Clue:
A controller missing it's springs and a controller having weary springs are two completely different things. Not sure I'd have a problem with replacing them with weaker springs though. Some GC controllers spring's suck.
Integrity of the scene is defined by the players.
Bingo. It's clearly been defined by this small society that a modified controller hurts the integrity of competitive play, and an overwhelming majority agrees. Of course, that doesn't make the majority right, but the burden of proof is on the minority, not us.
I'm surprised out of everyone you're against this Kye.
Why wouldn't I be? I put an obscene amount of time into this game back in the day to acquire my tech skill. I was motivated by my imagination to become the most technical Smash player out there. In my mind, at one point, I succeeded. A dream, constructed out of a single brick, hard work and innovation. The process was just as rewarding as the conclusion. Why would I want to see any other player's talents undermined by controller mods? Why would I want my own talents and hardwork undermined by other players controller mods?
Personally I think I could learn using a controller like the one explained. Kinda like what AR did for my game, watching the execution of certain techs or movements frame by frame helped me in my real time play. The modded controller will teach me how to react and the timing needed. Pressing the triggers all the way down quick is no problem for me. I tend to hold though instead of depressing quick. A controller like that could help me curb that habit.
If it's just a practice method, that's cool, and innovative. I have no qualms with that, as long as it's kept in the home.
Now apply this to highly under emphasized power shielding/parry techs. How can you learn the timing to it (parrying most specifically) when the initial execution is often thwarted cause of an error in how you depress the button? Why wait to learn how to depress consistently when you could learn the techs succeeding it and see if it's even worth your time?
That's where practice comes in. Problem is, people often lack the patience and imagination to see the rewards of practicing mundane things, such as power shielding, which is why techniques like that often never catch on in competitive communities unless someone breaks out with it and shows the benefits -- like Pivoting (which is still way underused). Power Shielding itself isn't even that difficult (I had Parry DOWN at one point), it just requires a dedicated mind.
The smash community is infamous for dismissing ideas until someone comes out shining with it.
The Smash community gets way too much flack from people claiming vantage points they don't actually own.
Edit: Kye have you seen
THIS?
Yeah, I saw it after you Faved it. Did you ever find out which Ganon that was?
-Kimo
(and anyone that thinks being technical is about having fast hands... that's why you're not technical)