Fatmanonice brought up that most people in the next generation will likely remember the late N64/Gamecube era. If that is the case, then next gen, the Nintendo 64 can be considered a retro console. My opinion is that if a console is three generation behind the current, it is a retro console. Example, Melee was released on Gamecube, Ice Climbers and Mr. Game & Watch only had games on the NES. Therefore, they are considered retro characters. Brawl came around on the Wii. As such, the NES and SNES could be considered retro consoles. In this case, to add to Ice Climbers and Mr. Game & Watch, Marth (Although the main face of Fire Emblem, he did not appear in a game since
Fire Emblem: Monshō no Nazo on January, 1994 for the SNES, therefore, since the console was three generations ago, it could be considered retro and so could Marth), Pit, and R.O.B. Pit and Marth have since lost that retro status by appearing in new games (Marth) or upcoming games (Pit). Now next gen come along and if this logic applies, the Nintendo 64 can be considered retro. So really, any character that has not appeared in a single game since the Nintendo 64 can be considered retro, not just NES and SNES.
@ChronoBound: You have a point there, but I think we'll see at least 46 characters without transformation included mainly because the Wii-U disc can handle about three times the size of the Wii's disc, meaning more information can be put in. Obviously a lot of it will go into modes and visuals, but as we're not expecting any big story mode on the Wii-U version, so I can see a roster in the late 40s without transformation easily occurring, not to mention the likelihood of DLC characters. But if we only get 44 characters, I think what would please the most fans is if Lip was replaced with King K. Rool/Dixie Kong and the fourth third-party character (Not Mega Man) with Saki Amamiya/Isa Jo since I doubt with just ten changes to the roster that we'll see a fourth third-party character.
Also, Toad could be removed. This is probably the only major site where Toad is generally supported, other sites such as IGN and GameFAQs are either against his inclusion or mixed. I see more support for Bowser Jr. and even Paper Mario. Ryu could be removed as well since many more people want Mega Man.
Fatmanonice said:
Well, he basically admitted that the clones were added only a few months before Melee was launched to stuff the roster so that fans wouldn't be mad.
Why would people be mad with just 20 characters in Melee? If anything, I would have preferred a roster without Pichu and Dr. Mario (I preferred Roy over Marth in that game and Mewtwo was unique, so not including those).
Fatamonice said:
I would say that it will be roughly the same, with about a 3 month standard deviation. The original Smash Bros was a very basic project and Melee was finished so fast because Sakurai worked on it 10+ hours a day, 6 days a week, for 11 months. One of the reasons Brawl was delayed was because of complications with the online features since it was the team's first time working with online for the Wii so that obstacle probably won't be present this time around as the WiiU's online infrastructure should be considerably easier to work with and the team has experience now.
You're forgetting that they have to update everything to HD and improve the models of all the characters in the game to above PS3/360 levels and considering how good Brawl looked, they're most certainly going to try to push close to the limit in not only visuals, but pack it with contents. It's not the characters, stages, and online that needs to be improved, it's that they're going to be adding new styles to fight with and new modes.
Fatmanonice said:
F-Zero's technically a dead franchise so its chances of getting anymore reps are virtually zilch. It's been seven years since the last installment and, for whatever reason, Nintendo keeps shooting down requests from third parties to pick up the series again.
I wouldn't say the franchise is dead yet nor do I think the chances are small. They may have very well skipped the Wii generation because a great F-zero game couldn't handle it and chosen to put it in the Wii-U instead where it has better online, is much more powerful, and that it'll likely sell better then
F-zero GX. You should also consider that Samurai Gorah was an Assist Trophy and I can't see the game going without upgrading at least one player from Assist Trophy status to playable character.
kenshen said:
what about some body from ff like cloud or Cecil
It will almost certainly not happen. Dragon Quest reps will get in before Final Fantasy.