The North Carolina Melee Power Rankings! Updated 8/14/14!

[-ACE-]

I was providing an example Kev. I made it clear in that post where I draw the line.

 

[Sneak8288]

and my post wasn't saying what will happen... but what should happen imo and are just ideas for the future.

in response to kevin

 

[Dr Peepee]

Sorry I was trying to respond to everything quickly. I expected the flood to keep coming LOL. <3 sneak

@Ace: Yeah I feel you. I'd prefer to have much more NC-only tourneys but we can't deny that OOS is coming to most of ours unless we start hosting more non-G6 things so that has to be a big part of our procedure for now unfortunately.

 

[Sneak8288]

maybe we can have tournaments specifically for rankings or maybe even round robins for rankings data or something like that especially for the smaller tournaments

 

[Mariabattleaxe]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2xWfEoFSlFU&feature=player_embedded#at=14

 

[Dr Peepee]

maybe we can have tournaments specifically for rankings or maybe even round robins for rankings data or something like that especially for the smaller tournaments

I'd be down lol. The trick is getting TOs to implement this stuff not saying it here. XD

 

[Sneak8288]

which is why i said TOs need to step it up!

 

[Juno McGrath]

What do you guys need me to do

*Takes sunglasses off*

 

[Mariabattleaxe]

See, I have been thinking about hosting again. With the full venue, or maybe a different one.
I just really hate hosting tournaments for NC.

I can provide a venue, etc... IF someone wants to host FOR me. I will front the money and everything.
But I am NOT busting my *** for NC ever again looool <3
Take that as you will.


Except for the brawl community.

 

[Sneak8288]

What do you guys need me to do

*Takes sunglasses off*

Makes sure matches get played asap and disqualify who doesn't listen or who is playing friendlies when they shouldn't and seriously disqualify them if they don't listen so we have enough time to do othings like pools or round robins or something like that

 

[-ACE-]

@Ace: Yeah I feel you. I'd prefer to have much more NC-only tourneys but we can't deny that OOS is coming to most of ours unless we start hosting more non-G6 things so that has to be a big part of our procedure for now unfortunately.

I don't see why you should prefer NC-only tourneys over tourneys that include people from OOS. The smash scene isn't supposed to molded to make it easy for the PR panelists; the panelists are supposed to be knowledgeable enough (familiar with not only our scene but other scenes within our region, as well as VA's scenes... again, this is where having more panelists helps) and unbiased enough to decide how much certain wins and losses to players from OOS are. There is nothing unfortunate about G6 being a big portion of the procedure to me. Snap stepping up is great. The fact that OOS players are willing to come to those events is effin awesome. I'm sure other people will step up soon as well, but in the meantime we should be thankful for what we have.

 

[Juno McGrath]

Makes sure matches get played asap and disqualify who doesn't listen or who is playing friendlies when they shouldn't and seriously disqualify them if they don't listen so we have enough time to do othings like pools or round robins or something like that

Pools are confirmed for G6 3

 

[Dr Peepee]

I don't see why you should prefer NC-only tourneys over tourneys that include people from OOS. The smash scene isn't supposed to molded to make it easy for the PR panelists; the panelists are supposed to be knowledgeable enough (familiar with not only our scene but other scenes within our region, as well as VA's scenes... again, this is where having more panelists helps) and unbiased enough to decide how much certain wins and losses to players from OOS are. There is nothing unfortunate about G6 being a big portion of the procedure to me. Snap stepping up is great. The fact that OOS players are willing to come to those events is effin awesome. I'm sure other people will step up soon as well, but in the meantime we should be thankful for what we have.

<.<

Okay yes those things are great but then don't complain when we have a lot of OOS and somewhat inui logic'ing to do. The panel is just working with what we have. It's unfortunate because it makes people unhappy and think we're not doing our job but I like having OOS at our tournaments obviously lol.

 

[Dark Hart]

yaaaaaaaaaaaay

 

[-ACE-]

<.<

Okay yes those things are great but then don't complain when we have a lot of OOS and somewhat inui logic'ing to do. The panel is just working with what we have. It's unfortunate because it makes people unhappy and think we're not doing our job but I like having OOS at our tournaments obviously lol.

You don't need the inui logic, that's my point. It's good that you have 3 panelists now, but I think you could use 4. Panelists should decide how important a win vs someone from OOS is, for reasons I listed in my previous post. There is too much gray area when I see something like, josh beat theo when theo was sick but theo beat adam when adam hadn't slept in 68 hours... So josh's win over theo is OMG HUGE. A win is a win, but when you carry it over to include who the next person beat it get's ******** imo.

 

[stingers]

dont worry guys
ill be the 4th panelist

 

[lord karn]

You don't need the inui logic, that's my point. It's good that you have 3 panelists now, but I think you could use 4. Panelists should decide how important a win vs someone from OOS is, for reasons I listed in my previous post. There is too much gray area when I see something like, josh beat theo when theo was sick but theo beat adam when adam hadn't slept in 68 hours... So josh's win over theo is OMG HUGE. A win is a win, but when you carry it over to include who the next person beat it get's ******** imo.

Wait. . . you just used Inui logic. @__@ Judging how important a certain win is because of who they beat or lost to is Inui logic. Bad Inui logic is saying A > C becasue A > D and D > C while ignoring that C > A. Just gotta think about all results.

And Theo didn't beat Adam this period.

 

[-ACE-]

Lol Alex, I didn't use Inui logic. I made fun of your use of it, AGAIN.

And are you just trolling? because if so, you're a damn good troll, but just in case: OF COURSE THEO DIDN'T BEAT ADAM THIS PERIOD. I WAS PROVIDING AN EXAMPLE WTF a;lfjafjaf

 

[lord karn]

lol, i'm dumb

 

[Lightsyde]

Have we not taken Sneak on in an attempt to get your opinions back here? Calm down.

You got to the argument after everybody had already chilled. haha YOU calm down, girl.

But really though

and

 

[TheLastCacely]

No..... I will be panelist.

 

[TheLastCacely]

did kevin basically just say that the only reason sneaks on the panel, was to bring diversity among race? lmao

 

[mr.fizwidget]

does the pr only look at set counts?

or is a 2-1 win worse than a 2-0?

 

[lord karn]

we don't currently consider 2-1 any worse than 2-0. I guess that's something up for discussion, though

 

[Ocean]

characters are more important than set count in my opinion, so I would start looking at that first.

 

[stingers]

characters are never important
ever

go back to cooking ocean

 

[Ocean]

i will ejaculate in your food

 

[MacD]

can't wait

 

[Ocean]

DF;WQORWARIPWJFKL;WEURKL;P


GOD DAMMIT MCCAIN

 

[MacD]

love you too ocean!!!!!!

 

[Dark Hart]

wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooow

 

[Ocean]

i have no words

 

[mr.fizwidget]

jesus ****





f

 

[Mariabattleaxe]

macdaddy <3
oh boy

 

[0Room]

So as a quick summary

We now have 3 panelists
$5+mm can now [maybe] count as a tournament match
Inui logic is bad


Anything else

 

[*P*L*U*R*]

characters are more important than set count in my opinion, so I would start looking at that first.

characters are never important
ever

go back to cooking ocean

i will ejaculate in your food

can't wait

DF;WQORWARIPWJFKL;WEURKL;P


GOD DAMMIT MCCAIN

love you too ocean!!!!!!

wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooow

i have no words

jesus ****





f

macdaddy <3
oh boy

hnpy8usphnuid;;di;rdoonjup9iidoz;jngifpgujipgsodojgofjkpspuiojhrndojnhgrsiupeojgu9posj9pug9ojfoijkps\


OH MY ****ING GOD

I CAN'T BREATHE

 

[Sneak8288]

I think chars should definitely matter to a certain extent. Beating Yays link shouldn't count as much as beating Yays fox. You can kinda compare that to ali beating cyrains sheik as opposed to his fox

 

[Bl@ckChris]

don't you mean shouldn't count?

cause i do plan on taking a few mm's with my fox, and i might even challenge some people with my falcon lol. but i don't really want that to work against my ganon's tournament deal.

i just want my secondaries to make me a little cash lol.

 

[stingers]

beating yays young link
in tournament
counts 100%
no johns

 

[Sneak8288]

yea i meant shouldn't