Chibo said:
@McFox: I'm surprised everyones willing to just throw away most of the early part of the game imo
If neither Xonar or Chaco are the play, then (besides Ronike w/ kirb), who is the play?
The problem is that
we are still talking about Xonar. This should have been dropped long ago. People have already made up their minds about him one way or the other, and yet he's still the focus of attention. There was
almost a diversion, until Chaco decided that he was a rebel and wasn't gonna have none of that "not talking about Xonar" that poeple were suggesting.
Ugh.
I guarantee use that scum is at LEAST using this smokescreen to their own advantage. After all, assuming Xonar's not scum, then all scum has to do is sit back and watch town claim several roles in an attempt not to lynch one of our own. Then, assuming they do have some way of recruiting us from anywhere (I thought of a way, but I won't share that now), they just sit back, comment occasionally, and otherwise lay low, which is not difficult in Xonarmafia - All Xonar, All the Time.
Then toNight, they can go after our claims, or they can do the opposite. I promise you if Chaco is still alive tomorrow, discussion will center heavily on him, and whether or not he has been recruited by one of the trainers. They continue to sit back and not get lynched as we further convolute things.
Yes, there are different elements to this game, but I think the best way to combat Mass Player Confusion is to just play it normally. We are still looking for scum to lynch. We still vote out one player per day. At least some people have powers that can be used at night. These are the things that are relevant to me. And a lot of this other stuff that's being discussed just serves to muddy up the issues and make things more headache-inducing, instead of making the game more clear.
We need some clarity.
I'd need to reread to look into anyone else. I'm still perfectly willing to lynch Swords, given my aforementioned reasons + he hasn't done anything to
improve my feelings about him. That's good enough for me right now.
If anyone is planning a reread, PLEASE take special precautions to avoid talking about Xonar in your post. Talk about how other people interacted with Xonar, fine, but if you just want to talk about something Xonar did or didn't do that was or wasn't scummy, I'm really not interested. We need a new discussion, a discussion about anyone except him.
"Hey, you're defending Xonar, ya card-carrying scum!"
I'm just tired of hearing about him. Anything anyone else has to say about Xonar would have to be
ridiculously insightful in order to accomplish adding any kind of meaningful dialogue to his scumminess. So please just spare us.
@Summoner - that was... a terrible post. In every sense of the word.
