DuDu- I kind of agree, but I feel like I'm just BARELY at the level I feel comfortable enough giving people advice. The way I see it, I take advice from players who place high and who I feel have not only LEARNED about high level play, but have experienced it. As such, I wouldn't want to give advice to anyone if I'm not in that same position.
But, I will LISTEN to advice from anyone. It's just, I wouldn't want some people sitting there giving me constant advice if they're not in the position I'd like to be in.
Maybe it's just cuz I have a lot of respect for Melee itself. Players who are amazing and who have gone through a lot to get to where they are, I have an immense amount of respect for and I'll gladly listen to them.
Players who are good but not that good it's like...You probably just think you're way better than you are, and most of the time it's right, they're just too blind to see it for how it is, and you gotta ask yourself, "Is that the person I want to be learning from? Is that where I want to be as a player?" And then you seek higher, or put things together on your own.
To be fair, advice from anyone CAN be good. It's the advice itself that you need to be worried about. Just so happens that most advice given from a bad player is probably gonna be bad. Sometimes I test it though anyways just in case.