I'd say Pika is top lol
That's just me though I guess. Luigi can be high too, but not Sonic lol
It is based on my experience because that ultimatly is all I have to go by other than opinions from others on those I've played and from those I've played. But perceptions are always clearer when you paint them yourself. And considering I use every character equally, I seem to have a better grasp of this than many. On the other hand, that's only me and my early and minimal experience. Random is teh Broken btw lol
Sheik is freakin crazy, but the reason I don't she will last is because she is predictable and repetitive with simple tactics that work "for now" and that only goes so far. Same reason I put the likes of Lucario so low. etc...
Agreed, he has some great match ups...just a lot of horrible ones too. That's what keeps him out of top. Even out of high. Mid is still reachable but he needs some dramatic changes and discoveries to overcome much of the roster ahead of him.
It took a good year for people like Isai to bring Falcon to the same level as everyone else. Why, is in my big *** post ^^^ lol
That sucks when that happens

That only goes so far though, I'm more or less trying to NOT overlook the other possible side to the game. Might not be the nature, but off stage play and defensive play were always part of it.
And that type of opportunity play, I think of it as Peach comboing in melee.
Here's a quote from Endrees Blog that is about Peach
Praxis wrote at 2:28 PM on Apr 3, 2008 :
Very good read, but your comments on Peach struck an interesting note with me. What you describe is EXACTLY how I play Peach- reading my opponents. I don't memorize combos or use the same series of attacks- I adjust based on who I'm playing and figure out how they tend to react. I've heard it from others who play Peach too.
(End quote)
(my quote)
Peach could combo plenty in melee and can again in Brawl. It's just not what anyone is used to. Now a Marth can't chain grabs, fairs and utilts together without thinking much. They have to follow and chase and trick. That's why I've heard from various Peach players that the transition was so easy, and it's not just because they're using Peach for many of them main other characters now and still feel the same about them.
(End quote)
You from above
"and making them do something stupid, like
attack " key word, smash attack. This may sound odd but most smash attacks don't work on me anymore and wont work well on any good players in the future. Why I think this is explained in my big post but it all comes down to the defensive game and stiking on opportunity. That's why characters like Sonic (don't disregard him just yet, Falcon was bottom in melee for a while too you know) may just become a winning character after all.
Yes, she has kill power. I've actually used her the least because I can't Random to her often, but that statement is a little false I admit. lol And her recovery is just fine, and her speed is great. It's an old post ok?!? lol No biggy, I still don't think she is much better than many of the characters above her.
Don't get it? hahaha that's awesome. Yeah, it's not the usual thing. I've kind of taken this game from another angle and from other sides. It's not the current tier list that's for sure, but it's a futuristic one I'm sure. And every character can stand their ground, I feel comfortable in winning with anyone right now. It's really quite interesting. In melee, I wasn't comfortable with so many so soon and I was as good as I am now after about the same time span when I started melee. It's going to be an interesting couple years of smash lol
Thanks, shouldn't need too much...
Edit: Oh, and I've recently decided that I love wolves, like the actual animal. What's the matter, scared? lol I love the taunts in this freakin game!!!