Sorry, a bit late to this conversation, but the thing about Mii costumes, “Deluxe” or otherwise, is that they’re characters that weren’t going to get in as a fully playable character, for one reason or another. They’re not going to put in a Geno costume if they want to put Geno in proper, they’re going to put in a Geno costume if they can’t (or they simply don’t want to) put him in.
They’re not saying, “Well, we could put him in, but let’s just make him a Mii costume instead”, they would hypothetically be saying, “Well, if we’re not able to make Geno a fully playable fighter due to [REDACTED], we can at least make him a Mii costume for his fans.” So the “slap in the face” ideology just seems silly to me.
And saying that Geno can’t become a Deluxe costume because he already had a regular one is, well... it’s ironic that this thread of all places is making up fanrules, after what we dealt with pre-Min Min. The only real “evidence” that it can’t happen is that it hasn’t happened yet, which is exactly the same as what the “Spirits deconfirm” crowd had.
I’ve been wanting Geno since 2003 or so. I’d be more than happy with a Deluxe costume. Does that make me a fake fan?
Of course you're not a fake fan. The notion of "fake fan" to start with is silly. All you need to be a fan of something is genuine love for it , nothing more , nothing less.
I think the "slap in the face" mentality is more so linked to how Hero was the perfect opportunity to reveal Geno's mii costume , and ever since then , he avoided every mii wave. Sakurai is very aware of the fan demand for Geno , and he made the mii costume to offer something for the fans.
SE have not refused Sakurai when he asked for the mii costume in Sm4sh , as well as Geno and Mallow's artworks for spirits in the base game of Ultimate. So if we follow that logic , if Nintendo/Sakurai ask for the costume , they don't have any reason to say no , it would generate even more profit for them.
Wich mean that Sakurai didn't asked for the costume for one reason or another , despise giving it the red carpet treatment in Sm4sh , almost treating him like a new fighter.
With Geno avoiding every mii wave since 2019 , being one of the 5 costumes remaining out of like , more than 20... It really make us wonder more and more where he is. So if we wait this long just to get the costume again it would be... Pretty anticlimatic , ngl.
I don't want to defend all the people that offer extreme takes when it come to that , but I admit that getting the costume again , with those circonstances in mind... Would be a bit disapointing for several active supporters.
It doesn't mean that Sakurai and the dev team "hate us and love laughing at our suffering" , not at all , it would mean that they couldn't get the character for X or Y reason , and gave us the costume instead so we still have
something.
In the end , I agree that treating it as a "slap to the face" is silly , rather , it would be anticlimatic for a lot of people.
Personnaly , despise only being a 2 years long supporter , Geno as a character means a lot to me , and he's pretty much the only reason I stick around in the speculation circle. I'm really invested in this character , and his history with Smash is just fascinating to me , there's really no other character with the same situation as him... So his inclusion would feel very special to me. A lot of characters would make me happy (Rayman , Midna , and so on) but I'm fine if they don't make the cut.
In the end , I just don't want to settle with a mii costume for Geno , I personnaly want to see this lil' guy finally make it in after so many years.
However , it's completely fair to not want that and simply want the costume to return , and maybe be upgraded.
---
Anyway , here's some Geno art to lighten up the mood :
There was a problem fetching the tweet