TL;DR version: I have trouble aiming the TAR at long range.
I don't have trouble aiming anything at long range (Ironically, it's the reverse). The TAR just requires practically an entire clip in order to really do well at that range. A 30 round, high power, stopping power boosted, clip. The SCAR May only dump half a clip at that range. A 20 round, high power, hardline, clip. See the difference?
Why is this unfair?
BECAUSE IT IS ESSENTIALLY TRYING TO COMPARE A SNIPER RIFLE TO AN SMG! (If you do, seriously, don't compare anything.) They are suited for a particular environment (SCAR Mid-long, TAR Close-Mid), and can only intrude on the other's "turf" with some capacity. Similar comparisons can be made with the Power snipers. The Intervention is better as a true sniper, while the Barrett has a more close up "Marksman" role. The Barrett CAN be used as a true sniper, but it's recoil throws off the aim too severely, and the semi-auto nature is ironically detrimental. The inverse is also true, but the sluggish RoF hinders the Intervention's capacity to do much close up. More on that when I get to it.
The bolded isn't true. The AK and TAR have similar levels of recoil, but TARs is more vertical, making it more manageable. Also, attachments add sway to the AK, making it kind of a useless gun.
A: You got it backwards, the AK has vertical recoil while the TAR is all over the place.
B: All sights add sway to the AK, but why the **** are you using sights on the AK?
C: I have used all three Heavy ARs for some time. The SCAR has a recoil a bit above the M4 (barely). The AK starts low, but gradually grows more severe. The TAR starts steady, before relatively quickly jumping all over the place.
As for the italics, who decided that? Power is huge for guns given how many standoffs there are in this game. The TAR with SP kills in 3 shots at any range, where recoil isn't going to matter. If you can't hit a target with 3 shots, you need to work on your aim.
A: The general public that's who! In case you notice, the most popular ARs are the ACR, SCAR, and M16. All are well known for their accuracy and sans the M16 (which is the least accurate of it's group, but still ****ing accurate), the most accurate of their weapons type.
B: The SCAR can also 3 hit at any range with stopping power, and you effectively contradicted yourself.
"the SCAR is better, well, sans the clip-size"
Yes exactly, this is what is going to ruin you anywhere at close range. The SCAR basically limits you to long distance because of this reason, as you can't risk taking it into CQC with that small of a clip. Either that or you waste an attachment on ext. mags, which could be much better used elsewhere.
Mid-Long, and yeah you can, and no you don't need to (I use a heartbeat sensor)
Bottom line, if you can aim and manage recoil, use the TAR. If you can't, well I'd still recommend using the TAR so you learn, but use the SCAR if you don't want to deal. There's a reason the TAR is in the top 3 guns used in GB whereas the SCAR wasn't even on the list.
What is this list that you speak of? No seriously, where is this list? I kinda want to know what some people use.