• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Tier List Speculation

Fly_Amanita

Master of Caribou
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
4,224
Location
Claremont, CA
1) You slowly encroach upon their space. It's obnoxious and takes a while, but DDD is generally able to do it. Still admittedly one of his bigger weaknesses, though.

2) Roll backwards, or just do a better job at keeping the opponent out. Also, DI better.

3) Dodge the leg.
 

bubbaking

Smash Hero
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
6,895
Location
Baldwin, NY, USA or Alexandria, VA, USA (Pick one)
1) Alright, fair enough. I main DDD in vBrawl, so I can definitely understand this strategy.

2) DDD's attack speed doesn't seem conducive to keeping the opponent out, though. I understand air camping may help a bit, but it also seems to me that chars like the spacees, Sheik, Lucario, etc could really hurt DDD once they get under him.

3) You can't dodge the leg during upB, which you'll be using if you're out of jumps, which the opponent will cause by pressuring your recovery. I'm not talking about lazy sex kicks done a million feet in the air. I'm talking about sex kicks done right above the ledge or even offstage to directly intercept the path you have to take to recover.

Granted, I have DDD in Mid Tier with all the other Mid Tier chars. I'm not like the others who are grouping him in a whole different tier at the bottom with G&W, Ness, ROB, and whoever else people seem to think are really bad for some reason.
 

Fly_Amanita

Master of Caribou
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
4,224
Location
Claremont, CA
DDD has a few reasonably fast attacks to counter approaches. As far as ground options go, dtilt, down-B, and ftilt all have a decent enough mix of speed and reach to be good at keeping people out. Pivot grab is reasonable against characters without a great deal of reach. Air walling is fine in some match-ups and not so great in others; it varies by the other character.

Also, your bit about the sex kicks is actually false. I'll leave it as an exercise to you to see why.
 

Yonder

Smashboard's 1st Sole Survivor
Joined
Oct 9, 2007
Messages
3,549
Location
Canada,BC
NNID
Skullicide
3DS FC
4055-4053-1813
So the top 2 characters in Melee are still the top 2 in this game?

:/.

Glad to see Ganondorf up there fairly high though!

Dunno what happened to Luigi on the other hand...and Dedede.
 

bubbaking

Smash Hero
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
6,895
Location
Baldwin, NY, USA or Alexandria, VA, USA (Pick one)
I don't see it as false when I personally have done it to DDD several times (shut up Drinking, I'm not theorycrafting :glare:). Example: Sheik. Needle him, bair him, force him to use up his meager three midair jumps (which he'll probably have used up offstage anyway if he was knocked away a decent distance 'cause his aerial mobility kinda sucks), and then nair above where he has to upB. I've done it to Guru, I've done it to 9k, and I've done it to my personal friends whenever they play DDD, and I've done it with more chars than just Sheik. Mario, Lucario, they all do the job pretty well. If DDD can't make it up to or past the ledge, then he can't recover. If he's knocked a decent enough distance away from the stage without his jumps, then he's dead. Personally, my friends and I think he needs some form of armor on his upB like he had in vBrawl (he had SA then, on top of an additional jump) because this problem is so bad.

Edit: I can definitely agree that dtilt and downB are probably good ways of keeping the opponent out on the ground, but I'm not so sure about ftilt. That move is pretty unsafe on shields. All it takes is the opponent to start WDing OoS for him to punish ftilt. WDing OoS is actually something that I don't see enough people using. It makes a lot of DDD's junk really unsafe. If DDD ftilts you, you can turn it into a WD OoS > grab.
 

DMG

Smash Legend
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
18,958
Location
Waco
Slippi.gg
DMG#931
Sheik isn't a fair example. She seems like a lame MU for D3
 

bubbaking

Smash Hero
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
6,895
Location
Baldwin, NY, USA or Alexandria, VA, USA (Pick one)
Lucario is pretty lame too, but what about my Mario example? :p

In fact, Mario can just use nair or bair, whichever one works best. On walled stages like DC, I like to go really far out there to gimp with bair and then just use the walls to come back.

I really don't understand why one of his jumps and his upB SA was removed. He really needed them, imo.
 

KayB

Smash Master
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 2, 2013
Messages
3,977
Location
Seoul, South Korea
Can you justify bowser being 7th?
Extremely good at gimping (especially against fast fallers), great horizontal recovery, great Oos options, great kill power (and good combos), good grab game (including koopa claw), has flame cancelling that can stop approach, has super armor, generally difficult to edgeguard imo, and he completely destroys everybody in smaller stages. He might not be seventh, but he's definitely top tier.

Man, I hate when Squirtle gets put that low.
I don't think he's a bad character, I just think generally a lot more characters have better tools than he has. Admittedly I don't main Squirtle nor have I seen top level play of him, so that might have something to do with it. Again, he's not bad. Technically, I still put him in mid-tier.

I play D3 get @ me tire wohres

No but for real is he THAT bad?

We discussed earlier but I am I just missing how ****ed he is in most MU's?

:C
He's not terrible, but he isn't very good either. If someone is willing to prove me otherwise...

I really don't understand why one of his jumps and his upB SA was removed. He really needed them, imo.
I'm pretty sure everybody who's ever used him feels this way.
 

bubbaking

Smash Hero
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
6,895
Location
Baldwin, NY, USA or Alexandria, VA, USA (Pick one)
I used to secondary him in 2.1. Then I dropped him when I realized that I was trying to be a spacee. :laugh:

Real talk, he gets combo'd to living hell, just like a spacee, except he doesn't have the tools of one, so it's a little frustrating. Also, because he's lighter (and falls a bit slower) he also gets CG'd pretty hard too. I know in 2.1, Ness could easily CG him and then end the CG with guaranteed follow-ups. Don't know if that's changed in 2.5, but I doubt it.
 

DMG

Smash Legend
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
18,958
Location
Waco
Slippi.gg
DMG#931
Ganon CG on Lucas is like, Jesus sunbeaming down at me, smiling cause he loves me
 

Deus

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
283
Location
Portland, OR
I definitely like the look of your tier list bubba king. Seems the most accurate IMO. One thing I would change is Rob's placement to be a little higher, just seen some nasty stuff with him against high tiers.

Also I wish Lucas was higher but, for the time being he really can't get past some of his weaknesses unfortunately. *sigh*

*Edit* Also saw someone saying how bad Falco's upB is... Isn't it better in P:M because the start up has flame damage as well, where in melee it did not. Or am I going crazy?
 

traffic.

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Sep 1, 2012
Messages
427
No particular hierarchy within tiers, with a few I just dont know enough about to place/really dont care about playing to put on a tier list.

S Tier
:fox: :falco: :sheik: :marth:

A Tier
:peach: :diddy: :mario2: :bowser2: :falcon: :zerosuitsamus:

B Tier
:snake: :lucario: :link2: :jigglypuff: :squirtle: :ike:

C Tier
:zelda: :lucas: :rob: :pit: :wolf:

D Tier
:charizard: :luigi2: :ivysaur: :pikachu2: :ness2: :toonlink:

Insufficient Data Tier
:dedede: :sonic: :dk2: :ganondorf: :wario:

G&W Tier
:awesome:
 

Vashimus

Smash Master
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
3,308
Location
Newark, NJ
It seems like ZSS and Squirtle are either put really high on people's lists, or really low. I can't tell if it's experience (or lack thereof) or bias that comes into play there. Kinda like Wario.

:phone:
 

Translucent

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
354
I love that Squirtle is so high traffic, mad props :). I don't think he is quite that high though, but it would be awesome if he is. I also think Wario needs to be pushed up quite a bit in your list.
 

iLink

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Messages
2,075
Location
NorCal
I decided to give this a shot. I kind of tried to order the characters in their respective tier but even I think some of their placement is rather sketchy. I really didn't know how to handle ZSS and Squirtle. I also think a few characters have some unearthed potency that hasn't been fully brought to light, for example I was tempted to place Sonic higher but I think I need to see a little more of him. Squirtle could also be a ***** I think.

S Tier
Falco
Fox
Sheik
Peach
Mario
Jigglypuff

A Tier
Marth
Lucario
Wolf
Diddy
Ike
Link
Wario
Snake
Pikachu
Sonic

B Tier
Pit
Lucas
Captain Falcon
Ganon
Squirtle
ZSS
DK
Charizard
DDD
Toon Link

C tier
Ness
Luigi
Game & Watch
Zelda
ROB
Bowser
Ivysaur
 

KayB

Smash Master
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 2, 2013
Messages
3,977
Location
Seoul, South Korea
G&W may not be a great character, but holy **** he's not so bad that he's in his own tier.

And does anybody else agree with me in that Luigi's one of the worst characters in the game?
 

Mr.Pickle

Smash Lord
Joined
Apr 23, 2009
Messages
1,208
Location
on a reservation
Awesome Sauce Tier
Fox
Falco
Jigglypuff
Shiek
Peach
Marth

Really Good Tier
Diddy
Wolf
Sonic
Lucas
Lucario
Zelda
Ike
Mario
Bowser
Pikachu

Pretty Good Tier
Wario
Ganon
Charizard
Captain Falcon
Pit
Dk
Squitle
Link
Snake
DDD

Decent tier
Rob
Luigi
Game & Watch
Ivysaur
Zss
Toon Link
Ness

I put a little thought into this, but I didn't spend the whole day thinking about it lol. So constructive criticism is welcome, but if your post reads something, "blargh x character is to low or high, you're an idot", well you can just eat a bag of ****s :glare:.
 

TheTTimeLives

Smash Cadet
Joined
Jan 24, 2011
Messages
58
Location
Orlando, FL
EDIT: Changed G&W and Toon Link

Wud up guys. Had an account back in the brawl days but figured I'd reactivate since I'm stopping by the boards so frequently for the latest on P:M

No particular order within tiers.

A:
Fox
Falco
Ivysaur
Marth
Sonic
Mario
Shiek
Peach


B:
Captain Falcon
Wolf
Ganondorf
DeDeDe
Snake
Lucas
Ike
Charizard
Pikachu
ZSS
G&W

C:
Ness
Bowser
Wario
Pit
Diddy Kong
Donkey Kong
Link
Toon Link
Jiggylypuff
Lucario
ROB
Zelda

D:

Squirtle


Butt:
Luigi

( I dunno maybe he's the best character in the game but I've never been successful with his terrible fast fall, crappy defensive options and hard to control wavedash. Misfire control is cool though )

It's good to be posting again.
 

traffic.

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Sep 1, 2012
Messages
427
It seems like ZSS and Squirtle are either put really high on people's lists, or really low. I can't tell if it's experience (or lack thereof) or bias that comes into play there. Kinda like Wario.
I'd say it has mostly to do with the amount of time practising against high tier matchups. With the lack of widespread results at this point it's hard to establish any kind of general placement, so the variety of lists really supports the individual's strongest toons. My squirtle is hardly refined to the level of my sheik or bowser, but as I'm learning to control him a lot more, the level of janks has really proven effective in a lot of situations. I die in a lot of silly ways, but that has everything more to do with poor execution than squirtle being bad.

With characters that aren't as widely played, the personal bias will always effect higher placement, but it's specifically the people that play a character well that have an idea of where a character should be in relation to the framework of established toons.

Translucent said:
I also think Wario needs to be pushed up quite a bit in your list.
Insufficient data implies that I don't know enough about them to place them anywhere appropriately. I might as well just put D3, Sonic, and G&W in the "I really hate them and no one I know plays them at all ever" tier. I am basing this off of personal experience, which unfortunately is based off of the results of only a few consistent opponents for the time being, we are just pretty adept gamers with a solid base of game experience experimenting with the cast in order to find who really suits our respective playstyles.
 

Archangel

Smash Hero
Joined
Dec 4, 2008
Messages
6,453
Location
Wilmington, Delaware
NNID
combat22386
I think the main issue with luigi is he's an improved version of his melee self but if you couldn't use him well in melee you won't be able to use him well at all in PM. Unlike characters like Bowser, Zelda and DK he hasn't been tweaked to play easier. He plays better. So his low rank to me I feel is starting to reflect his difficulty instead of his Viability.
 

bubbaking

Smash Hero
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
6,895
Location
Baldwin, NY, USA or Alexandria, VA, USA (Pick one)
What the heck? Luigi isn't that difficult to play at all. You just have to get used to staying grounded instead of SHFFLing all the time. As a Samus main, that's child's play. Luigi is one of my favorite characters to play around with. As such, I could say he's one of my 'more serious' characters. I'm talking from experience when I say that I don't think he's as good as most of the cast, but I also have everyone except for G&W in at least Mid Tier, so that isn't too bad.
 

DMG

Smash Legend
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
18,958
Location
Waco
Slippi.gg
DMG#931
Luigi has frustrating... moments I guess is the way to put it. Some characters have lame MU's, or you gotta deal with some lame disadvantage like having no range. But Luigi I feel like has to jank it up in terms of general mechanics. The amount of work you have to do with shield and WDing is insane I feel like.
 
Top Bottom