With all due respect to Shaya, that post was incorrect.
In regards to the combo actually being a thing, I had written
this up to explicitly mention most of the true combos associated with Up Throw and Thunder. It outlines how to test the combo out yourself as well as proof that the method is valid. (You just need to read the sections titled “Proving Up Throw to Turnaround Thunder is True” and “Clearing a Misunderstanding Related to the Method of Testing”. There’s also an Aside that talks about some interesting general-Smash quirk you’ve probably experienced but never noticed.) You wouldn’t believe how many times when conversing in various Smash outlets that that post has been mentioned. That’s why I wrote that document.
So yes, the combo is a thing. It’s true on DI read. I assure you that nothing was debunked. You can see it for yourself. When Up Throw to Thunder was first brought up here, it felt like the discussion was just about whether or not it was actually a thing. More valuable discussion would’ve been on the pros and cons of the combo. But that kind of discussion didn’t seem like it was going to happen. Oh well, at least there are places where that kind of conversation can actually happen.
With that, I bid you all adieu.