First off, I would like to defend myself from that FOS a little bit, by restating as Ronike said: I had said I was going to come on when I got some time to analyze some, and when I got that chance the most visible thing was smashbot's theory. I had to work an insane amount 6 of the days last week, as well as going to class on two of them, and didn't really have a chance to get on when I wasn't exhausted to a point where I couldn't think things through that well.
Secondly, smashbot, I didn't vote you because I was hoping that you would be able to provide a defense that didn't involve your theory. I really don't want to risk hitting another townie due to them doing something stupid(karthik not showing up, you so adamantly defending a theory that everyone pointed out holes in, without ever actually answering those holes etc.). However, it has now become apparent that your entire defense rests on that theory, and you can't make any argument outside of it except "I am not scum. I guarantee it. " Also, with 5 votes on you, as much pressure as could be placed wiithout actually lynching, you didn't even try to mount a strong defense essentially giving up. Between your refusal to argue anything without including your theory, and your apparent lack of care when you were so close to being lynched, I am now confident that you ARE mafia, and if you're not you are unable to let go of an idea you had until more evidence appears to suggest it may actually be true, so it is not a loss of someone very helpful. So, since Marshy un-voted to give others time to speak, and himself time to reread, I am making my vote when I get home from work tomorrow(assuming the lynch hasn't already happened), or possibly before work if I'm awake enough to check and those people have made their responses.