• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

[Left 4 Scum] Game Over: Scum Win

Pythag

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
May 7, 2007
Messages
2,627
Location
Flux
Sorry, but does anyone like being voted upon? I think I've made it abundantly clear that my frustration comes not from the receiving of votes but the bull**** reasons people are giving with them (when they give reasons at all). You're right, we seem to just be RLing until we hit scum, but no one's admitting it. And frankly, I think we have overtly better targets to go after than the ones we've been focusing on.

Conclusion: Everyone stop being scum/Tom hand-picked us for this game; how does town suck so much?
Circus, let us unpack this.
IF you agree that we are pretty much just RLing right now, and that we really don't have a whole lot to go on, THEN I can infer, that any reason that anyone gives for voting can be counted as bullshit.
So when I say, that you don't like being voted upon, I mean you lash out crazily in order to somehow "prove" yourself innocent, when in reality, to me it makes you seem more suspicious.

If we don't have anything, then why would you fight so hard to stay in the game when it's just a RL? Probably because you are scum. My vote stays.
 

mentosman8

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
153
Location
Naperville, IL
To Gheb's question about who the play is today, I'm starting to get a bit clearer idea as today goes on. McFox is one possibility, although more recently he has been looking a lot like a frustrated townie. I'm not sure whether to read it as scum defensive or that frustration however.

Circus is also on my list, would vote him to get a lynch through if need be.

To the other side, Circus raised a good point about Gheb. I have largely ignored his repeated comments about a me/Circus connection, because while I know it's not the case I have no way to refute his argument solely because it's his interpretation of things that happened. However, Circus' point that this seems to be ALL he brings up when someone calls him out does hold up. This is strange to me, because town Gheb I've seen has always been more spread out, this is the first time I've seen him so tunneled on one idea. Not sure what to make of it, but he is also on my suspect list.

I'm ok with a lynch of any of the three mentioned above.
 

~ Gheb ~

Life is just a party
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
16,916
Location
Europe
I'm tunneled on the idea because it remained largely ignored. Ronike was the only one except us 3 who commented on it. I'm usually spread out but this time round it's more difficult because it's apparently suspicious now.

:059:
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
69 Hours Until Deadline!

Uncap Count:
L-3[5] Kataefi (KevinM, Xiivi, Pythag, Gheb_01, Mayling)
[1] Chaco (Cello_Marl)
[1] The Marsh King (Circus)

[7] Not Uncapping (Chaco, mentosman8, Kataefi, frozenflame751, Rockin, McFox, The Marsh King)

Vote Count:
L-3[5] Circus (Xiivi, Gheb_01, Mayling, Pythag, KevinM)
[4] Not Voting (Chaco, Kataefi, Rockin, The Marsh King)
[3] McFox (frozenflame751, mentosman8, Cello_Marl)
[1] frozenflame751 (McFox)
[1] Xiivi (Circus)

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to uncap and 8 to lynch!
A deadline has been set for Wednesday, January 20th, Noon EST!

Okay guys, time to secure a lynch and uncap and stuff. Wanting to lynch Circus/Mayling today, preference is definitely Circus.

@Xiivi - that's exactly what I wanted! What do you make of Pythag in the Circus quote? What do you make of Pythag in general?
If Circus flips scum, then Pythag would be clear in my eyes. Looks a lot more like he was saying "Hit Pythag" more than "Pythag Hit X". Although that might just because Pythag has looked like the towniest of town all game along with Cello. One of the reasons I wanted Kevin dead so bad Day 2 was his wanting to wagon Pythag, who was just so obviously town Kevin looked scummy as hell. (Same with Circus continually wanting to wagon Cello.)
 

mentosman8

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
153
Location
Naperville, IL
Xiivi just reminded me, I forgot this in my last post

Uncap Kataefi

Marsh would be guaranteed dead tonight anyway pretty much, and Chaco hasn't done much today. Well earned uncap
 

McFox

Spread the Love
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 9, 2001
Messages
18,783
Location
Visiting from above.
Uncap: Kat

Agreed that Kat has stepped up his game, and I'd rather have three clears to talk to tomorrow than two.

I'll comment on other stuff soon, I'm moving to NY in three days and it's been a busy weekend.
 

Cello_Marl

Smash Rookie
Joined
Nov 4, 2009
Messages
0
@Circus, and to a lesser extent Gheb, is the only problem at this point that you have with me my lack of posts? If that's it, then why don't you give me something to focus on. Is there anything you want my opinion on?

@McFox, what do you think of Marsh's endorsement of Frozen?
 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
What I don't know is where YOU stand on the current events. No voting to look at, no actively engaging in the conversation (something you found scummy from my D1/D2 play), etc.... Just a catch up and early D3 opinions.
Yeah, sorry. I'm not following my own words lol

Only play/lynch I'm agreeing on is a Gheb lynch. He still hasn't convinced me all game that he's neither townie or interested in catching scum, so I wouldn't mind him going

Vote: Gheb

Xiivi, you've been playing a bit better today, so I'll cut you a bit of slack.

Honestly, I rather uncap chaco and I was really hoping he'd shine. Unfortunatly, he hasn't and Kat's been the one posting. Even though he's confirmed town, I'm not liking how he's been using his voice today (granted, I didn't do much better. in fact. kat's did a lot better then me in comparison). uncap: Kat All I've seen mostly was him on mayling. Wish he put a bit of pressure on others at least >>;;

So far, the only case I see on Cirus is the HIT issue he did. Still feel that's a null tell case since right now there's no way to prove it, really. Dunno, could be just me. The only thing I see on the case of cello is the activity issue (if either these are wrong or there's more to it, please correct me).

I rather NOT lynch Mayling (or at least, so quickly). Right now, she's sufficating in WIFOM, and I want to avoid another mislynch. If she's considered of a lynch, I rather wait till we knock off one scum or two (perfer two) so we'd have better odds of uncapping others.
 

Mayling

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Nov 7, 2008
Messages
227
Location
Lexington
Mayling - if you could go into some detail that would be cool for me. So the rhyming thing was suspicious... what else specifically are you finding suspicious about Circus? Also, I'm questioning you guys because you are the unclears =)
Okay, first off, to clarify what I meant about the rhyming thing. Although at first I tried to make a connection with the rhyming thing to scumminess, that sorta fell thru. I wouldn't advocate a lynch solely for Circus based on the rhyming thing; rather what I meant was since the rhyming thing I've had funny vibes on him. Sorta kept my eye on him. It didn't help that many other people that have played with him before has been saying he's scummy/been acting scum. So I guess I kinda tunneled guilty on him.

also, honestly, I don't like it when people buddy me. it makes me wary, like they're trying to trick me. >_< cus you're more likely to disagree with someone who's going against you, than someone who is buddying you. which circus sorta did, always saying that he was getting pro-town vibes (altho I never think he said why), and saying to stop posting stuff that made me look scummy.

The reason I voted Circus, finally, was because Xiivi's #807 sold me on his lynch. Not to mention that, but the other likely lynch candidate was McFox when Marshy's vote put him at l-2. I put my vote on Circus at that time because it seemed like a "this person or this person" sort of deal... so I was like.. don't think it's mcfox, go with circus... everyone's been saying he's scum this entire time, right?

Also, Circus really guns for cello_marl. like, what has cello_marl does that's so scummy? he was inactivey, not really posting... but what about mentos? his last post was five days ago
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=9300931&postcount=862
and it was only to rebuttal something negative i had said against him. even when mentos does post, did it ever really have clear thoughts, arguments, etc? has circus really said anything about him and his lack of contribution?

Something interesting I found while re-examining xiivi's post

And on that note, I'd be shocked if the Vyse lynch went through without scum help. So I'm looking at Vyse wagoners toDay.
There was also mention of Ronike saying that there were certainly scum on his wagon when he got voted.

So I pulled up these vote counts:

Vote Count:
[10] Vyse (Ronike, The Marsh King, Circus, Xiivi, Gheb_01, Pythag, Kataefi, frozenflame751, KevinM, Cello_Marl)
[4] Not Voting (Chaco, Mayling, Macman, mentosman8)
[1] mentosman8 (Mediocre)
[1] Ronike (McFox)
[1] Xiivi (Handorin)
[1] Mediocre (Vyse)
[0] Circus ()
[0] frozenflame751 ()
[0] KevinM ()
[0] Kataefi ()
[0] Cello_Marl ()
[0] Gheb_01 ()
[0] McFox ()
[0] Handorin ()
[0] Macman ()
[0] Pythag ()
[0] Mayling ()
[0] Chaco ()
[0] The Marsh King ()
Uncap Count:
[9] The Marsh King (Handorin, Pythag, KevinM, Chaco, Gheb_01, Ronike, Circus, Frozenflame751, McFox)
[2] Macman (Xiivi, Cello_Marl)
[0] Handorin ()

[5] Not Uncapping (Mayling, The Marsh King, Mediocre, Macman, Mentosman8, Kataefi)

Vote Count:
[9] Ronike (Chaco, Macman, The Marsh King, McFox, Cello_Marl, Gheb_01, Handorin, KevinM, Xiivi)
[5] Not Voting (mentosman8, Kataefi, frozenflame751, Rockin, Pythag)
[1] Kataefi (Mayling)
[1] Chaco (Ronike)
[1] Cello_Marl (Circus)
[0] KevinM ()
[0] Xiivi ()
[0] Mayling ()
[0] Gheb_01 ()
[0] mentosman8 ()
[0] Rockin ()
[0] Circus ()
[0] frozenflame751 ()
[0] McFox ()
[0] Handorin ()
[0] Macman ()
[0] Pythag ()
Vyse: Marshy, Cello_marl, KevinM, Xiivi, Gheb_01, Ronike, Circus, Pythag, Kataefi, Frozenflame751

Ronike: Marshy, Cello_marl, Kevinm, Xiivi, Gheb_01, Chaco, Macman, McFox, Handorin

Unclears who voted for both: cello_marl, gheb_01, xiivi, kevinm

there are many ways to look at this vote spread...

if kevinM or rockin could give us some more of their thoughts on why gheb is a suspect to them, I'd appreciate it. especially looking over these vote counts.

as for the unclears who voted both:

cello: like i said, i'm pretty certain he's town. him being on both the lists makes me raise my eyebrows a tad, but not enough to think he's suddenly scum or anything.

gheb_01: at first, i was leaning towards pro-town for gheb, but him being on both the lists makes me question his position a tad more.

actually, doing some rereading, i see why he's suspicious.

xiivi: xiivi's performance really boosted in this d3. at first, i really bought into his attack on circus, but i just don't know anymore. after all, he could be scum trying to get the final mislynch.

kevinM: kevinm has gotten away with so many things and i don't even know why. the push for a dead Ronike was just ridiculous and so was his answering to Kat's questions.

also
Yeah, sorry. I'm not following my own words lol

Only play/lynch I'm agreeing on is a Gheb lynch. He still hasn't convinced me all game that he's neither townie or interested in catching scum, so I wouldn't mind him going

Vote: Gheb
rockin at first I liked your post, cus it seemed reasonable and all but this kinda grated me the wrong way. according to cello, he says we're potentially in mylo (tho honestly I STILL don't know the difference between MYLO and LYLO.) that means we really have to make this lynch count, and you saying "i wouldn't mind him going" reflects to me a more d1 lynching attitude, where we have room to breathe.

@everyone. please ask me any questions you may have, even tho it seems everytime i open my mouth i just become scummier. but... i don't wanna get lynched and cause town to lose.
 

Mayling

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Nov 7, 2008
Messages
227
Location
Lexington
i was thinking under what cello mentioned of this possibly being MYLO (mentioned later in the post). even if it's not MYLO, it might be a good idea to think it is, anyway, just so the pressure is on and we can be extra careful
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
So you fear it's mislynch and lose.

So you think we must either lynch scum today, or we no lynch.

So the comment "maybe Xiivi is scum pushing that final mislynch", meaning you don't trust me (or are just trying to shovel doubt on me) and think Circus is innocent (yet still voting him). You also seem to think McFox is town, yet I wasn't even on the McFox wagon when Marsh King went L-2 on him, and had every ability to put him at L-1 [since I'm scum pushing the final mislynch after all] and he would have probably been lynched.

Your "I think Xiivi is town...but maybe not..." line of thinking that keeps coming up doesn't match your actual actions at all.

Xiivi
Circus
McFox

What alignment do you think they are without the "It could be X, but maybe it's Y..."? Straight up "town" or "scum" answers.

For it to be MYLO there needs to be four scum, correct? Do you think the scum is already on the Circus wagon, or not? Why the hell are you voting Circus if you think I'm scum pushing the 'final' mislynch? I really feel you're just throwing doubt where you can at this point.

Regardless Frozen/Rockin/Cello?/Mentos?/McFox? don't seem to have any intention of joining the Circus wagon at this point. We have like 40 hours until deadline. The clears haven't really showed any recent interest in the Circus wagon, who knows if they'll even vote before deadline? Are we really going to No Lynch? At least most cared enough to Uncap. -_-;;

Whatever. If people really aren't lynching Circus/Mayling today, then they should find someone to lynch. No lynch is awful.

PS: Circus hasn't really scumhunted at all. All he's done is OMGUS the people voting him, buddy whoever else he could, and try to lynch inactive-Cello specifically rather than any inactive over and over. And how no one noticing the blatant contradiction of "well I'm warming up to a McFox lynch...." when it's looking like it's going to happen so he can have an easy jump onto it to "guys now that the wagon has dissolved on McFox, I actually really thought he was town very passionately, I was just afraid to disagree! I bet my life (you can lynch me the next day), if McFox flips scum!" is beyond me.
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
but Circus is so close and we have like 40 hours and 40 inactives and I don't want no lynch >_<

but yeah, If people aren't going to lynch Circus I'll go to Mayling, who else is up for Mayling besides me and Kevin?
 

Circus

Rhymes with Jerkus
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
5,164
I could get behind a Mayling lynch, though I'm sure that doesn't ease you.

But honestly, if anyone other than Xiivi, Kevin, Gheb and Mayling are even still playing this game and feel like jumping on Xiivi or Kevin, you know I'm down for it (for real though, it seems like only four or five of us are even playing, and that's worrisome in and of itself).

Ununcap

Uncap: Kataefi


@Cello: The short answer is yes, my main beef with you is your inactivity. We have to start shaping a moderately strong/trustworthy group for endgame, and I don't want to be stuck in a situation where I have to rely on you, Frozen, Mentos, and Rockin to help lynch us scum. The precedent that has been shaping itself over the last few Days is currently telling me that I would probably be talking to myself if that ends up being the case. I've been singling you out specifically because I feel you've been the worst offender so far and our suspicions disagree with each other considerably (you apparently think Kevin is clear based on wishy-washy reasoning, while he's one of my top suspects). FrozenFlame might be as bad as if not worse than you in terms of getting a post made, but his suspicion of Xiivi makes me feel better about him. Even if I am aching for him and about a million other people to post more. Honestly, if I had to vote for him or Mentos or Rockin to avoid a mislynch, I'd comply almost as happily as I would for your lynch.

I might get to commenting on some other stuff in a bit, when I stop shaking from all the rage some of the more recent posts have instilled in me. Honestly, I don't consider myself much of a hothead, but the stupidity of this game is getting to me. We should not have this many inactive people and it should not be this hard to understand basic concepts and read entire posts instead of skimming over them.
 

Circus

Rhymes with Jerkus
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
5,164
I'm sorry, Xiivi. Do you not want to avoid mislynches? I see my gaff (I should have said "no lynch" instead of "mislynch") but I don't see how what I said is scummy. Even if you want to call that a Freudian Slip, I don't get how it's incriminating in any way.
 

Circus

Rhymes with Jerkus
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
5,164
I'm sorry, Xiivi. Do you not want to avoid mislynches?
This was not a rhetorical question.

And while you're answering that one, answer me this: Are you sick of reaching for imaginary weapons to use against me? Your arms must be getting sore after that last try.
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
Cool bitter sarcasm. Yes, I want to avoid mislynches.

Regardess where I was going was:
"Do you actually think Mayling is scummy, or would it just be self-preservation?

If we lynch Mayling and she turns up scum/town, who would you look at next?"

Now I just want to continue pushing your death because you're just screaming scum at every turn.
 

Circus

Rhymes with Jerkus
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
5,164
What you just asked and the question you posed in your 941 are not even remotely similar. I'm happy to answer a legitimate question. It's when you just sit there on your pedestal and ask me stupid things as if you've already bingo'd scum when I know you so clearly haven't that makes me bitter.

Yes, I think Mayling is actually scummy. If this was about self-preservation, I would have just switched over to McFox since he's the next biggest candidate for lynch (and, indeed, one of the only other people really discussed all Day).

If Mayling flips scum, it would probably just solidify my suspicion of Cello. Beyond that, I'm not sure what connections I could make, but I'm sure that's nothing a reread couldn't fix. There's also the added benefit of practically clearing certain other people I find suspicious like you and Kevin since you've taken side against her. If she flips town, then I'll probably go back to this dance I've been doing toDay.
 

Mayling

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Nov 7, 2008
Messages
227
Location
Lexington
So you fear it's mislynch and lose.

So you think we must either lynch scum today, or we no lynch.
In my post, I said I didn't know the difference between MYLO and LYLO. (I do now, yay!) And again, I was going off what Cello's mentioning of possible MYLO. Yes, I fear it's mislynch and lose because we have lynched two townies so far, and we really do need to hit scum.

So the comment "maybe Xiivi is scum pushing that final mislynch", meaning you don't trust me (or are just trying to shovel doubt on me) and think Circus is innocent (yet still voting him). You also seem to think McFox is town, yet I wasn't even on the McFox wagon when Marsh King went L-2 on him, and had every ability to put him at L-1 [since I'm scum pushing the final mislynch after all] and he would have probably been lynched.
Yeah, maybe you are scum pushing that final mislynch, I just don't know. I think it needs to be said, tho, cus no one else has questioned your sudden interest in this game. It's possible, if we're not in MYLO cus Cello never explained the math, you're town trying to bus a partner. I DON'T KNOW. I was trying to look at it from every possible scenario so I wouldn't be blindsided and everyone would know my thoughts. (After all, I've been attacked for lurking...and also only being 'defensive' but now I'm being attacked for sharing my thoughts. Kinda difficult situation.)

When I made that list of people who voted on both wagons, I was stating things about them that could be true and shouldn't be overlooked. Your sudden outburst of activity on d3 is sorta suspicious... suddenly you care a lot? So, yes, isn't it possible you're scum trying to look pro-town to make it through the day?

I also had the opportunity to put McFox at L-1, but voted Circus instead.

Your "I think Xiivi is town...but maybe not..." line of thinking that keeps coming up doesn't match your actual actions at all.

Xiivi
Circus
McFox

What alignment do you think they are without the "It could be X, but maybe it's Y..."? Straight up "town" or "scum" answers.
It's not exactly fair to make me state scum or town, because in my mind it's sometimes "If it's Circus, then maybe Xiivi is town. But if Circus is town, maybe it's Xiivi." That's why the post was very whirlwind thoughts. Like, I wanna say KevinM is scum, but also feel Circus is scummy. Does that make one town and one scum for sure, just cus KevinM is pushing, or did push, a Circus lynch? Maybe Kevinm is trying to bus his partner. :dizzy:

For it to be MYLO there needs to be four scum, correct? Do you think the scum is already on the Circus wagon, or not? Why the hell are you voting Circus if you think I'm scum pushing the 'final' mislynch? I really feel you're just throwing doubt where you can at this point.
I never said "I think Xiivi is scum pushing for a Circus lynch." I said "It's possible."
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
oh god, bussing theorizing before the lynch/flip

they both need to die >_>

I got active 'cause newbie wrapped up and I tend to only go all-out in 1 game at a time. Currently neglecting other games pretty bad. :/
 

Mayling

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Nov 7, 2008
Messages
227
Location
Lexington
oh god, bussing theorizing before the lynch/flip

they both need to die >_>

I got active 'cause newbie wrapped up and I tend to only go all-out in 1 game at a time. Currently neglecting other games pretty bad. :/
Why is a bus theory a bad thing?
 

McFox

Spread the Love
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 9, 2001
Messages
18,783
Location
Visiting from above.
Circus, your appeals to emotion are not helping your case. Neither is it helping anyone else who has felt personally butthurt because this is a frustrating game (and there are several of you). Of course no one likes to get lynched, but when you keep throwing "argh I'm so angry! :mad:", that doesn't make me think you're town.

The problem is that Xiivi is Circus' biggest opponent, and I absolutely do not trust him at all. His game has mirrored frozen's very well, basically coasting and just getting by because they weren't under pressure, and then now in D3 they suddenly have all the answers. Not to mention that they each picked the two easiest people to lynch regardless of alignment: I had my own problems, and Circus has been plagued by a single post from D1 just as much as Kev has.

So the problem I'm having is that I don't trust Xiivi at all and so don't want to follow him, butat the same time, Circus' defenses haven't done much to convince me that he's innocent.

I'll make a decision and post tomorrow.
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
Why is a bus theory a bad thing?
Because we don't actually have Circus's flip & we have all of 5 people on his wagon with a lot of people opposing it. It's just detracting from the wagon itself. >_>

and yeah okay, I'm done, whatever possessed me to write big posts/argue again just got crushed, back to small posts <_<
 

Kataefi

*smoke machine*
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
3,377
Location
igloo
I think Xiivi has this manic reach for Circus I'm feeling uncomfortable about - the fundamental point in his case relates entirely to a breadcrumbing scumtell that looks cloudy to me... I don't like his level of uncertainty here:

At this point when I'm reviewing, I go and reread again only to notice Circus slipped in an Uncap in one of his posts. Ugh. Need to rethink things about other people now, don't want to delete this stuff though.
Could you elaborate the bolded part? Which post are you referring to in particular?

___

*Cue Marshy and Chaco...* Where are you guys?
=(

___


So as much as I see Xiivi pushing for a Circus lynch hard, I see Circus pushing for a hard defence equally as much - AtE, omgus, whatever you wanna call it - I'm feeling uncomfortable with the way they're dealing with this exchange more as a partnership than a genuine "I hate you"/"don't hate me" crossover. Of course, this is all conjecture - I've got rereading to do, but I'd be interested to here
Marshy's and Chaco's thoughts, once in a blue moon :)
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
Could you elaborate the bolded part? Which post are you referring to in particular?
When I said that I didn't think scum was uncapping at that point in time (mainly because who was uncapping had some of my stronger town reads). I had 2 vote counts in that post and changed the colouring if you wish to look at it.
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
kat, specific to you; is this xiivi vs. susa and me just being stupid or is it xiivi&chibo vs. tom? cause it really feels like the second with him pushing right back at me & trying to lynch a person that should be obvtown (cello); but now you're saying it's reachy and i wondering if I'm just doing xiivi vs. susa all over again and just being real stupid.
 

Mayling

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Nov 7, 2008
Messages
227
Location
Lexington
Because we don't actually have Circus's flip & we have all of 5 people on his wagon with a lot of people opposing it. It's just detracting from the wagon itself. >_>

and yeah okay, I'm done, whatever possessed me to write big posts/argue again just got crushed, back to small posts <_<
So you don't like my bus theory because it takes away from your argument? ...

But if your argument is strong enough for a Circus lynch, it should be able to withstand something like a bus theory.
 

Xiivi

So much for friendship huh...
Premium
BRoomer
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Messages
20,342
Location
somewhere near Mt. Ebott
detracting as it isn't something to talk about beforehand + I'm not saying your bus theory breaks anything down + It can just be easily spun around saying "mayling could be bussing Circus right now!" even though I think you are both scummy I'm not trying to think about bussing and am more thinking about who's more likely to flip mafia & why like 1/2 the game doesn't seem to care about lynching and we're going to scramble now

pretty much Xiivi vs. SuSa was Day 1 of Anime Mafia and people were like "Maybe Xiivi is bussing SuSa!" and it was dumb and just resulted in no one actually doing anything except being suspicious of both of us (it was TvT) and then they went and scramble-lynched-town-Air and it was dumb. Scum just kept me alive the whole game saying I was suspicious the whole game because I posted lots/tunnel vs. susa and it was dumb and now it's just happening again. I hate mafia.

and then in newbie we lynched the people who were on the wagons because we were all afraid of bussing even though there were clearly people not on/disapproving of the lynch because we were dumb

I hate being town, I need to be scum more.
 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
rockin at first I liked your post, cus it seemed reasonable and all but this kinda grated me the wrong way. according to cello, he says we're potentially in mylo (tho honestly I STILL don't know the difference between MYLO and LYLO.) that means we really have to make this lynch count, and you saying "i wouldn't mind him going" reflects to me a more d1 lynching attitude, where we have room to breathe.
Okay, I shall explain the MYLO and LYLO situation

LYLO is 'lynch or lose' It basically means that if we eff up on another mislynch, mafia would win that round. Mylo is similar, as it involves into more of how the result of a night action . say if there's 4 townies with 3 mafs and a sk at night. If one maf nks one and sk kills another, the result would show that 2 townies would be left with a sk and 3 mafs, which will mean Maf would win on the following day.

Now then, it's not to say that I have a D1 attitude (then again, this is me really playing compared to D2 where I had to play catch up), but I would lynch Gheb above all others. I feel that he hasn't really done a lot of stuff except just pointed old topics and bullied the inactives D1 and D2. His RESPONSES to said things has NOT helped his case at all, and still hasn't proved otherwise that he's town.

Also Mayling, while I uderstand the worry Cello is showing, I'm not convinced that there's 4 mafs, mainly due to how the deaths have been showing. I believe even ronike second guessed himself on D2 where he thought there was 4, to it actually being three. Until a 4th victim is chosen, I'm going to still believe there's three. Nevertheless, I'm choosing my votes wisely.

Mayling, I would like to ask you a question. Do you see anything scummy about Cello? If not, then why so? I'm just curious.

Xiivi, as I said, I see little reason in a Cirus lynch. If you can tell me why he's scummy without using the HIT breadcrumb, then I may score you a vote on him.
 

#HBC | FrozeηFlame

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 26, 2005
Messages
2,031
Location
Albuquerque, NM
Soooo much scum in this game its out of control. >_<

But yeah, scrambling before the deadline is fukkin awful. Mayling lynch is the safest IMO. Don't think I'd get much out of her as a future clear anyway. Dear god I hope she's fukkin scum and tomorrow I can learn some **** from incaps.

Uncap: Kat since the other two have effectively given up.

Vote: Mayling
 
Top Bottom