Here are my exact notes on all the posts which I find the case on Kirbyoshi ever-growing. I took notes in a word Document and they are found in the spoiler
[Collapse=Notes on Kirbyo's Posts]Post 12 – Stupid post.
Post 22 – Leading town to believe that there are ONLY two set ups.
Post 35- brings up a point about Pokemon being “harder” to catch, inside information on the Trainer’s part?
Post 117- Hops on the Swords Wagon for a contradiction, parroting, saying “Obvtrainer is obvious” when little spec has been put into it.
Post 119- Asserts firm belief that Xonar didn’t slip and is the only person to take his words literally. Calls the Xonar wagon “useless” and says that Xonar isn’t acting scummy at all.
Overall noted: Kirbyo usually doesn’t comment on current issues.
Post 125- Contradiction, although he always calls contradictions scummy. Buddies with Xonar for some reason.
Post 127- Inside information still. “Most likely” added at end is probably added last second before post to provide a “safety” cushion to make it look like he’s not scum with this information. More Xonar buddying.
Post 129 – LOLOLOL. Calls most of the game “lol-able” for voting Xonar. CLAIMS Xonar buddying Ryker, when in fact, quite the contrary.
Post 133 – Claims Xonar shouldn’t claim. More buddying? Possibly related role wise
Post 135- Completely useless.
Post 139- Sheilded Role Fishing. Indirect attempt, but it’s still rolefishing. Trying to determine whether the buddyers are scum or town indirectly, but he’s disguising it as just a question
Post 256 – Calls out KevinM, who, IMO, has had more input into this game substantial-wise than him.
Post 302- MORE Xonar buddying, trying to convince town that he’s not scum. Claims that flip-floppers are scummy, but also, isn’t the fact that he’s trying to convince the town to switch their opinion on Xonar leading the player into a “scummy” flip-flop?
Post 319 – Calls for actions against Chaco if he would’ve hammered Xonar. Impulsive. Good Post 320 comeback from Omis.
Post 353- Might as well take it up the butt from Xonar. Ryker comes back to say that what Kirbyo says is not town widely agreed opinion.
Post 356- Claims that anybody in the game is a better lynch than Xonar. Desperate to call out people for little, nitpicky things.
The whole Weary, wary thing – anyone with a brain can determine what he was trying to say.
Post 406- Outlines a weird voting “pattern” that doesn’t really reflect the evidence against anyone.
Post 444- Validates the fact that trainers have to be in the same place as pokes to catch, when info is not quite confirmed. Leading town askew.
Post 461- More nitpicking about crap that nobody actually cares about.
Post 498- See 499 for my suspicions as well. Kirbyo cannot see why Xonar isn’t scummy, even though it’s been outlines several times. Skimming or in denial?
Two posts after – calls for Swords lynch. Hasn’t really been established as a case against him except the fact that he layed low during the Xonar thing, which happened with most ppl.
Post 521- My post made total sense, trying to dismiss a case by saying that my post didn’t make any sense is like trying to tell a neurosurgeon that you can do brain surgery because you think you can.
Post 525- Keeping lynching targets open so that he can manipulate it to his wants and needs. That’s why he wants them open.
Post 576- Still trying to lead town to a mindset that the game is set up in HIS speculated way and denounces any other possibilities when it’s entirely obvious that this game may be one of several designed ways.
Post 577- Don’t you ****ing dare. The case against me is miniscule compared to the truckloads of scum you exude every post.
[/Collapse
All in all, I will affirm the point that the case against Kirbyoshi is substantially more developed than the case against I, as well as other possibly lynch candidates. Allow me to elaborate on the posts, if you have any questions on my thinking. Basically, I think that Kirbyoshi is trying to manipulate the mindsets of players into believing that only HIS idea of the structure of this game is the correct one, dismisses possibilities of others, and may be skimming or picking and choosing his quotes to suit his point. He calls for lynches against people who haven't really had cases presented against them, and dismisses those who have strong cases against them (See: Xonar). He's continuinly nitpicking for small things (See, Weary/Wary and Xonar/Zonar) and it's starting to get annoying. He keeps his lynch targets open so that he may manipulate the game to his own will. He avoids the Xonar and Chaco Lynch, presumably, to keep his wild pokemon recruiting options open. His posts contain indiret rolefishing that disguise themselves as questions posted to other players. Mostly, his posts are not relevant to current subjects, as pointed out by many members, including Ryker and Ronike. Although he claims that certain set ups are "lol-able", he believes that his own claims are indeed, quite valid (see: harder to catch stronger pokemon?). He buddys Xonar alot, then claims that Ryker is the one who buddies Xonar.
I'm sure I've missed a few points in this gigantic wall of text here ^ All in all, I'm completely certain that a Kirbyoshi lynch is more substantial than a random lynch "just for the sake of lynching". It is obvious that Kirbyoshi will be no benefit to town (if he's town, which I doubt) if he continues to be as pessimistic, unassuring, and stubborn in his ability to determine scum from town. Please check my notes for further elaboration on points of interest.
For other posts that I feel substantiate a Kirbyo lynch, see:
Ronike's Post 499.
SwordsRBroken's 528
SwordsRBroken's 538.
Ronike's general dislike of Kirbyo is evident. Can't find the post, but he mentioned something about a parallel between his acts in this and Batmanfia.
With that, I will
Vote: Kirbyoshi and I urge anyone to please ask questions if they have any concerns with what I've posted, because I'd love an opportunity to prove my innocence.
Gheb, I obviously have not appreciated your tunneling on me now that I'm L-2, but I'm glad you've kicked me into gear. This is Mafia, I've gotta prove my worth, and I feel like, with this post, I've tried my best!
