ShadowLink84
Smash Hero
Sorry to disappoint you and Sonic.
Although if it helps you sleep better Sonic is the one character I have the least amount of experience with/against, so he could (probably) only move up for me.
Umm its not just Sonic, and you should be using more information than your experience. -_-
Ice climber's should be in 8th place.
Diddy could be around 4th or 5th
Marth should be above DDD IMO.
Pokemon trainer is far too low.
Ness should be above Lucas IMO,
Peach should be above Toon Link at least.
A few other things but you get my point.