I said POWER and FAST characters when I listed them, not heavyweights and lightweights. And since we're counting transformations, I've got two more fast characters for you, Shiek and Zero Suit Samus. Being heavy in weight doesn't change the play style that much, it's being slow and powerful/fast and weak that matters far more. Dedede's play style wouldn't change if he became light, and he probably wouldn't drop much in tier position, if at all.
Your quote~
...as heavyweight characters aren't in as much abundance as small, fast characters, which is what Dixie would be. Anyway, the post:
Heavyweight =! Power
Fast =! Fast + Small
You honestly think that the developers were looking at a mediocre show to design K. Rool? Rare has more originality then that and isn't so horribly idiotic to base the design off of one of the most horrendous shows untrue to the source material ever made. I have seen a couple episodes of the both the Mario and Zelda cartoons, it lowered my IQ points a fair bit. If you want to know what fans think of them, look no further then youtube poops.
...Rare's not the most original bunch... Most of their characters are animals/objects/mythic creatures with big eyes, human clothes, and for most purposes, cartoony. And look back at the picture I showed you, and see how close they really are, and remember how close their personalities were. I have no idea why you seem to hate that version of Bowser so much, yet love K.Rool despite them being virtually the same thing. (Do you just dislike turtles or something?) Youtube Poops are just harmless fun. You'll find it for basically everything. In fact, the most popular things normally get the most parody.
Since when was the Zelda cartoon good either? "EXCUUUUUSE ME PRINCESS!". While perhaps not as bad as CDI, they're still horrendous, and that's what matters.
....Exactly how old are you? You must be pretty young. Clearly didn't grow up on them, nor at an age to appriciate their camp value. Did you ever see that DK cartoon? What did you think of that? (K.Rool had a rockin air guitar back then)
The main reason I said the ness/lucas FS thing would be so that they'd be attracted away from just making him Giga K. Rool.
That would be worlds better than a PK Starstorm clone.
How will picking thing up with her hair give her anything besides items? Moves from sports are generally just excuses the the core character doesn't have enough good moves. Unless the character actually originates from is most well known from spin offs (Like Waluigi), spin off moves shouldn't be in their attacks. It's an insult to the character, Dixie is no exception. Really now, I've made a K. Rool moveset, let's see you make one for Dixie now that gives her a distinct playstyle, as bickering over who has more potetional isn't getting us anywhere.
It would make a cool extended grab, and seeing as it can be manipulated, can be used in many different attacks. You had to make up loads of K.Rool's stuff, so I don't know why you're ragging on the moves Dixie's picked up from sports games. Plus, the moves used in the spin offs fit her character. (Using boost barrels. Using giant bananas for batting at things)
Since I don't want to really do this, here are some quick B moves and a FS.
Neutral B: Barrel Throw- Dixie Kong flips her hair, and a barrel is seen being held in it. Dixie can walk around with the barrel, though at a slower rate, and has a reduced jump while holding it this way. When thrown, the barrel will roll faster than a standard barrel, but will also be weaker slighty.
Side B: Banana Swing-Dixie will take out a large banana, like the one used in Mario Superstar Baseball, and will hold it mudh like Dedede would hold his Jet Hammer. The move doesn't gain power from holding it longer, nor will it damage her. When released, she will simply swing the bat like normal, but if used against a projectile, she will bat it right back.
Up B: Barrel Blast- Dixie automatically pops into a barrel with a arrow painted on, which starts to spin around very rapidly. When B is pressed again, she will shoot forward in the direction the barrel was. Works like a faster version of the cut item.
Down B: Ponytail Twirl- A chargible move where Dixie pivots back. Can be charged for about as long as DK can charge a punch. When released on the ground, Dixie will spin right or left, depending on the direction, and turn fairly quickly. If a opponent its hit, it won't do much damage, but it will trap the foes, getting multiple hits. If used in the air, it can be used as a second recovery move, though it will only work horizontally, and won't help with any vertical recovery.
Final Smash: Rambi Racing- A tribute to the canceled Donkey Kong Racing, Dixie Jumps up into the sky, and a giant Rambi falls down with her on top. The Rambi is slightly smaller than Giga Bowser, but technically longer. The player can use the Rambi to charge into opponents, and can make the rhino do short hops as well. Is fairly fast, but can only attack at close range, and lasts about as long as other transformation Final Smashes.
And in any case, all this is doing is getting a bad rep for the both of us. Can we please just stop this? Nobody's going to win the argument, and we're mostly arguing over completely pointless subjects that won't affect their chances of getting in, going off on unrelated insiginicant details, like who's more serious (Bowser or K. Rool), K. Rool's origin, which of the two is less generic (Dixie or K. Rool), and so many more things. All it really comes down to in the end is a popularity contest.
Just admit defeat, then it will end. You can try to prove me wrong but, excuse my arrogance, that's not going to happen. You also don't seem to know that popularity isn't the driving force here, marketing is. While doesn't effect everything, it effects the main series quite a bit. >_>
K. Rool has more popularity on message boards, while Dixie has more in real life, generally speaking. But the only time Sakurai listens to the opinions of fans is when he hosts polls, otherwise he doesn't listen to what they think. Guess who are the ones who answer the polls? The ones on the message boards who are so geeky as to actually care who gets into a Smash game, like you and me.
And it seems he answered them by planning to put in Dixie. Your logic here is a bit flawed in this point. (Also, lol marketing is more important than popularity)