wow okay... lots of posts...
i'm very confused by what you've just said heat =? so you made an analysis on mayling knowing you didn't have enough information to find her scummy?...you gave information - so we can conclude such reads aren't stances so much as they are you presenting empty information for others to soak up. This statement is relevant because you didn't feel she had enough against her to make her scummy, so if this info you presented wasn't believable to you (which implies a possibility you considered her town), why did you spend time on her analysis, why couldn't you have read a suspect instead? importantly why did you present this information to begin with to 'make her scummy'? especially at the end of the Day? please answer my questions!
No, it was information, and she is scummy to sorts, but generally speaking I look at everyone from a "if they were scum" perspective in my re-reads. I have no reason to read them "as they were town" because it makes me miss the bigger picture, finding scum. Therefore, every re-read will be on things that make someone "scummy" in my eyes.
I did an analysis because I didn't like how she posted at all. Hence why I found her scummy. Her pointless one-liners, among other things (read: my re-read on her). However it wasn't enough to seal the deal.
She was in fact, a suspect, after a re-read I didn't have that problem with her (for now).
That being known, my post is going to make her look scummy to the fullest of my ability, even with that, I didn't have much against her, however SummonerAU reeked of it to me.
I'll do a reread of d2 and see where I stand then. 
