Makoto is alright. I like her as a character.
But for me? I went with Ann as my romance. Not only do I like her character development, but that... goddamn giggle. She's cute.
It's weird saying that as a teacher. But frankly the context of the game being played by adults who would likely look back at their own high school years makes it feel not that weird. Even funnier is the fact that I have had absolutely no intention of romancing any of the adults. Y I K E S.
To me, Futaba is just like, too much of a younger sister type vibe? Haven't had enough time to hang out with Haru but...eh. Still Ann for me. Also, I must say that the engagement with this game is so high for me that I don't think I'd be able to call myself a good person if I went with the "harem" romance result. I would feel like such a crappy person in the real world that I just don't think I could do it.
Maybe I'm weird. Or maybe that's just what happens when you play your first Persona game?