am I the only one who think (in singles) GnW is really bad? like c tier, an average character?
Probably. He's obviously not C tier for multiple reasons, and his matchups are really good aside from vs Marth and Metaknight really (which are like 6/4 out of his favor, then Snake and Diddy are more like 55/45, and Wario and Falco are even). For people who think he doesn't **** anyone, that's false. If you know low tier matchups, almost all of them are at least 70/30 G&W played correctly, and Luigi basically can't win against G&W either.
G&W is much much better than C tier because he has safe KO moves and shield pressure, and an extremely good juggling game, not to mention essentially ungimpable recovery, and some sick edgeguarding with lingering hitboxes. Sure, his startup is only average, but his ENDING lag is EXTREMELY low on most moves. Only UTD Zac plays him correctly however, and otherwise his representation is garbage ever since LeePuff fell out of the picture. You must be playing those pretty common n00b G&Ws if you think he's bad.
Also, G&W is extremely good on counterpick stages for various reasons.
G&W is A tier material, and his matchups are balanced in that tier.
also, GnW is broken on wifi. I dunno what you're talking about. He's alot harder to punish and its easier to land his kill moves.
No, he's 1000x easier to punish on lag. He's more prone to making a spacing mistake that can be shieldgrabbed, his recovery gets ***** a lot by lag, and winning spam wars gets even harder. He is EXTREMELY spacing oriented, and lag ***** spacing, and makes it much harder to powershield, which is another big negative more for G&W than most characters. A matchup like ROB that G&W should be winning very easily offline actually swings to ROB's favor on wifi due to how much easier it is to camp when the opponent is unable to powershield or space properly.
Furthermore, no good G&Ws place on the ladder ever. Like seriously.