It's actually really good for stuffing air approaches, and following up juggles. If you get in the habit of tossing an egg up every time your opponent is above you, you start controlling how they land, and it makes continuing the juggle that much easier.
It's good if you know 100% it's going to hit, otherwise you've made yourself a non-moving target who has gained 0 stage control, and most likely gave your opponent a free landing. Instead you could dashdance under them, threatening a dash/pivot grab their landing, or some
good anti-air moves (unlike eggs) like uair and rising bair.
P:M Yoshi is kinda sorta similar to brawl Yoshi after all, which confuses me when people never think about a simple jump OoS and DJC nair to hit people or just now finding out how good Bair is.
His Egg roll has less priority, Bair is still good to use, Dair is sometimes good to use when somebody falls on a platform, and eggs (while also not breaking until they hit something) became better since we can angle it behind us and create a wall with the eggs. Hell I was still messing around trying to find ways during that tournament to make eggs better, and in that video against link there was 2 or 3 occasions it set up for something.
Cause honestly, if anybody thinks Eggs are not good they should probably stop playing Yoshi cause that's basically all he was in Brawl and P:M is just Brawl 2.0 with melee physics thrown back in there.
Also, one of the more notable changes is the fact Down throw sets itself up against most of the cast compared to Brawl just being grab release.
Dude Idk what to say man... PM yoshi is not like brawl yoshi. He's like melee yoshi with some brawl hitboxes and a buffed sideB. Anyways since I feel strongly about this I am gonna go through the times egg toss "set up for something"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3j3a1Ej1cE#t=128 - here is a clear case of the link ****ing up. This egg toss was actually pretty bad, and he easily could have upBd you, likely killing you. Lucky for you he didn't react and got punished
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3j3a1Ej1cE#t=284 - this is actually pretty cool, but again it was a result of him being kind of dumb. Jumping and pulling a bomb towards you is a really bad option for link. Also the thing is, if you chose a better option like usmash, bair or uair, you would've gotten a way harder punish, however instead you chose that laggy egg throw and got minimal % for it. Egg toss commits you so hard to a not-so-great option, I don't see how you can defend it :/
Anyways I guess that's it. You got some stray egg toss hits, which were probably the only good times you used it. I am not saying egg toss is never a good option... Sometimes your opponent will try camping or putting themselves on the platform where you can't easily access them, so a egg toss to force a shield into a pressuring follow-up (even as simple as putting yourself beneath them) can be really good. Also I kinda liked your egg tosses before recovery, but at the same time it seems like they unnecessarily limit your options. Again it
commits you to something i.e., recovering low. Recovering low is good sometimes, but you pretty much always did, and lucky for you, you didn't really get punished for it. I think the link could've thrown out some upBs to stuff you really hard on a few occasions, but I think he was needlessly scared of the egg tosses. The thing about them is that they don't cover any space you were be jumping towards, since they leave the active space before you reach it, so players can just wait for you to do it and punish your predictable recovery.
Yo man sorry for calling you out, but like you said I shouldn't play yoshi anymore, and that hurts. I think a lot about this game and yoshi's options, and I think he has incredibly potential in this game (he DESTROYS floaties and tether recoveries), but none of that potential, imo, can be attributed to egg toss. When I look at the buff on egg toss it screams off stage pressure, since it can hit people who want to sweet spot by going low, and that's how I mostly use it (not the only way mind you).