poll is in order to decide if ranks should be changed, added, or both.
If pressed I could come up with several ideas for new posting rank names myself, and I know that editing posting ranks is quite simple, as I have administrated forums before. Let me know what you think, and let me know if you want me to clarify or embellish any of my arguments.