Dark_Ermac
Smash Apprentice
- Joined
- Jun 24, 2007
- Messages
- 104
Don't worry, KevinM, not everyone is that stupid.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
S*** I looked at my PM and I am in a Neighborhood, but it's anonymous, **** I'm a ******I'm not in a neighborhood![]()
Why are you so frustrated? I can see why you would get frustrated with Rei claiming a power role but why are you frustrated with the discussion of neighborhoods? No one is going to claim who is in their neighborhood, for reasons already stated, and us figuring out the fact that there are multiply neighborhoods can help us, as long as we keep certain details under wraps, we should be fine.Really glad to see that we've discussed what I thought was already blatantly obvious as soon as I read my ****in PM.
Also really glad to see that we have power roles claiming on D1.
SWF mafia hasn't changed at all.
Hey guys want to NOT mention who you're in a neighborhood with from now on, or should we gift mafia with exactly how this game works and all the possible connections from the start?
The tracker claim was pretty silly. Regardless, it can be useful.Really glad to see that we've discussed what I thought was already blatantly obvious as soon as I read my ****in PM.
Also really glad to see that we have power roles claiming on D1.
SWF mafia hasn't changed at all.
Agreed on keeping names silent.Hey guys want to NOT mention who you're in a neighborhood with from now on, or should we gift mafia with exactly how this game works and all the possible connections from the start?
Anonymous?S*** I looked at my PM and I am in a Neighborhood, but it's anonymous, **** I'm a ******![]()
I don't like this, no reasoning with the initial vote, and the fact that he DID attempt to pressure Vult, he just switched cause Rei was being more useful.Yes, mainly his hop from Vult to Rei after not really seeing much in Rei. Both Vult and Rei had his 'scummy' gap and he had looked into Vult before the hop. Other reasons being fishing and little things I don't want to mention.
I see. Anonymous as in you don't know names, or don't know roles/alignment?S*** I looked at my PM and I am in a Neighborhood, but it's anonymous, **** I'm a ******
Your strongest point is "little things I don't want to mention". Again, this cloak and dagger stuff doesn't help town. If you have hidden information that gives you a strong lead on someone but can't unveil it at the moment, dropping hints at it is a bad idea. Best case scenario is you have something, mafia knows it, and you die in the Night. Worst case scenario is you don't have anything and end up getting yourself or another townie lynched. Both are stupid.Yes, mainly his hop from Vult to Rei after not really seeing much in Rei. Both Vult and Rei had his 'scummy' gap and he had looked into Vult before the hop. Other reasons being fishing and little things I don't want to mention.
Something's very wrong with this summarization.Vult, you claimed a neighborhood before anyone else, with no pressure, but buckled when it came to the actual details that would support a wagon on Flame. At the time, you considered Flame scum.
As in, information related to the Neighborhood? Role information? What are you asking for?Is there any information I'm missing that would clear you as town, at least in this instance?
The latter.I see. Anonymous as in you don't know names, or don't know roles/alignment?
Your actions are deliberate and friendly, yet inherently unhelpful and lack conviction. I'd like to see you make some concrete statements on players rather than fleeting thoughts.OS: It gives you a strong town read, but at the same time you think I'm scummy? Was this just a typo?
If Mafia ARE in separate neighborhoods, they can claim and we can narrow our search later with more information. This would be the most unfortunate setup for town, but it is out of mafia's control. They either have it or don't.@Overswarm
What prevents Mafia from claiming neighborhood and, if pushed further, asking for neighbor names? Is this just basically like Halloween? Hit every neighborhood till we get the big candy bars (aka Mafia)?
I'm just trying to understand your logic here a little better.
No.Something's very wrong with this summarization.
Reread the thread or read-word it.
I didn't ask for anything specific.As in, information related to the Neighborhood? Role information? What are you asking for?
Overswarm, if you thought it would be useful information for town that the Vult/Frozen neighbourhood was outted, why did you not think that mentioning that there are multiple neighbourhoods not benefit town? Why did you continue to fish after this? Why did Rei's claim make you change your mind about claiming to belong to a neighbourhood?Because it's useful information for town.
It prevents outsiders from interpreting things in a way that results in anti-town actions and helps town recognize connections. The same reason you confirmed yourself to be his neighbor, kinda. -snipped for general idea-
Not that it matters now but some traps can backfire.Would you like me to explain a trap before or after it is sprung?
Seriously can we just lynch Blue Yoshi and get this nonsense over with. Xonar / Sworddancer can die too.I am still sad that Blue Yoshi has a vote on himself.
How does it concern you? Confusing Tracker with other investigators such as Watcher or Cop isn't uncommon among newer players.The fact that you somehow managed to confused Cop and Tracker which are very different is also a bit concerning.
The fact that there ARE such players is bad enough though.Don't worry, KevinM, not everyone is that stupid.
I don't see how that's the case tbh.Anonymous... that seems like an odd way to state you don't know their role/alignment.
Gheb, if I could come up with a scum variation of Gheb (that was actually clever and not just Scum 01 or Gheh 0scum), I would throw that back into your teeth so hard. I can't help that I happen to have one of the easiest to 'scum' names.
Wasn't only the amount of votes that bothered me but also the course of action with two people quickly hopping a wagon. That's a huge shift in momentum for something I call a very minor scumtell (if it's any at all). Unless you can tell me how and why there's a legit argument on -Rei- I'm actually surprised you're OK with people pounding votes on him just like that. Looks like the easy way out of D1 imo.Also couple of things, OS put Rei at L-3 by my count (adumbrodeus, rockin, seph, myself, OS) so I take it you are going off adumbrodeus' count in his #438? Where were you during this time Gheb? You seemed to like miss all the neighbourhood saga. I see nothing wrong with putting a 4th vote on anyone and linking me to it is silly Looks like you're just tossing me in there for no reason, like the amazing FoS you still haven't exactly explained.
I opted to pressure inactives only later on. I was actually on adum most of D1 and he was one of the most vocal players so far.So far Gheb I've gotten from that post "hindsight/parrotofKevinM possiblemistake jokenames lynch inactives you're dumb inactivies one line quotes arcainine" so pretty much avoided mentioning anything related to neighbours and then focused on (almost all) one line quotes regarding Rei's claim. Regardless of your thoughts on the neighbourhood buisness, the information is there now and you could be using it. If you want to go after inactives, why don't you also provide stances on actives at the same time? Or are we only allowed to do things after we lynch the inactives?
I'll answer that once frozen elaborates on what concerns him about the "confusion."Another thing, where have you seen new players mistake tracker for cop Gheb?
Click on the post number to the right of the thread name when you're looking at the forum.Sorry for going off-topic, but...
Also, Overswarm, how do you get a list of how many times people have posted in a thread?
http://www.smashboards.com/showthread.php?p=10267981#post10267981
This could be useful for me modding the 64 boards at times... so it's not only for mafia purposes...
Anyways, can you also answer the question in my last post as well?
I'm on 40 posts per page; please link to individual posts. I don't have a page 15.Well, I'll wait until I finish reading everything before I post who I find suspicious... but... well...
http://www.smashboards.com/showthrea...274625&page=15
Overswarm's 220 and 221
Overswarm... why did you ask that? I don't see how that helps in this game. If you saw my thing saying "currently viewing Smash 64 Discussion" or something... would you find me scummy? Some people do more than play mafia games on smashboards... don't see how this question is relevant at all to anything...
Can you explain?
I haven't read past 221... so you may have already asked that.
I did think it was useful information. That's why I persued that line of thought, and why we are where we are now.Overswarm, if you thought it would be useful information for town that the Vult/Frozen neighbourhood was outted, why did you not think that mentioning that there are multiple neighbourhoods not benefit town? Why did you continue to fish after this? Why did Rei's claim make you change your mind about claiming to belong to a neighbourhood?
I was reading that too. Should be helpful.Everyone, it's actually a really interesting read between the people claiming to be neighbours with 'x' and the phase where Vult was under pressure 3-6 pages or so in. I'm going to be reading it myself at a better time and I'll put up some stuff I find interesting later but for now I have a tutorial to make
Cool story, bro.Scummoner and Overscum just pounding two votes on Rei to put him @L-2 was either incredibly stupid or blatant scum. You guys seriously want to lynch Rei over Blue Yoshiscum, Scumeta-Kirby, Scumdancer, Scumnar et all? This day is going completely in the wrong direction. Take a step back and quit being dumb.
The same reason no one else claimed, I'd imagine. I had a strong suspicion that everyone was in a neighborhood, but needed it confirmed.The main question I wanted answered in that bunch of questions OS was "Why did Rei's claim make you change your mind about claiming to belong to a neighbourhood?" and I want to also add "Why didn't you claim that when Vult first claimed it?"
Why should there be an exception though? Since allignments and roles aren't confirmed within the neighborhood it's possible for all mafiosi to be in some neighborhood.The same reason no one else claimed, I'd imagine. I had a strong suspicion that everyone was in a neighborhood, but needed it confirmed.
Rei's claim, along with others, made it an obvious choice to claim. Anyone that avoids saying "I'm in a neighborhood" is gonna have to explain why. If Mafia isn't in a neighborhood and everyone else is, mafia would have to claim neighborhood to not stick out like a sore thumb.... and that's group them together. If mafia is and there are three mafia, they know of three separate neighborhoods to begin with, with anywhere from 3-9 townies involved.
Now that it's confirmed there are many neighborhoods, we need to see if there's an exception. This information won't help now, but if one of the exception flips over mafia later, it'll help a lot.
1.) What would you learn of me being in a neighborhood? Should be fairly obvious by now that everybody is in a neighborhood.
Same @ BY comment.2.) Only 3?
Well I was (and still am) suspicious of Adum for his selective pseudoscumhunting. Lacking credibility anyway you look at it imo. Sworddancer has posted 99% Wishy-wash and Meta-Kirby for playing exactly like he did in Pokémafia and Scumwars (zomg Metagaming!).
But my vote stays on BY until he posts something that actually has content. Wouldn't mind more ppl pressuring him.
3.) Said at least 3 times that I think Vult's town. Skim moar.
I think it's pretty obvious I don't skim.
I'm unaware if there are exceptions, as I'm not one. It'd be helpful to know if there are exceptions because, depending on how jungle made the game, he may have accidentally left a giant neon sign pointing at all the mafia members.Why should there be an exception though? Since allignments and roles aren't confirmed within the neighborhood it's possible for all mafiosi to be in some neighborhood.
![]()
Apparently it wasn't hard to break DBZ mafia. Twice. So who knows?Heh, I highly doubt that with Xiivi as the co-designer. Know him well enough he wouldn't do that.
![]()
I'm thorough. Knowing just my own neighborhood and vult/ff's existed could have still meant neighborhoods were special. I needed to know how far it went.Well, if you had a strong suspicion that there was AND you were in a neighbourhood AND you knew someone else was in a neighbourhood(Vult and Frozen) your output was still nothing on that front but you needed: strong suspicion AND your neighbourhood AND Vult's AND Rei's to act on it. Seems a little overkill fro mwhat I was expected from you(I'm not quite sure why this is, I just did)
This doesn't make sense. First you wanted us to call attention to Rei and his habbits, now you're cautioning us on accidental hammer? Hm.Stop voting Rei, don't want an accidental hammer.
Yeah, way to fail >=/S*** I looked at my PM and I am in a Neighborhood, but it's anonymous, **** I'm a ******![]()
This doesn't make sense. First you wanted us to call attention to Rei and his habbits, now you're cautioning us on accidental hammer? Hm.
FoS: Seph