1) I can't really argue against this.
2) I didn't say they were bad because of losing to me. A bunch of them were bad because they were, I dunno, bad. They didn't make it out of pools that were doable, etc. Also, if you're going to make inexperience johns, I know for fact a bunch of the Marths in those videos do not have good Peaches to regularly practice against, so the same can be applied.
3) If your point is, "Peach can beat Marth at high level" then fine. If you're arguing it's an even matchup or favourable for Peach, then no.
4) I don't have to play Marth or Peach to know somebody is mediocre. Bad habits and other things like that are good enough indicators. I'm nice, however, and often try to give people the benefit of the doubt anyway. When they additionally fail to perform in easy pools and don't even get top 48 or whatever... I dunno. Where are we drawing a line?
1) rofl
2) good point but you could also say the peaches have little Marth experience....not sure why I'm even bringing this up.
3) nah my point is that it's not 60-40 or worse but it's very winnable if you know how to do it or you get lucky Dsmashes/Stitchfaces and ba-bombs. It's somewhere around 56-44, Close to Even on DK64 or Dreamland and 55-45 in peaches favor on Brinstar....but who doesn't ban Brinstar?
4) Not making it out of pools at 1 event isn't always the best indicator....sometimes people are playing off, or hung over, or simply just in a stacked pool at some point. Apex and Pound 5 had alot of pretty good and very good players who didn't make it to bracket. Sometimes your just unlucky. Although I'd say anyone who can make it to final round of pools and beyond is at least decent.
Ice Climbers are my worst matchup and I know nothing about their current metagame. So I'm not inclined to talk about them at all.
Puff beats Sheik by a bit because Sheik's aerial mobility sucks and she gets Rested too easily. Puff doesn't win exchanges well in the MU but the ones she does win have a reasonable likelihood of leading to Sheik exploding, which sucks. Sheik doesn't have a good threat to punish Rest lag after dying because nothing she does after respawn kills Puff unless Puff is at like 80%+ anyway (so you need to get 5-8 hits to be able to come back and kill Puff, which is balls).
Sheik gets props for having a good jab that combos to Fair and Uair at higher percents.
